This article summarizes and analyzes the dilemma of alternative media as it has been theorized in selected statements in the literatures of mass communication. It locates the source of this dilemma in the theoretical assumptions about alternative media and their resulting inability to escape the seeming tradeoff between political effectiveness and organizational/cultural massification. It concludes by suggesting an alternative way of conceptualizing alternative media that instead of leading to efforts to build mirror images of mainstream media organizations with all their limitations, makes possible greater and more meaningful participation in public debates about the nature and direction of American society.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ades, Dawn
. 1976. Photomontage. New York: Pantheon.
2.
Allen, Peter
. 1985. Socialist worker—Paper with a purpose. Media, Culture and Society7 (2): 205-232.
3.
Altschull, J. Herbert
. 1990. From Milton to McLuhan: The ideas behind American journalism. White Plains, NY: Longman.
4.
Altschull, J. Herbert
. 1995. Agents of power: The media and public policy. White Plains, NY: Longman.
5.
Armstrong, David
. 1981. A trumpet to arms: Alternative media in America. Boston: South End.
6.
Aronowitz, Stanley
. 1996. The death and rebirth of American radicalism. London/New York: Routledge.
7.
Bagdikian, Ben
. 1992. The media monopoly. 4th ed.Boston: Beacon.
8.
Baldasty, Gerald
. 1992. The commercialization of news in the nineteenth century. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
9.
Barlow, William
. 1988. Community radio in the U.S.: The struggle for a democratic medium. Media, Culture, and Society10 (January): 81-105.
10.
Barnard, Ian
. 1996. Queerzines and the fragmentation of art, community, identity, and politics. Socialist Review26 (1/2): 69-95.
11.
Barnouw, Erik
, et al. 1997. Conglomerates and the media. New York: New Press.
12.
Bekken, Jon
. 1991. “These great and dangerous powers”: Postal censorship of the press. Journal of Communication15 (1): 55-71.
13.
Bekken, Jon
. 1993. The working class press at the turn of the century. In Ruthless criticism: New perspectives in U.S. communications history, edited by William S. Solomon and Robert McChesney. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
14.
Benjamin, Walter
. [1934] 1978. The author as producer. In Reflections: Essays, aphorisms, autobiographical writings, 220-238. New York: Schocken.
15.
Bennett, Tony
. 1982. Theories of the media, theories of society. In Culture, society and the media, edited by Michael Gurevitch, Tony Bennett, James Curran, and Janet Woollacott, 30-55. London: Methuen.
16.
Berger, John
. 1972. Ways of seeing. London: Penguin.
17.
Boggs, Carl
. 1993. Intellectuals and the crisis of modernity. Albany: State University of New York Press.
18.
Buck-Morss, Susan
. 1989. The dialectics of seeing: Walter Benjamin and the Arcades Project. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
19.
Bullert, B.J.
1997. Public television: Politics and the battle over documentary film. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
20.
Byerly, Carolyn
. 1995. News, consciousness, and social participation: The role of women's feature service in world news. In Feminism, multiculturalism, and the media: Global diversities, edited by Angharad Valdivia, 105-122. London: Sage.
21.
Calabrese, Andrew
, and Mark Borchert. 1996. Prospects for electronic democracy in the United States: Rethinking communication and social policy. Media, Culture, and Society18:249-268.
22.
Carey, James
. 1989. Communication as culture: Essays on media and society. Boston: Unwin Hyman.
23.
Carey, James
. 1998. The Internet and the end of the national communication system: Uncertain predictions of an uncertain future. Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly75 (1): 28-33.
24.
Cirino, Robert
. 1987. An alternative American communications system. In American media and mass culture: Left perspectives, edited by Donald Lazere, 568-576. Berkeley: University of California Press.
25.
Conlin, Joseph R.
, ed. 1974. The American Radical Press, 1880-1960. Vol. 1. Westport, CT: Greenwood.
26.
Croteau, David
, and Williams Hoynes. 1994. By invitation only: How the media limit public debate. Monroe, ME: Common Courage Press.
27.
Czitrom, Daniel
. 1982. Toward a new community? Modern communication in the social thought of Charles Horton Cooley, John Dewey, and Robert E. Park. In Media and the American mind: From Morse to McLuhan, 91-121. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
28.
Daressa, Lawrence
. 1987. The politics of distribution. Afterimage15 (2): 8-9.
29.
Denning, Michael
. 1990. The end of mass culture. International labor and working class history37 (Spring): 4-18.
30.
Downing, John
. 1984. Radical media: The political experience of alternative communication. Boston: South End.
31.
Duncan, Hugh Dalziel
. 1962. Communication and social order. New York: Bedminster.
32.
Duncombe, Stephen
. 1997. Notes from underground: Zines and the politics of alternative culture. London/New York: Verso.
33.
Eason, David
. 1984. Review essay: The new social history of the newspaper. Communication Research11 (1): 141-151.
