We introduce a theoretical argument linking group structure to an individual’s cohesion in collectively oriented task groups. We posit that status, the distribution of opinions, and social categories indirectly shape perceptions of cohesion by making individuals working on an uncertain task more or less susceptible to the opinions of others. Specifically, these factors influence how likely one is to succumb to the opinions of others, which in turn influences one’s likelihood of viewing one’s actions as valid or consonant with the expectations of the other members of the group. As this process repeats over time, it accumulates to affect individuals’ expressions of cohesion with group members. Results from a laboratory experiment corroborate this process.
AschSolomon E.1951. “Effects of Group Pressure upon the Modification and Distortion of Judgments.” Groups, Leadership, and Men S: 222–36.
2.
AschSolomon E.1956. “Studies of Independence and Conformity: I. A Minority of One against a Unanimous Majority.” Psychological Monographs: General and Applied70(9):1–70.
3.
BealDaniel J.CohenRobin R.BurkeMichael J.McLendonChristy L.2003. “Cohesion and Performance in Groups: A Meta-analytic Clarification of Construct Relations.” Journal of Applied Psychology88(6):989–1004.
4.
BeckwithCary. 2019. “Who Belongs? How Status Influences the Experience ofGemeinschaft.”Social Psychology Quarterly82(1):31–50.
5.
BemDaryl J.1967. “Self-Perception: An Alternative Interpretation of Cognitive Dissonance Theory.” Psychological Review74:183–200.
6.
BemDaryl J.1972. “Self-Perception Theory.” Pp. 1–62 in Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, edited by BerkowitzL.New York: Academic Press.
7.
BergerJosephCohenBernardZelditchMorris. 1972. “Status Characteristics and Social Interaction.” American Sociological Review37:241–55.
8.
BergerJosephFişekM. Hamit. 1970. “Consistent and Inconsistent Status Characteristics and the Determinations of Power and Prestige Orders.” Sociometry33(3):287–304.
9.
BergerJosephFişekM. HamitNormanRobert Z.ZelditchMorrisJr.1977. Status Characteristics and Social Interaction: An Expectation-States Approach. New York: Elsevier.
10.
BilligMichaelTajfelHenri. 1973. “Social Categorization and Similarity in Intergroup Behavior.” European Journal of Social Psychology3(1):27–52.
11.
BowlesHannahGelfandMichele. 2009. “Status and the Evaluation of Workplace Deviance.” Psychological Science21(1):49–54.
12.
ChiocchioFrancoisEssiembreHelene. 2009. “Cohesion and Performance: A Meta-analytic Review of Disparities between Project Teams, Production Teams, and Service Teams.” Small Group Research40(4):382–420.
13.
CorrellShelleyRidgewayCecilia. 2006. “Expectation States Theory.” Pp. 29–52 in The Handbook of Social Psychology, edited by DelamaterJ.New York: Springer.
14.
DippongJosephKalkhoffWillJohnsenEugene C.2017. “Status, Networks, and Opinion Change: An Experimental Investigation.” Social Psychology Quarterly80(2):153–73.
15.
DornbuschSanford M.ScottW. Richard. 1975. Evaluation and the Exercise of Authority. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
16.
FazioRussell H.1987. “Self-Perception Theory: A Current Perspective.” Pp. 129–50 in Social Influence: The Ontario Symposium, edited by ZannaM. P.OlsonJ. M.HermanC. P.Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
17.
FazioRussell H.ShermanSteven J.HerrPaul M.1982. “The Feature-Positive Effect in the Self-Perception Process: Does Not Doing Matter as Much as Doing?” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology42(3):404–11.
18.
FişekHamitBergerJosephNormanRobert. 1991. “Participation in Heterogeneous and Homogeneous Groups: A Theoretical Integration.” American Journal of Sociology97(1):114–42.
19.
HoggMichael A.2004. “Social Categorization, Depersonalization, and Group Behavior.” Pp. 203–31 in Perspectives on Social Psychology: Self and Identity, edited by BrewerM. B.HewstoneM.Oxford, UK: Blackwell.
20.
