During the Great Recession, exceptionally harsh economic conditions were often countered by austerity policies that, according to many, further worsened and protracted the negative conjuncture. Both elements, the poor state of the economy and the contractionary manoeuvers, are supposed to reduce the electoral prospects for incumbents. In this article, we compare the relative explanatory powers of these two theories before and during the economic crisis. We demonstrate that in normal times citizens are fiscally responsible, whereas during the Great Recession, and under certain conditions, austerity policies systematically reduced the support for incumbents on top of the state of the economy. This happened when the burdens of the manoeuvers were shared by many, in more equal societies, when the country was constrained by external conditionalities and when readjustments were mostly based on tax increases.
AlesinaAlberto and Andrea Passalacqua (2017) The Political Economy of Government Debt. In John Taylor and Harald Uhlig (eds) Handbook of Macroeconomics,
Vol. 2B.
Amsterdam:
Elsevier, 2599–2651.
2.
AlesinaAlberto, Carlo Favero and Francesco Giavazzi (2019) Austerity: When It Works and When It Does Not.
Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press.
3.
AlesinaAlberto, Dorian Carloni and Giampaolo Lecce (2013) The Electoral Consequences of Large Fiscal Adjustments. In Alberto Alesina and Francesco Giavazzi (eds) Fiscal Policy After the Financial Crisis.
Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press, 531–570.
4.
AlesinaAlberto and Francesco Giavazzi (2013) Fiscal Policy after the Financial Crisis.
Chicago, IL; London:
The University of Chicago Press.
5.
AlesinaAlberto, Roberto Perotti and José Tavares (1998)
The Political Economy of Fiscal Adjustments. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity1998(1): 197–266.
6.
AlonsoSonia and Rubén Ruiz-Rufino (2018) The Costs of Responsibility for the Political Establishment of the Eurozone (1999–2015). Party Politics. Epub ahead of print 11 April. doi: 10.1177/1354068818766182
7.
AngristJoshua David and Jörn-Steffen Pischke (2009) Mostly Harmless Econometrics: An Empiricist’s Companion.
Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press.
8.
ArmingeonKlaus and Kai Guthmann (2014)
Democracy in Crisis? The Declining Support for National Democracy in European Countries, 2007–2011. European Journal of Political Research53(3): 423–442.
9.
BellucciPaolo (2014)
The Political Consequences of Blame Attribution for the Economic Crisis in the 2013 Italian National Election. Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties24(2): 243–263.
10.
BengtssonÅsa (2004)
Economic Voting: The effect of political context, volatility and turnout on voters’ assignment of responsibility. European Journal of Political Research43(5): 749–767.
11.
BlythMark (2013) Austerity: The History of a Dangerous Idea.
Oxford; New York:
Oxford University Press.
12.
BoscoAnna and Susannah Verney (2016)
From Electoral Epidemic to Government Epidemic: The next level of the crisis in Southern Europe. South European Society and Politics21(4): 383–406.
13.
BrenderAdi and Allan Drazen (2008)
How Do Budget Deficits and Economic Growth Affect Reelection Prospects? Evidence from a Large Panel of Countries. American Economic Review98(5): 2203–2220.
14.
BuchananJames M and Richard E Wagner (1977) Democracy in Deficit. The Political Legacy of Lord Keynes.
New York:
Academic Press.
15.
CliftBen (2018) The IMF and the Politics of Austerity in the Wake of the Global Financial Crisis (1st edn).
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
16.
DassonnevilleRuth and Michael S Lewis-Beck (2014)
Macroeconomics, Economic Crisis and Electoral Outcomes: A national European pool. Acta Politica49(4): 372–394.
17.
DassonnevilleRuth and Michael S Lewis-Beck (2017)
Rules, Institutions and the Economic Vote: Clarifying clarity of responsibility. West European Politics40(3): 534–559.
18.
DassonnevilleRuth and Michael S Lewis-Beck (2019a)
A Changing Economic Vote in Western Europe? Long-Term Vs. Short-Term Forces. European Political Science Review11(1): 91–108.
19.
DassonnevilleRuth and Michael S Lewis-Beck (2019b)
Inequality and Party Support: Positional economic voting or a new dimension of valence?Regional Studies: 1–10.
20.
De GiorgiElisabetta and José Santana-Pereira (2016)
The 2015 Portuguese Legislative Election: Widening the coalitional space and bringing the extreme left in. South European Society and Politics21(4): 451–468.
EvansGeoffrey and Mark Pickup (2010)
Reversing the Causal Arrow: The political conditioning of economic perceptions in the 2000–2004 U.S. Presidential election cycle. The Journal of Politics72(4): 1236–1251.
23.
FiorinaMorris P (1981) Retrospective Voting in American National Elections.
New Haven, CT:
Yale University Press.
24.
FrankoWilliam, Caroline J Tolbert and Christopher Witko (2013)
Inequality, Self-Interest, and Public Support for “Robin Hood” Tax Policies. Political Research Quarterly66(4): 923–937.
