Discrimination-health research has been critiqued for neglecting the endogeneity of reports of discrimination to negative affect and the multidimensionality of mental health. To address these challenges, we model discrimination’s relationship to multiple psychological variables without directional constraints. Using time-dense data to identify associational network structures allows for joint testing of the social stress hypothesis, prominent in discrimination-health literature, and the negativity bias hypothesis, an endogeneity critique rooted in social psychology. Our results show discrimination predicts negative emotions from day-to-day but not vice versa, indicating that racial discrimination is a risk factor and not symptom of negative emotion. Furthermore, we identify sadness, guilt, hostility, and fear as a locus of interrelated emotions sensitive to racism-related stressors that emerges over time. Thus, we find support for what race scholars have argued for 120+ years in a model without a priori directional restrictions and then build on this work by empirically identifying cascading mental health consequences of discrimination.
AalbersGeorgeMcNallyRichard J.HeerenAlexandrede WitSanneFriedEiko I.2019. “Social Media and Depression Symptoms: A Network Perspective.”Journal of Experimental Psychology General148(8):1454–62.
2.
ArandaMaría P.ChaeDavid H.LincolnKaren D.TaylorRobert JosephWoodwardAmanda TolerChattersLinda M.2012. “Demographic Correlates of DSM-IV Major Depressive Disorder among Older African Americans, Black Caribbeans, and Non-Hispanic Whites: Results from the National Survey of American Life.”International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry27(9):940–47.
3.
AsparouhovTihomirMuthénBengt. 2020. “Comparison of Models for the Analysis of Intensive Longitudinal Data.”Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal27(2):275–97.
4.
Bonilla-SilvaEduardo. 1997. “Rethinking Racism: Toward a Structural Interpretation.”American Sociological Review62(3):465–80.
5.
BordersAshleyLiangChristopher T. H.2011. “Rumination Partially Mediates the Associations between Perceived Ethnic Discrimination, Emotional Distress, and Aggression.”Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology17(2):125–33.
6.
BorsboomDenny. 2017. “A Network Theory of Mental Disorders.”World Psychiatry16(1):5–13.
7.
BoschlooLynnvan BorkuloClaudia D.BorsboomDennySchoeversRobert A.2016. “A Prospective Study on How Symptoms in a Network Predict the Onset of Depression.”Psychother Psychosom85:183–84.
8.
BriefArthur P.BurkeMichael J.GeorgeJennifer M.RobinsonBrian S.WebsterJane. 1988. “Should Negative Affectivity Remain an Unmeasured Variable in the Study of Job Stress?”Journal of Applied Psychology73(2):193–98.
9.
BringmannLaura F.LemmensLotte H. J. M.HuibersMarcus J. H.BorsboomDennyTuerlinckxFrancis. 2015. “Revealing the Dynamic Network Structure of the Beck Depression Inventory-II.”Psychological Medicine45(4):747–57.
BringmannLaura F.VissersNathalieWichersMariekeGeschwindNicoleKuppensPeterPeetersFrenkBorsboomDennyTuerlinckxFrancis. 2013. “A Network Approach to Psychopathology: New Insights into Clinical Longitudinal Data.”PLOS ONE8(4):e60188. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0060188.
12.
BrondoloElizabethBlairIrene V.KaurAmandeep. 2018. “Biopsychosocial Mechanisms Linking Discrimination to Health: A Focus on Social Cognition.” Pp. 219–40 in The Oxford Handbook of Stigma, Discrimination, and Health. Vol. 1, edited by MajorB.DovidioJ. F.LinkB. G.Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
13.
BrotheridgeCéleste M.GrandeyAlicia A.2002. “Emotional Labor and Burnout: Comparing Two Perspectives of ‘People Work.’”Journal of Vocational Behavior60(1):17–39.
14.
BroudyRisaBrondoloElizabethCoakleyVonettaBradyNishaCassellsAndreaTobinJonathanSweeneyMonica. 2007. “Perceived Ethnic Discrimination in Relation to Daily Moods and Negative Social Interactions.”Journal of Behavioral Medicine30:31–43.
