The Transition to Parenthood and Marital Quality

Abstract

An extensive literature demonstrates a negative correlation between the presence of children and marital quality. Few of these studies are designed to test the reasons for this relationship. Using a national panel study, we examine two possible paths: that people who choose to have children differ from those who do not in ways that affect marital quality, and that having a child changes marital structure and process. The results of the analysis support neither hypothesis. Although marital quality deteriorated over the three-year period, the transition to parenthood does not seem to affect changes in marital happiness, interaction, disagreements, division of labor, satisfaction with division of labor, or number of marital problems. Having a child did, however, seem to deter divorce and permanent separation.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Applebaum, M. I. and R. B. McCall. 1983. “Designs and analysis in developmental psychology.” In Paul H. Mussen (ed.), Handbook of Child Psychology, 4th Edition. New York: Wiley.

Cherlin, Andrew. 1977. “The effects of children on marital dissolution.” Demography 14, 2: 265-272.

Feldman, Harold. 1971. “The effects of children on the family.” Pp. 107-125 in Andree Michael (ed.), Family Issues of Employed Women in Europe and America. Leiden: E. G. Brill.

Figley, Charles R. 1973. “Child density and the marital relationship.” J. of Marriage and the Family 35(May): 272-282.

Glenn, Norval D. and Sara McLanahan. 1982. “Children and marital happiness: a further specification of the relationship.” J. of Marriage and the Family 44(February): 63-72.

Hobbs, Daniel F., Jr. , and Sue Peck Cole. 1976. “Transition to parenthood: a decade replication.” J. of Marriage and the Family 38: 723-731.

Hobbs, Daniel F., Jr. , and Jane M. Wimbish. 1977. “Transition to parenthood by black couples.” J. of Marriage and the Family 39(November): 677-689.

Hoffman, L. W. and J. D. Mantis. 1978. “Influences of children on marital interaction and parental satisfactions and dissatisfactions.” Pp. 165-213 in R. M. Lerner and G. M. Spanier (eds.), Child Influences on Marital and Family Interaction. New York: Academic.

Houseknecht, Sharon K. 1979. “Childlessness and marital adjustment.” J. of Marriage and the Family 41(May): 259-265.

10.

Kessler, Ronald C. and David F. Greenberg. 1981. Linear Panel Analysis: Models of Quantitative Change. New York: Academic.

11.

LeMasters, E. E. 1957. “Parenthood as crisis.” Marriage and Family Living 19(November): 352-355.

12.

Marini, Margaret Mooney. 1980. “Effects of the number and spacing of children on marital and parental satisfaction.” Demography 17, 3: 225-242.

13.

Miller, Brent. 1976. “A multivariate developmental model of marital satisfaction.” J. of Marriage and the Family 38, 4: 643-657.

14.

Renne, Karen S. 1970. “Correlates of dissatisfaction in marriage.” J. of Marriage and the Family 32(January): 54-66.

15.

Rollins, Boyd C. and Kenneth L. Cannon. 1974. “Marital satisfaction over the family life cycle: a reevaluation.” J. of Marriage and the Family 36(May): 271-283.

16.

Rollins, Boyd C. and Harold Feldman. 1970. “Marital satisfaction over the family life cycle.” J. of Marriage and the Family 32(January): 20-27.

17.

Ryder, Robert G. 1973. “Longitudinal data relating marriage satisfaction and having a child.” J. of Marriage and the Family 35(November): 604-606.

18.

United States Bureau of the Census. 1983. “Fertility of American women, June 1981.” Current Population Reports, Series p-20, No. 378. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.

19.

White, Lynn K. 1983. “Determinants of spousal interaction: Marital structure or marital happiness.” J. of Marriage and the Family 45(August): 511-519.