A Differential Assessment of the Cumulative Versus Stabilizing Effect of Methadone Maintenance Treatment

Abstract

Differential response effectiveness is examined for patients during multiple episodes of metha done maintenance (MM) treatment. Subjects were 251 narcotics addicts who were divided into three groups based on their daily narcotics use pattern during their first two MM treatment penods: (I) a "stabilizing group"—showing no daily use for both periods, (2) a "cumulative group "—showing a lower level of daily use during the second period compared to the first, and (3) a "deteriorating group"—showing higher daily use during the second period. Behavioral measures for various narcotics-related variables were plotted over 4 time penods (pre-MM, during first MM, between first and second episodes, and during second MM) were compared. Results indicated several individual differences related to patients'response to multiple episodes of MM. Clinical, research, and policy implications are discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Africano, A. , M. Fortunato , and E. Padow. 1973. The impact of program treatment on marital unions in a methadone maintained patient population Proceedings of the National Conference on Methadone Treatment 1:538-44.

Almog, Y.J. , M.D. Anglin , and D.G. Fisher. 1993. Alcohol and heroin use patterns of narcotics addicts: Gender and ethnic differences American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 19:219-38.

Anglin, M.D. 1988. The efficacy of Civil Commitment in treating narcotics addiction Journal of Drug Issues 18:527-60.

Anglin, M.D. , I. Almog , D.G. Fisher , and K.R. Peters. 1989. Alcohol use by heroin addicts: Evidence for an inverse relationship. A study of methadone maintenance and drug-free treatment samples American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 15:191-207.

Anglin, M.D. , M.W. Booth , C.-F. Kao , L.L. Harlow , and K. Peters. 1987. Similarity of behavior within addict couples. Part II: Addiction-related variables The International Journal of the Addictions 22:583-607.

Anglin, M.D. , and Y-I. Hser. 1990. Treatment of drug abuse. In Crime and justice: An annual review of research Vol. 13. Edited by M. Tonry and J. Wilson. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

Anglin, M.D. , Y-I. Hser , and M. Booth. 1987. Sex differences in addict careers. 4: Treatment Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 13:253-80.

Anglin, M.D. , T.M. Ryan , M.W. Booth , and Y.-I. Hser. 1988. Ethnic differences in narcotics addiction. I: Characteristics of Chicano and Anglo methadone maintenance clients The International Journal of the Addictions 23:125-49.

Apsler, R. , and W.M. Harding. 1991. Cost-effectiveness analysis of drug abuse treatment: Current status and recommendations for future research In NIDA drug abuse services series, No. 1: Background papers on drug abuse financing and services research. DHHS Pub. No. (ADM) 91-1777 Washington, DC: National Institute on Drug Abuse.

10.

Bailey, R.C. , Y.-I. Hser , S.-C. Hsieh , and M.D. Anglin. 1994. Influences affecting maintenance and cessation of narcotics addiction The Journal of Drug Issues 24:249-72.

11.

Ball, J.C. , R. Laurence , J.A. Flueck , and D.N. Nurco. 1982. Lifetime criminality of heroin addicts in the United States Journal of Drug Issues , Summer, pp. 225-39.

12.

Blumstein, A. , J. Cohen , J.A. Roth , and C.A. Visher. 1986. Criminal careers and career criminals Vols. 1and2. Washington, DC: National Academy Press .

13.

Brown, L. , A.I. Alterman , M.J. Rutherford , J.S. Cacciola , and A.R. Zaballero. 1993. Addiction Severity Index scores of four racial/ethnic and gender groups of methadone maintenance patients Journal of Substance Abuse 5:269-79.

14.

Fairbank, J.A. , G.H. Dunteman , and W.S. Condelli. 1993. Do methadone patients substitute other drugs for heroin? Predicting substance use at 1-year follow-up American Journal of Drug & Alcohol Abuse 19:465-74.

15.

Green J. , J.H. Jaffe , J.A. Carlisi , and A. Zaks. 1978. Alcohol use in the opiate use cycle of the heroin addict International Journal of the Addictions 13:1021-33.

16.

Hall, W. , J. Bell , and J. Carless. 1993. Crime and drug use among applicants for methadone maintenance Drug and Alcohol Dependence 31:123-9.

17.

Halow, L.L. , and M.D. Anglin. 1984. Time series design to evaluate effectiveness of methadone maintenance intervention Journal of Drug Education 14:53-72.

18.

Hser, Y.-I. , M.D. Anglin , and C.-P. Chou. 1988. Evaluation of drug abuse treatment: A repeated measures design assessing methadone maintenance Evaluation Review 12:547-70.

19.

Joe, G.W. , D.D. Simpson , and S.B. Sells. 1994. Treatment process and relapse to opioid use during methadone maintenance American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 20:173-97.

20.

Joseph, H. , and P. Appel. 1985. Alcoholism and methadone treatment: Consequences for the patient and program American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Use 11:37-53.

21.

Leukefeld, C.G. 1985

The clinical connection: Drugs and crime

The International Journal of the Addictions 20:1049-64.

22.

Leukefeld, C.G. , and F.M. Tims. 1988. Compulsory treatment of drug abuse: Research and clinical practice NIDA research monograph series 86. DHHS Pub. No. (ADM) 88-1578. Rockville, MD: National Institute on Drug Abuse.

23.

Longabaugh, R. 1986. The matching hypothesis: Theoretical and empirical status Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

24.

Maddux, J. 1973. Characteristics of Mexican-American addicts In National Institute of Mental Health, proceedings, Institute on Narcotics Addiction among Mexican Americans in the Southwest, April 21-23, 1971. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office .

25.

McGlothlin, W.H. , M.D. Anglin , and B.D. Wilson. 1977. A follow-up of admissions to the California Civil Addict Program American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 4:179-99.

26.

Nurco, D.N. , A.J. Bonito , M. Lerner , and M.B. Batter. 1975. Studying addicts over time: Methodology and preliminary findings American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 2:183-96.

27.

Powers K.I. , and M.D. Anglin. 1993. Cumulative versus stabilizing effects of methadone maintenance: A quasi-experimental study using longitudinal self-report data Evaluation Review 17:243-70.

28.

Project Match Research Group. 1997. Matching alcoholism treatments to client heterogeneity: Project MATCH posttreatment drinking outcomes Journal of Studies on Alcohol 58:7-29.

29.

Rosenbaum, M. , J. Irwin , and S. Murphy. 1988. De facto destabilization as policy: The impact of short-term methadone maintenance Contemporary Drug Problems, Winter, pp. 491-517.

30.

Schut, J. , R.A. Steer , and F.I. Gonzalez. 1975. Types of arrest recorded for methadone maintenance patients before, during, and after treatment British Journal of Addictions 70:89-93.

31.

Simpson, D.D. , and S.B. Sells. 1983. Effectiveness of treatment for drug abuse: An overview of the DARP research program Advances in Alcohol and Substance Abuse 2:7-29.

32.

Swan, N. 1994. Research demonstrates long-term benefits of methadone maintenance NIDA Notes 9:1-4.

33.

Tatsuoka, M.M. 1988. Multivariate analysis: Techniques for educational and psychological research 2d ed. New York: Macmillan.

34.

White, J.M. , K.R. Dyer , R.L. Ali , M.D. Gaugewin , and S. Cormack. 1994. Injecting behaviour and risky needle use amongst methadone maintenance clients Drug and Alcohol Dependence 34:113-9.