To conduct a systematic review of published articles that describe simulators that could be used in otolaryngology for education, skill acquisition, and/or skill improvement.
Data Sources
Ovid and Embase databases searched July 14, 2011.
Review Methods
Three hundred fifty-three abstracts were independently reviewed by both authors, then 154 eligible articles were reviewed by both authors, and 95 articles were categorized by organ system (eg, otologic); type of simulator (eg, physical, virtual); whether the simulator was a prototype, could be purchased, or was constructed; validation; and level of learning assessment. Discrepancies were resolved by re-review and discussion.
Results
In addition to 11 overview articles, 28 articles described 16 otology simulators, most of which are virtual and prototypes. Ninteen articles described 10 sinus/rhinology simulators; most are virtual surgery simulators and prototypes. Eight articles described 8 oral cavity simulators, and 8 articles described neck simulators. Seventeen articles described 13 bronchoscopy simulators; several are full-body high-technology manikins adapted from other purposes. Five articles described eclectic simulators, including some for learning nontechnical and teamwork skills. Half of the simulators have been validated. Learning levels were often not assessed or assessment was limited to the learners’ perceptions.
Conclusion
A wide variety of simulators are available or under development. Lack of unified validation concepts and limited descriptions restricted our ability to assess model characteristics, availability, and validation. Simulators are emerging as powerful tools to facilitate learning; this review may provide a platform for discussion and refinement of the information reported and analyzed in evaluating simulators.
DeutschES. Simulation in otolaryngology: smart dummies and more. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2011;145:899-903.
2.
KneeboneRL. Practice, rehearsal, and performance: an approach for simulation-based surgical and procedure training. JAMA. 2009;302:1336-1338.
3.
McGaghieWCIssenbergSBCohenERBarsukJHWayneDB. Does simulation-based medical education with deliberate practice yield better results than traditional clinical education? A meta-analytic comparative review of the evidence. Acad Med. 2011;86:706-711.
HanscomR. Medical simulation from an insurer’s perspective. Acad Emerg Med. 2008;15:984-987.
8.
DereviankoAYSchwaitzbergSDTsudaS. Malpractice carrier underwrites fundamentals of laparoscopic surgery training and testing: a benchmark for patient safety. Surg Endosc. 2010;24:616-623.
9.
ZivAWolpePRSmallSDGlickS. Simulation-based medical education: an ethical imperative. Acad Med. 2003;78:783-788.
10.
The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration. http://www.annals.org/content/151/4/W-65.full. Accessed May 1, 2012.
SchoutBMAHendrikxAJMScherpbierAJJABemelmansBLH. Update on training models in endourology: a qualitative systematic review of the literature between January 1980 and April 2008. Eur Urol. 2008;54:1247-1261.
13.
GibberMKayeRFriedMP. Virtual simulation in the surgical world. Otolaryngol Clin North Am. 2009;42:891-900.
14.
KirkpatrickD. Great ideas revisited. Training Dev. 1996;50:54.
15.
HowellsTHEmeryFMTwentymanJE. Endotracheal intubation training using a simulator: an evaluation of the Laerdal adult intubation model in the teaching of endotracheal intubation. Br J Anaesth. 1973;45:400-402.
16.
FriedMPSadoughiBGibberMJ. From virtual reality to the operating room: the endoscopic sinus surgery simulator experiment. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2010;142:202-207.
TsueTTDuganJWBurkeyB. Assessment of surgical competency. Otolaryngol Clin North Am. 2007;40:1237-1259.
19.
Nogueira JuniorJFCruzDN. Real models and virtual simulators in otolaryngology: review of literature. Rev Bras Otorrinolaringol (Engl Ed). 2010;76:129-135.
20.
GeorgeAPDeR. Review of temporal bone dissection teaching: how it was, is and will be. J Laryngol Otol. 2010;124:119-125.
21.
OoiEHWitterickIJ. Rhinologic surgical training. Otolaryngol Clin North Am. 2010;43:673-689.
22.
LatifRKAkcaO. Simulation based training of airway management with Macintosh blade and Glidescope video laryngoscope. Minerva Anestesiol. 2011;77:1-3.
23.
EasonMP. Simulation devices in cardiothoracic and vascular anesthesia. Semin Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth. 2005;9:309-323.
24.
Abou-ElhamdKEAl-SultanAIRashadUM. Simulation in ENT medical education. J Laryngol Otol. 2010;124:237-241.
25.
SchaeferIIIJJ. Simulators and difficult airway management skills. Paediatr Anaesth. 2004;14:28-37.
CliftonNKlingmannCKhalilH. Teaching otolaryngology skills through simulation. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2011;268:949-953.