15.
BrownTony N.WilliamsDavid R.JacksonJames S.NeighborsHarold W.TorresMyriamSellersSherrill L.BrownKendrick T. 2000. “‘Being Black and Feeling Blue’: The Mental Health Consequences of Racial Discrimination.”Race and Society2(2):117–31.
16.
BrushEleanor R.KrakauerDavid C.FlackJessica C.2013. “A Family of Algorithms for Computing Consensus about Node State from Network Data.”PLOS Computational Biology9(7):e1003109. doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1003109.
17.
BurrowAnthony L.OngAnthony D.2010. “Racial Identity as a Moderator of Daily Exposure and Reactivity to Racial Discrimination.”Self and Identity9(4):383–402.
18.
ChaeDavid H.EpelElissa S.Nuru-JeterAmani M.LincolnKaren D.TaylorRobert JosephLinJueBlackburnElizabeth H.ThomasStephen B.2016. “Discrimination, Mental Health, and Leukocyte Telomere Length among African American Men.”Psychoneuroendocrinology63:10–16.
19.
ChaeDavid H.Nuru-JeterAmani M.LincolnKaren D.FrancisDarlene D.2011. “Conceptualizing Racial Disparities in Health: Advancement of a Socio-psychobiological Approach.”DuBois Review8(1):63–77.
20.
CheadleJacob E.GoosbyBridget J.JochmanJoseph C.TomasoCara C.Kozikowski YanceyChelsea B.NelsonTimothy D.2020. “Race and Ethnic Variation in College Students’ Allostatic Regulation of Racism-Related Stress.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences117(49):31053–62.
21.
ClarkRodneyAndersonNorman B.ClarkVernessa R.WilliamsDavid R.1999. “Racism as a Stressor for African Americans. A Biopsychosocial Model.”The American Psychologist54(10):805–16.
22.
CurtisDavid S.WashburnTessaLeeHedwigSmithKen R.KimJaewhanMartzConnor D.KramerMichael R.ChaeDavid H.2021. “Highly Public Anti-Black Violence Is Associated with Poor Mental Health Days for Black Americans.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences118(17):e2019624118. doi:10.1073/pnas.2019624118.
23.
DanillerAndrew. 2021. Majorities of Americans See at Least Some Discrimination Against Black, Hispanic and Asian People in the U.S. Washington, DC: Pew Research Center.
24.
DeLappRyan C. T.WilliamsMonnica T.2021. “Preparing for Racial Microaggressions: The Role of Cognition and Emotion in the Proactive Coping Process of African American College Students.”New Ideas in Psychology63:100897. doi:10.1016/j.newideapsych.2021.100897.
25.
DouglassSaraMirpuriSheenaEnglishDevinYipTiffany. 2016. “‘They Were Just Making Jokes’: Ethnic/Racial Teasing and Discrimination among Adolescents.”Cultural Diversity & Ethnic Minority Psychology22(1):69–82.
26.
Du BoisWilliam E. B.1906. The Health and Physique of the American Negro: A Sociological Study Made Under the Direction of Atlanta University by the Eleventh Atlanta Conference. Atlanta, GA: Atlanta University Press.
27.
EpskampSachaBorsboomDennyFriedEiko I.2018. “Estimating Psychological Networks and Their Accuracy: A Tutorial Paper.”Behavior Research Methods50(1):195–212.
28.
EpskampSachaWaldorpLourens J.MõttusRenéBorsboomDenny. 2018. “The Gaussian Graphical Model in Cross-Sectional and Time-Series Data.”Multivariate Behavioral Research53(4):453–80.
FreelonDeenMcIlwainCharltonClarkMeredith. 2016. “Beyond the Hashtags: #Ferguson, #Blacklivesmatter, and the Online Struggle for Offline Justice (Research Report).”Center for Media & Social Impact. http://cmsimpact.org/blmreport.
31.
FriedEiko I.CramerAngélique O. J.2017. “Moving forward: Challenges and Directions for Psychopathological Network Theory and Methodology.”Perspectives on Psychological Science12(6):999–1020.
