The “Second” Side of the Neck in Supraglottic Cancer

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to assess the impact of decisions made at operation for primary neck tumor on survival and cause of death—specifically, whether bilateral dissection, unilateral dissection, or delayed dissection influences eventual outcome. Of 244 patients with primary cancer of the supraglottis who were treated surgically, 22 (9%) had no neck treatment, 188 (77%) had unilateral neck dissection, and 34 (14%) had bilateral simultaneous neck dissection. Dissection on one or both sides of the neck was required later in 6 (27%) of the 22 patients with no neck treatment and in 32 (17%) of the 188 patients who had unilateral dissection. There were no differences among the treatment groups in the incidence of death from any cause or in the incidence of death from cancer, although neck stage did differ from group to group. The influence of delayed metastasis on survival was analyzed to explain these findings. Multivariate analysis demonstrated that death occurred at a rate 1.81 times higher in a person with a positive neck stage than in a person of the same age who had a negative stage. Also, death occurred at a rate 1.5 times higher for a person 10 years older than for a person with the same stage of disease. The influence of stage on the probability of need for a second dissection indicated that a patient with a positive neck stage had a 6.3 times greater likelihood of requiring a subsequent neck dissection than a person with a negative neck stage.