Although homophily is a widely studied phenomenon, less is known about how choice homophily forms at the micro level. Leveraging identity theory, this article uses qualitative methods to trace a four-stage process of identity matching within the case site of psychotherapy. Drawing from 90 interviews with therapists and 30 interviews with clients of therapy, I show how client and therapist (1) make salient certain identity meanings and (2) attempt an initial identity verification. Then, as client and therapist enter the therapy room, they (3) negotiate this perceived identity verification toward an identity match. This process generates safety and trust and leads to a final stage in which therapist and client (4) deepen their identity-based connections and generate satisfaction by mutually enacting their shared identities. I conclude by proposing a spectrum of homophily from thin homophily to thick homophily.
AnWeihua. 2022. “Friendship Network Formation in Chinese Middle Schools: Patterns of Inequality and Homophily.”Social Networks68:218–28.
3.
BoutylineAndreiWillerRobb. 2017. “The Social Structure of Political Echo Chambers: Variation in Ideological Homophily in Online Networks.”Political Psychology38(3):551–69.
ChanTackAnjanetteM.SmallMario L.2017. “Making Friends in Violent Neighborhoods: Strategies among Elementary School Children.”Sociological Science4:224–48.
6.
ConstantinoMichael J.BoswellJames F.CoyneAlice E.SwalesThomas P.KrausDavid R.2021. “Effect of Matching Therapists to Patients vs Assignment as Usual on Adult Psychotherapy Outcomes: A Randomized Clinical Trial.”JAMA Psychiatry78(9):960–69.
7.
DandekarPranavGoelAshishLeeDavid T.2013. “Biased Assimilation, Homophily, and the Dynamics of Polarization.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences110(15):5791–96.
8.
DickinsonEmily. [1894] 2012. Letters of Emily Dickinson. Garden City, NY: Dover Publications.
9.
DiMaggioPaulGaripFiliz. 2012. “Network Effects and Social Inequality.”Annual Review of Sociology38(1):93–118.
10.
EdmondsonAmy C.LeiZhike. 2014. “Psychological Safety: The History, Renaissance, and Future of an Interpersonal Construct.”Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior1(1):23–43.
11.
ErtlMelissa M.Mann-SaumierMichelleMartinRenee A.GravesDonald F.AltarribaJeanette. 2019. “The Impossibility of Client–Therapist ‘Match’: Implications and Future Directions for Multicultural Competency.”Journal of Mental Health Counseling41(4):312–26.
12.
ErtugGokhanBrenneckeJuliaKovácsBalázsZouTengjian. 2022. “What Does Homophily Do? A Review of the Consequences of Homophily.”Academy of Management Annals16(1):38–69.
13.
FonagyPeterAllisonElizabeth. 2014. “The Role of Mentalizing and Epistemic Trust in the Therapeutic Relationship.”Psychotherapy51(3):372–80.
14.
FreyErinBernsteinEthanRekenthalerNick. 2022. “Scarlet Letters: Rehabilitation through Transgression Transparency and Personal Narrative Control.”Administrative Science Quarterly67(4):968–1011.
15.
GerberElisabeth R.HenryAdam D.LubellMark. 2013. “Political Homophily and Collaboration in Regional Planning Networks.”American Journal of Political Science57(3):598–610.
16.
GersonKathleenDamaskeSarah. 2020. The Science and Art of Interviewing. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
17.
GoffmanErving. 2017. Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates. London, UK: Routledge.
18.
GreenbergJasonMollickEthan. 2017. “Activist Choice Homophily and the Crowdfunding of Female Founders.”Administrative Science Quarterly62(2):341–74.
19.
HeatonBrendaGondalNeha. 2023. “Health-Based Homophily in Public Housing Developments.”BMC Public Health23(1):238. doi:10.1186/s12889-023-15146-4.
20.
HermanSteven M.1998. “The Relationship between Therapist–Client Modality Similarity and Psychotherapy Outcome.”The Journal of Psychotherapy Practice and Research7(1):56–64.
21.
