From “Crying Expands the Lungs” to “You’re Going to Spoil That Baby”: How the Cry-It-Out Method Became Authoritative Knowledge

Abstract

The cry-it-out (CIO) method is a sleep training method that encourage parents to let their infants cry at night by themselves for increments of time in order to get them to eventually sleep through the night, on their own. The purpose of this analysis is to explore how the CIO method was constructed as authoritative knowledge to become a normative practice among modern parents. Drawing on various forms of media relevant to laying the groundwork for the promotion of the CIO method over the last 200 years, we examine how parents’ methods for getting babies to sleep have changed. We then argue that the CIO method ascended as authoritative knowledge mostly via the use of fear-based messages, enabling parents to feel validated when they decide to ignore their infants’ nighttime cries so that they can achieve better household sleep.

Keywords

Parent-child communication sleep historical topic

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ainsworth

M. D.

Blehar

Waters

Wall

(1978). Patterns of attachment: A psychological study of the strange situation. Erlbaum.

Alcott

W. A.

(1839). The young mother, or, management of children in regard to health. George W. Light.

Antonucci

T. C.

Mikus

(1998). The power of parenthood: Personality and attitudinal changes during the transition to parenthood. In Michaels

G. Y.

Goldberg

W. A.

(Eds.), The transition to parenthood: Current theory and research. Cambridge University Press.

Apple

R. M.

(1995). Constructing mothers: Scientific motherhood in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Social History of Medicine, 8(2), 161–178.

Barton

E. A.

Ratner

H. H.

(2001). Perceptions of “spoiling” and its relations to experience and ethnicity. In Occasional Paper Series, 2, Detroit, MI: Wayne State University, College of Urban, Labor, and Metropolitan Affairs.

Berger

P. L.

Luckmann

(1966). The social construction of reality: A treatise in the sociology of knowledge. Anchor Books.

Bigelow

K. M.

Morris

E. K.

(2001). John B. Watson’s advice on child rearing: Some historical context. Behavioral Development Bulletin, 1, 26–30.

Blum

(2002). Love at goon park: Harry Harlow and the science of affection. Berkeley Publishing (Penguin).

Boyd

(2008, February 7). Do people only use 10 percent of their brains? What’s the matter with only exploiting a portion of our gray matter? https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/do-people-only-use-10-percent-of-their-brains/

10.

Browner

C. H.

Press

(1996). The production of authoritative knowledge in American prenatal care. Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 10(2), 141–156.

11.

Bryson

(2010). At home: A short history of private life. New York: Doubleday.

12.

Burchinal

Skinner

Reznick

J. S.

(2010). European American and African American mothers’ beliefs about parenting and disciplining infants: A mixed-method analysis. Parenting, 10(2), 79–96.

13.

Cassell

Petter

Galpin , (1869). Cassell’s Household Guide: A complete encyclopedia of domestic and social economy and forming a guide to every department of practical life. Ludgate Hill.

14.

Davies

(1995). Babies co-sleeping with parents. Midwives: Official Journal of the Royal College of Midwives, 108, 384–386.

15.

Davis-Floyd

R. E.

Sargent

C. F.

(1997). Childbirth and authoritative knowledge: Cross-cultural perspectives. University of California Press.

16.

Dell

(1930). Love in the machine age: A psychological study of the transition from patriarchal society. Farrar & Rinchart.

17.

DeStefano

(2007). Vaccines and autism: Evidence does not support a causal association. Clinical Pharmacology & Therapeutics, 82, 756–759.

18.

Douglas

P. S.

Hill

P. S.

(2013). Behavioral sleep interventions in the first six months of life do not improve outcomes for mothers or infants: A systematic review. Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, 34(7), 497–507.

19.

Dunn

P. M.

(2000). Dr. Emmett Holt (1855–1924) and the foundation of North American pediatrics. Archives of Disease in Childhood—Fetal and Neonatal Edition, 83(3), 221–223.

20.

Ekirch

A. R.

(2006). At day’s close: Night in times past. W. W. Norton & Company.

21.

Elek

S. M.

Hudson

D. B.

Fleck

M. O.

(2002). Couples’ experiences with fatigue during the transition to parenthood. Journal of Family Nursing, 8(3), 221–240.

22.

Ellison

M. A.

(2003). Authoritative knowledge and single women’s unintentional pregnancies, abortions, adoption, and single motherhood: Social stigma and structural violence. Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 17(3), 322–347.

23.

Emerson

W. R. P.

(December, 1923). Does your child get tired? Good Housekeeping. 36–39.

24.

Ezzo

Buckman

(2012). On becoming babywise. Parentwise Solutions, Inc.

25.

Farrington

C. P.

Miller

Taylor

(2001). MMR and autism: Further evidence against a causal association. Vaccine, 19(27), 3632–3635.

