Abundant evidence now is available that free radicals are produced in excess when
myocardium is reperfused following an episode of ischemia and that free radicals
can injure myocytes and endothelial cells. Free radicals may contribute to
either reversible or irreversible manifestations of cell injury from ischemia
and reperfusion. Several investigators have observed that postischemic
contractile dysfunction (myocardial stunning) can be attenuated by a variety of
anti-free radical therapies, and there seems to be general agreement that free
radical injury contributes to stunning. Whether free radicals are an important
cause of lethal myocyte injury (“lethal reperfusion injury”) remains
controversial. Using similar interventions and animal models, both positive and
negative results have been reported from a growing number of studies done to
test the effect of anti-free radical therapies on infarct size. Proposed
explanations include differences in: 1) dose of drug and onset or duration of
treatment, 2) duration of occlusion or reperfusion, 3) methods of measuring
infarct size or area at risk, and 4) failure of some studies to control for
baseline variation in the major determinants of infarct size, e.g., collateral
blood flow. At present, none of these explanations seems sufficient to resolve
the question.
ArforsK-E, LundbergC, LindbomL, LundbergK, BeattyPG, and HarlanJM (1987). A
monoclonal antibody to the membrane glycoprotein complex CD18 inhibits
polymorphonuclear leukocyte accumulation and plasma leakage in
vivo. Blood69: 338–340.
2.
ArroyoCM, KramerJH, DickensBF, and WeglickiWB (1987).
Identification of free radicals in myocardial
ischemia/reperfusion by spin trapping with nitrone DMPO.
FEBS Lett.221: 101–104.
3.
BednarM, SmithB, PintoA, and MullaneKM (1985).
Nafazatrom-induced salvage of ischemic myocardium in
anesthetized dogs is mediated through inhibition of neutrophil
function. Circ. Res.57: 131–141.
4.
BernierM, HearseDJ, and ManningAS (1986).
Reperfusion-induced arrhythmias and oxygen free radicals:
Studies with “anti-free radical” interventions and a free radical generating
system in the isolated perfused rat heart. Circ.
Res.58: 331–340.
5.
BolliR, PatelBS, JeroudiMO, LaiEK, and McCayPB (1988).
Demonstration of free radical generation in “stunned”
myocardium of intact dogs with the use of the spin trap alpha-Phenyl
N-Tert-Butyl Nitrone. J. Clin. Invest.82: 476–485.
6.
BolliR, PatelBS, ZhuW-X, HartleyCJ, CharlatML, and RobertsR (1987). The
iron chelator desferoxamine attenuates postischemic ventricular
dysfunction. Am. J. Physiol.253:
H1372–H1380.
7.
BolliR, ZhuW-X, HartleyCJ, MichaelLH, RepineJ, HessML, KukrejaRC, and RobertsR (1987).
Attenuation of dysfunction in the postischemic “stunned”
myocardium by dimethylthiourea. Circulation76: 458–468.
8.
ChambersDE, ParksDA, PattersonG, RoyR, McCordJM, YoshidaS, ParmleyLF, and DowneyJM (1985).
Xanthine oxidase as a source of free radical damage in
myocardial ischemia. J. Mol. Cell. Cardiol.17: 145–152.
9.
CiuffoAA, OuyangP, BeckerLC, LevinL, and WeisfeldtML (1985).
Reduction of sympathetic inotropic response after ischemia in
dogs. Contributor to stunned myocardium. J. Clin.
Invest.75: 1504–1509.
10.
CrapoJD, FreemanBA, BarryBE, TurrensJF, and YoungSL (1983).
Mechanisms of hyperoxic injury to the pulmonary
microcirculation. Physiologist26: 170–176.
11.
DeBoerLWV, IngwallJS, KlonerRA, and BraunwaldE (1980).
Prolonged derangements of canine myocardial purine metabolism
after a brief coronary artery occlusion not associated with anatomic
evidence of necrosis. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.
USA77: 5471–5475.
12.
EddyLJ, StewartJR, JonesHP, EngersonTD, McCordJM, and DowneyJM (1987).
Free radical-producing enzyme, xanthine oxidase, is
undetectable in human hearts. Am. J.
Physiol.253: H709–H711.
13.
EllisSG, HenschkeCI, SandorT, WynneJ, BraunwaldE, and KlonerRA (1983).
Time course of functional and biochemical recovery of
myocardium salvaged by reperfusion. J. Am. Coll.
Cardiol.1: 1047–1055.
14.
EnglerRL, DahlgrenMD, PetersonMA, DobbsA, and
Schmid-SchonbeinGW (1986).
