Most medical researchers and social scientists concur that mental illness is caused by “nature” and “nurture,” yet efforts to reduce stigma tend to focus on biomedical causes. This study analyzed original survey data collected from 1,849 respondents in 2021–2022 who were randomly assigned to 16 experimental vignette conditions. Each vignette portrayed a man and varied according to which psychiatric diagnosis his situation resembled (alcohol dependence, depression, or schizophrenia) and what caused it: genetics (nature), environmental stress (nurture), or both. Control conditions included subclinical distress and no explanation. Exposure to the environmental explanation (vs. no explanation) predicted identifying mental illness, reduced expectation of violence toward others, increased willingness to socially interact, and optimism for recovery with treatment. Exposure to the nature and nurture explanation (vs. no explanation) predicted reduced desire for social distance. Implications of these findings for future research and for contact-based anti-stigma efforts are presented.
AnderssonMatthew A.HarknessSarah K.2018. “When Do Biological Attributions of Mental Illness Reduce Stigma? Using Qualitative Comparative Analysis to Contextualize Attributions.” Society and Mental Health8(3):175–94.
2.
AngermeyerMatthias C.HolzingerAnitaCartaMauro G.SchomerusGeorg. 2011. “Biogenetic Explanations and Public Acceptance of Mental Illness: Systematic Review of Population Studies.” The British Journal of Psychiatry199(5):367–72.
3.
AssaryElhamVincentJohn PaulKeersRobertPluessMichael. 2018. “Gene-Environment Interaction and Psychiatric Disorders: Review and Future Directions.” Seminars in Cell & Developmental Biology77:133–43.
4.
BarczykAmanda N.2015. “Relationship between the Public’s Belief in Recovery, Level of Mental Illness Stigma, and Previous Contact.” Community Mental Health Journal51(1):38–47.
5.
BennettLauraThirlawayKathrynMurrayAlexandra J.2008. “The Stigmatising Implications of Presenting Schizophrenia as a Genetic Disease.” Journal of Genetic Counseling17(6):550–59.
6.
ChatmonBenita N.2020. “Males and Mental Health Stigma.” American Journal of Men’s Health14(4):1557988320949322. doi:10.11 77/1557988320949322.
7.
ChoudhryFahad RiazManiVasudevanMingLong Chiau, and Tahir Mehmood Khan. 2016. “Beliefs and Perception about Mental Health Issues: A Meta-synthesis.” Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment12:2807–18.
8.
CorriganPatrick W.2000. “Mental Health Stigma as Social Attribution: Implications for Research Methods and Attitude Change.” Clinical Psychology7(1):48–67.
9.
CorriganPatrick W.BinkAndrea B.SchmidtAnnie. 2018. “Reducing Physical Illness Stigma: Insights from the Mental Illness Arena.” Pp. 413–27 in The Oxford Handbook of Stigma, Discrimination, and Health. Oxford Library of Psychology, edited by MajorB.DovidioJ. F.LinkB. G.New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
10.
CorriganPatrick W.EdwardsAnnette BacksGreenAmyDiwanSarah LickeyPennDavid L.2001. “Prejudice, Social Distance, and Familiarity with Mental Illness.” Schizophrenia Bulletin27(2):219–25.
11.
CorriganPatrick W.GreenAmyLundinRobertKubiakMary AnnPennDavid L.2001. “Familiarity with and Social Distance from People Who Have Serious Mental Illness.” Psychiatric Services52(7):953–58.
12.
CorriganPatrick W.MarkowitzFred E.WatsonAmyRowanDavidKubiakMary Ann. 2003. “An Attribution Model of Public Discrimination towards Persons with Mental Illness.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior44(2):162–79.
13.
CorriganPatrick W.WatsonAmy C.2007. “The Stigma of Psychiatric Disorders and the Gender, Ethnicity, and Education of the Perceiver.” Community Mental Health Journal43(5):439–58.
14.
Dar-NimrodIlanHeineSteven J.2011. “Genetic Essentialism: On the Deceptive Determinism of DNA.” Psychological Bulletin137(5):800–18.
15.