32.
FriedEiko I.van BorkuloClaudia D.CramerAngélique O. J.BoschlooLynnSchoeversRobert A.BorsboomDenny. 2017. “Mental Disorders as Networks of Problems: A Review of Recent Insights.”Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology52(1):1–10.
33.
FruchtermanThomas M. J.ReingoldEdward M.1991. “Graph Drawing by Force-Directed Placement.”Software: Practice and Experience21(11):1129–64.
34.
GeeGilbert C.SpencerMichael S.ChenJuanTakeuchiDavid. 2007. “A Nationwide Study of Discrimination and Chronic Health Conditions among Asian Americans.”American Journal of Public Health97(7):1275–82.
35.
GoosbyBridget J.CheadleJacob E.MitchellColter. 2018. “Stress-Related Biosocial Mechanisms of Discrimination and African American Health Inequities.”Annual Review of Sociology44:319–40.
36.
GrangerClive W. J.1969. “Investigating Causal Relations by Econometric Models and Cross-Spectral Methods.”Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society37(3):424–38.
37.
HaidtJonathan. 2017. “The Unwisest Idea on Campus: Commentary on Lilienfeld (2017).”Perspectives on Psychological Science12(1):176–77.
38.
HamakerEllen L.AsparouhovTihomirBroseAnnetteSchmiedekFlorianMuthénBengt. 2018. “At the Frontiers of Modeling Intensive Longitudinal Data: Dynamic Structural Equation Models for the Affective Measurements from the COGITO Study.”Multivariate Behavioral Research53(6):820–41.
39.
HarrellCamara Jules P.BurfordTanisha I.CageBrandi N.NelsonTravette McNairShearonSherondaThompsonAdrianGreenSteven. 2011. “Multiple Pathways Linking Racism to Health Outcomes.”Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race8(1):143–57.
40.
HarrellShelly P.2000. “A Multidimensional Conceptualization of Racism-Related Stress: Implications for the Well-Being of People of Color.”American Journal of Orthopsychiatry70(1):42–57.
41.
HaslbeckJonas M. B.BringmannLaura F.WaldorpLourens J.2021. “A Tutorial on Estimating Time-Varying Vector Autoregressive Models.”Multivariate Behavioral Research56(1):120–49.
42.
HernándezRafael J.VillodasMiguel T.2020. “Overcoming Racial Battle Fatigue: The Associations between Racial Microaggressions, Coping, and Mental Health among Chicana/o and Latina/o College Students.”Culture Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology26(3):399–411.
43.
HickenMargaret T.LeeHedwigAilshireJenniferBurgardSarah A.WilliamsDavid R.2013. “‘Every Shut Eye, Ain’t Sleep’: The Role of Racism-Related Vigilance in Racial/Ethnic Disparities in Sleep Difficulty.”Race and Social Problems5(2):100–12.
44.
HodsonGordonDhontKristof. 2015. “The Person-Based Nature of Prejudice: Individual Difference Predictors of Inter-group Negativity.”European Review of Social Psychology26(1):1–42.
45.
HoggardLori S.HillLaBarron K.GrayDeLeon L.SellersRobert M.2015. “Capturing the Cardiac Effects of Racial Discrimination: Do the Effects ‘Keep Going’?”International Journal of Psychophysiology: Official Journal of the International Organization of Psychophysiology97(2):163–70.
46.
HoubenMarliesVan Den NoortgateWimKuppensPeter. 2015. “The Relation between Short-Term Emotion Dynamics and Psychological Well-Being: A Meta-analysis.”Psychological Bulletin141(4):901–30.
47.
JacksonJames S.GurinGerald. 1979. National Survey of Black Americans, 1979-1980. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research [distributor].
48.
JacksonJames S.WilliamsDavid R.1995. Detroit Area Study, 1995: Social Influence on Health: Stress, Racism, and Health Protective Resources. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research [distributor].
49.