Accumulation of polymorphonuclear leukocytes during 3-h
experimental myocardial ischemia. Am. J.
Physiol.251: H93–H100.
15.
EnglerRL,
Schmid-SchonbeinGW, and PavelecRS (1983).
Leukocyte capillary plugging in myocardial ischemia and
reperfusion in dogs. Am. J. Pathol.111: 98–111.
16.
FantoneJC and WardPA (1982).
Role of oxygen-derived free radicals and metabolites in
leukocyte-dependent inflammatory reactions. Am. J.
Pathol.107: 397–418.
17.
FarberNE, VercellottiGM, JacobHS, PieperGM, and GrossGJ (1988).
Evidence for a role of iron-catalyzed oxidants in functional
and metabolic stunning in the canine heart. Circ.
Res.63: 351–360.
18.
FlammES, DemopoulosHB, SeligmanML, PoserRG, and RansohoffJ (1978). Free
radicals in cerebral ischemia. Stroke9: 445–447.
19.
FreemanBA and CrapoJD (1982).
Biology of disease. Free radicals and tissue
injury. Lab. Invest.47: 412–426.
20.
FridovichI (1978). The
biology of oxygen radicals. Science201: 875–880.
21.
GallagherKP, BudaAJ, PaceD, GerrenRA, and ShlaferM (1986).
Failure of superoxide dismutase and catalase to alter size of
infarction in conscious dogs after 3 hours of occlusion followed by
reperfusion. Circulation74: 1424–1433.
22.
GarlickPB, DaviesMJ, HearseDJ, and SlaterTF (1987).
Direct detection of free radicals in the reperfused rat heart
using electron spin resonance spectroscopy. Circ.
Res.61: 757–760.
23.
GlowerDD, SprattJA, NewtonJR, WolfeJA, RankinJS, and SwainJL (1987).
Dissociation between early recovery of regional function and
purine nucleotide content in postischaemic myocardium in the conscious
dog. Cardiovasc. Res.21: 328–336.
24.
GoLO, MurryCE, RichardVJ, WeischedelGR, JenningsRB, and ReimerKA (1988).
Myocardial neutrophil accumulation during reperfusion after
reversible and irreversible ischemic injury. Am. J.
Physiol.255:
H1188–H1198.
25.
GrangerDN, RutiliG, and McCordJM (1981).
Superoxide radicals in feline intestinal
ischemia. Gastroenterology81: 22–29.
26.
GrankvistK, MarklundS, SehlinJ, and TaljedalIB (1979).
Superoxide dismutase, catalase, and scavengers of hydroxyl
radical protect against the toxic action of alloxan on pancreatic islet
tissue in vitro. Biochem. J.182: 17–25.
27.
GrossGJ, FarberNE, HardmanHF, and WarltierDC (1986).
Beneficial effects of superoxide dismutase and catalase in
stunned myocardium of dogs. Am. J. Physiol.250: H372–H377.
28.
GrumCM, RagsdaleRA, KetaiLH, and ShlaferM (1986).
Absence of xanthine oxidase or xanthine dehydrogenase in the
rabbit myocardium. Biochem. Biophys. Res.
Comm.141: 1104–1108.
29.
HearseDJ and TosakiA (1987). Free
radicals and reperfusion-induced arrhythmias: Protection by spin trap agent
PBN in the rat heart. Circ. Res.60: 375–383.
30.
HeyndrickxGR, MillardRW, McRitchieRJ, MarokoPR, and VatnerSF (1975).
Regional myocardial functional and electrophysiological
alterations after brief coronary artery occlusion in conscious
dogs. J. Clin. Invest.56: 978–985.
31.
HoffmeisterHM, MauserM, and SchaperW (1985).
Effect of adenosine and AICAR on ATP content and regional
contractile function in reperfused canine myocardium.
Bas. Res. Cardiol.80: 445–458.
32.
ItoBR, TateH, KobayashiM, and SchaperW (1987).
Reversibly injured, postischemic canine myocardium retains
normal contractile reserve. Circ. Res.61: 834–846.
33.
JenningsRB and ReimerKA (1981).
Lethal myocardial ischemic injury.
Am. J. Pathol.102: 241–255.
34.
JenningsRB and ReimerKA (1983).
Factors involved in salvaging ischemic myocardium: Effect of
reperfusion of arterial blood. Circulation68: 125–136.
35.
JenningsRB, ReimerKA, and
SteenbergenC (1986).
Myocardial ischemia revisited. The osmolar load, membrane
damage, and reperfusion. J. Mol. Cell.
Cardiol.18: 769–780.
