Building on social psychological research on individual bias, this article uses the concept of “perceived blameworthiness” to investigate whether Black and Latino boys are perceived by teachers as being more culpable, or “blameworthy,” than White boys for objectively identical, routine classroom misbehavior at school. To isolate teacher bias from true differences in behavior, I use an original video experiment involving 1,339 teachers in 295 U.S. schools. Teachers in the experiment are randomly assigned to view and respond to a video of a White, Black, or Latino boy committing identical misbehavior. I find that Black boys experience teacher blaming bias, where they are perceived as being more “blameworthy” than White boys for identical misbehavior. Results for Latino boys are directionally similar to those for Black boys but do not reach statistical significance. Findings have implications for racialized assessments of behavior across a range of evaluative contexts.
AngristJoshua D.PischkeJörn-Steffen. 2008. Mostly Harmless Econometrics: An Empiricistś Companion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
2.
BerkovichIzhakGrinshtainYael. 2022. “Typology of 'Tough Love' Leadership in Urban Schools Facing Challenging Circumstances.” Urban Education57(1):108–34.
3.
BowlesSamuelGintisHerbertOsborneMelissa. 2001. “The Determinants of Earnings: A Behavioral Approach.” Journal of Economic Literature39(4):1137–76.
4.
BradshawCatherine P.MitchellMary M.O’BrennanLindsey M.LeafPhilip J.2010. “Multilevel Exploration of Factors Contributing to the Overrepresentation of Black Students in Office Disciplinary Referrals.” Journal of Educational Psychology102(2):508–20.
5.
BridgesGeorge S.SteenSara. 1998. “Racial Disparities in Official Assessments of Juvenile Offenders: Attributional Stereotypes as Mediating Mechanisms.” American Sociological Review64(3):554–70.
6.
CarterPrudence L.2005. Keepin’ It Real: School Success beyond Black and White. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
7.
CollinsPatricia Hill. 2015. “Intersectionality’s Definitional Dilemmas.” Annual Review of Sociology41:1–20.
8.
DeeThomas S.2005. “A Teacher Like Me: Does Race, Ethnicity, or Gender Matter?” The American Economic Review95(2): 158–65.
9.
EgaliteAnna J.KisidaBrian. 2018. “The Effects of Teacher Match on Students’ Academic Perceptions and Attitudes.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis40(1): 59–81. doi:10.3102/0162373717714056.
10.
ElliottSinikkaReidMegan. 2019. “Low-Income Black Mothers Parenting Adolescents in the Mass Incarceration Era: The Long Reach of Criminalization.” American Sociological Review84(2):197–219.
11.
FaderJamie J.KurlychekMegan C.MorganKirstin A.2014. “The Color of Juvenile Justice: Racial Disparities in Dispositional Decisions.” Social Science Research44:126–40.
12.
FergusonAnn A.2001. Bad Boys: Public Schools in the Making of Black Masculinity. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
13.
GarlandDavid. 2012. Punishment and Modern Society: A Study in Social Theory. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
14.
GayGeneva. 2018. Culturally Responsive Teaching: Theory, Research, and Practice. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
15.
GershensonSethHartCassandraHymanJoshuaLindsayConstancePapageorgeNicholas W.2018. “The Long-Run Impacts of Same-Race Teachers.” Working Paper 25254. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
16.
GilliamWalter S.MaupinAngela N.ReyesChin R.AccavittiMariaShicFrederick. 2016. Do Early Educators’ Implicit Biases Regarding Sex and Race Relate to Behavior Expectations and Recommendations of Preschool Expulsions and Suspensions?New Haven, CT: Yale Child Study Center, Yale University.
17.
GoffPhillip A.JacksonMatthew C.LeoneDiLewisBrooke A.CulottaCarmen M.DiTomassoNatalie A.2014. “The Essence of Innocence: Consequences of Dehumanizing Black Children.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology106(4):526–45.
18.
GregoryAnneHuangFrancis L.AnyonYolandaGreerEldridgeDowningBarbara. 2018. “An Examination of Restorative Interventions and Racial Equity in Out-of-School Suspensions.” School Psychology Review47(2):167–82.
KinslerJosh. 2011. “Understanding the Black–White School Discipline Gap.” Economics of Education Review30(6):1370–83.
21.
KrysanMariaCouperMick P.FarleyReynoldsFormanTyrone. 2009. “Does Race Matter in Neighborhood Preferences? Results from a Video Experiment.” American Journal of Sociology115(2):527–59.
22.
LewisAmanda E.DiamondJohn B.2015. Despite the Best Intentions: How Racial Inequality Thrives in Good Schools. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
23.
LindsayConstance A.HartCassandra M. D.2017. “Exposure to Same-Race Teachers and Student Disciplinary Outcomes for Black Students in North Carolina.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis39(3):485–510.
24.
MorrisEdward W.2005. “'Tuck in That Shirt!' Race, Class, Gender, and Discipline in an Urban School.” Sociological Perspectives48(1):25–48.
25.
MorrisEdward W.2012. Learning the Hard Way: Masculinity, Place, and the Gender Gap in Education. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
26.