26.

Ferber

(1985). Solve your child’s sleep problems. Touchstone.

27.

Fleiss

Hodges

F. M.

(2000). Sweet dreams: A pediatrician’s secrets for baby’s good night’s sleep. Lowell House.

28.

Fullerton

A. M.

(1911). A handbook of obstetric nursing for nurses, students, and mothers. Blakiston’s Son & Company.

29.

Furstenberg

F. F.

(1966). Industrialization and the American family: A look backward. American Sociological Review, 31(3), 326–337.

30.

Gardner

Campbell

(1991). Assessing postpartum fatigue. American Journal of Maternal Child Nursing, 16, 264–266.

31.

Germo

G. R.

Goldberg

W. A.

Keller

M. A.

(2009). Learning to sleep through the night: Solution or strain for mothers and young children? Infant Mental Health Journal, 30(3), 223–244.

32.

Giordano

Abidin

(2006). Twelve hours’ sleep by twelve weeks old: A step-by-step plan for baby sleep success. Penguin Random House.

33.

Gradisar

Jackson

Spurrier

N. J.

Gibson

Whitham

Williams

A. S.

Dolby

Kennaway

D. J.

(2016). Behavioral interventions for infant sleep problems: A randomized controlled trial. Pediatrics, 137(6), e20151486.

34.

Grattan

T. C.

(1859). Civilized America. Bradbury and Evans.

35.

Griscom

J. H.

(1848). The uses and abuses of air: Showing its influence in sustaining life and producing disease. Redfield.

36.

Gunnar

M. R.

Quevedo

K. M.

(2007a). Early care experiences and HPA axis regulation in children: a mechanism for later trauma vulnerability. Progress in Brain Research, 167, 137–149

37.

Gunnar

M. R.

Quevedo

K. M.

(2007b). The neurobiology of stress and development. Annual Review of Psychology, 58, 145–173.

38.

Hall

W. W.

(1870). Sleep: Or the hygiene of the night. Montreal: Dawson Brothers Publishing.

39.

Henley

M. M.

(2015). Alternative and authoritative knowledge: The role of certification for defining expertise among doulas. Social Currents, 2(3), 260–279.

40.

Hiscock

Fisher

(2015). Sleeping like a baby? Infant sleep: Impact on caregivers and current controversies. Journal of Paediatric Child Health, 51(4), 361–364.

41.

Holt

E. F.

(1892). From attic to cellar or housekeeping made easy. The Salem Press Publishing and Printing Company.

42.

Holt

L. E.

(1892). The care and feeding of children: A catechism for the use of mothers and children nurses. D. Appleton & Company.

43.

Howson

(2018). “I see no other option:” Maternal practices of sleep-training and co-sleeping as the management of vulnerability. Studies in the Maternal, 10(1), 1.

44.

Humphreys

(2002). No safe place: Disease and panic in American history. American Literary History, 14(4), 845–857.

45.

Jackson

(1989). Three in a bed: The benefits of sleeping with your baby. Bloomsbury.

46.

Jordan

(1992). Technology and social interaction: Notes on achievement of authoritative knowledge. IRL Technical Report IRL 92-0027. Institute for Research Institute on Learning.

47.

Jordan

Davis-Floyd

(1993). Birth in four cultures: A crosscultural investigation of childbirth in Yucatan, Holland, Sweden, and the United States. Waveland.

48.

Lee

G. M.

Friedman

J. F.

Ross-Degnan

Hibberd

P. L.

Goldman

D. A.

(2003). Misconceptions about colds and predictors of health service utilization. Pediatrics, 111(2), 231–236.

49.

Mavor

(1819). Catechism of health: Containing simple and easy rules and directions for the management of children and observations of the conduct of health in general for the use of schools and families. Samuel Wood & Sons.

50.

McKenna

J. J.

Gettler

L. T.

(2007). Cultural influences on infant and childhood sleep biology and the science that studies it: Toward a more inclusive paradigm, part II. In Loughlin

G. M.

Carroll

J. L.

Marcus

C. L.

(eds.), Sleep in children: Developmental changes in sleep patterns. Marcel Dekker.

51.

McKenna

J. J.

Gettler

L. T.

(2016). There is no such thing as infant sleep, there is no such thing as breastfeeding, there is only breastsleeping. Acta Paediatrica, 105(1), 17–21.

52.

McKenna

J. J.

Thoman

E. B.

Anders

T. F.

Sadeh

Schechtman

V. L.

Glotzbach

S. F.

(1993). Infant-parent co-sleeping in an evolutionary perspective: Implications for understanding infant sleep development and the sudden infant death syndrome. Sleep, 16(3), 263–282.

53.