25.
GiulianiMarco (2019)
Economic Vote and Globalization before and During the Great Recession. Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties. Epub ahead of print 19 April. doi: 10.1080/17457289.2019.1697881
26.
GiulianiMarco and Sergio A Massari (2018) It’s the Economy, Stupid: Votare in Tempo Di Crisi.
Bologna:
Il Mulino.
27.
GuptaSanjeev, João T Jalles, Carlos Mulas-Granados and Michela Schena (2018)
Planned Fiscal Adjustments: Do governments fulfil their commitments?European Union Politics19(3): 383–407.
28.
HellwigTimothy (2015) Globalization and Mass Politics: Retaining the Room to Maneuver.
New York:
Cambridge University Press.
29.
HübscherEvelyne and Thomas Sattler (2017)
Fiscal Consolidation under Electoral Risk. European Journal of Political Research56(1): 151–168.
30.
JensenCarsten and Peter B Mortensen (2014)
Government Responses to Fiscal Austerity. Comparative Political Studies47(2): 143–170.
31.
KayserMark Andreas and Michael Peress (2016) The Buck Stops There? Benchmarking Elections in Open Economy. In Jack Vowles and Georgios Xezonalis (eds) Globalization and Domestic Politics: Parties, Elections, and Public Opinion.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 89–112.
32.
KeyValdimer O (1966) The Responsible Electorate; Rationality in Presidential Voting, 1936–1960.
Cambridge:
Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
33.
KosmidisSpyros (2018)
International Constraints and Electoral Decisions: Does the room to maneuver attenuate economic voting?American Journal of Political Science62(3): 519–534.
34.
LaverMichael and Kenneth Benoit (2015)
The Basic Arithmetic of Legislative Decisions. American Journal of Political Science59(2): 275–291.
35.
Lewis-BeckMichael S and Costa M Lobo (2017) The Economic Vote: Ordinary vs extraordinary times. In Kai Arzheimer, Jocelyn Evans and Michael S Lewis-Beck (eds) The Sage Handbook of Electoral Behaviour,
Vol. 2.
London:
Sage, 606–629.
36.
Lewis-BeckMichael S and Mary Stegmaier (2013)
The Vp-Function Revisited: A survey of the literature on vote and popularity functions after over 40 years. Public Choice157(3–4): 367–385.
37.
MarshMichael and Slava Mikhaylov (2014)
A Conservative Revolution: The electoral response to economic crisis in Ireland. Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties24(2): 160–179.
38.
NannestadPeter and Martin Paldam (1994)
The Vp Function a Survey of the Literature on Vote and Popularity. Public Choice79(3–4): 213–245.
39.
NeumayerEric and Thomas Plümper (2017) Robustness Tests: Causal Inference with Observational Data.
Cambridge; New York:
University Printing House.
40.
PiersonPaul (ed.) (2001) The New Politics of the Welfare State.
Oxford; New York:
Oxford University Press.
41.
PowellG Bingham and Guy D Whitten (1993)
A Cross-National Analysis of Economic Voting: Taking account of the political context. American Journal of Political Science37(2): 391–414.
42.
RaessDamian and Jonas Pontusson (2015)
The Politics of Fiscal Policy During Economic Downturns, 1981–2010. European Journal of Political Research54(1): 1–22.
43.
RoweKelly T (2015)
Making Voice Count: Economic voting and the number of parties. Party Politics21(5): 803–812.
44.
Ruiz-RufinoRubÉN and Sonia Alonso (2017)
Democracy without Choice: Citizens’ perceptions of government autonomy during the eurozone crisis. European Journal of Political Research56(2): 320–345.
45.
SalmonKeith (2017)
A Decade of Lost Growth: Economic policy in Spain through the great recession. South European Society and Politics22(2): 239–260.
46.
SavageLee (2019)
The Politics of Social Spending after the Great Recession: The return of partisan policy making. Governance32(1): 123–141.
47.
SchuiFlorian (2014) Austerity: The Great Failure.
New Haven, CT:
Yale University Press.
48.
SilvaCarlos Nunes and Guy D Whitten (2017) Clarity of Responsibility and Vote Choice. In Kai Arzheimer, Jocelyn Evans and Michael S Lewis-Beck (eds) The Sage Handbook of Electoral Behaviour,
Vol. 1.
London:
Sage, 584–605.
49.
StegmaierMary, Michael S Lewis-Beck and Brandon Beomseob Park (2017) The Vp Function: A Review. In Kai Arzheimer, Jocelyn Evans and Michael S. Lewis-Beck (eds) The Sage Handbook of Electoral Behaviour (
Vol. 2).
London:
Sage, 584–605.
50.
TalvingLiisa (2017)
The Electoral Consequences of Austerity: Economic policy voting in Europe in times of crisis. West European Politics40(3): 560–583.
51.
WeschleSimon (2014)
Two Types of Economic Voting: How economic conditions jointly affect vote choice and turnout. Electoral Studies34: 39–53.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
