The Effect of Motorcycle Helmet Use On the Probability of Fatality and the Severity of Head and Neck Injuries

Abstract

This article evaluates the effectiveness of motorcycle helmets in accident situations. A latent variable model is developed and estimated. It is concluded that (1) motorcycle helmets have no statistically significant effect on the probability of fatality; (2) helmets reduce the severity of head injuries; and (3) past a critical impact speed, helmets increase the severity of neck injuries. Further analysis establishes the qualitative and quantitative nature of the head-neck injury trade-off.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams, J.G.U. (1983) "Public safety legislation and the risk compensation hypothesis: the example of motorcycle helmet legislation." Environment and Planning C 1: 193-203.

American Association for Automotive Medicine ( 1976) The Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS. Morton Grove, IL: Author.

Baker, S.P. and R.S. Fisher (1977) "Alcohol and motorcycle fatalities." Amer. J. of Public Health 67: 246-249.

Champion, H.R. , S.P. Baker , C. Benner , R. Fisher , Y.H. Caplan , W.B. Long , R.A. Cowley , and W. Gill (1975) "Alcohol intoxication and serum osmolality." Lancet 7922: 1402-1404.

Chang, C. (1981) "A cross-classification analysis of the effectiveness of safety helmets in motorcycle accident injuries." Institute of Transportation Engineers J. 51: 17-25.

Dare, C.E. , J.C. Owens , and S. Krane (1979) "Effect of motorcycle safety helmet use on injury location and severity: before-and-after helmet law repeal in Colorado." Institute of Transportation Engineers J. 49: 9-15.

Forester, T.H. , R.F. McNown , and L.D. Singell (1984) "A cost-benefit analysis of the 55 mph speed limit ." Southern Economic J. 50: 631-641.

Hart, D.N.J. , P.W. Cotter , and W.A.A.G. MacBeth (1975) "Christchurch traffic trauma survey: part 2, victims and statistics." New Zealand Medical J. 81: 542-546.

Hartunian, N.S. , C.N. Smart , T.R. Willemain , and P.L. Zador (1983) "The economics of safety deregulation: lives and dollars lost due to repeal of motorcycle helmet laws." J. of Health Politics, Policy and Law 8: 76-98.

10.

Heilman, D.R. , J.B. Weisbuch , R.W. Blair , and L.L. Graf (1982) "Motorcycle-related trauma and helmet usage in North Dakota." Annuals of Emergency Medicine 11: 659-664.

11.

Hurt, H. H. Jr. , J.V. Ouellet , and D.R. Thom (1981, January) Motorcycle Accident Cause Factors and Identification of Countermeasures, Volume I: Technical Report, Contract DOT HS-5-01160. Washington, DC.

12.

Koshal, R.K. (1976) "Deaths from road accidents in the United States: an econometric analysis." J. of Transport Economics and Policy 10: 219-226.

13.

Kraus, J.F. , R.S. Riggins , and C.E. Franti (1975) "Some epidemiologic features of motorcycle collision injuries." Amer. J. of Epidemiology 102: 99-109.

14.

Luna, G.K. , M.K. Copass , M.R. Oreskovich , and C.J. Carrico (1981) "The role of helmets in reducing head injuries from motorcycle accidents: a political or medical issue?" Western J. of Medicine 135: 89-92.

15.

McSwain, N.E. and M. Lummis (1980) "Impact of repeal of motorcycle helmet law." Surgery, Gynecology and Obstetrics 151: 215-24.

16.

Motorcycle Industry Council (1985) Motorcycle Statistical Annual. Costa Mesa, CA: Author.

17.

Mueller, A. (1980) "Evaluation of the costs and benefits of motorcycle helmet laws." Amer. J. of Public Health 70: 586-592.

18.

Peltzman, S. (1975) "The effects of automobile safety regulation." J. of Political Economy 83: 677-725.

19.

Prinzinger, J.M. (1982) "The effect of the repeal of helmet use laws on motorcycle fatalities." Atlantic Econ. J. 10: 36-39.

20.

Russo, P.K. ( 1978) "Easy Rider-hard facts: motorcycle helmet laws ."New England J. of Medicine 299: 1074-1076.

21.

Scott, R.E. (1983) Motorcycle Accidents and Motorcycle Injuries—A Review. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute.

22.

Snively, G.G. (1983) "Head injury protection," in C. L. Ewing et al. (eds.). Impact Injury of the Head and Spine. Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.

23.

U.S. Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (1980, April) A Report to Congress on the Effect of Motorcycle Helmet Use Law Repeal-A Case for Helmet Use. Washington, DC: Author.

24.

Wilde, G.J.S. (1982) "The theory of risk homeostasis: implications for safety and health." Risk Analysis 2: 209-225.