HoggMichael A.2007. “Uncertainty-Identity Theory.” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology39:69–129.
21.
HoggMichael A.MullinBarbara-A. 1999. “Joining Groups to Reduce Uncertainty: Subjective Uncertainty Reduction and Group Identification.” Pp. 249–79 in Social Identity and Social Cognition, edited by AbramsD.HoggM. A.Oxford, UK: Blackwell.
22.
ImaiKosukeKeeleLukeYamamotoTeppei. 2010. “Identification, Inference and Sensitivity Analysis for Causal Mediation Effects.” Statistical Science25(1):51–71.
23.
JohnsonCathrynDowdTimothy J.RidgewayCecilia L.2006. “Legitimacy as a Social Process.” Annual Review of Sociology32:53–78.
24.
KalkhoffWillBarnumChristopher. 2000. “The Effects of Status-Organizing and Social Identity Processes on Patterns of Social Influence.” Social Psychology Quarterly63(2):95–115.
25.
KalkhoffWillFriedkinNoah E.JohnsenEugene C.2010. “Status, Networks, and Opinions: A Modular Integration of Two Theories.” Advances in Group Processes27:1–38.
26.
KanterRosabeth Moss. 1977. Men and Women of the Corporation. New York: Basic Books.
27.
KelleyChristopher P.SoboroffShane D.LovagliaMichael J.2017. “The Status Value of Age.” Social Science Research66:22–31.
28.
KrullJennifer L.MacKinnonDavid P.2001. “Multilevel Modeling of Individual and Group Level Mediated Effects.” Multivariate Behavioral Research36(2):249–77.
29.
KuwabaraKo. 2011. “Cohesion, Cooperation, and the Value of Doing Things Together: How Economic Exchange Created Relational Bonds.” American Sociological Review76(4):560–80.
30.
LawlerEdward J.ThyeShane R.YoonJeongkoo. 2000. “Emotion and Group Cohesion in Productive Exchange.” American Journal of Sociology106:616–57.
31.
LawlerEdward J.ThyeShane R.YoonJeongkoo. 2009. Social Commitments in a Depersonalized World. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
32.
LataneBibb. 1981. “The Psychology of Social Impact.” American Psychologist36(4):343.
33.
LeDouxJoseph. 1998. The Emotional Brain: The Mysterious Underpinnings of Emotional Life. New York: Simon & Schuster.
34.
LovagliaMichael J.HouserJeffrey A.1996. “Emotional Reactions and Status in Groups.” American Sociological Review61(5):867–83.
35.
MartinRobinGardikiotisAntonisHewstoneMiles. 2002. “Levels of Consensus and Majority and Minority Influence.” European Journal of Social Psychology32(5):645–65.
36.
MelamedDavidMunnChristopher W.BarryLeanneMontgomeryBradleyOkuwobiOneyu F.2019. “Status Characteristics, Implicit Bias, and the Production of Racial Inequality.” American Sociological Review84(6):1013–36.
37.
MelamedDavidSavageScott V.2013a. “Status, Numbers and Influence.” Social Forces91(3):1085–1104.
38.
MelamedDavidSavageScott V.2013b. “Predicting Social Influence with Faction Size and Relative Status.” Social Science Research42(5):1346–56.
39.
MelamedDavidSavageScott V.2016. “Status, Faction Sizes, and Social Influence: Testing the Theoretical Mechanism.” American Journal of Sociology122(1):201–32.
40.
MelamedDavidSavageScott V.MunnChristopher. 2019. “Uncertainty and Social Influence.”Socius 5(1): doi: 10.1177/2378023119866971.
41.
MolmLinda D.CollettJessica L.SchaeferDavid R.2007. “Building Solidarity through Generalized Exchange: A Theory of Reciprocity.” American Journal of Sociology113(1):205–42.
42.
MooreJames. 1968. “Status and Influence in Small Group Interactions.” Sociometry31(1):47–63.
43.
OldmeadowJulian A.PlatowMichael J.FoddyMargaretAndersonDonna. 2003. “Self-Categorization, Status, and Social Influence.” Social Psychology Quarterly66(2):138–52.
44.