28.
FriedMPUribeJISadoughiB. The role of virtual reality in surgical training in otorhinolaryngology. Curr Opin Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2007;15:163-169.
29.
SewellCMorrisDBlevinsNH. Validating metrics for a mastoidectomy simulator. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2007;125:421-426.
30.
KuppersmithRBJohnstonRJonesSBJenkinsHA. Virtual reality surgical simulation and otolaryngology. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1996;122:1297-1298.
31.
CaversaccioMEichenbergerAHauslerR. Virtual simulator as a training tool for endonasal surgery. Am J Rhinol. 2003;17:283-290.
32.
DayJD. Virtual temporal bone: an interactive 3-dimensional learning aid for cranial base surgery: commentary. Neurosurgery. 2009;64(suppl 5):ons230.
33.
RossSKJaiswalVThomasS. Re: Yorick’s skull model for tonsillectomy tie training. Clin Otolaryngol. 2008;33:630.
34.
DieckmannPPheroJCDIssenbergSBKardong-EdgrenSOstergaardDDRingstedC. The first research consensus summit of the society for simulation in healthcare: conduction and a synthesis of the results. Simul Healthc. 2011;6(suppl):S1-S9.
PettineoCMVozenilekJAKharaschMWangEAitchisonP. Epistaxis simulator. Simul Healthc. 2008;3:239-241.
37.
KuppersmithRBJohnstonRMoreauDLoftinRBJenkinsH. Building a virtual reality temporal bone dissection simulator. Stud Health Technol Inform. 1997;39:180-186.
38.
MathewsSBHetzlerDGHilsingerJr.RL. Incus and stapes footplate simulator. Laryngoscope. 1997;107:1614-1616.
39.
JohnNWThackerNPokricM. An integrated simulator for surgery of the petrous bone. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2001;81:218-224.
40.
AgusMGiachettiAGobbettiE. Mastoidectomy simulation with combined visual and haptic feedback. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2002;85:17-23.
41.
AgusMGiachettiAGobbettiE. A haptic model of a bone-cutting burr. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2003;94:4-10.
42.
WietGJStredneyDSessannaDBryanJAWellingDBSchmalbrockP. Virtual temporal bone dissection: an interactive surgical simulator. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2002;127:79-83.
43.
LeungRSamyRNLeachJLMurugappanSStredneyDWietG. Radiographic anatomy of the infracochlear approach to the petrous apex for computer-assisted surgery. Otol Neurotol. 2010;31:419-423.
44.
OwaAOGbejuadeHOGiddingsC. A middle-ear simulator for practicing prosthesis placement for otosclerosis surgery using ward-based materials. J Laryngol Otol. 2003;117:490-492.
45.
BernardoAPreulMCZabramskiJMSpetzlerRF. A three-dimensional interactive virtual dissection model to simulate transpetrous surgical avenues. Neurosurgery. 2003;52:499-505.
46.
SewellCMorrisDBlevinsNBarbagliFSalisburyK. Quantifying risky behavior in surgical simulation. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2005;111:451-457.
47.
SewellCMorrisDBlevinsNHBarbagliFSalisburyK. Evaluating drilling and suctioning technique in a mastoidectomy simulator. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2007;125:427-432.
48.
SewellCMorrisDBlevinsNH. Providing metrics and performance feedback in a surgical simulator. Comput Aided Surg. 2008;13:63-81.
49.
ZirkleMRobersonDWLeuwerRDubrowskiA. Using a virtual reality temporal bone simulator to assess otolaryngology trainees. Laryngoscope. 2007;117:258-263.
50.
MalikMUDiaz Voss VarelaDAFrancisHW. Using a virtual reality temporal bone simulator to enhance surgical competency in procedural tasks: a pilot study. Laryngoscope. 2011;121(suppl 4):s186.
51.
TrierPNoeKOSorensenMSMosegaardJ. The visible ear surgery simulator. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2008;132:523-525.
52.
SorensenMSMosegaardJTrierP. The visible ear simulator: a public PC application for GPU-accelerated haptic 3D simulation of ear surgery based on the visible ear data. Otol Neurotol. 2009;30:484-487.
53.
O’LearySJHutchinsMAStevensonDR. Validation of a networked virtual reality simulation of temporal bone surgery. Laryngoscope. 2008;118:1040-1046.
54.
ZhaoYCKennedyGHallRO’LearyS. Differentiating levels of surgical experience on a virtual reality temporal bone simulator. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2010;143(5)(suppl 3):S30-S35.
55.
