Do Specialty Courts Achieve Better Outcomes for Children in Foster Care Than General Courts?

Abstract

Objective:

This study assessed the effects of unified family and drug treatment courts (DTCs) on the resolution of cases involving foster care children and the resulting effects on school performance.

Method:

The first analytic step was to assess the impacts of presence of unified and DTCs in North Carolina counties on time children spent in foster care and the type of placement at exit from foster care. In the second step, the same data on foster care placements were merged with school records for youth in Grades 3–8 in public schools. The effect of children’s time in foster care and placement outcomes on school performance as measured by math and reading tests, grade retention, and attendance was assessed using child fixed-effects regression.

Results:

Children in counties with unified family courts experienced shorter foster care spells and higher rates of reunification with parents or primary caregivers. Shorter foster care spells translated into improved school performance measured by end-of-grade reading and math test scores. Adult DTCs were associated with lower probability of reunification with parents/primary caregivers.

Conclusion:

The shortened time in foster care implies an efficiency gain attributable to unified family courts, which translate into savings for the court system through the use of fewer resources. Children also benefit through shortened stays in temporary placements, which are related to some improved educational outcomes.

Keywords

child welfare crime and justice (adult and juvenile)education

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Akin

B. A.

2011. “Predictors of Foster Care Exits to Permanency: A Competing Risks Analysis of Reunification, Guardianship, and Adoption.” Children and Youth Services Review 33:999–1011.

Allison

P. D.

2009. Fixed Effects Regression Models. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Ashford

J. B.

2004. “Treating Substance-Abusing Parents: A Study of the Pima County Family Drug Court Approach.” Juvenile and Family Court Journal 55:27–37.

Attar-Schwartz

2009. “School Functioning of Children in Residential Care: The Contributions of Multilevel Correlates.” Child Abuse & Neglect 33:429–40.

Babb

B. A.

1998. “Fashioning an Interdisciplinary Framework for Court Reform in Family Law: A Blueprint to Construct a Unified Family Court.” Southern California Law Review 71:469–545.

Brown

R. T.

2010. “Systematic Review of the Impact of Adult Drug Treatment Courts.” Translational Research 155:263–74.

Bruns

E. J.

Pullmann

M. D.

Weathers

E. S.

Wirschem

M. L.

Murphy

J. K.

. 2012. “Effects of a Multidisciplinary Family Treatment Drug Court on Child and Family Outcomes: Results of a Quasi-Experimental Study.” Child Maltreatment 17:218–30.

Burrus

Making

Finigan

M. W.

. 2011. “Show me the Money: Child Welfare Cost Savings of a Family Drug Court.” Juvenile and Family Court Journal 62:1–14.

Caspi

Wright

B. R. E.

Moffitt

T. E.

Silva

P. A.

. 1998. “Early Failure in the Labor Market: Childhood and Adolescent Predictors of Unemployment in the Transition to Adulthood.” American Sociological Review 63:424–51.

10.

Chambers

R. M.

Potter

C. C.

. 2008. “The Match Between Family Needs and Services for High-Risk Neglecting Families.” Journal of Public Child Welfare 2:229–52.

11.

Chuang

Moore

Barrett

Young

M. S.

. 2012. “Effect of an Integrated Family Dependency Treatment Court on Child Welfare Reunification, Time to Permanency and Re-Entry Rates.” Children and Youth Services Review 34:1896–902.

12.

Connell

C. M.

Katz

K. H.

Saunders

Tebes

J. K.

. 2006. “Leaving Foster Care—The Influence of Child and Case Characteristics on Foster Care Exit Rates.” Children and Youth Services Review 28:780–98.

13.

Courtney

M. E.

Hook

J. L.

. 2012. “Evaluation of the Impact of Enhanced Parental Legal Representation on the Timing of Permanency Outcomes for Children in Foster Care.” Children and Youth Services Review 34:1337–43.

14.

Courtney

M. E.

McMurtry

S. L.

Zinn

. 2004. “Housing Problems Experienced by Recipients of Child Welfare Services.” Child Welfare 83:393–422.

15.

