This article uses panel data from 745 married women in the Detroit Metropolitan Area to examine the mental health effects of employment and parenting status changes. Contrary to popular belief, the transition to parenting is not directly related to increases in psychological distress. Changes in employment status, however, are. Women who significantly increase their labor force participation report lower levels of psychological distress over the study period, while women who significantly decrease their labor force participation report higher psychological distress. The effects of labor force changes on mental health are not all modified by parenting status or changes in parenting status. The transition to parenting and increased parenting responsibilities, however, are indirectly related to increased psychological distress insofar as they result in decreased labor force participation. The implications of these results are used to evaluate four competing perspectives on the relationship between roles, stress, and psychological functioning.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aneshensel, Carol , Ralph R. Frerichs, and Virginia A. Clark.1981. “Family Roles and Sex Differences in Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior22:379-393.
2.
Baruch, Grace K. and Rosalind C. Barnett.1985. “Women's Involvement in Multiple Roles and Psychological Distress.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology49:135-145.
3.
Baruch, Grace K. , Lois Biener, and Rosalind C. Barnett.1987. “Women and Gender in Research on Work and Family Stress.”American Psychologist42:130-136.
4.
Bernard, Jessie. 1972. The Future of Marriage. New York: World.
5.
Bernard, Jessie. 1974. The Future of Motherhood. New York: Dial.
6.
Bianchi, Suzanne M. and Daphne Spain. 1986. American Women in Transition. New York: Russell Sage.
7.
Coser, Rose L. and Gerald Rokoff.1971. “Women in the Occupational World: Social Disruption and Conflict.”Social Problems18:535-554.
8.
DeMeis, Debra , Ellen Hock, and Susan L. McBride.1986. “The Balance of Employment and Motherhood: Longitudinal Study of Mother's Feelings About Separation from Their First-Born Infants.”Developmental Psychology22:627-632.
9.
Derogatis, Leonard. 1977. SCL-90: Administration, Scoring and Procedures Manual for the Revised Version. Baltimore: Clinical Psychometrics Research Unit, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine.
10.
Glenn, Norval D. and Sara S. McLanahan.1981. “The Effects of Offspring on the Psychological Well-Being of Older Adults.”Journal of Marriage and the Family43:409-421.
11.
Gove, Walter R.1972. “The Relationship Between Sex Roles, Marital Status, and Mental Illness.”Social Forces51:34-44.
12.
Gove, Walter R. and Michael R. Geerken.1977. “The Effect of Children and Employment on the Mental Health of Married Men and Women.”Social Forces56:66-76.
13.
Gove, Walter R. and Jeannette Tudor.1973. “Adult Sex-Roles and Mental Illness.”American Journal of Sociology78:812-835.
14.
Hall, Douglas T.1975. “Pressures from Work, Self, and Home in the Life Stages of Married Women.”Journal of Vocational Behavior6:121-132.
15.
Hochschild, Arlie. 1989. The Second Shift: Working Parents and the Revolution at Home. New York: Viking.
16.
Hock, Ellen, M.Therese Gnezda , and Susan L. McBride.1984. “Attitudes Toward Employment and Motherhood Following Birth of First Child.”Journal of Marriage and the Family44:425-431.
17.
Holahan, Carole K. and Lucia A. Gilbert.1979. “Interrole Conflict for Working Women: Careers Versus Jobs.”Journal of Applied Psychology64:86-90.
18.
Kandel, Denise and Mark Davies, 1986. “Adult Sequelae of Adolescent Depressive Symptoms.”Archives of General Psychiatry43:255-262.
19.
Kandel, Denise , Mark Davies, and Victoria Raveis.1985. “The Stressfulness of Daily Social Roles for Women: Marital, Occupational, and Household Roles.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior26:67-78.
20.
Kessler, Ronald C. and James A. McRae.1982. “The Effect of Wives' Employment on the Mental Health of Married Men and Women.”American Sociological Review47:216-227.
21.