JelsmaElizabeth B.GoosbyBridget J.CheadleJacob E.2021. “Do Trait Psychological Characteristics Moderate Sympathetic Arousal to Racial Discrimination Exposure in a Natural Setting?”Psychophysiology58(4):e13763. doi:10.1111/psyp.13763.
50.
JochmanJoseph C.CheadleJacob E.GoosbyBridget J.TomasoCaraKozikowskiChelseaNelsonTimothy. 2019. “Mental Health Outcomes of Discrimination among College Students on a Predominately White Campus: A Prospective Study.”Socius: Sociological Research for a Dynamic World5. doi:10.1177/2378023119842728.
51.
JonesPayton J.MairPatrickMcNallyRichard J.2018. “Visualizing Psychological Networks: A Tutorial in R.”Frontiers in Psychology9:1742. doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01742.
52.
JosephNataria T.PetersonLaurel M.GordonHeatherKamarckThomas W.2020. “The Double Burden of Racial Discrimination in Daily-Life Moments: Increases in Negative Emotions and Depletion of Psychosocial Resources among Emerging Adult African Americans.”Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology27(2):234–44.
53.
JussimLeeCrawfordJarret T.AnglinStephanie M.StevensSean T.DuarteJose L.2016. “Interpretations and Methods: Towards a More Effectively Self-Correcting Social Psychology.”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology66:116–33.
54.
KimGiyeonParmeleePatriciaBryantAmi N.CrowtherMartha R.ParkSoohyunPartonJason M.ChaeDavid H.2017. “Geographic Region Matters in the Relation between Perceived Racial Discrimination and Psychiatric Disorders among Black Older Adults.”The Gerontologist57(6):1142–47.
55.
LaheyBenjamin B.2009. “Public Health Significance of Neuroticism.”American Psychologist64(4):241–56.
56.
LevineDebra SiegelHimleJoseph A.AbelsonJamie M.MatuskoNikiDhawanNikhilTaylorRobert Joseph. 2014. “Discrimination and Social Anxiety Disorder among African-Americans, Caribbean Blacks, and Non-Hispanic Whites.”The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease202(3):224–30.
57.
LewisTené T.CogburnCourtney D.WilliamsDavid R.2015. “Self-Reported Experiences of Discrimination and Health: Scientific Advances, Ongoing Controversies, and Emerging Issues.”Annual Review of Clinical Psychology11(1):407–40.
58.
LilienfeldScott O.2017. “Microaggressions: Strong Claims, Inadequate Evidence.”Perspectives on Psychological Science12(1):138–69.
59.
LukianoffGregHaidtJonathan. 2018. The Coddling of the American Mind: How Good Intentions and Bad Ideas are Setting up a Generation for Failure. New York, NY: Penguin Press.
60.
LuoYeXuJunGranbergEllenWentworthWilliam M.2012. “A Longitudinal Study of Social Status, Perceived Discrimination, and Physical and Emotional Health among Older Adults.”Research on Aging34(3):275–301.
61.
MajorBrendaQuintonWendy J.McCoyShannon K.2002. “Antecedents and Consequences of Attributions to Discrimination: Theoretical and Empirical Advances.” Pp. 251–330 in Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. Vol. 34, edited by ZannaM. P.Amsterdam: Elsevier.
62.
MasseyDouglas S.2004. “Segregation and Stratification: A Biosocial Perspective.”Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race1(1):7–25.
63.
MaysVickie M.CochranSusan D.BarnesNamdi W.2007. “Race, Race-Based Discrimination, and Health Outcomes among African Americans.”Annual Review of Psychology58(1):201–25.
64.
McNallyRichard J.RobinaughDonald J.WuGwyneth W.Y.WangLiDesernoMarie K.BorsboomDenny. 2015. “Mental Disorders as Causal Systems: A Network Approach to Posttraumatic Stress Disorder.”Clinical Psychological Science3(6):836–49.
65.
MekawiYaraHyattCourtland S.Maples-KellerJessicaCarterSierraMichopoulosVasilikiPowersAbigail. 2021. “Racial Discrimination Predicts Mental Health Outcomes beyond the Role of Personality Traits in a Community Sample of African Americans.”Clinical Psychological Science9(2):183–96.
