Building the ship in dry dock: The case for pre-independence constitution-building in Scotland

Abstract

For newly independent states, constitution-building can be a defining moment: a time when national identities are asserted, values and norms articulated, and founding myths created. The constitution-building process is a critical juncture between the divergent paths of stable and well-functioning democracy, on one hand, or persistent instability, coups, repression, and state failure, on the other. But what is the proper relationship of constitution-building to state formation? Should constitution-building occur before or after state formation? Or should the two processes somehow proceed in parallel? To address these questions in a Scottish context, this article draws on state-formation and constitution-building processes in the Westminster-derived tradition. The article considers the advantages and disadvantages of these sequences, and discusses the circumstances in which they might be applicable. It concludes by making some tentative recommendations for a pre-independence constitution-building process in Scotland.

Keywords

Constitution-building state formation Scottish independence Commonwealth constituent assembly sequencing

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Acemoglu

Robinson

(2012) Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity and Poverty. New York: Crown Business.

Ackerman

Bruce

(1991) We the People, Volume 1: Foundations. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.

Arato

Andrew

(2016) Post Sovereign Constitution Making: Learning and Legitimacy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Austin

Granville

(2000) The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Bell

Christine

Zulueta-Fülscher

Kimana

(2016) Sequencing Peace Agreements and Constitutions in the Political Settlement Process. Stockholm: International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance.

Bulmer

W Elliot

(2011) An Analysis of the Scottish National Party’s Draft Constitution for Scotland. Parliamentary Affairs 64(4): 674–693.

Bulmer

W Elliot

(2015) A Constitution for the Common Good: Strengthening Scottish Democracy After the Independence. Edinburgh: Luath Press.

Bulmer

W Elliot

(2016) Constituting Scotland: The Scottish National Movement and the Westminster Model. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

Bulmer

W Elliot

(2018) Foundations for Freedom: A discussion paper on the process for establishing an independent Scotland’s Constitution. Common Weal. Available at: https://commonweal.scot/library/foundations-for-freedom-a-discussion-paper-on-the-process-for-establishing-an-independent-scotlande28099s-constitution1/ (accessed 3 July 2019).

10.

Butt

Lindsey

(2012) The Constitution of Indonesia: A Contextual Analysis. Oxford: Hart Publishing.

11.

Choudhry

Sedelius

Kyrychenko

(2018) Semi-Presidentialism and Inclusive Governance in Ukraine: Reflections for Constitutional Reform. Stockholm: International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance.

12.

Covell

Maureen

(1985) Possibly Necessary But Not Necessarily Possible: Revision of the constitution in Belgium. In Banting

Keith G

Simeon

Richard

(eds) Redesigning the State: The Politics of Constitutional Change in Industrialized Nations. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 71–94.

13.

Darnolf

(1997) Democratic Electioneering in Southern Africa: The Contrasting Cases of Botswana and Zimbabwe. Goteborg: Goteborg Studies in Politics, Goteborg University Press.

14.

De Smith

(1961) Westminster’s Export Models: The Legal Framework of Responsible Government. Journal of Commonwealth Political Studies 1(1): 2–16.

15.

Dunsterville

Lionel

(2012) The Adventures of Dunsterforce. Luton: Andrews UK.

16.

Elkins

Zachary

Ginsburg

Tom

Melton

James

(2009) The Endurance of National Constitutions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

17.

Elster

Jon

(1995) Forces and Mechanisms in the Constitution-Making Process. Duke Law Journal 45: 364–396.

18.

Elster

Jon

Offe

Claus

Preuss

Ulrich K

(1996) Institutional Design in Post-Communist Societies: Rebuilding the Ship at Sea. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

19.

Fitzmaurice

John

(1996) The Politics of Belgium: A Unique Federalism (Nations of the Modern World: Europe). London: Routledge.

20.

Frankel

Jeffrey A

(2012) The Natural Resource Curse: A survey of diagnoses and some prescriptions. HKS Faculty Research Working Paper Series RWP12-014. Boston, MA: John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University.

21.

Galligan

Denis J

Versteeg

Mila

(eds) (2012) Social and Political Foundations of Constitutions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

22.

Gargarella

Roberto

(2010) The Legal Foundations of Inequality: Constitutionalism in the Americas, 1776–1860. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

23.

Ghai

Yash-Pal

(2010) The Chimera of Constitutionalism: State, economy and society in Africa. In Deva

Swati

(ed.) Law and (In)Equalities: Contemporary Perspectives. Lucknow: Eastern Book Company.

24.

Hardin

Russell

(1989) Why a Constitution. In Grofman

Bernard

Wittman

Donald

(eds) The Federalist Papers and the New Institutionalism. New York: Agathon Press.