36.
JenningsRB, SchaperJ, HillML, SteenbergenCJr, and
ReimerKA (1985).
Effect of reperfusion late in the phase of reversible
ischemic injury. Changes in cell volume, electrolytes, metabolites and
ultrastructure. Circ. Res.56: 262–278.
37.
JenningsRB, SommersHM, SmythGA, FlackHH, and LinnH (1960).
Myocardial necrosis induced by temporary occlusion of a
coronary artery in the dog. Arch. Pathol.70: 68–78.
38.
JollySR, KaneWJ, BailieMB, AbramsGD, and LucchesiBR (1984).
Canine myocardial reperfusion injury: Its reduction by the
combined administration of superoxide dismutase and
catalase. Circ. Res.54: 277–285.
39.
JollySR, KaneWJ, HookBG, AbramsGD, KunkelSL, and LucchesiBR (1986).
Reduction of myocardial infarct size by neutrophil depletion:
Effect of duration of occlusion. Am. Heart
J.112: 682–690.
40.
JollySR and LucchesiBR (1983).
Effect of BW755 in an occlusion-reperfusion model of ischemic
myocardial injury. Am. Heart J.106: 8–13.
41.
KrauseSM and HessML (1984).
Characterization of cardiac sarcoplasmic reticulum
dysfunction during short-term, normothermic, global
ischemia. Circ. Res.55: 176–184.
42.
KusuokaH, PorterfieldJ, WeismanHF, WeisfeldtML, and MarbanE (1987).
Pathophysiology and pathogenesis of stunned myocardium.
Depressed Ca2+ activation of contraction as a consequence of
reperfusion-induced cellular calcium overload in ferret
hearts. J. Clin. Invest.79: 950–961.
43.
LazdunskiM, FrelinC, and VigneP (1985). The
sodium/hydrogen exchange system in cardiac cells: Its biochemical and
pharmacological properties and its role in regulating internal
concentrations of sodium and internal pH. J. Mol.
Cell. Cardiol.17: 1028–1042.
44.
LittMR, JeremyRW, WeismanHF, WinkelsteinJA, and BeckerLC (1989).
Neutrophil depletion limited to reperfusion reduces
myocardial infarct size after 90 minutes of ischemia: Evidence for
neutrophil-mediated reperfusion injury.
Circulation80: 1816–1827.
45.
MansonPN, AnthenelliRM, ImMJ, BulkleyGB, and HoopesJE (1983). The
role of oxygen free radicals in ischemic tissue injury in island skin
flaps. Ann. Surg.198: 87–90.
46.
MatsudaM, FujiwaraH, OnoderaT, WuD-J, KawamuraA, IshidaM, TakemuraG, KidaM, UegaitoT, FujiwaraY, and FujiwaraT (1988).
Failure to reduce infarct size by intracoronary infusion of
human superoxide dismutase at reperfusion in the pig heart:
Immunohistochemical and histological analysis.
Circulation78: 11–372.
(Abstract.)
47.
McCordJM (1985).
Oxygen-derived radicals in postischemic tissue
injury. N. Engl. J. Med.312: 158–163.
48.
MullaneKM, ReadN, SalmonJA, and MoncadaS (1984). Role
of leukocytes in acute myocardial infarction in anesthetized dogs:
Relationship to myocardial salvage by anti-inflammatory
drugs. J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther.228: 510–522.
49.
MurphyJG, SmithTW, and MarshJD (1988).
Mechanisms of reoxygenation-induced calcium overload in
cultured chick embryo heart cells. Am. J.
Physiol.254:
H1133–H1141.
50.
MurryCE, RichardVJ, JenningsRB, and ReimerKA (1989).
Free radicals do not cause myocardial stunning after four 5
minute coronary occlusions. Circulation80: 296. (Abstract.)
51.
MuxfeldtM and SchaperW (1987). The
activity of xanthine oxidase in hearts of pigs, rabbits, rats and
humans. Bas. Res. Cardiol.82: 486–492.
52.
MyersML, BolliR, LekichR, HartleyCJ, and RobertsR (1985).
Enhancement of recovery of myocardial function by oxygen
free-radical scavengers after reversible regional ischemia.
Circulation72: 915–921.
53.
NaslundU, HaggmarkS, JohanssonG, MarklundSL, ReizS, and ObergA (1986).
Superoxide dismutase and catalase reduce infarct size in a
porcine myocardial occlusion-reperfusion model. J.
Mol. Cell. Cardiol.18: 1077–1084.
54.
NejimaJ, KnightDR, FallonJT, UemuraN, MandersWT, CanfieldDR, CohenMV, and VatnerSF (1989).