DeLucaJoseph S.VaccaroJohnSedaJennaYanosPhilip T.2018. “Political Attitudes as Predictors of the Multiple Dimensions of Mental Health Stigma.” International Journal of Social Psychiatry64(5): 459–69.
16.
DobranskyKerry M.2020. “Reassessing Mental Illness Stigma in Mental Health Care: Competing Stigmas and Risk Containment.” Social Science & Medicine249:112861. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2020. 112861.
17.
EdwardsKatie M.TurchikJessica A.DardisChristina M.ReynoldsNicoleGidyczChristine A.2011. “Rape Myths: History, Individual and Institutional-Level Presence, and Implications for Change.” Sex Roles65(11–12):761–73.
18.
ElliottMarta. 2023. “Explanatory Models of Mental Illness among Working Professionals Diagnosed with Bipolar or Depression in the United States.” International Journal of Social Psychiatry69(2):476–82. doi:10.1177%2F00207640221109156.
19.
EylemOzlemWitLeonore DeStratenAnnemieke VanSteublLenaMelissourgakiZanetaDanışmanGözde TopgüloğluVriesRalph DeKerkhofAd JFMBhuiKamaldeepCuijpersPim. 2020. “Stigma for Common Mental Disorders in Racial Minorities and Majorities: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis.” BMC Public Health20(1):879. doi:10.1186/s12889-020-0896.
20.
FelixElizabethLynnFreda. 2022. “Mental Health Stigma and Social Contact Revisited: The Role of Network Closeness and Negativity.” Society and Mental Health12(1):49–63.
21.
GadermannAnne M.GuhnMartinZumboBruno. 2012. “Estimating Ordinal Reliability for Likert-Type and or t-Type and Ordinal Item Response Data: A Conceptual, Empirical, and Practical Guide.” Practical, Assessment, Research, and Evaluation17:3. doi:/10.7275/n560-j767.
22.
GoffmanErving. 1963. Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
23.
HayesAndrew F.2017. Introduction to Mediation, Moderation, and Conditional Process Analysis: A Regression-Based Approach. 2nd ed.New York, NY: Guilford Press.
24.
HeiderFritz. 1958. The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations. New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons Inc.
25.
HorwitzAllan V.2021. DSM: A History of Psychiatry’s Bible. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
26.
Jolicoeur-MartineauAlexiaBelskyJaySzekelyEszterWidamanKeith F.PluessMichaelGreenwoodCeliaWazanaAshley. 2020. “Distinguishing Differential Susceptibility, Diathesis-Stress, and Vantage Sensitivity: Beyond the Single Gene and Environment Model.” Development and Psychopathology32(1):73–83.
27.
KendlerKenneth S.2019. “From Many to One to Many—The Search for Causes of Psychiatric Illness.” JAMA Psychiatry76(10):1085–91.
28.
KvaaleErlend P.HaslamNickGottdienerWilliam H.2013. “The ‘Side Effects’ of Medicalization: A Meta-analytic Review of How Biogenetic Explanations Affect Stigma.” Clinical Psychology Review33(6):782–94.
29.
LebowitzMatthew S.AhnWoo-kyoung. 2012. “Combining Biomedical Accounts of Mental Disorders with Treatability Information to Reduce Mental Illness Stigma.” Psychiatric Services63(5):496–99.
30.
LebowitzMatthew S.AppelbaumPaul S.2019. “Biomedical Explanations of Psychopathology and Their Implications for Attitudes and Beliefs about Mental Disorders.” Annual Review of Clinical Psychology15:555–77.
31.
LeeAaron ALaurentSean M.WykesThomas L.Kitchen AndrenKatherine A.BourassaKatelynn A.McKibbinChristine L.2014. “Genetic Attributions and Mental Illness Diagnosis: Effects on Perceptions of Danger, Social Distance, and Real Helping Decisions.” Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology49(5):781–89.
32.
LewisTené T.CogburnCourtney D.Williams.David R.2015. “Self-Reported Experiences of Discrimination and Health: Scientific Advances, Ongoing Controversies, and Emerging Issues.” Annual Review of Clinical Psychology11(1):407–40.
33.
