The debate about electoral reform in Britain has experienced periodic revivals, as critics have challenged the established system of first- past-the-post. The debate has revolved about how British elections trans late votes into seats, and how representative elections should work: whether priority should be given to the principle of strong government or "fairness" to minor parties and social groups. The article concludes that despite a heated debate, prospects for reform are uncertain in Britain, since public opinion about this issue remains ambivalent; there are no provisions for binding referendums; and the opposition remains divided about the most appropriate alternative.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Allsop, S. (1992). "An Inquest into the Treatment of the Proportional Representation Issue during the General Election." Representation , 31 (113): Spring-Summer.
2.
Blake, Lord (1976). Report of the Hansard Society Commission on Electoral Reform. London: The Hansard Society .
3.
Bogdanor, V. (1981). The People and the Party System. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
4.
Bogdanor, V. and D. Butler , (eds.). (1983). Democracy and Elections: Electoral Systems and their Political Consequences. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
5.
Butler, D. (1963). The British Electoral System since 1918. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
6.
Butler, D. (1993). "The Plant Report 1993: The Third Report of Labour's Working Party on Electoral Systems." Representation, 31 (116): 77-79.
7.
Butt, R. (1989). A History of Parliament: The Middle Ages. London: Constable.
8.
Campbell-Savours, D. (1993). "The Pros and Cons of Plant," The Guardian, Friday 2 April 1993, p. 20.
9.
Davies, P. and B. Clement. (1993). "Smith Backs Referendum over Commons PR," The Independent, 20 May 1993.
10.
Dunleavy., P., H. Margetts and S. Weir. (1992a). "Replaying the 1992 General Election: How Britain would have voted under Alternative Electoral Systems," LSE Public Policy Paper no. 3, London .
11.
Dunleavy, P., H. Margetts and S. Weir. (1992b). "Proportional Representation in Action: A report on Simulated PR Elections in 1992," Representation , 31 (113): 14-18.
12.
Finer, S. (ed.) (1975). Adversary Politics and Electoral Reform. London: Anthony Wigram.
13.
Georghiou, M. (1993). "Labour Responses to Plant," Representation, 31 (116): 81-83.
14.
Hart, J. (1992). Proportional Representation: Critics of the British Electoral System, 1820-1945. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
15.
Hailsham, Lord. (1976). Elective Dictatorship. London : BBC.
16.
Inter-Parliamentary Union (1993). Electoral Systems: A World-wide Comparative Study. Geneva : Inter-Parliamentary Union.
17.
Kellner, P. (1992). "The Devil-You-Know Factor," Representation, 31 (113): Spring-Summer.
18.
Labour Party (1992a). "The Electoral System and the Scottish Parliament: Report from the Labour Party's Working Party on Electoral Systems endorsed by the national executive Committee," (The Labour Party, London, January)
19.
Labour Party (1992b). "Democracy, Representation and Elections: Interim Report of the Labour Party Working Party on Electoral Systems," The Plant Report. (The Labour Party , London, June)
20.
Labour Party (1993). "The Third Report of the Working Party on Electoral Reform," (The Labour Party, London)
21.
Marquand, D. (1992). "Halfway to Citizenship." In The Changing Labour Party, (M. J. Smith and J. Spear, eds.). London : Routledge
22.
McLean, I. (1991). "Forms of Representation and Systems of Voting ." In Political Theory Today, ( D. Held, ed.). Stanford: Stanford University Press.
23.
Mitchell, A. (1993). "The Pros and Cons of Plant," The Guardian, Friday 2 April 1993, p. 20.
24.
Norris, P. (1985). "Women In European Legislative Elites." West European Politics, 12: 90-101.
25.
Norris, P. and I. Crewe. (1993). "Have the Marginals Vanished?" Electoral Studies, 12(2).
26.
Reeve, A. and A. Ware. (1992). Electoral Systems: A Comparative and Theoretical Introduction. London: Routledge.
27.
Representation (1993). Articles by David Butler, Richard Wainwright, Keith Best and Mary Georghiou in response to the Plant Reports.
28.
Seymour, C.S. (1915). Electoral Reform in England andWales. New Haven: Yale University Press.
29.
Smith, MJ and J. Spear. (1992). The ChangingLabour Party. London: Routledge .
30.
Weir, S. (1992). "Waiting for Change: Public Opinion and Electoral Reform." Political Quarterly, 63(2): 197-221.
31.
White, M. and P. Wintour. (1993). "Smith Expects to Win Unions' Vote ," The Guardian, 25 September 1993, p. 27.