Superoxide dismutase reduces reperfusion arrhythmias but
fails to salvage regional function of myocardium at risk in conscious
dogs. Circulation79: 143–153.
55.
ParksDA, BulkleyGB, and GrangerDN (1983).
Role of free radicals in shock, ischemia, and organ
preservation. Surgery94: 428–432.
56.
ParksDA, BulkleyGB, GrangerDN, HamiltonSR, and McCordJM (1982).
Ischemic injury in the cat small intestine: Role of
superoxide radicals. Gastroenterology82: 9–15.
57.
PatelB, JeroudiMO, O'NeillPG, RobertsR, and BolliR (1988).
Human superoxide dismutase fails to limit infarct size after
2-h ischemia and reperfusion. Circulation78: 11–373.
(Abstract.)
58.
PrzyklenkK and KlonerRA (1989).
“Reperfusion injury” by oxygen-derived free radicals? Effect
of superoxide dismutase plus catalase, given at the time of reperfusion, on
myocardial infarct size, contractile function, coronary microvasculature,
and regional myocardial blood flow. Circ.
Res.64: 86–96.
59.
RecknagelRO, GlendeEAJr,
UgazioG, KochRR, and
SrinivasanS (1974). New
data in support of the lipoperoxidation theory for carbon tetrachloride
liver injury. In: International Symposium on
Hepatotoxicity, EliakimM., EscharJ, and ZimmermanHJ (eds). Academic
Press, London, pp.
7–17.
60.
ReimerKA, HillML, and JenningsRB (1981).
Prolonged depletion of ATP and of the adenine nucleotide pool
due to delayed resynthesis of adenine nucleotides following reversible
myocardial ischemic injury in dogs. J. Mol. Cell.
Cardiol.13: 229–239.
61.
ReimerKA and JenningsRB (1979). The
“wavefront phenomenon” of myocardial ischemic cell death. II. Transmural
progression of necrosis within the framework of ischemic bed size
(myocardium at risk) and collateral flow. Lab.
Invest.40: 633–644.
62.
ReimerKA, MurryCE, and RichardVJ (1989). The
role of neutrophils and free radicals in the ischemic-reperfused heart: Why
the confusion and controversy?J. Mol. Cell. Cardiol.21: 1225–1239.
63.
ReimerKA, MurryCE, YamasawaI, HillML, and JenningsRB (1986).
Four brief periods of myocardial ischemia cause no cumulative
ATP loss or necrosis. Am. J. Physiol.251:
H1306–H1315.
64.
RichardVJ, MurryCE, JenningsRB, and ReimerKA (1988).
Therapy to reduce free radicals during early reperfusion does
not limit the size of myocardial infarcts caused by 90 minutes of ischemia
in dogs. Circulation78: 473–480.
65.
RomsonJL, HookBG, KunkelSL, AbramsGD, SchorkMA, and LucchesiBR (1983).
Reduction of the extent of myocardial injury by neutrophil
depletion in the dog. Circulation67: 1016–1023.
66.
RomsonJL, HookBG, RigotVH, SchorkMA, SwansonDP, and LucchesiBR (1982). The
effect of ibu-profen on accumulation of Indium-111 labeled platelets and
leukocytes in experimental myocardial infarction.
Circulation66: 1002–1011.
67.
RosenkranzER and BuckbergGD (1983).
Myocardial protection during surgical coronary
reperfusion. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol.1: 1235–1246.
68.
SchreiberRD and
Muller-EberhardHJ (1979).
Complement and renal disease. In:
Immunologic Mechanisms of Renal Disease,
WilsonCB (ed). Churchill
Livingston, London, pp.
67–105.
69.
ShawS (1987).
Characterization of human leukocyte differentiation
antigens. Immunol. Today8: 1–3.
70.
SheaMJ, MurtaghJJ, JollySR, AbramsGD, PittB, and LucchesiBR (1984).
Beneficial effects of nafa-zatrom on ischemic reperfused
myocardium. Eur. J. Pharmacol.102: 63–70.
71.
ShiratoC, MiuraT, OoiwaH, ToyofukuT, WilbornWH, and DowneyJM (1989).
Tetrazolium artifactually indicates superoxide
dismutase-induced salvage in reperfused rabbit heart.
J. Mol. Cell. Cardiol.21: 1187–1193.
72.
SimpsonPJ, FantoneJC, MickelsonJK, GallagherKP, and LucchesiBR (1988).
Identification of a time window for therapy to reduce
experimental canine myocardial injury: Suppression of neutrophil activation
during 72 hours of reperfusion. Circ. Res.63: 1070–1079.