InbarYoelLammersJoris. 2012. “Political Diversity in Social and Personality Psychology.”Perspectives on Psychological Science7(5):496–503.
22.
KatzJack. 1996. “Families and Funny Mirrors: A Study of the Social Construction and Personal Embodiment of Humor.”American Journal of Sociology101(5):1194–237.
23.
KittsJames A.LealDiego F.2021. “What Is(n’t) a Friend? Dimensions of the Friendship Concept among Adolescents.”Social Networks66:161–70.
24.
KossinetsGueorgiWattsDuncan J.2009. “Origins of Homophily in an Evolving Social Network.”American Journal of Sociology115(2):405–50.
25.
LangAriellaEdwardsNancyFleiszerAndrea. 2008. “Safety in Home Care: A Broadened Perspective of Patient Safety.”International Journal for Quality in Health20(2):130–35.
26.
LeszczenskyLarsPinkSebastian. 2019. “What Drives Ethnic Homophily? A Relational Approach on How Ethnic Identification Moderates Preferences for Same-Ethnic Friends.”American Sociological Review84(3):394–419.
27.
LibermanZoeKinzlerKatherine D.WoodwardAmanda L.2021. “Origins of Homophily: Infants Expect People with Shared Preferences to Affiliate.”Cognition212:104695. doi:10.1016/j.cognition.2021.104695.
28.
LizardoOmar. 2006. “How Cultural Tastes Shape Personal Networks.”American Sociological Review71(5):778–807.
McMillanCassie. 2022. “Worth the Weight: Conceptualizing and Measuring Strong versus Weak tie Homophily.”Social Networks68:139–47.
31.
McPhersonMiller J.Smith-LovinLynn. 1987. “Homophily in Voluntary Organizations: Status Distance and the Composition of Face-to-Face Groups.”American Sociological Review52(3):370–79.
32.
McPhersonMiller J.Smith-LovinLynnRawlingsCraig. 2021. “The Enormous Flock of Homophily Researchers: Assessing and Promoting a Research Agenda.” Pp. 459–70 in Personal Networks: Classic Readings and New Directions in Egocentric Analysis, edited bySmallM. L.PerryB. L.PescosolidoB.SmithE. B.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
33.
MelamedDavidSweitzerMatthewSimpsonBrentAbernathyJered Z.HarrellAshleyMunnChristopher W.2020. “Homophily and Segregation in Cooperative Networks.”American Journal of Sociology125(4):1084–127.
34.
MillsC. Wright. [1959]2000. The Sociological Imagination. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
35.
MoonSarah H.SandageSteven J.2019. “Cultural Humility for People of Color: Critique of Current Theory and Practice.”Journal of Psychology and Theology47(2):76–86.
36.
NehringDanielFrawleyAshley. 2020. “Mindfulness and the ‘Psychological Imagination.’”Sociology of Health & Illness42(5):1184–201.
OwensTimothy J.RobinsonDawn T.Smith-LovinLynn. 2010. “Three Faces of Identity.”Annual Review of Sociology36(1):477–99.
39.
ReicherStephenHopkinsNickStevensonCliffordPandeyKavitaShankarShailTewariShruti. 2021. “Identity Enactment as Collective Accomplishment: Religious Identity Enactment at Home and at a Festival.”British Journal of Social Psychology60(2):678–99.
40.
RekenthalerNick. 2023. “The ‘Waves:’ Conceptualizing Covid-19 as an Event through One (Particularly) Contested Metaphor.”Poetics99:101808. doi:10.1016/j.poetic.2023.101808.
41.
RiveraLauren A.2012. “Hiring as Cultural Matching: The Case of Elite Professional Service Firms.”American Sociological Review77(6):999–1022.
42.
SealeElizabethBuckAlisonParrottaKylie. 2012. “Who’s to Blame? The Identity Talk of Welfare-to-Work Program Managers.”Sociological Perspectives55(3):501–27.
43.
SeawrightJason. 2016. “The Case for Selecting Cases That Are Deviant or Extreme on the Independent Variable.”Sociological Methods & Research45(3):493–525.
