This study examines how aid activities by the World Bank and China, which take two competing approaches to building state capacity, affect a recipient government’s effort to build state legitimacy vis-à-vis its population. The study operationalized legitimacy drawing on Levi’s ‘quasi-voluntary compliance,’ and empirically analyzed the two approaches’ effects at the local level. The study used the Afrobarometer survey conducted in Tanzania in 2014 and geocoded datasets for aid projects. Chinese aid, characterized by its ‘Developmental State’ approach, was associated with higher projection of state legitimacy at local level. Meanwhile, the World Bank’s aid, which encourages building state legitimacy in a ‘contractarian’ way, did not demonstrate such a correlation, and there was limited evidence that the co-location of projects from both donors may condition the effects of the World Bank aid.
AidData (2017) WorldBank_GeocodedResearchRelease_Level1_v1.4.2 Geocoded Dataset. AidData. Williamsburg, VA and Washington, DC. Available at: http://aiddata.org/research-datasets
BaldwinKateWintersMatthew S. (2020) How Do Different Forms of Foreign Aid Affect Government Legitimacy? Evidence from an Informational Experiment in Uganda. Studies in Comparative International Development55(2): 160–183. DOI: 10.1007/s12116-020-09303-8.
6.
BanikDanBullBenedicte (2018) Chinese Engagement in Africa and Latin America: Does It Matter for State Capacity?Third World Thematics: A TWQ Journal3(4): 532–551. DOI: 10.1080/23802014.2018.1531682.
7.
BermeoSarah Blodgett (2016) Aid Is Not Oil: Donor Utility, Heterogeneous Aid, and the Aid-Democratization Relationship. International Organization70(1): 1–32. DOI: 10.1017/S0020818315000296.
8.
BesleyTimothy (2020) State Capacity, Reciprocity, and the Social Contract. Econometrica88(4): 1307–1335. DOI: 10.3982/ecta16863.
9.
BlairRobert AMartyRobertRoesslerPhilip (2022) Foreign Aid and Soft Power: Great Power Competition in Africa in the Early Twenty-First Century. British Journal of Political Science52(3): 1355–1376. DOI: 10.1017/S0007123421000193.
10.
BlairRobert ARoesslerPhilip (2021) Foreign Aid and State Legitimacy: Evidence on Chinese and US Aid to Africa from Surveys, Survey Experiments, and Behavioral Games. World Politics73(2): 315–357. DOI: 10.1017/S004388712000026X.
11.
BlairRobert AWintersMatthew S (2020) Foreign Aid and State-Society Relations: Theory, Evidence, and New Directions for Research. Studies in Comparative International Development55(2): 123–142. DOI: 10.1007/s12116-020-09301-w.
12.
BlankenshipBrian (2018) When Do States Take the Bait? State capacity and the provocation logic of terrorism. Journal of Conflict Resolution62(2): 381–409. DOI: 10.1177/0022002716645656.
13.
BluhmRichardDreherAxelFuchsAndreasParksBradleyStrangeAustinMichaelTierney (2018) Connective Financing: Chinese infrastructure projects and the diffusion of economic activity in developing countries. Aid Data Working Paper No. 64. Williamsburg, VA: AidData at William & Mary.
14.
BräutigamDeborah (2008) Introduction: Taxation and state-building in developing countries. In BräutigamDeborahFjelstadOdd-HelgeMooreMick (eds) Taxation and State-Building in Developing Countries: Capacity and Consent. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press, 1–33.
15.
BrazysSamuelElkinkJohan A.KellyGina (2017) Bad Neighbors? How co-located Chinese and world bank development projects impact local corruption in Tanzania. Review of International Organizations12(2): 227–253. DOI: 10.1007/s11558-017-9273-4.
16.
CaugheyDevinWarshawChristopher (2016) The Dynamics of State Policy Liberalism, 1936–2014. American Journal of Political Science60(4): 899–913. DOI: 10.1111/ajps.12219.
17.
CostelloAnna BOsborneJason W (2005) Best Practices in Exploratory Factor Analysis: Four recommendations for getting the most from your analysis. Practical Assessment, Research and Evaluation10: 7. DOI: 10.7275/jyj1-4868.
18.
CramerChristopherSteinHowardWeeksJohn (2006) Ownership and Donorship: Analytical issues and a Tanzanian case study. Journal of Contemporary African Studies24(3): 415–436. DOI: 10.1080/02589000600976745.
19.
DagherRuby (2018) Legitimacy and Post-Conflict State-Building: The undervalued role of performance legitimacy. Conflict, Security and Development18(2): 85–111. DOI: 10.1080/14678802.2018.1447860.
20.
De JanvryAlainDethierJean-Jacques (2012) The World Bank and Governance: The bank’s efforts to help developing countries build state capacity. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 6275. Policy Research Working Paper. Washington, DC.
21.
DietrichSimoneMahmudMinhajWintersMatthew S (2018) Foreign Aid, Foreign Policy, and Domestic Government Legitimacy: Experimental evidence from Bangladesh. Journal of Politics80(1): 133–148. DOI: 10.1086/694235.
22.
DolanLindsay R (2020) Rethinking Foreign Aid and Legitimacy: Views from aid recipients in Kenya. Studies in Comparative International Development55(2): 143–159. DOI: 10.1007/s12116-020-09302-9.
23.
DreherAxelFuchsAndreasHodlerRolandParksBradley CRaschkyPaul ATierneyMichael J (2019) African Leaders and the Geography of China’s Foreign Assistance. Journal of Development Economics140: 44–71. DOI: 10.1016/j.jdeveco.2019.04.003.