RashotteLisa. 2007. “Social Influence.” Pp. 4426–29 in The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Sociology, edited by G. Ritzer. Hoboken, NJ: Blackwell.
45.
RashotteLisa SlatteryWebsterMurrayJr.2005. “Gender Status Beliefs.” Social Science Research34(3):618–33.
46.
RhodesMarjorieChalikLisa. 2013. “Social Categories as Markers of Intrinsic Interpersonal Obligation.” Psychological Science24(6):999–1006.
47.
RidgewayCecilia L.CorrellShelley J.2006. “Consensus and the Creation of Status Beliefs.” Social Forces85(1):431–53.
48.
RidgewayCecilia L.NakagawaSandra. 2017. “Is Deference the Price of Being Seen as Reasonable? How Status Hierarchies Incentivize Acceptance of Low Status.” Social Psychology Quarterly80(2):132–52.
49.
SavageScott V.MelamedDavidVincentAaron. 2013. “The Role of Uncertainty in Social Influence.” Advances in Group Processes30:109–29.
50.
SavageScott V.SommerZachary L.2016. “Should I Stay or Should I Go? Reciprocity, Negotiation, and the Choice of Structurally Disadvantaged Actors to Remain in Networks.” Social Psychology Quarterly79(2):115–35.
51.
SomersMark John. 1995. “Organizational Commitment, Turnover, and Absenteeism: An Examination of Direct and Interaction Effects.” Journal of Organizational Behavior16(1):49–58.
52.
SteinhardtMary A.DolbierChristyn L.GottliebNell H.McCalisterKatherine T.2003. “The Relationship between Hardiness, Supervisor Support, Group Cohesion, and Job Stress as Predictors of Job Satisfaction.” American Journal of Health Promotion17(6):382–89.
53.
TajfelHenri. 1974. “Social Identity and Intergroup Behavior.” Social Science Information13(2):65–93.
54.
TajfelHenri. 1982. “Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations.” Annual Review of Psychology33:1–39.
55.
TajfelHenriBilligM. G.BundyR. P.FlamentClaude. 1971. “Social Categorization and Intergroup Behavior.” European Journal of Social Psychology1(2):149–78.
56.
TajfelHenriTurnerJohn. 1979. “An Integrative Theory of Intergroup Conflict.” Pp33–47 in The Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations, edited by WilliamsJ. A.WorchelS.Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
57.
TanfordSarahPenrodSteven. 1984. “Social Influence Model: A Formal Integration of Research on Majority and Minority Influence Processes.” Psychological Bulletin95(2):189.
58.
ThauStefanCrossleyCraigBennettRebecca J.SczesnySabine2007. “The Relationship between Trust, Attachment, and Antisocial Work Behaviors.” Human Relations60(8):1155–79.
59.
ThyeShaneLawlerEdward J.YoonJeongkoo. 2011. “The Emergence of Embedded Relations and Group Formation in Networks of Competition.” Social Psychology Quarterly74(4):387–413.
60.
ThyeShaneLawlerEdward J.YoonJeongkoo. 2019. “The Formation of Group Ties in Open Interaction Groups.” Social Psychology Quarterly82(2):158–81.
61.
TormalaZakary L.DeSensiVictoria L.2009. “The Effects of Minority/Majority Source Status on Attitude Certainty: A Matching Perspective.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin35(1):114–25.
62.
TropeYaacov. 1979. “Uncertainty-Reducing Properties of Achievement Tasks.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology39(9):1505–18.
63.
WagnerDavid. 1988. “Status Violations: Toward an Expectation States Theory of the Social Control of Deviance.” Pp. 110–22 in Status Generalization: New Theory and Research, edited by Webster Jr.M.FoschiM.Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
64.
WalkerHenry A.ThomasGeorge M.ZelditchMorris. 1986. “Legitimation, Endorsement, and Stability.” Social Forces64(3):620–43.
65.
WebsterMurrayFoschiMartha. 1988. Status Generalization: New Theory and Research. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
66.
WebsterMurrayRashotteLisa Slattery. 2010. “Behavior, Expectations and Status.” Social Forces88(3):1021–49.