ZhaoYCKennedyGYukawaKPymanBO’LearyS. Improving temporal bone dissection using self-directed virtual reality simulation: results of a randomized blinded control trial. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2011;144:357-364.
56.
ZhaoYCKennedyGYukawaKPymanBO’LearyS. Can virtual reality simulator be used as a training aid to improve cadaver temporal bone dissection? results of a randomized blinded control trial. Laryngoscope. 2011;121:831-837.
57.
VolskyPGHughleyBBPeirceSMKesserBW. Construct validity of a simulator for myringotomy with ventilation tube insertion. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2009;141:603-608.e1.
58.
KerwinTShenHWStredneyD. Enhancing realism of wet surfaces in temporal bone surgical simulation. IEEE Trans Vis Comput Graph. 2009;15:747-758.
59.
SowerbyLJRehalGHuseinMDoylePCAgrawalSLadakHM. Development and face validity testing of a three-dimensional myringotomy simulator with haptic feedback. J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2010;39:122-129.
60.
WheelerBDoylePCChandaranaSAgrawalSHuseinMLadakHM. Interactive computer-based simulator for training in blade navigation and targeting in myringotomy. Comput Methods Programs Biomed. 2010;98:130-139.
61.
AllisonWAHamiltonSTGadreAK. Temporal bone simulator as a training and assessment tool for temporal bone dissection. Laryngoscope. 2010;120(suppl 3):S64.
62.
VaradarajanVVermaRAuccottW. The portable temporal bone lab—a useful training adjunct for the ENT trainee. Clin Otolaryngol. 2010;35:449-450.
63.
HilbertMMullerW. Virtual reality in endonasal surgery. Stud Health Technol Inform. 1997;39:237-245.
64.
WeghorstSAirolaCOppenheimerP. Validation of the Madigan ESS simulator. Stud Health Technol Inform. 1998;50:399-405.
65.
RudmanDTStredneyDSessannaD. Functional endoscopic sinus surgery training simulator. Laryngoscope. 1998;108:1643-1647.
66.
EdmondCVJr. Impact of the endoscopic sinus surgical simulator on operating room performance. Laryngoscope. 2002;112:1148-1158.
67.
AroraHUribeJRalphW. Assessment of construct validity of the endoscopic sinus surgery simulator. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2005;131:217-221.
68.
GlaserAYHallCBUribeSJFriedMP. The effects of previously acquired skills on sinus surgery simulator performance. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2005;133:525-530.
69.
JakubowiczDMPriceEMGlassmanHJ. Effects of a twenty-four hour call period on resident performance during simulated endoscopic sinus surgery in an accreditation council for graduate medical education-compliant training program. Laryngoscope. 2005;115:143-146.
70.
SolyarACuellarHSadoughiBOlsonTRFriedMP. Endoscopic sinus surgery simulator as a teaching tool for anatomy education. Am J Surg. 2008;196:120-124.
71.
GlaserAYHallCBUribeSJIFriedMP. Medical students’ attitudes toward the use of an endoscopic sinus surgery simulator as a training tool. Am J Rhinol. 2006;20:177-179.
72.
BockholtUEckeUMullerWVossG. Realtime simulation of tissue deformation for the nasal endoscopy simulator (NES). Stud Health Technol Inform. 1999;62:74-75.
73.
EckeUKlimekLMullerWZieglerRMannW. Virtual reality: Preparation and execution of sinus surgery. Comput Aided Surg. 1998;3:45-50.
74.
TolsdorffBPommertAHohneKH. Virtual reality: a new paranasal sinus surgery simulator. Laryngoscope. 2010;120:420-426.
75.
OssowskiKLRheeDCRubinsteinENFergusonBJ. Efficacy of sinonasal simulator in teaching endoscopic nasal skills. Laryngoscope. 2008;118:1482-1485.
76.
LeungRMLeungJVescanADubrowskiAWitterickI. Construct validation of a low-fidelity endoscopic sinus surgery simulator. Am J Rhinol. 2008;22:642-648.
77.
NogueiraJFStammACLyraMBalieiroFOLeaoFS. Building a real endoscopic sinus and skull-base surgery simulator. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2008;139:727-728.
78.
StammANogueiraJFLyraM. Feasibility of balloon dilatation in endoscopic sinus surgery simulator. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2009;140:320-323.
79.
PearsonCRWallaceHC. The tonsil cup: a simple teaching aid for tonsillectomy. J Laryngol Otol. 1997;111:1064-1065.
80.
SivanandanIMorrisESoarJ. The Palm-LM (laryngeal airway) simulator. Anaesthesia. 2003;58:825-826.
81.
StreetIBeechTJenningsC. The Birmingham trainer: a simulator for ligating the lower tonsillar pole. Clin Otolaryngol. 2006;31:79.
