The self has long been construed as a rational, cognitive construct; the cognitive decline of dementia has therefore been largely viewed as the loss of self. Through qualitative interviews, we find that persons with dementia strive to maintain a coherent self despite their increasing disability. Using the theories of affect control theory (ACT) and ACT-Self, we illustrate their shift from using denotative (cognitive) meanings to reliance on connotative (affective) meanings in defining the situation and choosing identities to enact. As persons with dementia lose the cognitive ability to access shared definitions and reflected appraisals, their connection to the social world narrows to affective meanings of established sentiments and emotional reactions from others. Our findings underscore the creative agency of self and the limitations of the rationalistic bias of sociology by recognizing an affective self that stands in complement to the generally acknowledged cognitive self.
BeardRenée L.2004. “In Their Voices: Identity Preservation and Experiences of Alzheimer’s Disease.”Journal of Aging Studies18(4):415–28.
3.
BeardRenée L.NearyTara M.2013. “Making Sense of Nonsense: Experiences of Mild Cognitive Impairment.”Sociology of Health & Illness35(1):130–46.
4.
BoyleKaitlin M.2019. “Sexual Assault and Identity Disruption: A Sociological Approach to Posttraumatic Stress.”Society and Mental Health7(2):69–84.
5.
BrittLoryHeiseDavid R.1992. “Impressions of Self-Directed Action.”Social Psychology Quarterly, 55(4): 335–350.
6.
CaddellLisa S.ClareLinda. 2010. “The Impact of Dementia on Self and Identity: A Systematic Review.”Clinical Psychology Review30(1):113–26.
7.
CaddellLisa S.ClareLinda. 2013. “How Does Identity Relate to Cognition and Functional Abilities in Early-Stage Dementia?”Aging Neuropsychology and Cognition20(1):1–21.
CharmazKathy. 2002. “Stories and Silences: Disclosures and Self in Chronic Illness.”Qualitative Inquiry8(3):302.
10.
Cohen-MansfieldJ.Parpura-GillA.GolanderH.2006. “Salience of Self-Identity Roles in Persons with Dementia: Differences in Perceptions among Elderly Persons, Family Members and Caregivers.”Social Science & Medicine62(3):745–57.
11.
CooleyCharles H.1902. Human Nature and the Social Order. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons.
12.
FontanaAndreaSmithRonald W.1989. “Alzheimer’s Disease Victims: The ‘Unbecoming’ of Self and the Normalization of Competence.”Sociological Perspectives32(1):35–46.
13.
FrancisLinda E.AdamsRichard E.2019. “Two Faces of Self and Emotion in Symbolic Interactionism: From Process to Structure and Culture—And Back.”Symbolic Interaction42(2):250–77.
14.
FrancisLinda E.AdamsRichard E.KonigAlexandraHoeyJesse. 2019. “Identity and the Self in Elderly Adults with Alzheimer’s Disease.” Pp. 381–401 in Identities in Everyday Life, edited by J.E. Stets and R.T. Serpe. New York: Oxford University Press.
15.
FreelandRobert E.HoeyJesse. 2018. “The Structure of Deference: Modeling Occupational Status Using Affect Control Theory.”American Sociological Review83(2):243–77.
16.
GlaserBarney G.StraussAnselm L.1967. The Discovery of Grounded Theory; Strategies for Qualitative Research. Chicago: Aldine.
17.
GouldMark. 2009. “Culture, Personality, and Emotion in George Herbert Mead: A Critique of Empiricism in Cultural Sociology.”Sociological Theory27(4):435–48.
18.
GrossJenniferHarmonMary E.MyersRebecca A.EvansRachel L.KayNatalie R.Rodriguez-CharbonierSenezHerzogThomas R.2004. “Recognition of Self among Persons with Dementia: Pictures versus Names as Environmental Supports.”Environment and Behavior36(3):424–54.
19.
GubriumJaber F.1986. “The Social Preservation of Mind: The Alzheimer’s Disease Experience.”Symbolic Interaction9(1):37–56.
20.
HarknessSarah K.KroskaAmy. 2019. “Self-Stigma and the Social Interactions of Mental Health Patients.”Advances in Group Processes36:79–94.
