In this article, I reconstruct Étienne Balibar’s work against the background of the debate on modern universal citizenship. I argue that universal citizenship is neither fundamentally emancipatory nor fundamentally oppressive but is rather both. In order to defend this position, I build on Balibar’s concept of the “citizen subject.” First, I parse this concept, showing how it allows us to think about the contradictions of modern universal citizenship. In the second section, I elucidate its temporal logic and show how it undermines the telos of modern universal citizenship. In sections three to five, I show how citizenship’s universalism clarifies both its oppressive and its emancipatory thrust. The dialectic of universal citizenship, I argue, unfolds as a conflict between and within political universals. In the conclusion, I will tie up these different strands and end with some reflections on the conditions of possibility of this dialectic.
AlthusserL. (2005). For Marx. (Trans. B. Brewster). London: Verso.
2.
ArendtH. (1969). Crises of the Republic. New York: Harcourt.
3.
ArendtH. (1976 [1951]). The Origins of Totalitarianism. New York: Houghton Miffler Harcourt.
4.
ArruzaC. (2017). “Capitalism and the Conflict Over Universality: A Feminist Perspective.” Philosophy Today61 (4): 847-861.
5.
BalibarÉ. (1988). “Propositions on Citizenship.” Ethics98 (4): 723-730.
6.
BalibarÉ. (1992a). Les Frontières de la Démocratie. Paris: La Découverte.
7.
BalibarÉ. (1992b). “Foucault and Marx: The Question of Nominalism.” In Michel Foucault: Philosopher, edited by ArmstrongT. J., 38-56. New York and London: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
8.
BalibarÉ. (1993). “The Non-Contemporaneity of Althusser.” In The Althusserian Legacy, edited by SprinkerM.KaplanA., 1-16. London: Verso.
9.
BalibarÉ. (1994a). Masses, Classes, Ideas: Studies on Politics and Philosophy Before and After Marx. (Trans. J. Swenson). London: Routledge.
10.
BalibarÉ. (1994b). “Man and Citizen: Who’s Who.” The Journal of Political Philosophy2 (2): 99-114.
11.
BalibarÉ. (1994c). “Subjection and Subjectivation.” In Supposing the Subject, edited by CopjecJ., 1-15. London: Verso Books.
12.
BalibarÉ. (1995). “The Infinite Contradiction.” Yale French Studies88: 142-164.
13.
BalibarÉ. (1996). “Structural Causality: Overdetermination and Antagonism.” In Postmodern Materialism and the Future of Marxist Theory, edited by CallariA.RuccioD. F., 109-120. Middletown, CT: Weslayan University.
14.
BalibarÉ. (1998). Spinoza and Politics. (Trans. P. Snowdon). London: Verso.
15.
BalibarÉ. (1999). “Interview: Conjectures and Conjunctures.” Radical Philosophy97 (September/October): 30-41.
16.
BalibarÉ. (2000 [1989]). “What Makes a People a People? Rousseau and Kant.” In Masses, Classes and the Public Sphere, edited by HillM.MontagW., 105-131. London: Verso.
17.
BalibarÉ. (2001). Nous, Citoyens d’Europe? Les Frontières, l’État, le Peuple. Paris: La Découverte.
18.
BalibarÉ. (2002a). Politics and the Other Scene. (Trans. C. Jones and J. Swenson). London: Verso.
19.
BalibarÉ. (2002b). Droit de Cité. Paris: PUF.
20.
BalibarÉ. (2003) “The Subject.” In Umbr(a), edited by CopjecJ., 9-22. Buffalo: Center for the Study of Psychoanalysis and Culture.
21.
BalibarÉ. (2004). We, The People of Europe? Reflections on Transnational Citizenship. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
22.
BalibarÉ. (2005a). L’Europe, l’ Amérique, la Guerre. Paris: La Découverte.
BalibarÉ. (2008). “Historical Dilemmas of Democracy and their Contemporary Relevance for Citizenship.” Rethinking Marxism20 (4): 522-538.
27.
BalibarÉ. (2009a). “Interview with Étienne Balibar.” In Communities of Sense: Rethinking Aesthetics and Politics, edited by HinderliterB.MaimonV.MansoorJ.McCormickS., 317-336. Durham, Duke University Press.
28.