Kessler, Ronald C. and James A. McRae. 1984. “A Note on the Relationships of Sex and Marital Status to Psychological Distress.” Pp. 109-130 in Research in Community and Mental Health (Vol. 4), edited by James Greenley.New York: JAI.
22.
Lueck, Marjorie , Ann C. Orr, and Martin O'Connell. 1982. “Trend in Child Care Arrangements of Working Mothers.”Current Population Reports, Special Studies P-23, No. 117. Washington, DC: Bureau of the Census.
23.
McLanahan, Sara S. and Julia Adams. 1987. “Parenthood and Psychological Well-Being.” Pp. 237-257 in Annual Review of Sociology (Vol. 13), edited by W.R. Scott and J.F. Short.Palo Alto, CA: Annual Reviews.
24.
Marks, Stephen R.1977. “Multiple Roles and Role Strain: Some Notes on Human Energy, Time, and Commitment.”American Sociological Review42:921-936.
25.
Menaghan, Elizabeth G.1983. “Marital Stress and Family Transitions: A Panel Analysis.”Journal of Marriage and the Family45:371-386.
26.
Menaghan, Elizabeth G.1989. “Role Changes and Psychological Well-Being: Variations in Effects by Gender and Role Repertoire.”Social Forces67:693-714.
27.
Miller, Joanne , Carmi Schooler, Melvin L. Kohn, and Karen Miller.1979. “Women and Work: The Psychological Effects of Occupational Conditions.”American Journal of Sociology85:66-94.
28.
Mirowsky, John and Catherine E. Ross. 1986. “Social Patterns of Distress.” Pp. 23-45 in Annual Review of Sociology (Vol. 12), edited by W. R. Scott and J. F. Short.Palo Alto, CA: Annual Reviews.
29.
Pearlin, Leonard I. 1974. “Sex Roles and Depression.” Pp. 191-207 in Life Span Development Psychology Conference: Normative Life Crises, edited by N. Datan and L. Ginsberg.New York: Academic Press.
30.
Radloff, Lenore S.1975. “Sex Differences and Depression: The Effects of Occupational and Marital Status.”Sex Roles1:249-265.
31.
Ross, Catherine E. and Joan Huber.1987. “Hardship and Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior26:312-327.
32.
Ross, Catherine E. and John Mirowsky.1988. “Child Care and Emotional Adjustment to Wives' Employment.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior29:127-138.
33.
Ross, Catherine E. , John Mirowsky, and Joan Huber.1983. “Dividing Work, Sharing Work, and In-Between: Marriage Patterns and Depression.”American Sociological Review48:809-823.
34.
Rossi, Alice.1968. “Transition to Parenthood.”Journal of Marriage and the Family30:26-39.
35.
Ryder, Norman B.1979. “The Future of American Fertility.”Social Problems26:359-369.
36.
Sieber, Sam.1974. “Toward a Theory of Role Accumulation.”American Sociological Review39:567-578.
37.
Stewart, Abigail J. and Joseph M. Healy.1989. “Linking Individual Development and Social Changes.”American Psychologist44:30-42.
38.
Thoits, Peggy.1983. “Multiple Identities and Psychological Well-Being: A Reformulation and Test of the Social Isolation Hypothesis.”American Sociological Review48:174-187.
Thoits, Peggy. 1987. “Negotiating Roles.” Pp. 11-22 in Spouse, Parent and Worker: On Gender and Multiple Roles, edited by F. Crosby.New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
41.
Thompson, Maxine S. and Margaret E. Ensminger.1989. “Psychological Well-Being Among Mothers with Schoolage Children.”Social Forces67:715-730.
42.
Townsend, Aloen and Patricia Gurin.1981. “Re-examining the Frustrated Homemaker Hypothesis: Role Fit, Personal Dissatisfaction, and Collective Discontent.”Sociology of Work and Occupations8:464-488.
43.
Vecchio, Robert P.1984. “Demographic and Attitudinal Differences Between Part-Time and Full-Time Employees.”Journal of Occupational Behavior5:213-218.
44.
Waldron, Ingrid and Joan Herold.1986. “Employment, Attitudes Toward Employment, and Women's Health.”Women and Health11:79-98.