MorrisEdward W.PerryBrea L.2017. “Girls Behaving Badly? Race, Gender, and Subjective Evaluation in the Discipline of African American Girls.” Sociology of Education90(2):127–48.
27.
Office of Civil Rights, U.S. Department of Education. 2020. “2017-18 Civil Rights Data Collection.” Washington, DC: Office of Civil Rights.
28.
OkonofuaJason A.EberhardtJennifer L.2015. “Two Strikes: Race and the Disciplining of Young Students.” Psychological Science26(5):617–24.
29.
OkonofuaJason A.PauneskuDavidWaltonGregory M.2016. “Brief Intervention to Encourage Empathic Discipline Cuts Suspension Rates in Half among Adolescents.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences113(19):5221–26.
30.
OwensJayanti. 2016. “Early Childhood Behavior Problems and the Gender Gap in Educational Attainment in the United States.” Sociology of Education89(3): 236–58.
31.
OwensJayantiMcLanahanSara. 2020. “Unpacking the Drivers of Racial Disparities in School Suspension and Expulsion in the U.S.” Social Forces98(4):1548–77.
32.
OwensJayanti. 2022. “Double Jeopardy: Teacher Biases, Racialized Organizations, and the Production of Racial/Ethnic Disparities in School Discipline.” American Sociological Review87(6):1007–1048.
33.
PegueroAnthony A.ShekarkharZahra. 2011. “Latino/a Student Misbehavior and School Punishment.” Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences33(1):54–70.
34.
PetrilliMichael J.2012. The Diverse Schools Dilemma: A Parent’s Guide to Socioeconomically Mixed Public Schools. Washington, DC: Thomas B. Fordham Institute.
35.
RameyDavid M.2018. “The Social Construction of Child Social Control via Criminalization and Medicalization: Why Race Matters.” Sociological Forum33(1):139–64.
36.
ReddingChristopher. 2019. “A Teacher Like Me: A Review of the Effect of Student–Teacher Racial/Ethnic Matching on Teacher Perceptions of Students and Student Academic and Behavioral Outcomes.” Review of Educational Research89(4): 499–535.
37.
RiosVictor M.2011. Punished: Policing the Lives of Black and Latino Boys. New York, NY: New York University Press.
38.
RocqueMichael. 2010. “Office Discipline and Student Behavior: Does Race Matter?” American Journal of Education116(4): 557–81.
39.
RuedaEréndira. 2015. “The Benefits of Being Latino: Differential Interpretations of Student Behavior and the Social Construction of Being Well Behaved.” Journal of Latinos and Education14(4):275–90.
40.
SchulmanKevin A.BerlinJesse A.HarlessWilliamKernerJon F.SistrunkShyrlGershBernard J.DubeRossTaleghaniChristopher K.BurkeJennifer E.WilliamsSankey. 1999. “The Effect of Race and Sex on Physicians’ Recommendations for Cardiac Catheterization.” New England Journal of Medicine340(8):618–26.
41.
SkibaRussell J.ChungChoong-GeunTrachokMeganBakerTimberly L.SheyaAdamHughesRobin L.2014. “Parsing Disciplinary Disproportionality: Contributions of Infraction, Student, and School Characteristics to Out-of-School Suspension and Expulsion.” American Educational Research Journal51(4):640–70.
42.
SkibaRussell J.HornerRobert H.ChungChoong-GeunRauschM. KaregaMaySeth L.TobinTary. 2011. “Race Is Not Neutral: A National Investigation of African American and Latino Disproportionality in School Discipline.” School Psychology Review40(1):85–107.
43.
StarckJordan G.RiddleTravisSinclairStaceyWarikooNatasha. 2020. “Teachers Are People Too: Examining the Racial Bias of Teachers Compared to Other American Adults.” Educational Researcher49(4):273–84.
44.
SteffensmeierDarrellUlmerJefferyKramerJohn. 1998. “The Interaction of Race, Gender, and Age in Criminal Sentencing: The Punishment Cost of Being Young, Black, and Male.” Criminology36(4):763–98.
45.
TysonKarolyn. 2003. “Notes from the Back of the Room: Problems and Paradoxes in the Schooling of Young Black Students.” Sociology of Education76(4):326–43.
46.
VavrusFrancesColeKimMarie. 2002. “'I Didn’t Do Nothin': The Discursive Construction of School Suspension.” The Urban Review34(2):87–111.
47.
WallaceJohn M.GoodkindSaraWallaceCynthia M.BachmanJerald G.2008. “Racial, Ethnic, and Gender Differences in School Discipline among U.S. High School Students: 1991-2005.” The Negro Educational Review59(1–2):47–62.
48.
WeinsteinRhona S.2002. Reaching Higher: The Power of Expectations in Schooling. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
49.
WelchKellyPayneAllison Ann. 2018. “Latino/a Student Threat and School Disciplinary Policies and Practices.” Sociology of Education91(2):91–110.
50.
WelchKellyPayneAllison AnnChiricosTedGertzMarc. 2011. “The Typification of Hispanics as Criminals and Support for Punitive Crime Control Policies.” Social Science Research40(3):822–40.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
