We study the effect of supply and demand-induced oil price uncertainty on the cost of debt for a sample of US loans credited during the 1990 to 2019 period. We estimate oil price uncertainty following Jurado et al.’s study, whereby oil price uncertainty is captured by forecasting the unpredictable fluctuations of oil prices. Interestingly, our findings reveal that oil price uncertainty induced by supply shocks increases cost of credit, while oil price uncertainty driven by demand shocks decreases the cost of bank loans. In further analysis, the positive association between supply induced oil price uncertainty and interest loan spread is more pronounced for major users of oil, while the negative effect of demand driven oil price uncertainty on the cost of bank loans is stronger for firms that belong to industries that produce oil. Overall, our findings feed into the emerging discussion of the differentiating effects of oil price uncertainty on micro-level outcomes and provide useful implications for both bankers and borrowing firms.
JEL Classification: G20 - Financial Institutions and Services: General; Q41 - Energy: Demand and Supply; Prices; Q43 - Energy and the Macroeconomy
BarskyR. B.KilianL.2004. “Oil and the Macroeconomy since the 1970s.”Journal of Economic Perspectives18 (4): 115.
8.
BaumeisterC.HamiltonJ. D.2019. “Structural Interpretation of Vector Autoregressions with Incomplete Identification: Revisiting the Role of Oil Supply and Demand Shocks.”American Economic Review109 (5): 1873–910.
9.
BaumeisterC.KilianL.2012. “Real-time Forecasts of the Real Price of Oil.”Journal of Business & Economic Statistics30 (2): 326–36.
10.
BaumeisterC.KilianL.2015. “Forecasting the Real Price of Oil in a Changing World: A Forecast Combination Approach.”Journal of Business & Economic Statistics33 (3): 338–51.
11.
BaumeisterC.KilianL.2016. “Forty Years of Oil Price Fluctuations: Why the Price of Oil May Still Surprise Us.”Journal of Economic Perspectives30 (1): 139–60.
12.
BaumeisterC.KorobilisD.LeeT. K.2022. “Energy Markets and Global Economic Conditions.”Review of Economics and Statistics104 (4): 828–44.
13.
BaumeisterC.PeersmanG.2013. “Time-varying Effects of Oil Supply Shocks on the US Economy.”American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics5 (4): 1–28.
14.
BermpeiT.KalyvasA. N.WolfeS.2024. “Does IRS Monitoring Matter for the Cost of Bank Loans?”Journal of Financial Services Research65 (2): 153–88.
15.
BernankeB. S.1983. “Irreversibility, Uncertainty, and Cyclical Investment.”Quarterly journal of Economics98 (1): 85–106.
16.
BharathS. T.DahiyaS.SaundersA.SrinivasanA.2011. “Lending Relationships and Loan Contract Terms.”The Review of Financial Studies24 (4): 1141–203.
BloomN.2009. “The Impact of Uncertainty Shocks.”Econometrica77 (3): 623–85.
19.
BloomN.2014. “Fluctuations in Uncertainty.”Journal of Economic Perspectives28 (2): 153–76.
20.
BobenriethE.WrightB.ZengD.2013. “Stocks-to-use Ratios and Prices as Indicators of Vulnerability to Spikes in Global Cereal Markets.”Agricultural Economics44 (1): 43–52.
21.
BrennanM. J.1958. “The Supply of Storage.”American Economic Review48: 50–72.
22.
BulanL. T.2005. “Real Options, Irreversible Investment and Firm Uncertainty: New Evidence from US Firms.”Review of Financial Economics14 (3–4): 255–79.
23.
BüyükşahinB.RobeM. A.2014. “Speculators, Commodities and Cross-market Linkages.”Journal of International Money and Finance42: 38–70.
DelisM. D.IosifidiMKokasS.XefterisD.OngenaS.2020. “Enforcement Actions on Banks and the Structure of Loan Syndicates.”Journal of Corporate Finance60: 101527.
29.
EberhartA. C.MaxwellW. F.SiddiqueA. R.2004. “An Examination of Long-term Abnormal Stock Returns and Operating Performance Following R&D Increases.”The Journal of Finance59 (2): 623–50.
30.
EdelsteinP.KilianL.2009. “How Sensitive are Consumer Expenditures to Retail Energy Prices?”Journal of Monetary Economics56 (6): 766–79.
31.
ElderJ.MiaoH.RamchanderS.2013. “Jumps in Oil Prices: The Role of Economic News.”Energy Journal34 (3): 217–37.
32.
ElderJ.SerletisA.2010. “Oil Price Uncertainty.”Journal of Money, Credit and Banking42 (6): 1137–59.
