The problem of toleration has traditionally been addressed from liberal perspectives, emphasizing the individual over the community. In contrast, postmodern thought introduces the theory of the gift, revealing the bonds erased by liberal individualism. This article proposes an alternative conceptualization of tolerance within the paradigm of the gift: tolerance as accepting the gift. The existence of the given demands tolerance of its disruptive implications: the encounter with the other and the recognition of an underlying debt. Drawing on the debate on the gift between Jean-Luc Marion, Jacques Derrida and John Milbank, I explore the social and political implications of this perspective on tolerance. I argue that radical acceptance of the gift requires abandoning the paradigm of sameness in favour of difference and recognizing the impossibility of abstractly resolving the problem of tolerance. While liberal tradition privileges individual freedom, tolerance from the perspective of the gift calls for communitarian virtues – hospitality, responsibility and forgiveness. Finally, recognizing the radical ‘given condition’ of the gift rethinks politics not from a sovereign hierarchy of power but from an anti-sovereigntist paradigm rooted in vulnerability.
BalthasarHans Urs von. 2000. Mysterium Paschale: The Mystery of Easter. Ignatius Press.
2.
BaumanZygmunt. 2000. Liquid Modernity. Polity.
3.
BejczyIstvan.1997. “Tolerantia: a Medieval Concept.” Journal of the History of Ideas58, no. 3: 365.
4.
CaputoJohn D.1997. The Prayers and Tears of Jacques Derrida. Religion Without Religion. Indiana University Press.
5.
CaputoJohn D.1999. “Apostles of the Impossible on God and the Gift in Derrida and Marion.” In God, the Gift Postmodernism, edited by CaputoJohn D.ScanlonMichael J., 185–222. Indiana University Press.
6.
CaputoJohn D.2000. “Philosophy and Prophetic Postmodernism: toward a Catholic Postmodernity.” American Catholic Philosophical Quaterly74, no. 4: 549–67.
7.
CaputoJohn D.2015. The Weakness of God: A Radical Theology of the Cross. Augsburg Fortress Publishers.
8.
CaputoJohn D.ScanlonMichael J.. 1999. “Introduction: Apology for the Impossible: Religion and Postmodernism.” In God, the Gift, and Postmodernism, edited by CaputoJohn D.ScanlonMichael J., 1–19. Indiana University Press.
9.
DerridaJacques. 1994. Given Time I. Counterfeit Money. University of Chicago Press.
10.
DerridaJacques. 1995. The Gift of Death. University of Chicago Press.
11.
DerridaJacques. 2005. Paper Machine. Stanford University Press.
12.
DouglasMary.2002. “Foreword.” In The Gift: The Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies, edited by DouglasMary. ix–xxiii. Routledge.
13.
DufourmantelleAnneDerridaJacques. 2000. Of Hospitality. Stanford University Press.
14.
ForstRainer. 2013. Toleration in Conflict. Cambridge University Press.
15.
GaleottiAnna Elisabetta. 2002. Toleration as Recognition. 1st ed.Cambridge Univ. Press.
16.
GaleottiAnna Elisabetta. 2015. “The Range of Toleration: from Toleration as Recognition Back to Disrespectful Tolerance.” Philosophy & Social Criticism41, no. 2: 93–110.
17.
HénaffMarcel. 2019. The Philosophers’ Gift: Reexamining Reciprocity. Fordham University Press.
18.
HerreroMontserrat. 2015. La Política Revolucionaria De John Locke. Tecnos.
19.
HortonJohn.1996. “Toleration as Virtue.” In Toleration: An Elusive Virtue, edited by HeydDavid, 28–43. Princeton University Press.
20.
KearneyRichardDerridaJacquesMarionJean-LucCaputoJohn D.. 1999. “On the Gift: a Discussion Between Jacques Derrida and Jean-Luc Marion.” In God, the Gift, and Postmodernism, edited by CaputoJohn D.ScanlonMichael J., 54–79. Indiana University Press.
21.
LipovetskyGilles. 2016. De La Ligereza: Hacia Una Civilización De Lo Ligero. Editorial Anagrama.
22.
LockeJohn. 2010. Locke on Toleration. Cambridge University Press.
23.
MarionJean-Luc. 2004 In In Excess: Studies of Saturated Phenomena. Fordham University Press.
24.
MarionJean-Luc. 2012. God Without being. Second edition ed.The University of Chicago Press.
25.
MarionJean-Luc. 2013. Being Given: Toward a Phenomenology of Givenness. Stanford University Press.
26.
MaussMarcel. 2002. The Gift: The Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies. Routledge Classics.
27.
MilbankJohn.1995. “Can a Gift Be Given? Prolegomena to a Future Trinitarian Metaphysic.” Modern Theology11, no. 1: 119–61.
28.
MilbankJohn. 2009. The Future of Love: Essays in Political Theology. Cascade Books.
29.
MillJohn Stuart. 2003. On Liberty. Yale University Press.
30.
NancyJean-Luc. 2008a In The Inoperative Community, edited by ConnorPeter. University of Minnesota Press.
31.
NancyJean-Luc. 2008b. “The Intruder.” In Corpus, 161–70. Fordham University Press.
32.
RawlsJohn. 1996. Political Liberalism. Columbia University Press.
33.
RazJoseph. 1988. The Morality of Freedom. Oxford University Press.
34.
SeligmanAdam B.2003. “Tolerance, Tradition and Modernity.” Cardozo Law Review24, no. 4: 1645–56.
35.
SeligmanAdam.2014. “Introduction: Living Together Differently and the Challenge of Deep Pluralism.” In Religious Education and the Challenge of Pluralism, edited by SeligmanAdam, 1–24. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
36.
SeligmanAdam B.2021. “Human Rights, Belonging and the Challenge of Difference.” Philosophy & Social Criticism47, no. 4: 426–39.
37.
SeligmanAdam B.WellerRobert P.. 2019. “Framing Gifts.” In How Things Count as the Same. Memory, Mimesis, and Metaphor, 99–117. Oxford University Press.
38.
SeligmanAdam B.WellerRobert P.PuettMichael J.BennettSimon. 2008. Ritual and Its Consequences: An Essay on the Limits of Sincerity. Oxford University Press.
39.
SeligmanAdam B.WasserfallRahel R.MontgomeryDavid W.. 2015. Living with Difference: How to Build Community in a Divided World. University of California Press.
40.
ShepherdAndrew. 2014. The Gift of the Other: Levinas, Derrida, and a Theology of Hospitality. James Clarke.
41.
vonBalthasar. 1983. “Hans Urs. the Glory of the Lord: a Theological Aesthetics. Volume I.” In Seeing the Form, edited by FessioJosephRichesJohn. Ignatius Press.
42.
WaldronJeremy.2015. “Locke Toleration and the Rationality of Persecution.” In Justifying Toleration: Conceptual and Historical Perspectives, edited by MendusSusan, 61–86. Cambridge University Press.
43.
WikanUnni.2000. “Citizenship on Trial: Nadia’s Case.” Dædalus129, no. 4: 55–76.
44.
WilliamsBernard.1996. “Toleration: an Impossible Virtue?” In Toleration: An Elusive Virtue, edited by HeydDavid, 18–27. Princeton University Press.
