Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2023-1
The 14th Amendment in the Supreme Court's Plessy 1 and Brown 2 Decisions and Influences on Editorial Arguments about Segregation in the Southern United States,1960–1964
A content analysis of the editorial pages of the Birmingham News from 1960 to 1964 shows that, despite its staunch segregationist stance, the paper's editorial pages, nonetheless, produced strong integrationist narratives. This paradox was borne of discordant interpretations of 14th Amendment rights featured in the Supreme Court's Plessy (1896) and Brown (1954) decisions. Rise of staunch segregationist groups and officials after the Court's 1954 Brown decision drove News editors to embrace greater democratic pluralism. The evolution in editorial approach corresponded to the paper's gradual adoption of Brown's interpretations of 14th Amendment rights. Change in the valence of the paper's narratives supports Condit’s (1987) thesis that rhetorical “crafting” of public morality about race brought about greater tolerance and acceptance of racial equality in America.
CarterD. (2000). The politics of rage: George Wallace and the origins of the new conservatism and the transformation of American politics. Louisiana State University Press.
2.
CarterD. T. (1996). Legacy of rage: George Wallace and the transformation of American politics. The Journal of Southern History, 62(1), 3–26.
3.
CarterH. (1955). The South and I. LOOK (28 June), pp. 74–80.
ConditC. M. (1987). Crafting virtue: The rhetorical construction of public morality. Quarterly Journal of Speech, 73(1), 79–97. https://doi.org/10.1080/00335638709383795
6.
ConnerlyC. (2005). The most segregated city in America’: City planning and civil rights in Birmingham, 1920-1980. Charlottesville, VA: University of Virginia Press.
DavisD. (1997). An industry in transition: Major trends in American daily newspapers, 1945–1965 (Ph.D. Dissertation), Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama.
9.
DavisD. (2001). The press and race: Mississippi journalists confront the movement. University Press of Mississippi.
10.
EdmondsonA. (2014). A Pulitzer from the North, a libel suit from the South: Reaction to four Southern editors’ civil rights coverage, 1954–1967. First Amendment Law Review, 12(2), 461–498.
11.
EskewG. T. (2014). George C. Wallace, 1963–1967, 1971–1979, 1983–1987. In WebbS. L.ArmbresterM. E. (Eds.), Alabama governance: A political history of the state (pp. 249–264). University of Alabama Press.
12.
EskridgeW. (2002). Some effects of identity-based social movements on constitutional law in the twentieth century. Michigan Law Review, 100(8), 2062–2407. https://doi.org/10.2307/1290434
13.
EskridgeW. (2009). A pluralist theory of the equal protection clause. University of Pennsylvania Journal of Constitutional Law, 11(5), 1239–1267.
14.
GarrowD. (1987). The Supreme Court’s pursuit of equality and liberty and the burdens of history. In DevinsN.DouglassD. (Eds.), Redefining equality (pp. 205–217). Oxford University Press.
15.
GarrowD. (1994). Hopelessly hollow history: Revisionist devaluing of Brown v. Board of Education. Virginia Law Review, 80(1), 151–160. https://doi.org/10.2307/1073593
16.
GuthrieJ. W.SpringerM. (2004). From ‘Plessy’ to ‘Brown’ and back to ‘Plessy’ Peabody. Journal of Education, 79(2), 5–32.
KlarmanM. (2007). Brown vs. board of education and the civil rights movement: The supreme court and the struggle for racial equality. Oxford University Press.
21.
LewisG. (2006). Massive resistance: The white response to the civil rights movement. Hoddler Arnold.
22.
Loder-JacksonT. (2015). Schoolhouse activists: African-American educators and the long Birmingham civil rights movement. SUNY Press.
23.
LowellA. L. (1981). Public opinion. In M.Javanowitz & P.Hirsch (Eds.), Reader in public opinion and mass communication (pp. 10–16). N.Y.: Free Press.
24.
McWhorterD. (2001). Carry me home: Birmingham, Alabama: The climactic battle of the civil rights revolution. Simon & Schuster.
25.
McWhorterD. (2013). Good and evil in Birmingham. The New York Times, 21 January 2013, Sec. A, 21.
RainesH. (2006). The one that got away: A memoir. Scribner.
29.
RawlsJ. (2005). Political liberalism (2nd ed.). Columbia University Press.
30.
RawlsJ. (1999 [1971]). A theory of justice (2nd ed.). Harvard University Press.
31.
RobertsG.KlibanoffH. (2006). The race beat: The press, the civil rights struggle, and the awakening of a nation. Alfred A. Knopf.
32.
RousseauJ. (1997 [1762]). The social contract. Cambridge University Press.
33.
ThorntonJ. (2002). Dividing lines: municipal politics and the struggle for civil rights in Montgomery, Birmingham, and Selma. University of Alabama Press.
34.
TushnetM. (1994). The significance of Brown vs. Board of Education. Virginia Law Review, 80(1), 173–184. https://doi.org/10.2307/1073595
35.
WallaceD. (2013). Massive resistance and media suppression: The segregationist response to dissent during the civil rights movement. LFB Scholarly Publishing, LLC.
36.
WatsonB. (2010). Freedom summer: The savage season that made Mississippi burn and made America a democracy. Viking.
37.
WhalenJ. (2000). Maverick among the magnolias: The Hazel Brannon Smith story. Xlibris Corp.
38.
WhittJ. (2010). Burning crosses and activist journalism: Hazel Brannon Smith and the Mississippi civil rights movement. University Press of America.
39.
WoodwardC. (1974). The strange career of Jim Crow. Oxford University Press.
40.
WoodwardC. (1974). The strange career of Jim Crow. Oxford University Press.