33.
ElFayoumiK.2018. “The Balance Sheet Effects of Oil Market Shocks: An Industry Level Analysis.”Journal of Banking and Finance95: 112–27.
34.
EstrellaA.HardouvelisG. A.1991. “The Term Structure as a Predictor of Real Economic Activity.”Journal of Finance46 (2): 555–76.
35.
FerdererJ. P.1996. “Oil Price Volatility and the Macroeconomy.”Journal of Macroeconomics18 (1): 1–26.
36.
FilippidisM.FilisG.MagkonisG.2024. “Evaluating Oil Price Forecasts: A Meta-analysis.”Energy Journal45 (2): 71–89.
37.
FrancisB.HasanI.HuangY.SharmaZ.2012. “Do Banks Value Innovation? Evidence from US Firms.”Financial Management41 (1): 159–85.
38.
FrancisB. B.HasanI.ZhuY.2014. “Political Uncertainty and Bank Loan Contracting.”Journal of Empirical Finance29: 281–86.
39.
FullerK. P.WuQ.YildizS.2024. “Corporate Debt Policy and Tax Uncertainty.”Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting62 (1): 247–70.
40.
GemanH.OhanaS.2009. “Forward Curves, Scarcity and Price Volatility in Oil and Natural Gas Markets.”Energy Economics31 (4): 576–85.
41.
GrahamJ. R.LiS.QiuJ.2008. “Corporate Misreporting and Bank Loan Contracting.”Journal of Financial Economics89 (1): 44–61.
42.
GundersenT. S.2020. “The Impact of US Supply Shocks on the Global Oil Price.”The Energy Journal41 (1): 151–74.
43.
HamiltonJ. D.1983. “Oil and the Macroeconomy since World War II.”Journal of Political Economy91 (2): 228–48.
44.
HamiltonJ. D.2003. “What Is an Oil Shock?”Journal of Econometrics113 (2): 363–98.
45.
HasanI.HoiC. K. S.WuQ.ZhangH.2014. “Beauty is in the Eye of the Beholder: The Effect of Corporate Tax Avoidance on the Cost of Bank Loans.”Journal of Financial Economics113 (1): 109–130.
46.
HasanI.HoiC. K.WuQ.ZhangH.2017. “Social Capital and Debt Contracting: Evidence from Bank Loans and Public Bonds.”Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis52 (3): 1017–47.
47.
HasanM. M.WongJ. B.Al MamunM. A.2022. “Oil Shocks and Corporate Social Responsibility.”Energy Economics107: 105881.
48.
HeY.WangS.LaiK. K.2010. “Global Economic Activity and Crude Oil Prices: A Cointegration Analysis.”Energy Economics32 (4): 868–76.
49.
HuangT.SunZ.2024. “Climate Policy Uncertainty and Firm Investment.”International Journal of Finance and Economics29 (4): 4358–71.
50.
HuangY. S.HasanI.HuangY. C.LinC. Y.2021. “Political Uncertainty and Bank Loan Contracts: Does Government Quality Matter?”Journal of Financial Services Research60: 157–85.
51.
HuizingaJ.1993. “Inflation Uncertainty, Relative Price Uncertainty, and Investment in US Manufacturing.”Journal of Money, Credit and Banking25 (3): 521–49.
52.
JensC. E.2017. “Political Uncertainty and Investment: Causal Evidence from US Gubernatorial Elections.”Journal of Financial Economics124 (3): 563–79.
53.
JoS.2014. “The Effects of Oil Price Uncertainty on Global Real Economic Activity.”Journal of Money, Credit and Banking46 (6): 1113–35.
54.
JuelsrudR. E.LarsenV. H.2023. “Macroeconomic Uncertainty and Bank Lending.”Economics Letters225: 111041.
55.
JulioB.YookY.2012. “Political Uncertainty and Corporate Investment Cycles.”The Journal of Finance67 (1): 45–83.
KangW.de GraciaF. P.RattiR. A.2017. “Oil Price Shocks, Policy Uncertainty, and Stock Returns of Oil and Gas Corporations.”Journal of International Money and Finance70: 344–59.
58.
KangW.LeeK.RattiR. A.2014. “Economic Policy Uncertainty and Firm-level Investment.”Journal of Macroeconomics39: 42–53.
59.
KilianL.2008. “Exogenous Oil Supply Shocks: How Big are They and How Much Do They Matter for the US Economy?”Review of Economics and Statistics90 (2): 216–40.
60.