34.
Engleman, Ralph
. 1996. Public radio and television in America: A political history. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
35.
Ewen, Stuart
. 1986. BILLBOARDS of the FUTURE: A brief history. In Communication and domination: Essays to honor Herbert I. Schiller, edited by Jorg Becker, Goran Hedebro, and Leena Paldan. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
36.
Ferrell, Jeff
. 1991. “The song the capitalist never sings”: The brotherhood of timber workers and the culture of conflict. Labor History32 (3): 422-431.
37.
Friedman, Sam
. 1974. Social change and rank-and-file newspapers. Insurgent Sociologist4 (2): 55-57.
38.
Fuller, Margaret
. [1840] 1983. Letter to William Channing, 22 March. Reprinted in The letters of Margaret Fuller, edited by Robert N. Hudspeth, Vol. II: 1839-1841. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
39.
Fuller, Margaret
. 1845. Woman in the nineteenth century. New York: Greeley & McElrath.
40.
Garnham, Nicholas
. 1990. Capitalism and communication. London: Sage.
41.
Garofalo, Reebee
. 1992. Understanding mega-events: If we are the world, then how do we change it? In Rockin' the boat: Mass music and mass movements, edited by Reebee Garofalo, 15-35. Boston: South End.
42.
Garrison, William Lloyd
. 1852. Selections from the writings and speeches of William Lloyd Garrison. Boston: R. F. Wallcut. Reprint, New York: Negro Universities Press, 1968.
43.
Gitlin, Todd
. 1980. The whole world is watching: Mass media in the making and unmaking of the new left. Berkeley: University of California Press.
44.
Gitlin, Todd
. 1995. The twilight of common dreams: Why America is wracked by culture wars. New York: Metropolitan.
45.
Glass, Fred
. 1984. Labor and new media technology: A union of necessity. Labor Studies Journal9 (2): 131-150.
46.
Glessing, Robert
. 1970. The underground press in America. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
47.
Godfried, Nathan
. 1997. WCFL: Chicago's voice of labor, 1926-78. Urbana/Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
48.
Grace, Tony
. 1985. The trade-union press in Britain. Media, culture and society7 (2): 233-256.
49.
Green, Martin
. 1988. New York 1913: The Armory Show and the Paterson Strike Pageant. New York: Scribner.
50.
Hall, Stuart
. 1980. Cultural studies: Two paradigms. Media, Culture and Society2 (1): 59-72.
51.
Hall, Stuart
. 1985. Religious ideologies and social movements in Jamaica. In Religion and ideology, edited by Robert Bocock, 269-296. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
52.
Hamilton, James
. 2000. The inter-not?M/C Reviews [Online], 11 May. Available: http://www.api-network.com/mc/reviews/features/politics/internot.html
53.
Hardt, Hanno
. 1990. Newsworkers, technology, and journalism history. Critical Studies in Mass Communication7:346-365.
54.
Hardt, Hanno
. 1993. Alternative visions of democracy: Theories of culture and communication in the United States. In Communication and democracy, edited by Slavko Splichal and Janet Wasko, 87-102. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
55.
Hardt, Hanno
, and Bonnie Brennen, eds. 1995. Newsworkers: Toward a history of the rank and file. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
56.
Haywood, William
. [1929] 1966. Bill Haywood's book: The autobiography of William D. Haywood. Reprint, New York: International Publishers.
57.
Heartfield, John
. 1977. Photomontages of the Nazi period. New York: Universe.
58.
Heyer, Paul
. 1988. Communications and history: Theories of media, knowledge, and civilization. New York: Greenwood.
59.
Hochheimer, John
. 1993. Organizing democratic radio: Issues in praxis. Media, culture, and society15:473-486.
60.
Hudson, Frederic
. 1873. Journalism in the United States, from 1690-1872. New York: Harper & Brothers.
61.
Huesca, Robert
. 1995. Subject-authored theories of media practice: The case of Bolivian tin miners' radio. Communication Studies46 (3/4): 149-168.
62.
Irwin, Will
. [1911] 1969. The American newspaper. Collier's, January-July. Reprint, Ames: Iowa State University Press.
63.
Jacobs, Karrie
, and Steven Heller. 1992. Angry graphics: Protest posters of the Reagan/Bush era. Salt Lake City, UT: Peregrine Smith.
Juhasz, Alexandra
. 1995. AIDS TV: Identity, community, and alternative video. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
66.
Kahn, Douglas
. 1985. John Heartfield: Art and mass media. New York: Tanam.
67.
Kaniss, Phyllis
. 1991. Making local news. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
68.
Lasar, Matthew
. 1999. Pacifica radio: The rise of an alternative network. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
69.
Lazere, Donald
. 1987. Introduction. In American media and mass culture: Left perspectives. Berkeley: University of California Press.
70.
