In a referendum held at the same time as the 1993 general election, a majority of New Zealanders voted to establish a new propor tional electoral system to replace their traditional simple plurality system, to take effect after April 1995. New Zealanders were responding to the destabilizing effects of party system dealignment, increasing dispropor tionality of election outcomes, and a succession of governments which many believed had ignored public opinion in their efforts to reform the economy. Competition between the two increasingly discredited major parties set a referendum process in motion, which few politicians thought would end in a vote for change. In part due to a political culture support ing populist democratic values, a majority of New Zealanders voted for proportional representation despite a well-funded all-out propaganda campaign against it. With four parties already represented in parliament at the end of 1993, New Zealand will move to multiparty competition. If successful, the experiment could set an example for similar reform in other plurality democracies.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Armstrong, J. (1993). "Anti-MMP Ads Cost $300,000 in One Week". New Zealand Herald, 20 November.
2.
Bartolini, S. and P. Mair, (1990). Identity, Competition, and Electoral Availability: the Stabilisation of European Electorates 1885-1985. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
3.
Boston, J. and M. Holland, (1987). The Fourth Labour Government: Radical Politics in New Zealand. Auckland: Oxford University Press.
4.
Boston, J. and P. Dalziel, (1992). The Decent Society: Essays in Response to National's Economic and Social Policies. Auckland: Oxford University Press.
5.
Castles, F. (1993). "Changing Course in Economic Policy: the English-Speaking Nations in the 1980s." In Families of Nations, (F. Castles, ed.), pp. 3-34. Aldershot: Gower Publishing.
6.
Catt, H., P. Harris, and N.S. Roberts, (1992). Voters' Choice: Electoral Change in New Zealand?Palmerston North: Dunmore.
7.
Cowen, P.B., T. Cowen, and A. Tabbarok, (1992). An Analysis of Proposals for Constitutional Change in New Zealand. Wellington: New Zealand Business Roundtable.
8.
Debnam, G. (1990). "Adversary Politics in New Zealand: Climate of Stress and Policy Aggressors." Journal of Commonwealth and Comparative Politics, XXVIII(I): 1-24.
9.
Easton, B., (ed.) (1989). The Making of Rogernomics. Auckland: Auckland University Press.
Heylen Research Centre (1992; 1993). One Network News/Heylen Political Polls. Auckland: Heylen Research Centre.
12.
Jackson, W.K. (1978). "A Political Scientist Look at Parliament." In The Reform of Parliament, (Sir J. Marshall, ed.), pp. 15-25. Wellington: New Zealand Institute of Public Administration.
13.
Jackson, W.K. (1992). "Caucus: the Anti-Parliament System?" In New Zealand Politics in Perspective, ( H. Gold, ed.), pp. 233-246. Auckland: Longman Paul.
14.
Jackson, W.K. (1993). "The Origins of the Electoral Referendums." In Taking It to the People, (A. McRobie , ed.), pp. 15-23. Christchurch: Hazard Press.
15.
Jesson, B. (1989). Fragments of Labour. Auckland : Penguin.
16.
Lamare, J. (1991). "Crisis in Confidence: Political Powerlessness in New Zealand." In The 1990 General Election: Perspectives on Political Change in New Zealand, (E.M. McLeay, ed.), pp. 163-172. Wellington: Department of Politics, Victoria University.
17.
Levine, S. and N.S. Roberts, (1993). "The New Zealand Electoral Referendum of 1993 ." Electoral Studies, 12: 158-167.
18.
Lijphart, A. (1984). Democracies: Patterns of Majoritarian and Consensus Government in Twenty-One Countries. New Haven: Yale University Press.
19.
MacDonald, F. (1993). "A Run For Their Money." New Zealand Listener 11-17 December, pp. 24-27.
20.
McManus, J. (1993). "Anti-MMP Ads Target the Poor, Fearful, Thick, and Gullible," Independent, 9 July.
21.
Miller, R. (1992). "The Minor Parties." In New Zealand Politics in Perspective, (H. Gold, ed.), pp. 310-325. Auckland: Longman Paul.
22.
Mulgan, R. (1989). Democracy and Power in New Zealand, (2nd ed.). Auckland: Oxford University Press.
23.
Mulgan, R. (1990). "The Changing Electoral Mandate." In The Fourth Labour Government: Politics and Policy in New Zealand, (M. Holland and J. Boston, eds.), pp. 11-21. Auckland: Oxford University Press.
24.
Mulgan, R. (1992). "The Elective Dictatorship in New Zealand." In New Zealand Politics in Perspective, ( H. Gold, ed.), pp. 513-531. Auckland: Longman Paul.
25.
Palmer, G. (1979). Unbridled Power?Auckland: Oxford University Press.
26.
Palmer, G. (1992). New Zealand's Constitution in Crisis: Reforming Our Political System. Dunedin: John McIndoe.
27.
Royal Commission on the Electoral System ( 1986). Towards a Better Democracy. Wellington : Government Printer.
28.
Select Committee on Electoral Law (1988). Report of the Electoral Law Committee. Wellington : Government Printer.
29.
Simpson, T. (1975). "Huey Long's Other Island: Style in New Zealand Politics." In New Zealand Politics: A Reader, (S. Levine, ed.), pp. 149-162. Melbourne: Cheshire.
30.
Vowles, J. (1990). "Nuclear-Free New Zealand and Rogernomics: the Survival of a Labour Government." Politics, 25: 81-91.
31.
Vowles, J. (1993). "Why Voters Rebel: Opinion on Electoral Reform in New Zealand, 1990-1992." Paper presented to the British Political Studies Association Conference, University of Leicester, 20-22 April.
32.
Vowles, J. (1994). "Dealignment and Demobilization: Nonvoting in New Zealand 1938-1990." Australian Journal of Political Science , 28(1).
33.
Vowles, J. and E.P. Aimer, (1993). Voters' Vengeance: The 1990 Election in New Zealand and the Fate of the Fourth Labour Government. Auckland : Auckland University Press.