KilianL.2009. “Not All Oil Price Shocks are Alike: Disentangling Demand and Supply Shocks in the Crude Oil Market.”American Economic Review99 (3): 1053–69.
61.
KilianL.2019. “Measuring Global Real Economic Activity: Do Recent Critiques Hold up to Scrutiny?”Economics Letters178: 106–110.
62.
KilianL.HicksB.2013. “Did Unexpectedly Strong Economic Growth Cause the Oil Price Shock of 2003–2008?”Journal of Forecasting32 (5): 385–94.
63.
KilianL.VigfussonR. J.2017. “The Role of Oil Price Shocks in Causing US Recessions.”Journal of Money, Credit and Banking49 (8): 1747–76.
64.
KoopG.KorobilisD.2012. “Forecasting Inflation Using Dynamic Model Averaging.”International Economic Review53 (3): 867–86.
65.
KumarA.MallickS.2024. “Oil Price Dynamics in Times of Uncertainty: Revisiting the Role of Demand and Supply Shocks.”Energy Economics129: 107152.
66.
MaghyerehA.AbdohH.2020. “Asymmetric Effects of Oil Price Uncertainty on Corporate Investment.”Energy Economics86: 104622.
67.
MyersS. C.1977. “Determinants of Corporate Borrowing.”Journal of Financial Economics5 (2): 147–75.
68.
PhanD. H. B.TranV. T.NguyenD. T.2019. “Crude Oil Price Uncertainty and Corporate Investment: New Global Evidence.”Energy Economics77: 54–65.
69.
PhanD. H. B.TranV. T.NguyenD. T.LeA.2020. “The Importance of Managerial Ability on Crude Oil Price Uncertainty-firm Performance Relationship.”Energy Economics88: 104778.
70.
PindyckR. S.1993. “A Note on Competitive Investment under Uncertainty.”The American Economic Review83 (1): 273–77.
71.
PindyckR. S.2004. “Volatility and Commodity Price Dynamics.”Journal of Futures Markets: Futures, Options, and Other Derivative Products24 (11): 1029–47.
72.
PrestB. C.2018. “Explanations for the 2014 Oil Price Decline: Supply or Demand?”Energy Economics74: 63–75.
73.
RafteryA. E.KárnýM.EttlerP.2010. “Online Prediction under Model Uncertainty via Dynamic Model Averaging: Application to a Cold Rolling Mill.”Technometrics52 (1): 52–66.
74.
RaunigB.ScharlerJ.SindermannF.2017. “Do Banks Lend Less in Uncertain Times?”Economica84 (336): 682–711.
75.
ReadyR. C.2018. “Oil Prices and the Stock Market.”Review of Finance22 (1): 155–76.
76.
SerletisA.XuL.2019. “Markov Switching Oil Price Uncertainty.”Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics81 (5): 1045–64.
77.
SongX.YangB.2022. “Oil Price Uncertainty, Corporate Governance and Firm Performance.”International Review of Economics and Finance80: 469–87.
78.
SymeonidisL.ProkopczukM.BrooksC.LazarE.2012. “Futures Basis, Inventory and Commodity Price Volatility: An Empirical Analysis.”Economic Modelling29 (6): 2651–63.
79.
TriantafyllouA.DotsisG.SarrisA.2020. “Assessing the Vulnerability to Price Spikes in Agricultural Commodity Markets.”Journal of Agricultural Economics71 (3): 631–51.
80.
TriantafyllouA.VlastakisN.KellardN.2024. “Oil Price Uncertainty and the Macroeconomy.”SSRN4790038.
81.
UddinG. S.RahmanM. L.ShahzadS. J. H.RehmanM. U.2018. “Supply and Demand Driven Oil Price Changes and Their Non-linear Impact on Precious Metal Returns: A Markov Regime Switching Approach.”Energy Economics73: 108–121.
82.
WangY.XiangE.RuanW.HuW.2017. “International Oil Price Uncertainty and Corporate Investment: Evidence from China’s Emerging and Transition Economy.”Energy Economics61: 330–39.
83.
WongJ. B.HasanM. M.2021. “Oil Shocks and Corporate Payouts.”Energy Economics99: 105315.
84.
XuQ.FuB.WangB.2022. “The Effects of Oil Price Uncertainty on China’s Economy.”Energy Economics107: 105840.
85.
YenY. F.2013. “The Impact of Bank’s Human Capital on Organizational Performance: How Innovation Influences Performance.”Innovation15 (1): 112–27.
86.
ZhengY.ZhouM.WenF.2021. “Asymmetric Effects of Oil Shocks on Carbon Allowance Price: Evidence from China.”Energy Economics97: 105183.
