Evaluating Health Outcomes of Criminal Justice Populations Using Record Linkage: The Importance of Aliases

Abstract

Individuals in contact with the criminal justice system are a key population of concern to public health. Record linkage studies can be useful for studying health outcomes for this group, but the use of aliases complicates the process of linking records across databases. This study was undertaken to determine the impact of aliases on sensitivity and specificity of record linkage and how this affects ascertainment of mortality. Records for a cohort of prisoners were linked to methadone maintenance treatment (MMT) and mortality records. The record linkage was conducted in two stages. First, the linkage was undertaken using the participant’s name and date of birth as recorded in a prior study. Then, a second linkage was undertaken using these identifiers, plus all known aliases. Sensitivity was 64%, and specificity 100%, for the first linkage. When aliases were added to the linkage, sensitivity increased to 86% and specificity remained 100%. The standardized mortality ratio was 4.3 for the first linkage, increasing to 6.1 when aliases were used. These results suggest that the potential effects of participant aliases on linkage outcomes, and methods for mitigating these effects should be carefully considered when planning and undertaking record linkage studies with criminal justice populations.

Keywords

prisoners criminal justice record linkage alias

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Australian Bureau of Statistics. 2009. Causes of Death, 2007. Canberra: Australian Bureau of Statistics.

Begier, E.M. , Y. Bennani , L. Forgione , A. Punsalang , D.B. Hanna , J. Herrera , L. Torian , M. Gbur , K.A. Sepkowitz , and F. Parvez. 2010. ‘‘Undiagnosed HIV Infection Among New York City Jail Entrants, 2006: Results of a Blinded Serosurvey.’’ Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes 54:93-101.

Binswanger, I.A. , P.M. Krueger , and J.F. Steiner. 2009. ‘‘Prevalence of Chronic Medical Conditions Among Jail and Prison Inmates in the USA Compared With the General Population.’’ Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 63:912-9.

Binswanger, I.A. , M.F. Stern , R.A. Deyo , P.J. Heagerty , A. Cheadle , J.G. Elmore , and T.D. Koepsell. 2007. ‘‘Release From Prison-A High Risk of Death for Former Inmates.’’ New England Journal of Medicine 356:157-65.

Blakely, T. , and C. Salmond. 2002. ‘‘Probabilistic Record Linkage and a Method to Calculate the Positive Predictive Value.’’ International Journal of Epidemiology 31:1246-52.

Brook, E.L. , D.L. Rosman , and C.D.J. Holman. 2008. ‘‘Public Good Through Data Linkage: Measuring Research Outputs From the Western Australian Data Linkage System.’’ Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health 32:19-23.

Butler, T. , G. Andrews , S. Allnutt , C. Sakashita , N.E. Smith , and J. Basson. 2006. ‘‘Mental Disorders in Australian Prisoners: A Comparison With a Community Sample.’’ Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 40:272-6.

Dolan, K. , J. Shearer , M. MacDonald , R.P. Mattick , W. Hall , and A. Wodak. 2003. ‘‘A Randomised Controlled Trial of Methadone Maintenance Treatment Versus Wait List Control in an Australian Prison System.’’ Drug and Alcohol Dependence 72:59-65.

D’Souza, R.M. , T. Butler , and N. Petrovksy. 2005. ‘‘Assessment of Cardiovascular Disease Risk Factors and Diabetes Mellitus in Australian Prisons: Is the Prisoner Population Unhealthier Than the Rest of the Australian Population?’’ Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health 29:318-23.

10.

Gabriel, G. , T. Burns , R. Scott-Ram , R. Adlington , and L. Bansi. 2008. ‘‘Prevalence of Chlamydia trachomatis and Associated Risk Factors in Women Inmates Admitted to a Youth Offenders Institute in the UK.’’ International Journal of STD and AIDS 19:26-9.

11.

Jaro, M.A. 1995. ‘‘Probabilistic Linkage of Large Public-Health Data Files.’’ Statistics in Medicine 14:491-8.

12.

Kariminia, A. , T. Butler , S. Corben , J. Kaldor , M. Levy , and M. Law. 2005. ‘‘Mortality Among Prisoners: How Accurate is the Australian National Death Index?’’ Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health 29:572-5.

13.

Kariminia, A. , T. Butler , S.P. Corben , M.H. Levy , L. Grant , J. Kaldor , and M.G. Law. 2007. ‘‘Extreme Cause-Specific Mortality in a Cohort of Adult Prisoners-1988 to 2002: A Data-Linkage Study.’’ International Journal of Epidemiology 36:310-6.

14.

Kavanagh, L. , D. Rowe , J. Hersch , K.J. Barnett , and R. Reznik. 2010. ‘‘Neurocognitive Deficits and Psychiatric Disorders in a NSW Prison Population.’’ International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 33:20-6.

15.

Lawrence, G. , I. Dinh , and L. Taylor. 2008. ‘‘The Centre for Health Record Linkage: A New Resource for Health Services Research and Evaluation .’’ Health Information Management Journal 37:60-2.

16.

Martin, R.E. , T.G. Hislop , G.D. Grams , B. Calam , E. Jones , and V. Moravan. 2004. ‘‘Evaluation of a Cervical Cancer Screening Intervention for Prison Inmates.’’ Canadian Journal of Public Health 95:285-9.

17.

Martin, R.E. , T.G. Hislop , G.D. Grams , V. Moravan , and B. Calam. 2005. ‘‘Beware of Multiple Names in Database Linkage Research: Prevalence of Aliases in Female Prison Population.’’ British Medical Journal 331:335-6.

18.

Merrall, E.L.C. , A. Kariminia , I.A. Binswanger , M. Hobbs , M. Farrell , J. Marsden , S.J. Hutchinson , and S.M. Bird. 2010. ‘‘Meta-Analysis of Drug-Related Deaths Soon After Release From Prison.’’ Addiction 105:1545-54.

19.

Nakhaee, F. , A. McDonald , D. Black , and M. Law. 2007. ‘‘A Feasible Method for Linkage Studies Avoiding Clerical Review: Linkage of the National HIV/AIDS Surveillance Databases With the National Death Index in Australia. ’’ Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health 31:308-12.

20.

Odegard, E. , E. J. Amundsen, K.B. Kielland, and R. Kristoffersen. 2010. ‘‘The Contribution of Imprisonment and Release to Fatal Overdose Among a Cohort of Norwegian Drug Abusers.’’ Addiction Research and Theory 18:51-8.

21.

Rosen, D.L. , V.J. Schoenbach , and D.A. Wohl. 2008. ‘‘All-Cause and Cause-Specific Mortality Among Men Released From State Prison, 1980-2005. ’’ American Journal of Public Health 98:2278-84.