66.
Mendoza-DentonRodolfoDowneyGeraldinePurdieValerie J.DavisAngelinaPietrzakJanina. 2002. “Sensitivity to Status-Based Rejection: Implications for African American Students’ College Experience.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology83(4):896–918.
67.
MercerSterett H.Zeigler-HillVirgilWallaceMarion T.HayesDemarquis M.2011. “Development and Initial Validation of the Inventory of Microaggressions Against Black Individuals.”Journal of Counseling Psychology58(4):457–69.
68.
MichaelsEliThomasMarilynReevesAlexisPriceMelisaHassonRebeccaChaeDavidAllenAmani. 2019. “Coding the Everyday Discrimination Scale: Implications for Exposure Assessment and Associations with Hypertension and Depression among a Cross Section of Mid-life African American Women.”Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health73(6):577–84.
69.
MillerKelly. 1897. A Review of Hoffman’s Race Traits and Tendencies of the American Negro. Washington, DC: The American Negro Academy.
70.
OngAnthony D.2021. “Racial Incivility in Everyday Life: A Conceptual Framework for Linking Process, Person, and Context.”Perspectives of Psychological Science16(5):1060–74.
71.
OngAnthony D.BurrowAnthony L.2017. “Microaggressions and Daily Experience: Depicting Life as It Is Lived.”Perspectives on Psychological Science12(1):173–75.
72.
OngAnthony D.BurrowAnthony L.Fuller-RowellThomas E.JaNicole M.SueDerald Wing. 2013. “Racial Microaggressions and Daily Well-Being among Asian Americans.”Journal of Counseling Psychology60(2):188–99.
73.
PascoeElizabeth A.RichmanLaura. 2009. “Perceived Discrimination and Health: A Meta-analytic Review.”Psychological Bulletin135(4):531–54.
74.
PavalkoEliza K.MossakowskiKrysia N.HamiltonVanessa J.2003. “Does Perceived Discrimination Affect Health? Longitudinal Relationships between Work Discrimination and Women’s Physical and Emotional Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior44(1):18–34.
75.
PilverCorey E.DesaiRaniKaslStanislavLevyBecca R.2011. “Lifetime Discrimination Associated with Greater Likelihood of Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder.”Journal of Women’s Health20(6):923–31.
76.
PotterLindsey N.BrondoloElizabethSmythJoshua M.2019. “Biopsychosocial Correlates of Discrimination in Daily Life: A Review.”Stigma and Health4(1):38–61.
77.
PriestNaomiWilliamsDavid R.2018. Racial Discrimination and Racial Disparities in Health. Pp. 163–82 in The Oxford Handbook of Stigma, Discrimination, and Health, edited by MajorB.DovidioJ. F.LinkB. G.New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
78.
PriestNaomiPerryRyanFerdinandAngelineKelaherMargaretParadiesYin. 2017. “Effects over Time of Self-Reported Direct and Vicarious Racial Discrimination on Depressive Symptoms and Loneliness among Australian School Students.”BMC Psychiatry17(1):50.
79.
PrinceMartinPatelVikramSaxenaShekharMajMarioMaselkoJoannaPhillipsMichael R.RahmanAtif. 2007. “No Health without Mental Health.”Global Mental Health370(9590):859–77.
80.
RaudenbushStephen W.BrykAnthony S.2001. Hierarchical Linear Models: Applications and Data Analysis Methods. 2nd ed.Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications, Inc.
81.
SalvatoreJessicaSheltonJ. Nicole. 2007. “Cognitive Costs of Exposure to Racial Prejudice.”Psychological Science18(9):810–15.
82.
SaudinoKimberly J.PedersenNancy L.LichtensteinPaulMcClearnG. E.PlominRobert. 1997. “Can Personality Explain Genetic Influences on Life Events?”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology72(1):196–206.
83.