BalibarÉ. (2009b). “Ideas of Europe: Civilization and Constitution.” Iris1 (1): 3-17.
29.
BalibarÉ. (2009c). “On the Aporias of Marxian Politics: From Civil War to Class Struggle.” Diacritics39 (2): 59-73.
30.
BalibarÉ. (2009d). “Violence and Civility: On the Limits of Political Anthropology.” Differences: a Journal of Feminist Cultural Studies20 (2/3): 9-35.
31.
BalibarÉ. (2010a). “Antinomies of Citizenship.” Journal of Romance Studies10 (2): 1-20.
32.
BalibarÉ. (2010b). “Philosophy and the Frontiers of the Political (A Biographical-Theoretical Interview with Emanuela Fornari).” Iris2 (3): 23-67.
33.
BalibarÉ. (2011). Citoyen Sujet et Autres Essais d’Anthropologie Philosophique. Paris: PUF.
34.
BalibarÉ. (2012a) “Civic Universalism and its Internal Exclusions: The Issue of Anthropological Difference.” Boundary 239 (1): 207-229.
35.
BalibarÉ. (2012b). “The ‘Impossible’ Community of Citizens: Past and Present Problems.” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space30: 437-449.
36.
BalibarÉ. (2012c). “Postscript: The Idea of ‘New Enlightenment” [Nouvelles Lumières] and the Contradictions of Universalism.” In Political Theology and Early Modernity, edited by HammillG. L.LuptonJ. R., 299-305. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
37.
BalibarÉ. (2013a). “On the Politics of Human Rights.” Constellations20 (1): 18-26.
38.
BalibarÉ. (2013b). “Politics of Debt.” Postmodern Culture23 (3).
39.
BalibarÉ. (2014a). Equaliberty: Political Essays. (Trans. J. Ingram). London and Durham: Duke University Press.
40.
BalibarÉ. (2014b). “Préface.” In L’Autre Citoyen: L’Idéal Républicain et les Antilles après l’Esclavage, LarcherS. (Auth.).Paris: Armand Colin, 5-12.
41.
BalibarÉ. (2015a). Violence and Civility: On the Limits of Political Philosophy. (Trans. G. M. Goshgarian). New York: Columbia University Press.
42.
BalibarÉ. (2015b). Citizenship. (Trans. T. Scott-Railton). London: Polity.
43.
BalibarÉ. (2015c). “Après la Révolution, Avant les Révolutions.” ZINBUN46: 41-56.
44.
BalibarÉ. (2015d). “Foucault’s Point of Heresy: ‘Quasi-Transcendentals’ and the Transdisciplinary Function of the Episteme.” Theory, Culture & Society32 (5–6): 45-77.
45.
BalibarÉ. (2015e). “On the Basic Concepts of Historical Materialism.” In Reading Capital (The Complete Edition), edited by AlthusserL.BalibarÉ.EtabletR.MachereyP.RancièreJ., 57-480 (Trans. B. Brewster and D. Fernbach). London: Verso.
46.
BalibarÉ. (2016a). Des Universels: Essais et Conférences. Paris: Galilée.
47.
BalibarÉ. (2016b). “Critique in the 21st Century: Political Economy Still, and Religion Again.” Radical Philosophy200 (November/December): 11-22.
BalibarÉ. (2016d). “Vers un Nouveau Cosmopolitisme? Étrangers, Pas Ennemis.” Altérités9 (1): 9-26.
50.
BalibarÉ. (2016e). Europe: Crise et Fin?Lormont: Le Bord de L’Eau.
51.
BalibarÉ. (2017a). Citizen Subject: Foundations for Philosophical Anthropology. (Trans. S. Miller). New York: Fordham University Press.
52.
BalibarÉ. (2017b). The Philosophy of Marx (Updated New Edition). (Trans. C. Turner and G. Elliott). London: Verso.
53.
BalibarÉ. (2017c). “A Point of Heresy in Western Marxism: Althusser’s and Tronti’s Antithetic Readings of Capital in the Early 1960’s.” In The Concept in Crisis: Reading Capital Today, edited by NesbittN., 93-112. Durham: Duke University Press.
54.
BalibarÉ. (2017d). “A New Querelle of Universals.” Philosophy Today61 (4): 929-945.