Lee, Alfred McClung
. 1937. The daily newspaper in America: The evolution of a social instrument. New York: Macmillan.
71.
Lewis, Roger
. 1972. Outlaws of America: The underground press and its context: Notes on a cultural revolution. Baltimore: Penguin.
72.
McChesney, Robert
. 1999. Rich media, poor democracy: Communication politics in dubious times. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
73.
McFarland, C. K.
, and Robert Thistlethwaite. 1983. 20 years of a successful labor paper: The Working Man's Advocate, 1829-49. Journalism Quarterly60 (Spring): 35-40.
74.
Media Foundation
. 2000. The Media Foundation [Online], 15 May. Available: http://www.adbusters.org/
75.
Mills, C. Wright
. 1956. The power elite. New York: Oxford University Press.
76.
Monthly Review. 1996. Theme issue on “Capitalism and the information age” (July/August).
77.
Moore, Roger
. 1997. Is the Left nuts? (Or is it me?). The Nation, 17 November, pp. 16, 18.
78.
Mosco, Vincent
. 1996. The political economy of communication. London: Sage.
79.
Nord, David Paul
. 1984. The evangelical origins of mass media in America, 1815-1835. Journalism Monographs88 (May).
80.
Peck, Abe
. 1985. Uncovering the sixties: The life and times of the underground press. New York: Pantheon.
81.
Rabinowitz, Paula
. 1994. They must be represented: The politics of documentary. London/New York: Verso.
82.
Rodriguez, Clemencia
. 1996. Shedding useless notions of alternative media. Peace Review8 (1): 63-68.
83.
Ruff, Allen
. 1997. “We called each other comrade”: Charles H. Kerr & Company, Radical publishers. Urbana/Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
84.
Rutenbeck, Jeffrey
. 1991. Toward a history of the ideologies of partisanship and independence in American journalism. Journal of Communication Inquiry15 (2): 126-139.
85.
Salzman, Jason
. 1998. Making the news: A guide for nonprofits and activists. Boulder, CO: Westview.
86.
Santa Cruz, Adriana
. 1995. Fempress: A communication strategy for women. Gender and Development3 (1): 51-54.
87.
Schiller, Daniel
. 1981. Objectivity and the news: The public and the rise of commercial journalism. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
88.
Schudson, Michael
. 1978. Discovering the news: A social history of the American newspaper. New York: Basic Books.
89.
Schudson, Michael
. 1987. Critical response. Critical studies in mass communication4 (4): 405-408.
90.
Seeger, Arthur
. 1987. An unreported class war: Ideology and self-censorship on the Berkeley Barb. Communication10:31-50.
91.
Shore, Elliot
. 1985. Selling socialism: The Appeal to Reason and the radical press in turn-of-the-century America. Media, Culture and Society7 (2): 147-168.
92.
Shore, Elliot
. 1988. Talkin' socialism: J.A. Wayland and the role of the press in American radicalism, 1890-1912. Lawrence: University of Kansas Press.
93.
Siebert, Fred
. 1952. Freedom of the press in England, 1476-1776: The rise and decline of government controls. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
94.
Sinclair, Upton
. 1906. The jungle. New York: Jungle.
95.
Smith, Howie
. 1983. Broadcasting labor history. Canadian Oral History Association6:49-53.
96.
Smith, Jeffery
. 1990. Franklin and Bache: Envisioning the enlightened republic. New York: Oxford University Press.
97.
Socialist Review. 1994. Special issue on “Radical democracy”23 (3).
98.
Solomon, William
. 1995. The site of newsroom labor: The division of editorial practices. In Newsworkers: Toward a history of the rank and file, edited by Hanno Hardt and Bonnie Brennen, 110-134. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
99.
Solomon, William
, and Robert McChesney, eds. 1993. Ruthless criticism: New perspectives in U.S. communication history. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
100.
Sparks, Colin
. 1993. Raymond Williams and the theory of democratic communication. In Communication and democracy, edited by Slavko Splichal and Janet Wasko, 69-86. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
101.
Trend, David
. 1993. Rethinking media activism: Why the Left is losing the culture war. Socialist Review23 (2): 5-33.
102.
Turner, Kathleen
. 1980. Ego defense and media access: Conflicting rhetorical needs of a contemporary social movement. Central States Speech Journal31 (2): 106-116.
103.
Valdivia, Angharad N.
1995. Feminist media studies in a global setting: Beyond binary contradictions and into multicultural spectrums. In Feminism, multiculturalism, and the media: Global diversities, edited by Angharad Valdivia, 7-29. London: Sage.
104.
van Zoonen, Liesbet
. 1994. Feminist media studies. London: Sage.
105.
Williams, Raymond
. 1958. Culture is ordinary. In Conviction, edited by Norman Mackenzie, 74-92. London: MacGibbon & Kee.
106.
Williams, Raymond
. 1961. The long revolution. New York: Columbia University Press.