LincolnTania M.ArensElisabethBergerCorneliaRiefWinfried. 2008. “Can Antistigma Campaigns Be Improved? A Test of the Impact of Biogenetic vs. Psychosocial Causal Explanations on Implicit and Explicit Attitudes to Schizophrenia.” Schizophrenia Bulletin34(5):984–94.
34.
LinkBruce G.WellsJenniferPhelanJo C.YangLawrence. 2015. “Understanding the Importance of ‘Symbolic Interaction Stigma’: How Expectations about the Reactions of Others Adds to the Burden of Mental Illness Stigma.” Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal38(2):117–24.
35.
MarkowitzFred E.AngellBethGreenbergJan S.2011. “Stigma, Reflected Appraisals, and Recovery Outcomes in Mental Illness.” Social Psychology Quarterly74(2):144–65.
36.
MarkowitzFred E.EngelmanDouglas J.2017. “The ‘Own’ and the ‘Wise’: Does Stigma Status Buffer or Exacerbate Social Rejection of College Students with a Mental Illness?”Deviant Behavior38(7):744–55.
37.
MartinJack K.PescosolidoBernice A.TuchSteven A.2000. “Of Fear and Loathing: The Role of Disturbing Behavior, Labels, and Causal Attributions in Shaping Public Attitudes toward People with Mental Illness.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior41(2):208–23.
38.
MossakowskiKrysia N.KaplanLauren M.HillTerrence D.2011. “Americans’ Attitudes toward Mental Illness and Involuntary Psychiatric Medication.” Society and Mental Health1(3):200–16.
39.
National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine. 2016. Ending Discrimination Against People with Mental and Substance Use Disorders. The Evidence for Stigma Change. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
40.
PerryBreaPescosolidoBernice A.KrendlAnne. 2020. “The Unique Nature of Public Stigma toward Opioid Use Disorders: A National Study.” Addiction115:2317–26.
41.
PescosolidoBernice A.Halpern-MannersAndrewLuoLiyingPerryBrea. 2021. “Trends in Public Stigma of Mental Illness in the US, 1996-2018.” JAMA Network Open4(12):e2140202. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2021.40202.
42.
PescosolidoBernice A.ManagoBiancaMonahanJohn. 2019. “Evolving Public Views on the Likelihood of Violence from People with Mental Illness: Stigma and Its Consequences.” Health Affairs38(10):1735–43.
43.
PescosolidoBernice A.MonahanJohnLinkBruce G.StueveAnnKikuzawa.Saeko1999. “The Public’s View of the Competence, Dangerousness, and Need for Legal Coercion of Persons with Mental Health Problems.” American Journal of Public Health89(9):1339–45.
44.
PhelanJo C. 2005. “Geneticization of Deviant Behavior and Consequences for Stigma: The Case of Mental Illness.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior46(4):307–22.
45.
PhelanJo C.YangLawrence H.Cruz-RojasRosangely. 2006. “Effects of Attributing Serious Mental Illnesses to Genetic Causes on Orientations to Treatment.” Psychiatric Services57(3):382–87.
46.
RagsdaleJames M.ElliottMarta. 2022. “Opioid Addiction, Attributions, and Stigma: An Online Vignette Experimental Study.” Stigma and Health7(2):205–13.
47.
ReadJohnHarréNiki. 2001. “The Role of Biological and Genetic Causal Beliefs in the Stigmatisation of ‘Mental Patients.’”Journal of Mental Health10(2):223–35.
48.
RStudio Team. 2020. “RStudio: Integrated development for R. ” RStudio, PBC, Boston, MA. http://www.rstudio.com/.
49.
RüschNicolasToddAndrew R.BodenhausenGalen V.CorriganPatrick W.2009. “Biogenetic Models of Psychopathology, Implicit Guilt, and Mental Illness Stigma.” Psychiatry Research179(3):328–32.
50.
SchaumanOliverMacLeodAndrew K.ThornicroftGrahamClementSarah. 2019. “Mental Illness Related Discrimination: The Role of Self-Devaluation and Anticipated Discrimination for Decreased Well-Being.” Stigma and Health4(1):11–18.
51.
