The Comparison Group Problem in Bereavement Studies and the Retrospective Pretest

Abstract

An elaboration of Campbell and Stanley's (1963) retrospective pretest design to include a "surrogate comparison group" is described. The successful use of the design is illustrated and tested using data from a longitudinal investigation of bereavement outcome following pregnancy loss. The bereaved group was not significantly different from the surrogate comparison group of currently pregnant women in their retrospection of their prepregnancy mental health status. The pregnant surrogate group's current mental health status also did not differ from the bereaved group's retrospections concerning their mental health during their pregnancies. Implications for the use of the design are also discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barglow, P. , I. Istiphan , J.E. Bedger , and C. Welbourne. 1973. Response of unmarried adolescent mothers to infant or fetal death. In Adolescent psychiatry, vol. II: Development and clinical studies , ed. C. Feinstein and P. Giovaccini , 285-300. New York: Basic Books.

Campbell, D. , and J. Stanley. 1963. Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for research. Chicago: Rand McNally.

Carlson, D.B. , and R.C. Labarba. 1979. Maternal emotionality during pregnancy and reproductive outcome: A review of the literature. International Journal of Behavioral Development 2:343-76.

Clarke, M. , and A.J. Williams. 1979. Depression in women after perinatal death. Lancet, 916-17.

Derogatis, L.R. , K. Rickels , and A.F. Rock. 1981. The SCL-90 and the MMPI: A step in the validation of a new self-report scale. British Journal of Psychiatry 138:185-93.

Deutsch, M. , and M.E. Collins. 1951. Interracial housing:A psychological evaluation ofa social experiment. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

Helmrath, T.A. , and E.M. Steinitz. 1978. Death of an infant: Parental grieving and the failure of social support. Journal of Family Practice 6, no. 4:785-90.

Kauffman, M. , J. Elizur , and L. Harpazy. 1982. An "epidemic" of spontaneous abortion: Psychosocial factors. Israeli Journal of Psychiatry and Related Sciences 19, no. 3:239-46.

Kellner, K.R. , W.H. Donnelly , and S.D. Gould. 1984. Parental behavior after perinatal death: Lack of predictive demographic and obstetric variables. Obstetrics and Gynecology 63, no. 6:809-14.

10.

LaRoche, C. , M. Lalinec-Michaud , F. Engelsmann , N. Fuller , M. Copp , M. McQuade-Soldatos , and R. Azima. 1984. Reactions to perinatal death: A follow-up study. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 29:14-19.

11.

Laurell-Borulf, Y. 1982. Long-term adjustment after an emotional crisis: A follow-up of women with a perinatally dead infant. (English abstract. Krislosningi Langtidsperspek T IV:157-67.

12.

Mednick, S.A. , R. Cudeck , J.J. Griffith , S.A. Talovic , and F.A. Schulsinger . 1984. The Danish high risk project: Recent methods and findings. In Children at risk for schizophrenia , ed. N. F. Watt , E. J. Anthony , L. C. Wynne , and J. E. Rolf. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

13.

Parkes, C.M. 1975. Determinants of outcome following bereavement. Omega 6, no. 4:303-23.

14.

Rowe, J. , R. Clyman , C. Green , C. Mikkelsen , J. Haight , and L. Ataide. 1978. Follow-up of families who experience a perinatal death. Pediatrics 62, no. 2:166-69.

15.

Sanders, C.M. 1979-1980. A comparison of adult bereavement in the death of a spouse, child and parent. Omega 10, no. 4:303-22.

16.

Videka-Sherman, L. 1982. Coping with the death of a child: A study over time. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 52, no. 4:688-698.

17.

Wolff, J.R. , P.E. Nielson , and P. Schiller. 1970. The emotional reaction to a stillbirth . American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 108, no. 1:73-77.

18.

Zisook, S. , R.A. DeVaul , and M.A. Click. 1982. Measuring symptoms of grief and bereavement . American Journal of Psychiatry 139:1590-93.