Courtney

M. E.

Piliavin

Kaylor-Grogan

Nesmith

. 2001. “Foster Youth Transitions to Adulthood: A Longitudinal View of Youth Leaving Care.” Child Welfare 80:685–717.

16.

Currie

Spatz Widom

. 2010. “Long-Term Consequences of Child Abuse and Neglect on Adult Economic Well-Being.” Child Maltreatment 15:111–20.

17.

Domitrovich

1998. “Utilizing an Effective Economic Approach to Family Court: A Proposal for a Statutory Unified Family Court in Pennsylvania.” Duquesne Law Review 37:1–66.

18.

Eckenrode

Laird

Doris

. 1993. “School Performance and Disciplinary Problems Among Abused and Neglected Children.” Developmental Psychology 29:53–62.

19.

Elliott

2013. “The Effects of Economic Instability on Children’s Educational Outcomes.” Children and Youth Services Review 35:461–71.

20.

Green

B. L.

Furrer

Worcel

Burrus

Finigan

M. W.

. 2007. “How Effective are Family Treatment Drug Courts? Outcomes from a Four-Site National Study.” Child Maltreatment 12:43–59.

21.

Henggeler

S. W.

Halliday-Boykins

C. A.

Cunningham

P. B.

Randall

Shapiro

S. B.

Chapman

J. E.

. 2006. “Juvenile Drug Court: Enhancing Outcomes by Integrating Evidence-Based Treatments.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 74:42–54.

22.

Holst

K. Y.

2010. “Good Score: Examining Twenty Years of Drug Courts in the United States and Abroad.” Valparaiso University Law Review 45:73–106.

23.

Hook

Courtney

M. E.

. 2011. “Employment Outcomes of Former Foster Youth as Young Adults: The Importance of Human, Personal, and Social Capital.” Children and Youth Services Review 33:1855–65.

24.

Hora

P. F.

2002. “A Dozen Years of Drug Treatment Courts: Uncovering Our Theoretical Foundation and the Construction of a Mainstream Paradigm.” Substance Use & Misuse 37:1469–88.

25.

Hoxby

2000. “Peer Effects in the Classroom: Learning from Gender and Race Variation.” NBER Working Paper Series, 7867. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.

26.

Ives

M. L.

Chan

Y. F.

Modisette

K. C.

Dennis

M. L.

. 2010. “Characteristics, Needs, Services, and Outcomes of Youths in Juvenile Treatment Drug Courts as Compared to Adolescent Outpatient Treatment.” Drug Court Review 7:10–56.

27.

Jellinek

M. S.

Murphy

J. M.

Poitrast

Quinn

Bishop

S. J.

Goshkp

. 1992. “Serious Child Mistreatment in Massachusetts: The Course of 206 Children through the Courts.” Child Abuse and Neglect 16:179–85.

28.

Jones

1998. “The Social and Family Correlates of Successful Reunification of Children in Foster Care.” Children and Youth Services Review 20:305–23.

29.

Jonson-Reid

Drake

Kohl

P. L.

. 2009. “Is the Overrepresentation of the Poor in Child Welfare Caseloads Due to Bias or Need?” Children and Youth Services Review 31:422–27.

30.

Jonson-Reid

Emery

C. R.

Drake

Stahlschmidt

M. J.

. 2010. “Understanding Chronically Reported Families.” Child Maltreatment 15:271–81.

31.

Kinard

2001. “Characteristics of Maltreatment Experience and Academic Functioning among Maltreated Children.” Violence and Victims 16:323–37.

32.

Koh

2010. “Permanency Outcomes of Children in Kinship and Non-Kinship Foster Care: Testing the External Validity of Kinship Effects.” Children and Youth Services Review 32:389–98.

33.

Landsverk

Davis

Ganger

Newton

Johnson

. 1996. “Impact of Child Psychosocial Functioning on Reunification from Out-of-Home Placement.” Children and Youth Services Review 18:447–62.

34.

Lawrence

C. Nicole

Rosanbalm

Katie D.

Dodge

Kenneth A.

. 2011. “Multiple Response System: Evaluation of Policy Change in North Carolina’s Child Welfare System.” Children and Youth Services Review 33:2355–65.