SchlierBjörnSchmickSylviaLincolnTania Marie. 2014. “No Matter of Etiology: Biogenetic, Psychosocial and Vulnerability-Stress Causal Explanations Fail to Improve Attitudes towards Schizophrenia.” Psychiatry Research215(3):753–59.
52.
SchnittkerJason. 2008. “An Uncertain Revolution: Why the Rise of a Genetic Model of Mental Illness Has Not Increased Tolerance.” Social Science & Medicine67(9): 1370–81.
53.
SchofieldCasey A.Abdul-ChaniMonicaGaudianoBrandon A.2020. “Impact of Causal Explanations for Social Anxiety Disorder on Stigma and Treatment Perceptions.” Journal of Mental Health29(1):84–91.
54.
ShearerAmy L.RothElizabethCefaluMathew S.BreslauJoshuaMcBainRyan K.WongEunice C.BurnamM. AudreyCollinsRebecca L.2021. “Contact with Persons with Mental Illness and Willingness to Live Next Door to Them: Two Waves of a California Survey of Adults.” Psychiatric Services72(1):23–30.
55.
SmithTom W., Michael Davern, Jeremy Freese, and Stephen Morgan. 2018. “General Social Surveys, 1972-2016.” Chicago, IL: National Opinion Research Center.
56.
StiltonNava R.FlannellyKevin J.MilsteinGlenVaalerMargaret L.2011. “Stigma in America: Has Anything Changed? Impact of Perceptions of Mental Illness and Dangerousness on the Desire for Social Distance: 1996 and 2006.” The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease199(6):361–66.
57.
StuartHeather. 2006. “Mental Illness and Employment Discrimination.” Current Opinion in Psychiatry19(5):522–26.
ThoitsPeggy A.2011. “Resisting the Stigma of Mental Illness.” Social Psychology Quarterly74(1):6–28.
60.
van‘t VeerJob T. B.KraanHerro F.DrosseartStans HCModdeJacqueline M.2006. “Determinants That Shape Public Attitudes towards the Mentally Ill.” Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology41(4):310–17.
61.
WalkerIanReadJohn. 2002. “The Differential Effectiveness of Psychosocial and Biogenetic Causal Explanations in Reducing Negative Attitudes toward ‘Mental Illness.’”Psychiatry65(4):313–25.
62.
WeinerBernard. 1980. “A Cognitive (Attribution)-Emotion-Action Model of Motivated Behavior: An Analysis of Judgments of Help-Giving.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology39(2):186–200.
63.
WeinerBernard. 1993. “On Sin Versus Sickness: A Theory of Perceived Responsibility and Social Motivation.” American Psychologist48(9):957–65.
64.
WeinerBernard. 2012. “An Attribution Theory of Motivation.” Pp. 135–55 in Handbook of Theories of Social Psychology, edited by Van LangeP. A. M.KruglanskiA. W.HigginsE. T.Newbury Park, CA: SAGE.
65.
WeinerBernardOsborneDannyRudolphUdo. 2011. “An Attributional Analysis of Reactions to Poverty: The Political Ideology of the Giver and the Perceived Morality of the Receiver.” Personality and Social Psychology Review15(2):199–213.
66.
WeinerBernardPerryRaymond P.MagnussonJamie. 1988. “An Attributional Analysis of Reactions to Stigmas.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology55(5):738–48.
67.
WheatonBlairMontazerShirin. 2017. “Studying Stress in the Twenty-First-Century: An Update of Stress Concepts and Research.” Pp. 180–206 in A Handbook for the Study of Mental Health: Social Contexts, Theories, and Systems, edited by ScheidT. L.WrightE. R.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
68.
XiongJiaqiLipsitzOrlyNasriFloraLuiLeanna M. W.GillHartejPhanLeeChen-LiDavid, et al. 2020. “Impact of Covid-19 Pandemic on Mental Health in the General Population: A Systematic Review.” Journal of Affective Disorders277:55–64.
69.
ZumboBruno D.GadermannAnne M.ZeisserCornelia. 2007. “Ordinal Versions of Coefficients Alpha and Theta for Likert Rating Scales.” Journal of Modern Applied Statistical Methods6:21–29.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
