Under which conditions do regional organizations in the Americas impose sanctions on member states that violate democracy? To address this question, the article combines a qualitative comparative analysis applied to 55 presumed threats to democracy brought to the attention of regional organizations (ROs), and a process tracing analysis of two cases of the imposition of sanctions. The analysis reveals that ROs impose sanctions despite lack of support or even obstruction by the US, when the threats are committed against the incumbent in relatively weak member states. The unique case in which an RO suspended a relatively powerful state because of threats by the incumbent required the convergence of interests between ROs’ most powerful member states, and the support of the US. The article demonstrates that under specific conditions, ROs in the Americas can become relatively autonomous enforcers of democracy-protection norms.
ArceneauxCraigPion-berlinDavid (2007) Issues, Threats, and Institutions: Explaining OAS responses to democratic dilemmas in Latin America. Latin American Politics and Society41(1): 1–31.
2.
ArrighiJean-Michel (2015) La OEA y El Derecho Internacional, Vol. 24. Mexico City: Editorial Porrúa.
3.
BeachDerek (2018) Achieving Methodological Alignment When Combining QCA and Process Tracing in Practice. Sociological Methods & Research47(1): 64–99.
4.
BennettAndrewCheckelJeffrey T (2015) Process Tracing: From Metaphor to Analytical Tool. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
5.
BerryDavid S (2005) Non-Democratic Transitions: Reactions of the OAS and CARICOM to Aristide’s Departure. Journal of International Law & Com33: 249–262.
6.
BonifaceDexter (2007) The OAS’s Mixed Record. In LeglerThomasLeanSharonBonifaceDexter (eds) Promoting Democracy in the Americas. Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins University Press, 40–62.
7.
BonifaceDexter (2002) Is There a Democratic Norm in the Americas? An analysis of the organization of American states. Global Governance3: 365–381.
8.
ClosaCarlosPalestiniStefano (2018) Tutelage and Regime Survival in Democracy Protection in Regional Organizations. The case of MERCOSUR and UNASUR. World Politics70(3): 443–476.
9.
ClosaCarlosPalestiniStefanoCastilloPablo (2016) Regional Organisations and Mechanisms for Democracy Protection in Latin America, the Caribbean, and the European Union. Hamburg: EU-LAC Foundation.
10.
ClosaCarlosPalestiniStefano (2015) Between Democratic Protection and Self-Defense : The Case of Unasur and Venezuela. Florence: EUI Working Papers RSCAS 2015/93.
11.
DupuyAlex (2006) The Prophet and Power. Jean-Bertrand Aristide, the International Community, and Haiti. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield.
12.
DupuyAlex (2005) From Jean-Bertrand Aristide to Gerard Latortue: The Unending Crisis of Democratization in Haiti. Journal of Latin American Anthropology10(1): 186–205.
13.
DusaAdrian (2019) QCA with R. A Comprehensive Resource. Cham: Springer.
14.
DonnoDaniela (2010) Who Is Punished? Regional intergovernmental organizations and the enforcement of democratic norms. International Organization64(4): 593–625.
15.
GoldbergDavid (2007) Haiti 2004. CARICOM’s Democracy Promotion Efforts. In LeglerThomasLeanSharonBonifaceDexter (eds) Promoting Democracy in the Americas. Baltimore, MD: The John Hopkins University Press.
16.
GonzálezManuel CamiloLiendoNicolás Alejandro (2017) La Defensa Colectiva de La Democracia En América Latina: ¿Por Qué? ¿Cómo? ¿Cuándo?Análisis Político91: 3–17.
17.
GrandersonColin (2004) The CARICOM Initiative towards Haiti. A case of small states diplomacy. Focal Point3(6): 1–4.
18.
HeineJorgeWeiffenB (2014) 21st Century Democracy Promotion in the Americas. Standing up for the Polity. Abingdon: Routledge.
19.
KramerKirstin (2004) Keeping the Peace in Haiti. Washington Report on the Hemisphere. Washington, DC: The Council for Hemispheric Affairs.
20.
LeglerThomas (2012) The Democratic Charter in Action: Reflections on the Honduran crisis. Latin American Policy3(1): 74–87.
21.
LeglerThomasGarelli-RíosOrnela (2018) La Protección de La Democracia Ante La Crisis Venezolana : Los Límites Del Nexo Hemisférico-Regional de Gobernanza En Las Américas. Pensamiento Propio23: 159–188.
22.
LevittBarry Steven (2006) A Desultory Defense of Democracy: OAS resolution 1080 and the inter-American democratic charter. Latin American Politics & Society48(3): 93–123.
23.
LongTomFriedmanMax Paul (2019) The Promise of Precommitment in Democracy and Human Rights: The Hopeful, Forgotten Failure of the Larreta Doctrine. Perspectives on Politics. doi:10.1017/S1537592719002676
24.
McCoyJennifer L (2006) International Response to Democratic Crisis in the Americas, 1990–2005. Democratization13(5): 756–775.
25.
NolteDetlef (2014) Latin America’s New Regional Architecture: A Cooperative or Segmented Regional Governance Complex? 2014/89. RCAS EUI Working Papers, Florence.
26.
Ribeiro HoffmannAndrea (2019) Negotiating Normative Premises in Democracy Promotion: Venezuela and the inter-American democratic charter. Democratization26(5): 815–831.
27.
PerinaRubén M (2015) The Organization of American States as the Advocate and Guardian of Democracy. Lanham: University Press of America.
28.
RaginCharles (2008) Redesigning Social Inquiry. Fuzzy Sets and Beyond. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
29.
SchnablyStephen J (2000) American System. In FoxGregoryRothBrad (eds) Democratic Governance and International Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 155–198.
30.
ShawCarolyn (2004) Cooperation, Conflict and Consensus in the Organization of American States. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
31.
SchneiderCarsten QClaudiusWagemann (2013) Set-Theoretic Methods for the Social Sciences. A Guide to Qualitative Comparative Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
32.
SmithBetsy (2018) Killing Democracy Softly: Executive privilege and the defense of democracy in the Americas. Latin American Policy9(2): 208–237.
33.
SmithMatthew (2005). An Island among Islands: Haiti’s Strange Relationship with the Caribbean Community. Social and Economic Studies Social and Economic Studies54(54): 176–1953.
34.
SvolikMilan W (2014) Which Democracies Will Last? Coups, incumbent takeovers, and the dynamic of democratic consolidation. British Journal of Political Science45(4): 715–738.
35.
TimmermannSophia (2018) Venezuelan Membership in MERCOSUR: A case for the significance of party politics?Paper presented at the International Congress of the Latin American Studies Association, 23–26May, Barcelona, Spain.
36.
Van der VleutenAnnaHoffmannAndrea Ribeiro (2010) Explaining the Enforcement of Democracy by Regional Organizations: Comparing EU, Mercosur and SADC. Journal of Common Market Studies48(3): 737–758.
37.
von BorzyskowskiInkenVabulasFelicity (2019) Credible Commitments? Explaining IGO suspensions to sanction political backsliding. International Studies Quarterly63(1): 139–152.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