35.

Lee

Jonson-Reid

Drake

. 2012. “Foster Care Re-entry: Exploring the Role of Foster Care Characteristics, In-Home Child Welfare Services and Cross-Sector Services.” Children and Youth Services Review 34:1825–33.

36.

Leiter

Johnsen

M. C.

. 1997. “Child Maltreatment and School Performance Declines: An Event-History Analysis.” American Educational Research Journal 34:563–89.

37.

Leslie

L. K.

James

Monn

Kauten

M. C.

Zhang

Aarons

. 2010. “Health-Risk Behaviors in Young Adolescents in the Child Welfare System.” Journal of Adolescent Health 47:26–34.

38.

Linden

Cohen

Bader

Magnani

. 2010. “Developing Accountability in the Lives of Youth: Defining the Operational Features of Juvenile Treatment Courts.” Special Issue on Juvenile Drug Courts 7:125.

39.

MacMillan

H. L.

Wathen

C. N.

Barlow

Fergusson

D. M.

Leventhal

J. M.

Taussig

H. N.

. 2009. “Interventions to Prevent Child Maltreatment and Associated Impairment.” The Lancet 373:250–66.

40.

McCart

M. R.

Henggeler

S. W.

Chapman

J. E.

Cunningham

P. B.

. 2012. “System-Level Effects of Integrating a Promising Treatment into Juvenile Drug Courts.” Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 43:231–43.

41.

McGlade

Ware

Crawford

. 2009. “Child Protection Outcomes for Infants of Substance-Using Mothers: A Matched-Cohort Study.” Pediatrics 124:285–93.

42.

McNichol

Tash

. 2001. “Parental Substance Abuse and the Development of Children in Family Foster Care.” Child Welfare 80:239–56.

43.

Miller

2004. How do Court Continuances Influence the Time Children Spend in Foster Care. Olympia, WA: Washington State Institute for Public Policy.

44.

N. C. Administrative Office of the Courts. 2006. North Carolina’s Unified Family Courts: Best Practices and Guidelines. Raleigh: N.C. Administrative Office of the Courts, Court Programs and Management Services Division.

45.

Nikulina

Widom

C. S.

Czaja

. 2011. “The Role of Childhood Neglect and Childhood Poverty in Predicting Mental Health, Academic Achievement and Crime in Adulthood.” American Journal of Community Psychology 48:309–21.

46.

North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. 2008. Child Placement and Payment System Child Placement and Payment System Manual. North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. Accessed April 18, 2013, http://info.dhhs.state.nc.us/olm/manuals/dss/csm-80/man/CPPS_Manual.htm.

47.

Pecora

P. J.

Williams

Kessler

R. C.

Hiripi

O’Brien

Emerson

Herrich

M. A.

Torres

. 2006. “Assessing the Educational Achievements of Adults who were Formerly Placed in Family Foster Care.” Child & Family Social Work 11:220–31.

48.

Pecora

P. J.

Kessler

R. C.

O’Brien

White

C. R.

Williams

Hiripi

Herrick

M. A.

. 2006. “Educational and Employment Outcomes of Adults Formerly Placed in Foster Care: Results from the Northwest Foster Care Alumni Study.” Children and Youth Services Review 28:1459–81.

49.

Potter

C. C.

Klein-Rothschild

. 2002. “Getting Home on Time: Predicting Timely Permanence for Young Children.” Child Welfare 81:123–50.

50.

Rempel

Fox-Kralstein

Cissner

. 2004. “Drug Courts as Effective Treatment Alternative.” Criminal Justice 19:34.

51.

Rosenberg

S. A.

Robinson

Cordelia C.

. 2004. “Out-of-Home Placement for Young Children with Developmental and Medical Conditions.” Children and Youth Services Review 26:711–23.

52.

Rumberger

R. W.

1995. “Dropping Out of Middle School: A Multilevel Analysis of Students and Schools.” American Educational Research Journal 32:583–625.

53.

Salvatore

Henderson

J. S.

Hiller

M. L.

White

Samuelson

. 2010. “An Observational Study of Team Meetings and Status Hearings in a Juvenile Drug Court.” Drug Court Review 7:95–124.

