Can the writing ability of students really be assessed by using standardized, objective tests? This question is explored here along with a discussion of the alternatives and some advice for principals to help their English and language arts teachers con front the issue.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Akeju, S.A. "The Reliability of General Certification of Education Examination English Composition Papers in West Africa. " Journal of Educational Measurement9(1972).
2.
Ashburn, Robert. "An Experiment in the Essay-Type Question." In Readings in Educational and Psychological Measurement, edited by Chase and Ludlow.Boston : Houghton-Mifflin, 1966.
3.
Breland, Hunter, and Gaynor, Judith. "A Comparison of Direct and Indirect Assessments of Writing Skill ." Journal of Educational Measurement, Summer 1979.
4.
Bridgeford, Nancy, and Stiggins, Richard.A Consumer's Guide to Writing Assessment. Portland, Oreg.: Northwest Regional Educational Laboratory, 1980.
5.
Charney, David. "The Validity of Using Holistic Scoring To Evaluate Writing: A Critical Overview." Research in the Teaching of English, February 1984.
6.
Coffman, William. "On the Reliability of Ratings of Essay Examinations in English." Research in the Teaching of English5( 1971).
7.
Cooper, Charles. "Measuring Growth in Writing." English Journal, March 1975.
8.
_. "Holistic Evaluation of Writing." In Evaluating Writing , edited by Cooper and Odell.Urbana, Ill.: National Council of Teachers of English, 1974.
9.
Davis, Barbara; Scriven, Michael; and Thomas, Susan.The Evaluation of English Instruction. Inverness, Calif. : Edge-press, 1981.
10.
Diedrich, Paul.Measuring Growth in English. Urbana, Ill.: NCTE, 1974.
11.
Godshalk, F.I.: Swineford, S.; and Coffman, W.E.The Measurement of Writing Ability. New York: College Board, 1966.
12.
Lloyd-Jones, Richard. "Primary Trait Scoring." In Evaluating Writing, edited by Cooper and Odell.Urbana, Ill.: NCTE, 1974.
13.
McColly, William. "What Does Research Say About the Judging of Writing Ability?" Journal of Educational Research, December 1970.
14.
Myers, Miles.A Procedure for Writing Assessment and Holistic Scoring. Urbana, Ill.: NCTE, 1981.
15.
Odell, Lee. "Defining and Assessing Competence in Writing." In The Nature and Measurement of Competency in English, edited by Cooper.Urbana, Ill.: NCTE, 1981.
16.
Palmer, Orville. "Sense or Nonsense? The Objective Testing of English Composition." English Journal, May 1961.
17.
Purves, Alan, et al. CommonSense and Testing in English. Urbana, Ill.: NCTE, 1975.
18.
Sanders, Sara, and Littlefield, John. "Perhaps Test Essays Can Reflect Significant Improvement in Freshman Composition: Report of a Successful Attempt." Research in the Teaching of English9( 1975).
19.
Slotnick, Henry B. "Toward a Theory of Computer Essay Grading." Journal of Educational Measurement9( 1972).
20.
Spandel, Vicki, and Stiggins, Richard.Direct Measures of Writing Skill: Issues and Applications. Portland, Oreg.: Northwest Regional Laboratory, 1980.
Stiggins, Richard. "A Comparison of Direct and Indirect Writing Assessment Methods." Research in the Teaching of English16( 1982).
23.
Veal, Ramon, and Hudson, Sally. "Direct and Indirect Measures for Large Scale Evaluation of Writing ." Research in the Teaching of English, October 1983.