21.
HeiseDavid R.1979. Understanding Events: Affect and the Construction of Social Action. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
22.
HeiseDavid R.2007. Expressive Order: Confirming Sentiments in Social Actions. New York: Springer.
23.
KonigAlexandraFrancisLinda E.JoshiJyotiRobillardJulie M.HoeyJesse. 2017. “Qualitative Study of Affective Identities in Dementia Patients for the Design of Cognitive Assistive Technologies.”Journal of Rehabilitation and Assistive Technologies Engineering4:1–15.
24.
KontosPia C.MillerKaren-LeeKontosAlexis P.2017. “Relational Citizenship: Supporting Embodied Selfhood and Relationality in Dementia Care.”Sociology of Health & Illness39(2):182–98.
25.
LivelyKathryn J.SteelmanLala CarrPowellBrian. 2010. “Equity, Emotion, and Household Division of Labor Response.”Social Psychology Quarterly73(4):358–79.
26.
MacKinnonNeil Joseph. 1994. Symbolic Interactionism as Affect Control. Albany: State University of New York Press.
27.
MacKinnonNeil Joseph. 2015. Self-Esteem and Beyond. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
28.
MacKinnonNeil JosephHeiseDavid R.2010. Self, Identity, and Social Institutions. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
29.
MacKinnonNeil J.RobinsonDawn R.2014. “Back to the Future: 25 Years of Research in Affect Control Theory.”Advances in Group Processes, 31: 139-173.
MaynardDouglas W.TurowetzJason. 2017. “Doing Diagnosis: Autism, Interaction Order, and the Use of Narrative in Clinical Talk.”Social Psychology Quarterly80(3):254–75.
32.
MeadGeorge Herbert. 1934. Mind, Self, and Society: From the Standpoint of a Social Behaviorist. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
33.
OronaCelia J.1990. “Temporality and Identity Loss Due to Alzheimer’s Disease.”Social Science & Medicine30(11):1247–56.
34.
OsgoodCharles E.MayWilliam H.MironMurray S.1975. Cross-Cultural Universals of Affective Meaning. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
35.
RobinsonDawn T.2014. “The Role of Cultural Meanings and Situated Interaction in Shaping Emotion.”Emotion Review6(3):189–95.
36.
RodriquezJason. 2011. “’It’s a Dignity Thing’: Nursing Home Care Workers’ Use of Emotions: Nursing Home Workers Use of Emotions.”Sociological Forum, 26(2): 265–286.
37.
RodriquezJason. 2013. “Narrating Dementia: Self and Community in an Online Forum.”Qualitative Health Research23(9):1215–27.
38.
SabatSteve R.HarréRom. 1992. “The Construction and Deconstruction of Self in Alzheimer’s Disease.”Ageing & Society12(4):443–61.
39.
ScalesKeziaBaileySimonMiddletonJoanneSchneiderJustine. 2017. “Power, Empowerment, and Person-Centred Care: Using Ethnography to Examine the Everyday Practice of Unregistered Dementia Care Staff.”Sociology of Health & Illness39(2):227–43.
40.
SchröderTobiasHoeyJesseRogersKimberly B.2016. “Modeling Dynamic Identities and Uncertainty in Social Interactions.”American Sociological Review81(4):828–55.
41.
ShankDaniel B.LulhamRohan. 2016. “Symbolic Interaction with Consumer Products: An Affect Control Theory Approach.”Sociology Compass10(7):613–22.
42.
TolhurstEdwardWeichtBernhardKingstonPaul. 2017. “Narrative Collisions, Sociocultural Pressures and Dementia: The Relational Basis of Personhood Reconsidered.”Sociology of Health & Illness39(2):212–26.
43.
VittoriaA. K.1998. “Preserving Selves: Identity Work and Dementia.”Research on Aging20(1):91–136.
44.
VittoriaAnne K.1999. “‘Our Own Little Language’: Naming and the Social Construction of Alzheimer’s Disease.”Symbolic Interaction22(4):361–84.
45.
WestiusAndersKallenbergKjellNorbergAstrid. 2010. “Views of Life and Sense of Identity in People with Alzheimer’s Disease.”Ageing & Society30(7):1257–78.