44.
SepulvadoBrandonWoodMichael LeeFridmanskiEthanWangChengChandlerMatthew J.LizardoOmarHachenDavid. 2022. “Predicting Homophily and Social Network Connectivity from Dyadic Behavioral Similarity Trajectory Clusters.”Social Science Computer Review40(1):195–211.
45.
SimonGregory E.ImelZachary E.LudmanEvette J.SteinfeldBradley J.2012. “Is Dropout after a First Psychotherapy Visit Always a Bad Outcome?”Psychiatric Services63(7):705–707.
46.
SmithJeffrey A.McPhersonMillerSmith-LovinLynn. 2014. “Social Distance in the United States: Sex, Race, Religion, Age, and Education Homophily among Confidants, 1985 to 2004.”American Sociological Review79(3):432–56.
47.
SmithTimothy B.TrimbleJoseph E.2016. “Matching Clients with Therapists on the Basis of Race or Ethnicity: A Meta-analysis of Clients’ Level of Participation in Treatment.” Pp.115–28 in Foundations of Multicultural Psychology: Research to Inform Effective Practice, edited by SmithT. B.TrimbleJ. E.Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
SteffensNiklas K.HaslamS. AlexanderReicherStephen D.PlatowMichael J.KatrienFransenYangJieRyanMichelle K.JettenJolandaPetersKimBoenFilip. 2014. “Leadership as Social Identity Management: Introducing the Identity Leadership Inventory (ILI) to Assess and Validate a Four-Dimensional Model.”The Leadership Quarterly25(5):1001–24.
50.
StetsJan E.JohnAldecoaQuinnBloomJoelWinegar. 2021. “Using Identity Theory to Understand Homophily in Groups.” Pp. 285–302 in Identities in Action: Developments in Identity Theory, edited by BrennerP. S.StetsJ. E.SerpeR. T.Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing.
51.
StetsJan E.CarterMichael J.2011. “The Moral Self: Applying Identity Theory.”Social Psychology Quarterly74(2):192–215.
52.
StrykerSheldon. 2008. “From Mead to a Structural Symbolic Interactionism and Beyond.”Annual Review of Sociology34(1):15–31.
53.
TajfelHenriTurnerJohn C.1986. “Social Categorization, Social Identity, and Social Comparison.” Pp. 61–76 in Differentiation between Social Groups, edited by TajfelH.London, UK: Academic Press.
54.
TavoryIddo. 2023. “A Theory of Intersubjectivity: Experience, Interaction and the Anchoring of Meaning.”Theory and Society52(5):865–84.
55.
TimmermansStefanTavoryIddo. 2022. Data Analysis in Qualitative Research: Theorizing with Abductive Analysis. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
56.
TurnerJonathan H.StetsJan E.2006. “Sociological Theories of Human Emotions.”Annual Review of Sociology32(1):25–52.
57.
UenoKojiWrightEric R.GaymanMathew D.McCabeJanice M.2012. “Segregation in Gay, Lesbian and Bisexual Youth's Personal Networks: Testing Structural Constraint, Choice Homophily and Compartmentalization Hypotheses.”Social Forces90(3):971–91.
58.
VaiseyStephenLizardoOmar. 2010. “Can Cultural Worldviews Influence Network Composition?”Social Forces88(4):1595–618.
59.
Wagner-PacificiRobin. 2019. What Is an Event?Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
60.
WeberHannesSchwenzerMarcHillmertSteffen. 2020. “Homophily in the Formation and Development of Learning Networks among University Students.”Network Science8(4):469–91.
61.
WimmerAndreasLewisKevin. 2010. “Beyond and below Racial Homophily: ERG Models of a Friendship Network Documented on Facebook.”American Journal of Sociology116(2):583–642.
62.
ZhaoLinda. 2023. “Networks in the Making: Friendship Segregation and Ethnic Homophily.”Social Science Research110:102813. doi:10.1016/j.ssresearch.2022.102813.