ScottKate M.LimCarmenAl-HamzawiAliAlonsoJordiBruffaertsRonnyCaldas-de-AlmeidaJosé MiguelFlorescuSilvia, et al. 2016. “Association of Mental Disorders with Subsequent Chronic Physical Conditions.”JAMA Psychiatry73(2):150–58.
84.
SeatonEleanor K.YipTiffanySellersRobert M.2009. “A Longitudinal Examination of Racial Identity and Racial Discrimination among African American Adolescents.”Child Development80(2):406–17.
85.
Smith-BynumMia A.LambertSharon F.EnglishDevinIalongoNicholas S.2014. “Associations between Trajectories of Perceived Racial Discrimination and Psychological Symptoms among African American Adolescents.”Development and Psychopathology26(4, Pt. 1):1049–65.
86.
SolórzanoDanielCejaMiguelYossoTara. 2000. “Critical Race Theory, Racial Microaggressions, and Campus Racial Climate: The Experiences of African American College Students.”Journal of Negro Education69(1–2):60–73.
87.
SotoJosé A.Dawson-AndohNana A.BeLueRhonda. 2011. “The Relationship between Perceived Discrimination and Generalized Anxiety Disorder among African Americans, Afro Caribbeans and Non-Hispanic Whites.”Journal of Anxiety Disorders25(2):258–65.
88.
SterlingPeter. 2012. “Allostasis: A Model of Predictive Regulation.”Physiology Behavior106(1):5–15.
89.
TegethoffMarionStalujanisEstherBelardiAngeloMeinlschmidtGunther. 2016. “Chronology of Onset of Mental Disorders and Physical Diseases in Mental-Physical Comorbidity – A National Representative Survey of Adolescents.”PLoS One. 11(10):e0165196. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0165196.
90.
ThomasKaMala S.BardwellWayne A.Ancoli-IsraelSoniaDimsdaleJoel E.2006. “The Toll of Ethnic Discrimination on Sleep Architecture and Fatigue.”Health Psychology25(5):635–42.
91.
TorresLucasOngAnthony D.2010. “A Daily Diary Investigation of Latino Ethnic Identity, Discrimination, and Depression.”Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology16(4):561–68.
92.
TruongKimberly A.MuseusSamuel D.McGuireKeon M.2016. “Vicarious Racism: A Qualitative Analysis of Experiences with Secondhand Racism in Graduate Education.”International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education29(2):224–47.
93.
TynesBrendesha M.GiangMichael T.WilliamsDavid R.ThompsonGeneene N.2008. “Online Racial Discrimination and Psychological Adjustment among Adolescents.”Journal of Adolescent Health43(6):565–69.
94.
TynesBrendesha M.WillisHenry A.StewartAshley M.HamiltonMatthew W.2019. “Race-Related Traumatic Events Online and Mental Health among Adolescents of Color.”Journal of Adolescent Health65(3):371–77.
95.
WalsemannKatrinaGeeGilbert. 2009. “Does Health Predict the Reporting of Racial Discrimination or Do Reports of Discrimination Predict Health? Findings from the National Longitudinal Study of Youth.”Social Science and Medicine68(9):1676–84.
96.
WatsonDavidClarkLee Anna. 1994. The PANAS-X: Manual for the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule-Expanded Form. Ames: The University of Iowa.
97.
WilliamsDavid R.MohammedSelina A.2009. “Discrimination and Racial Disparities in Health: Evidence and Needed Research.”Journal of Behavioral Medicine32(1):20–47.
98.
WilliamsDavid R.YuYanJacksonJames S.AndersonNorman B.1997. “Racial Differences in Physical and Mental Health: Socioeconomic Status, Stress, and Discrimination.”Journal of Health Psychology2(3):335–51.
99.
WilliamsMonnica T.2020. “Microaggressions: Clarification, Evidence, and Impact.”Perspectives on Psychological Science15(1):3–26.
100.
ZhangAmyGoosbyBridget J.CheadleJacob E.2021. “In the Flow of Life: Capturing Affective Socializing Dynamics Using a Wearable Sensor and Intensive Daily Diaries.”Socius: Sociological Research or a Dynamic World7. doi:10.1177/2378023121106400.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