54.

Schaeffer

C. M.

Henggeler

S. W.

Chapman

J. E.

Halliday-Boykins

C. A.

Cunningham

P. B.

Randall

Shapiro

S. B.

. 2010. “Mechanisms of Effectiveness in Juvenile Drug Court: Altering Risk Processes Associated with Delinquency and Substance Abuse.” Drug Court Review 7:57.

55.

Schepard

Bozzomo

J. W.

. 2003. “Efficiency, Therapeutic Justice, Mediation, and Evaluation: Reflections on a Survey of Unified Family Courts.” Family Law Quarterly 37:333–60.

56.

Shaffer

D. K.

2011. “Looking Inside the Black Box of Drug Courts: A Meta-Analytic Review.” Justice Quarterly 28:493–521.

57.

Shaw

T. V.

2010. “Reunification from Foster Care: Informing Measures over Time.” Children and Youth Services Review 32:485–91.

58.

Simmel

2012. “Highlighting Adolescents’ Involvement with the Child Welfare System: A Review of Recent Trends, Policy Developments, and Related Research.” Children and Youth Services Review 34:1197–207.

59.

StataCorp. 2009. Stata Statistical Software: Release 11. College Station, TX: StataCorp LP.

60.

Stein

D. M.

Deberard

Homan

. 2012. “Predicting Success and Failure in Juvenile Drug Treatment Court: A Meta-Analytic Review.” Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 44:159–68.

61.

Stone

2007. “Child Maltreatment, Out-of-Home Placement and Academic Vulnerability: A Fifteen-Year Review of Evidence and Future Directions.” Children and Youth Services Review 29:139–61.

62.

Taussig

H. N.

Clyman

R. B.

Landsverk

. 2001. “Children Who Return Home from Foster Care: A 6-year Prospective Study of Behavioral Health Outcomes in Adolescence.” Pediatrics 108:e10.

63.

Tribiano

J. J.

2012. Federal Register. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.

64.

Tsai

2000. “The Trend Toward Specialized Domestic Violence Courts: Improvements on an Effective Innovation.” Fordham Law Review 68:1285–327.

65.

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. 2008. Child Welfare Information Gateway: Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act of 2008. US Department of Health and Human Services. https://www.childwelfare.gov/systemwide/laws_policies/federal/index.cfm?event=federallegislation.viewlegis&id=121 Assessed April 18, 2013.

66.

Vanderploeg

Jeffrey J.

Connell

Christian M.

Caron

Colleen

Saunders

Leon

Katz

Karol H.

Tebes

Jacob Kraemer

. 2007. “The Impact of Parental Alcohol or Drug Removals on Foster Care Placement Experiences: A Matched Comparison Group Study.” Child Maltreatment 12:125–36.

67.

Waddell

MacMillan

Pietrantonio

A. M.

. 2004. “How Important Is Permanency Planning for Children? Considerations for Pediatricians Involved in Child Protection.” Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics 25:285–92.

68.

Waldron

H. B.

Turner

C.W.

. 2008. “Evidence-Based Psychosocial Treatments for Adolescent Substance Abuse.” Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology 37:238–61.

69.

Williams

R. J.

Change

S. Y.

. 2000. “A Comprehensive and Comparative Review of Adolescent Substance Abuse Treatment Outcome.” Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 7:138–66.

70.

Wooldridge

Jeffrey

. 2001. Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

71.

Worcel

Sonia D.

Furrer

Carrie J.

Green

Beth L.

Burrus

Scott W. M.

Finigan

Michael W.

. 2008. “Effects of Family Treatment Drug Courts on Substance Abuse and Child Welfare Outcomes.” Child Abuse Review 17:427–43.

72.

Wulczyn

Smithgall

Chen

. 2009. “Child Well-Being: The Intersection of Schools and Child Welfare.” Review of Research in Education 33:35–62.

73.

Zetlin

A. G.

Weinberg

L. A.

Kimm

. 2004. “Improving Education Outcomes for Children in Foster Care: Interventions by an Education Liaison.” Journal of Education for Students 9:421–29.