24.
DreherAxelFuchsAndreasParksBradley CStrangeAustinTierneyMichael J (2022) Banking on Beijing: The Aims and Impacts of China’s Overseas Development Program. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
25.
DunningThad (2004) Conditioning the Effects of Aid: Cold war politics, donor credibility, and democracy in Africa. International Organization58(2): 409–423. DOI: 10.1017/S0020818304582073.
26.
FurukawaMitsuaki (2018) Management of the International Development Aid System: The case of Tanzania. Development Policy Review36(S1): O270– O284. DOI: 10.1111/dpr.12229.
27.
GelmanAndrewHillJennifer (2006) Data Analysis Using Regression and Multilevel/Hierarchical Models. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
28.
HanauerLarryMorrisLyle J (2014) Chinese Engagement in Africa: Drivers, Reactions, and Implications for U.S. Policy. Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corporation.
29.
HansonJonathanSigmanRachel (2021) Leviathan’s Latent Dimensions: Measuring state capacity for comparative political research. Journal of Politics 83(4): 1495–1510. DOI: 10.1086/715066.
HaytonJames CAllenDavid GScarpelloVida (2004) Factor Retention Decisions in Exploratory Factor Analysis: A tutorial on parallel analysis. Organizational Research Methods7(2): 191–205. DOI: 10.1177/1094428104263675.
32.
HendrixCullen S (2010) Measuring State Capacity: Theoretical and empirical implications for the study of civil conflict. Journal of Peace Research47(3): 273–85. DOI: 10.1177/0022343310361838.
33.
HerbstJeffrey (2000) States and Power in Africa. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
34.
JacksonRobert H (1987) Quasi-States, Dual Regimes, and Neoclassical Theory: International jurisprudence and the third world. International Organization41(4): 519–549.
35.
KeuleersFloor (2015) Explaining External Perceptions: The EU and China in African public opinion. Journal of Common Market Studies53(4): 803–821. DOI: 10.1111/jcms.12231.
36.
KinyondoAbel (2019) Is China Recolonizing Africa?World Affairs182(2): 128–165.
37.
KrasnerStephen DRisseThomas (2014) External Actors, State-Building, and Service Provision in Areas of Limited Statehood: Introduction. Governance27(4): 545–567. DOI: 10.1111/gove.12065.
38.
LakeDavid A (2016) The Statebuilder’s Dilemma: On the Limits of Foreign Intervention. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
39.
LeviMargaret (1988) Of Rule and Revenue. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
40.
LiXiaoyunBanikDanTangLixiaWuJin (2014) Difference or Indifference: China’s development assistance unpacked. IDS Bulletin45(4): 22–35. DOI: 10.1111/1759-5436.12090.
41.
MarquetteHeatherBeswickDanielle (2011) State Building, Security and Development: State building as a new development paradigm?Third World Quarterly32(10): 1703–1714.
42.
Müller-CreponCarlHunzikerPhilippCedermanLars Erik (2021) Roads to Rule, Roads to Rebel: Relational state capacity and conflict in Africa. Journal of Conflict Resolution65(2–3): 563–590. DOI: 10.1177/0022002720963674.
43.
NayOlivier (2014) International Organisations and the Production of Hegemonic Knowledge: How the World Bank and the OECD helped invent the fragile state concept. Third World Quarterly35(2): 210–231. DOI: 10.1080/01436597.2014.878128.
PrichardWilsonCobhamAlexGoodallAndrew (2014) The ICTD Government Revenue Dataset. ICTD Working Paper 19. Brighton: ICTD. DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.2496442.
46.
Rabe-HeskethSophiaSkrondalAndersZhengXiaohui (2007) Multilevel Structural Equation Modeling. In Sik-YumLee (ed.) Handbook of Latent Variable and Related Models. Amsterdam, Netherlands: North-Holland, 209–227.
47.
RobinsonAmanda Lea (2014) National versus Ethnic Identification in Africa Modernization, Colonial Legacy, and the Origins of Territorial Nationalism. World Politics66(4): 709–746. DOI: 10.1017/S0043887114000239.
48.
SacksAudreyLeviMargaret (2010) Measuring Government Effectiveness and Lts Consequences for Social Welfare in Sub-Saharan African Countries. Social Forces88: 2325–2351.
49.
SatoJinShigaHiroakiKobayashiTakaakiKondohHisahiro (2011) ‘Emerging Donors’ from a Recipient Perspective: An Institutional Analysis of Foreign Aid in Cambodia. World Development39(12): 2091–2104. DOI: 10.1016/j.worlddev.2011.04.014.
50.
The Research and Analysis Working Group (2005) Poverty and Human Development Report 2005. Dar es Salaam, Tanzania: Mkuki na Nyota.
51.
van De WalleStevenScottZoe (2011) The Political Role of Service Delivery in State-Building: Exploring the relevance of European history for developing countries. Development Policy Review29(1): 5–21.
52.
WeberMax (1946) Politics as a Vocation. In From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology, ed. and trans. GerthH. H.Wright MillsC.New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 77–128.
53.
WintersMatthew S (2010) Choosing to Target: What types of countries get different types of world bank projects. World Politics62(3): 422–458. DOI: 10.1017/S0043887110000092.
54.
World Bank Independent Evaluation Group (2008) Decentralization in Client Countries: An Evaluation of World Bank Support, 1999-2007. Washington, DC: World Bank Publications.
55.
Ziegler RogersMelissaWellerNicholas (2013) Income Taxation and the Validity of State Capacity Indicators. Journal of Public Policy34(2): 183–206. DOI: 10.1017/S0143814X1300024X.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