Nash

(2007). Inescapable ecologies: A history of environment, disease, and knowledge. University of California Press.

54.

Pascoe

J. M.

Solomon

(1994). Prenatal correlates of indigent mother’s attitudes about spoiling their young infants: A longitudinal study. Developmental Behavioral Pediatrics, 15(3), 367–369.

55.

Patterson

K. D.

(1992). Yellow fever epidemics and mortality in the United States, 1693–1905. Social Science & Medicine, 34(8), 855–865.

56.

Radford

(1999, March). The ten percent myth. The Skeptical Inquirer, 23(2).

57.

Ramos

K. D.

Youngclarke

D. M.

(2006). Parenting advice books about child sleep: Cosleeping and crying it out. Sleep, 29(12), 1616–1623.

58.

Rees

(2016). Industrialization and urbanization in the United States, 1880–1929. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of American History.

59.

Richardson

B. W.

(1880). Appleton’s journal: A magazine of general literature: New series–Vol. VIII. D. Appleton and Company.

60.

Rosenberg

(1987). The care of strangers: The rise of America’s hospital system. Johns Hopkins University Press.

61.

Rothbart

M. K.

Ziaie

O’Boyle

C. G.

(1992). Self-regulation and emotion in infancy. New directions for child and adolescent development, 1992(55), 7–23.

62.

Ruchala

P. L.

Halstead

(1994). The postpartum experience of low-risk women: A time of adjustment and change. Maternal Child Nursing Journal, 22(3), 83–89.

63.

Salzinger

(1994). On Watson. In Todd

J. T.

Morris

E. K.

(Eds.). Modern perspectives on John B. Watson and classical behaviorism (pp. 151–158). Greenwood.

64.

Senn

M. J. E.

(1975). Insights on the child development movement in the United States. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 40(3–4, Serial No. 161).

65.

Small

M. F.

(1999). Our babies, ourselves: How biology and culture shape the way we parent. Anchor Books.

66.

Smith

(2016). The Ferber method and other behavioral sleep training methods: Do they disrupt attachment and impact physical and psychological wellbeing? Nursing Masters, Paper 31.

67.

Smyke

A. T.

Boris

N. W.

Alexander

G. M.

(2002). Fear of spoiling in at-risk African American mothers. Child Psychiatry and Human Development, 32(4), 295–307.

68.

Socolar

R. R. S.

Stein

R. E. K.

(1995). Spanking infants and toddlers: Maternal belief and practice. Pediatrics, 95, 105–111.

69.

Solomon

Martin

Cottington

(1993). Spoiling an infant: Further support for the construct. Topics in Early Childhood Special Education, 13, 175–183.

70.

Solter

(2004). Crying for comfort: Distressed babies need to be held. Mothering Magazine, 122.

71.

Spock

(1946). The common-sense book of baby and childcare. Duell, Sloan and Pearce.

72.

Starr

(1982). The social transformation of American medicine: The rise of a sovereign profession and the making of a vast industry. Basic Books.

73.

Stearns

P. N.

Rowland

Giarnella

(1996). Children’s sleep: Sketching historical change. Journal of Social History, 30(2), 345–366.

74.

Tannenbaum

M. B.

Helper

Zimmerman

R. S.

Saul

Jacobs

Wilson

Albarracín

(2015). Appealing to fear: A meta-analysis of fear appeal effectiveness and theories. Psychological Bulletin, 141(6), 1178–1204.

75.

Tomori

. (2015). Nighttime breastfeeding: An American cultural dilemma. New York, NY: Berghahn Books.

76.

U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (1976). 200 years of American medicine (1776-1976). https://www.nlm.nih.gov/hmd/pdf/200 years.pdf

77.

U.S. Department of Labor, Children’s Bureau (1914/1929). Infant care. https://archive.org/details/infantcare00unit/page/54

78.

Virnoche

M. E.

(2001). Scientific motherhood. Encyclopedia of Gender and Society, 1, 739–740.

79.

Waldburger

Spivack

(2007). The sleepeasy solution: The exhausted parent’s guide to getting your child to sleep- from birth to age 5. Health Communications, Inc. Books.

80.

Watson

J. B.

Watson

R. R.

(1928). Psychological care of the infant and child. Norton.

81.

Weinraub

Bender

R. H.

Friedman

S. L.

Susman

E. J.

Knoke

Bradley

Houts

Williams

(2012). Patterns of development change in infants’ nighttime sleep awakenings from 6 through 36 months of age. Developmental Psychology, 48(6), 1511–1528.

82.

Weissbluth

(1987). Healthy sleep habits, happy child. Ballantine Books.

83.

Wiebe

R. H.

(1996). Self-rule: A cultural history of American democracy. University of Chicago Press.