25.

Harding

(2012) The Constitution of Malaysia: A Contextual Analysis. Oxford: Hart Publishing.

26.

Henry

Martin

(2017) Jamaica at 55: The making of the constitution of Jamaica. The Gleaner. Available at: http://jamaica-gleaner.com/article/focus/20170730/martin-henry-jamaica-55-making-constitution (accessed 31 January 2018).

27.

Hirschl

Ran

(2010) Constitutional Theocracy. Harvard: Harvard University Press.

28.

Huntington

(1993) The Clash of Civilizations. “Foreign Affairs. Summer 1993." New Yok: Council on Foreign Relations.

29.

Inglehart

Welzel

(2005) Modernization, Cultural Change and Democracy: The Human Development Sequence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

30.

Law

David

Versteeg

Mila

(2012) The Declining Influence of the United States Constitution. New York University Law Review 87(3): 762–858.

31.

Lerner

Hannah

(2011) Making Constitutions in Deeply Divided Societies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

32.

Mokopakgosi

Brian

(2008) The 1965 Self-Government Elections and the Transfer of Power in the Bechuanaland Protectorate. South African Historical Journal 60: 85–102.

33.

Navot

Suzie

(2014) The Constitution of Israel: Contextual Analysis. Oxford: Hart Publishing.

34.

Negretto

Gabriel

(2013) Making Constitutions: Presidents, Parties, and Institutional Choice in Latin America. New York: Cambridge University Press.

35.

Nehru

(1988) True Significance of a Constituent Assembly: Selected words of Jawaharlal Nehru 11: 18. Jawaharlal Nehru Memorial Fund. Available at: https://archive.org/stream/HindSwaraj-Nehru-SW-11/nehru.sw.vol.11_djvu.txt (accessed 31 January 2018).

36.

Ordeshook

Peter C

(1992) Constitutional Stability. Constitutional Political Economy 3(2): 137–175.

37.

Parkinson

Charles

(2008) Bills of Rights and Decolonization: The Emergence of Domestic Human Rights Instruments in Britain’s Overseas Territories. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

38.

Patapan

Haig

Wanna

John

Weller

Patrick

(2005) Westminster Legacies: Democracy and Responsible Government in Asia and the Pacific. Sydney: University of New South Wales Press.

39.

Popelier

Patricia

Lemmens

Koen

(2015) The Constitution of Belgium: A Contextual Analysis. Oxford: Hart Publishing.

40.

Russell

Peter H

(1993) Constitutional Odyssey: Can Canadians Become a Sovereign People? Toronto: Toronto University Press.

41.

Saati

Abrak

(2015) The Participation Myth: Outcomes of Participatory Constitution Building Processes on Democracy. Doctoral Thesis, Umeå: Umeå University.

42.

Scottish Government (2013) Scotland’s Future: Your Guide to an Independent Scotland (White Paper).

43.

Scottish Government (2014) Scotland’s Future: The Scottish Independence Bill: A Constultation on an Interim Constitution for Scotland. Available at: https://www2.gov.scot/Resource/0045/00452762.pdf (accessed 10 September 2020).

44.

Scottish National Party (SNP) (1995) Citizens not Subjects: the Parliament and Constitution of an Independent Scotland. Edinburgh: SNP.

45.

Scottish National Party (SNP) (2002) A Constitution for a Free Scotland. Edinburgh: SNP.

46.

Singh

(1990) Role of the Congress in the Framing of India’s Constitution. The Indian Journal of Political Science 51(2): 153–171.

47.

Smilov

(2013) Constitutionalism of Shallow Foundations. In Galligan

Versteeg

(eds) The Social and Political Foundations of Constitutions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

48.

Thornhill

Chris

(2011) A Sociology of Constitutions: Constitutions and State Legitimacy in Historical-Sociological perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

49.

Waseem

Mohammad

(2015) Constitutionalism and Extra-Constitutionalism in Pakistan. In Tushnet

Mark

Khosla

Madhav

(eds) Unstable Constitutionalism: Law and Politics in South Asia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 124–158.

50.

Toth

Gabor Atilla

(ed.) (2011) Constitution for a Disunited Nation: On Hungary’s 2011 Fundamental Law. Budapest: Central European University Press.

51.

Wheatley

Jonathan

Mendez

Fernando

(eds) (2016) Patterns of Constitutional Design: The Role of Citizens and Elites in Constitution-Making. London: Routledge.

52.

Wolczuk

(2001) Moulding of Ukraine: The Constitutional Politics of State Formation. Budapest: Central European Press.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.08 MB