82.
VadodariaSWatkinNThiessenFPonniahA. The first cleft palate simulator. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2007;120:259-261.
83.
RuthenbeckGSOwenHReynoldsKJ. A virtual reality throat examination simulation. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2008;132:433-435.
84.
NagyKMommaertsMY. Advanced S(t)imulator for cleft palate repair techniques. Cleft Palate-Craniofac J. 2009;46:1-5.
85.
SchebestaKHupflMRinglHMachataA-ChiariAKimbergerO. A comparison of paediatric airway anatomy with the SimBaby high-fidelity patient simulator. Resuscitation. 2011;82:468-472.
86.
KingPHBlanksSTRummelDMPattersonD. Simulator training in anesthesiology: an answer?Biomed Instrum Technol. 1996;30:341-345.
87.
LiuABhasinYBowyerM. A haptic-enabled simulator for cricothyroidotomy. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2005;111:308-313.
88.
JohnBSuriIHillermannCMendoncaC. Comparison of cricothyroidotomy on manikin vs. simulator: a randomised cross-over study. Anaesthesia. 2007;62:1029-1032.
89.
FriedmanZYou-TenKEBouldMDNaikV. Teaching lifesaving procedures: the impact of model fidelity on acquisition and transfer of cricothyrotomy skills to performance on cadavers. Anesth Analg. 2008;107:1663-1669.
90.
MurphyCRooneySMaharajCLaffeyJHarteB. A comparison of three cuffed emergency percutaneous cricothyroidotomy devices with surgical cricothyroidotomy performed by experienced anaesthesiologists. Eur J Anaesthesiol. 2009;26:220.
91.
PettineoCMVozenilekJAWangEFlahertyJKharaschMAitchisonP. Simulated emergency department procedures with minimal monetary investment: cricothyrotomy simulator. Simul healthc. 2009;4:60-64.
92.
RyzynskiA. Airway part-task trainer: how to be green and budget lean. Can J Anesth. 2010;57:S22.
93.
SiuLWBoetSBorgesBC. High-fidelity simulation demonstrates the influence of anesthesiologists’ age and years from residency on emergency cricothyroidotomy skills. Anesth Analg. 2010;111:955-960.
94.
HesselfeldtRKristensenMSRasmussenLS. Evaluation of the airway of the SimMan full-scale patient simulator. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 2005;49:1339-1345.
95.
LatifRBautistaADuanX. Teaching advanced airway management skills: using simulation to accelerate the fiberoptic intubation learning curve. Crit Care Med. 2010;38:A134.
96.
HolcombJBDumireRDCrommettJW. Evaluation of trauma team performance using an advanced human patient simulator for resuscitation training. J Trauma Inj Infect Crit Care. 2002;52:1078-1085.
RoweRCohenRA. An evaluation of a virtual reality airway simulator. Anesth Analg. 2002;95:62-66.
99.
DeutschESChristensonTCurryJHossainJZurKJacobsI. Multimodality education for airway endoscopy skill development. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2009;118:81-86.
100.
MandalSPatelARCGoldringJJP. A simulated bronchoscopy course for new specialist trainees. Thorax. 2010;65:A117.
101.
PatelARCMandalSGoldringJJP. Simulated bronchoscopy training delivered by experienced peers improves confidence of new trainees. Thorax. 2010;65:A116.
102.
DalalPGDalalGBPottLBezinoverDProzeskyJBosseau MurrayW. Learning curves of novice anesthesiology residents performing simulated fibreoptic upper airway endoscopy. Can J Anesth. 2011;58:802-809.
103.
De HoyosALSaludLPughC. Toward a simulation and an assessment method for the practice of rigid bronchoscopy. Innov Technol Tech Cardiothorac Vasc Surg. 2009;4:154.
104.
ContagSPKleinAMBlountACJohnsMMIII. Validation of a laryngeal dissection module for phonomicrosurgical training. Laryngoscope. 2009;119:211-215.
105.
BoazNTAnderhuberF. The uses of soft embalming for cadaver-based dissection, instruction in gross anatomy, and training of physicians. FASEB J. 2009;23(suppl 1):480.3.
106.
PughAClarkeSWongJEsplenMJ. Providing psychosocial training for inpatient head and neck cancer surgery nurses: a knowledge translation initiative. Psycho-Oncology. 2010;19:S36-S37.
107.
HaleyACBiermanJRobinsonJKLioPMcGaghieW. Melanoma opportunistic screening: facilitators, barriers, and performance toward detection and recognition by third-year medical students. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2011;64:AB120.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