73.
SimpsonPJ, MickelsonJK, FantoneJC, GallagherKP, and LucchesiBR (1987).
Iloprost inhibits neutrophil function in vitro and in vivo
and limits experimental infarct size in canine heart.
Circ. Res.69: 666–673.
74.
SimpsonPJ, MitsosSE, VenturaA, GallagherKP, FantoneJC, AbramsGD, SchorkMA, and LucchesiBR (1987).
Prostacyclin protects ischemic-reperfused myocardium in the
dog by inhibition of neutrophil activation. Am.
Heart J.113: 129–137.
75.
SimpsonPJ, ToddRFIII,
FantoneJC, MickelsonJK, GriffinJD, and LucchesiBR (1988).
Reduction of experimental canine myocardial reperfusion
injury by a monoclonal antibody (anti Mol, anti CD11b) that inhibits
leukocyte adhesion. J. Clin. Invest.81: 624–629.
76.
SwainJL, SabinaRL, McHalePA, GreenfieldJCJr, and
HolmesEW (1982).
Prolonged myocardial adenine nucleotide depletion after brief
ischemia in the open-chest dog. Am. J.
Physiol.242: H818–H826.
77.
TamuraY, ChiL, DriscollEM, HoffPT, FreemanBA, GallagherKP, and LucchesiBR (1988).
Superoxide dismutase conjugated to polyethylene glycol
provides sustained protection against myocardial ischemia/reperfusion injury
in canine heart. Circ. Res.63: 944–959.
78.
TanakaM, BrooksSE, FitzHarrisGP, StolerRC, JenningsRB, and ReimerKA (1990).
Effect of the IB4anti-CD18 antibody on myocardial
PMN accumulation and infarct size in dogs. Faseb
J.18: A1020. (Abstract.)
79.
TanakaM, StolerRC, FitzHarrisGP, JenningsRB, and ReimerKA (1990).
Evidence against the “early protection-delayed death”
hypothesis of superoxide dismutase therapy in experimental myocardial
infarction. Polyethylene glycol-superoxide dismutase plus catalase does not
limit myocardial infarct size in dogs. Circ.
Res.67: 636–644.
80.
UraizeeA, ReimerKA, MurryCE, and JenningsRB (1987).
Failure of superoxide dismutase to limit size of myocardial
infarction after 40 minutes of ischemia and 4 days of reperfusion in
dogs. Circulation75: 1237–1248.
81.
VedderNB, WinnRK, RiceCL, ChiEY, ArforsKE, and HarlanJM (1988). A
monoclonal antibody to the adherence-promoting leukocyte glycoprotein,
CD-18, reduces organ injury and improves survival from hemorrhagic shock and
resuscitation in rabbits. J. Clin. Invest.81: 939–944.
82.
WeinerJM, ApsteinCS, ArthurJH, PirzadaFA, and HoodWBJr (1976).
Persistence of myocardial injury following brief periods of
coronary occlusion. Cardiovasc. Res.10: 678–686.
83.
WeissSJ and Lo BulgioAF (1982).
Biology of disease: Phagocyte-generated oxygen metabolites
and cellular injury. Lab. Invest.47: 5–18.
84.
WernsSW, SheaMJ, DriscollEM, CohenC, AbramsGD, PittB, and LucchesiBR (1985). The
independent effects of oxygen radical scavengers on canine infarct size:
Reduction by superoxide dismutase but not catalase.
Circ. Res.56: 895–898.
85.
WernsSW, SimpsonPJ, MickelsonJK, SheaMJ, PittB, and LucchesiBR (1988).
Sustained limitation by superoxide dismutase of canine
myocardial injury due to regional ischemia followed by
reperfusion. J. Cardiovasc. Pharmacol.11: 36–44.
86.
WinegradS (1984).
Regulation of cardiac contractile proteins. Correlations
between physiology and biochemistry. Circ.
Res.55: 565–574.
87.
WinterbournCC (1981).
Production of hydroxyl radicals from paraquat radicals and
H2O2. FEBS Lett.128: 339–342.
88.
ZweierJL, FlahertyJT, and WeisfeldtML (1987).
Direct measurement of free radical generation following
reperfusion of ischemic myocardium. Proc. Natl.
Acad. Sci. USA84: 1404–1407.
89.
ZweierJL, RayburnBK, FlahertyJT, and WeisfeldtML (1987).
Recombinant superoxide dismutase reduces oxygen free radical
concentrations in reperfused myocardium. J. Clin.
Invest.80: 1728–1734.