BalibarÉ. (2018a). Spinoza Politique: Le Transindividuel. Paris: PUF.
57.
BalibarÉ. (2018b). Libre Parole. Paris: Galilée.
58.
BalibarÉ. (2018c). “Exploitation.” In Political Concepts: A Critical Lexicon, edited by BernsteinJ. M.OphirA.StolerA. L., 131-144. New York: Fordham University Press.
BalibarÉ. (2019). “Absolute Capitalism.” In Mutant Neoliberalism, edited by CallisonW.ManfrediZ., 269-290. NY: Fordham University Press.
61.
BalibarÉ. (2020a). Histoire Interminable: D’un Siècle l’Autre (Écrits 1). Paris: La Découverte.
62.
BalibarÉ. (2020b). “Ontological Difference, Anthropological Difference, and Equal Liberty.” European Journal of Philosophy (Advance Publication).
63.
BalibarÉ.E.Laclau (2010). “Entretien avec et entre Étienne Balibar et Ernesto Laclau (interview by Basterra, G., Glasson, Deschaumes G., Ivekovic, R., Manchev, B. and Naishtat, F.)” Rue Descartes67 (1): 78-99.
64.
BalibarÉ.I.Wallerstein (1991). Race, Nation, Class: Ambiguous Identities. (Trans. C. Turner). London: Verso Books.
65.
BalibarÉ.B.CassinA.De Libera (2014). “Subject.” In Dictionary of Untranslatables: A Philosophical Lexicon, edited by CassinB., 1069-1090. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
66.
BellamyR. (2008). Citizenship: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
67.
BoonenC. (2020a). “At the Outer Limits of Democratic Division: On Citizenship, Conflict and Violence in the Work of Chantal Mouffe and Étienne Balibar.” International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society (Online First).
68.
BoonenC. (2020b). A Theory of Insurgent Citizenship: Democratic Action between Emancipation and Transformation. (Unpublished Dissertation).
69.
BosniakL. (2017). “Status Non-Citizens.” In The Oxford Handbook of Citizenship, edited by ShacharA.BauböckR.BloemraadI.VinkM., 314-336. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
70.
BrombergS. (2018). “Thinking Through Balibar’s Dialectics of Emancipation.” Historical Materialism26 (1): 223-254.
71.
CaseyLeo (2018). “The perils of universalism.” Dissent65 (1): 42-50.
72.
CelikatesR. (2010). “Die Demokratisierung der Demokratie: Etienne Balibar über die Dialektik von konstituierender und konstituierter Macht” In BröcklingU.FeustelR. (Eds.) Das Politische Denken: Zeitgenössische Positionen. Bielefeld: Transcript, p. 59-76.
73.
ChambersS. A. (2014). Bearing Society in Mind: Theories and Politics of the Social Formation. London: Rowman and Littlefield.
EnglertG. (2016). “Liberty and Industry: John Locke, John Stuart Mill, and the Economic Foundations of Political Membership.” Polity48 (4): 551-579.
76.
FraserN.L.Gordon (1994). “Civil Citizenship Against Social Citizenship? On the Ideology of Contract-Versus-Charity.” In The Condition of Citizenship, edited by Van SteenbergenB., 90-107. London: SAGE Publications.
77.
GetachewA. (2016). “Universalism after Postcolonialism.” Political Theory44 (6): 821-845.
78.
GlennE. N. (2002). Unequal Freedom: How Race and Gender Shaped American Citizenship and Labour. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
79.
GündoğduA. (2015). Rightlessness in an Age of Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
HindessB. (2004). “Citizenship for All.” Citizenship Studies8 (3): 305-315.
82.
IngramJ. D. (2008). “What is a ‘Right to Have Rights’? Three Images of the Politics of Human Rights.” American Political Science Review102 (4): 401-416.
83.
IngramJ. D. (2013). Radical Cosmopolitics: The Ethics and Politics of Democratic Universalism. New York: Columbia University Press.
84.
IngramJ. D. (2015). “Democracy and Its Conditions: Étienne Balibar and the Contribution of Marxism to Radical Democracy.” In Thinking Radical Democracy: The Return of Politics in Post-War France, edited by BreaughM.HolmanC.MagnussonR.MazzocchiP.PennerD., 210-233. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
85.
IsinE.RuppertE. (2015). Being Digital Citizens. London: Rowman & Littlefield.
86.
KouvelakisS. (2005). “The Marxian Critique of Citizenship: For a Rereading of On the Jewish Question.” The South Atlantic Quarterly104 (4): 707-721.
87.
LampertJ. (2009). “Theory of Delay in Balibar, Freud and Deleuze: Décalage, Nachtraglichkeit, Retard.” In Deleuze and History, edited by BellJ. A.ColebrookC., 72-91. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
88.
LentinA. (2004). Racism and Anti-Racism in Europe. London: Pluto Press.
89.
LentinA. (2008). “Europe and the Silence about Race.” European Journal of Social Theory11 (4): 487-503.
90.
LievensM. (2007). “De Democratisering van de Grens: Etienne Balibar over Transnationaal Burgerschap.” Ethische Perspectieven17 (2): 242-257.
91.
LillaM. (2018). The Once and Future Liberal: After Identity Politics.London: Hurst and Company.
92.
MacphersonC. B. (2011 [1962]). The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
93.
MarksS. (2009). “False Contingency.” Current Legal Problems62 (1): 1-21.
94.
MehtaU. S. (1990). “Liberal Strategies of Exclusion.” Politics and Society18 (4): 427-454.
95.
MenkeC. (2015). Kritik der Rechte. Berlin: Suhrkamp.
96.
MezzadraS. (2007). “‘Property of the Self’: Individual Autonomy and the Modern European Discourse of Citizenship.” In Autonomy: Beyond Kant and Hermeneutics, edited by BanerjeeP.DasS. K., 37-48. London: Anthem Press.
97.
MillsC. W. (2017). Black Rights/White Wrongs: The Critique of Racial Liberalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
98.
MontagW. (2013) Althusser and his Contemporaries: Philosophy’s Perpetual War. Durham and London: Duke University Press.
99.
MontagW. (2018). “Between Subject and Citizen: On Étienne Balibar’s Foundations for Philosophical Anthropology.” Radical Philosophy2 (2): 39-46.
100.
MorfinoV. (2015). “The Concept of Structural Causality in Althusser.” Crisis & Critique2 (2): 87-107.
101.
OksalaJ. (2012). Foucault, Politics and Violence. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.
102.
PfeiferG. (2020). “Balibar, Citizenship, and the Return of Right Populism.” Philosophy and Social Criticism46 (3): 323-341.
103.
PlumauzilleC. M. (2020). “Quelque Chose de Pourri au Royaume de l’Universalisme Républicain.” Libération (24 June 2020).
104.
ReadJ. (2004). “Writing in Conjuncture.” Borderlands e-Journal3 (1).
105.
ReadJ. (2016). The Politics of Transindividuality.Chicago: Haymarket Books.
106.
ReadJ. (2017). “The ‘Other Scene’ of Political Antropology: Between Transindividuality and Equaliberty.” In Balibar and the Citizen Subject, edited by MontagW.ElsayedH., 111-131. Edinburgh: Edinburgh Press.
107.
RoddR. (2018). “The ‘I’ and the ‘We’ of Citizenship in the Age of Waning Democracy: Wolin and Balibar on Citizenship, the Political and Dedemocratization.” Citizenship Studies22 (3): 312-328.
108.
TaylorK. Y. (2016). From #Blacklivesmatter to Black Liberation. Chicago: Haymarket Books.
109.
TombaM. (2019). Insurgent Universality: An Alternative Legacy of Modernity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
110.
ToscanoA. (2014). “Transition Deprogrammed.” South Atlantic Quarterly113 (4): 761-775.
111.
TurnerB. S. (1990). “Outline of a Theory of Citizenship.” Sociology24 (2): 189-217.
112.
YazdaniK. (2021). “The Poverty of Mainstream Universalism and Exclusive Identity Politics.” openDemocracy (23 March 2021).
113.
YoungI. M. (1989). “Polity and Group Difference: A Critique of the Ideal of Universal Citizenship.” Ethics99: 250-274.
114.
WalkerG. (2012). “Citizen-Subject and the National Question: On the Logic of Capital In Balibar.” Postmodern Culture22 (3).
115.
ŽižekS. (2008). The Ticklish Subject: The Absent Centre of Political Ontology (New Edition). London: Verso.
