In three studies, we examined the influence of social network reactions on feelings toward a romantic partner. Study 1 was a large survey (N = 858), Study 2 was a vignette design in which social network reactions were manipulated, and Study 3 was a laboratory-based, dating game experiment. We found extensive support for the social network effect, whereby relationship approval from family and friends leads individuals to feel more love, more committed, and more positive about a partner. We also examined whether psychological reactance moderated social network influence. Analyses revealed two types of reactance: defiant reactance (doing the opposite of that urged by others) and independent reactance (a desire to make free and independent decisions). Independent reactance but not defiant reactance interacted with network effects and buffered the effects of social adversity. Independent individuals appear capable of ignoring disapproving network opinions. Findings demonstrate a noteworthy interaction between individuals and their social environment.
BlairKaren L.HolmbergDiane. 2008. “Perceived Social Network Support and Well-Being in Same-Sex versus Mixed-Sex Romantic Relationships.” Journal of Social and Personal Relationships25:769–91.
2.
BrehmJack W.1966. A Theory of Psychological Reactance. New York: Academic Press.
3.
BrownAllison R.FinneySara J.FranceMegan K.2011. “Using the Bifactor Model to Assess the Dimensionality of the Hong Psychological Reactance Scale.” Educational and Psychological Measurement71:170–85.
4.
BryanLauraFitzpatrickJackiCrawfordDuaneFischerJudith. 2001. “The Role of Network Support and Interference in Women’s Perception of Romantic, Friend, and Parental Relationships.” Sex Roles45:481–99.
5.
BryantChalandra M.CongerRand D.1999. “Marital Success and Domains of Social Support in Long-Term Relationships: Does the Influence of Network Members Ever End?” Journal of Marriage and the Family61:437–50.
6.
ChartrandTanyaDaltonAmy N.FitzsimonsGavan J.2007. “Nonconscious Relationship Reactance: When Significant Others Prime Opposing Goals.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology43:719–26.
7.
DillardJames P.ShenLijiang. 2005. “On the Nature of Reactance and Its Role in Persuasive Health Communication.” Communication Monographs72:144–68.
8.
DowdE. ThomasMilneChristopher R.WiseSteven L.1991. “The Therapeutic Reactance Scale: A Measure of Psychological Reactance.” Journal of Counseling and Development69:541–45.
9.
DriscollRichardDavisKeith E.LipetzMilton E.1972. “Parental Interference and Romantic Love: The Romeo & Juliet Effect.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology24:1–10.
10.
EtcheverryPaul E.AgnewChristopher R.2004. “Subjective Norms and the Prediction of Romantic Relationship State and Fate.” Personal Relationships11:409–28.
11.
EtcheverryPaulLeBenjaminCharaniaMahnaz R.2008. “Perceived versus Reported Social Referent Approval and Romantic Relationship Commitment and Persistence.” Personal Relationships15:281–95.
12.
FelmleeDiane. 2001. “No Couple Is an Island: A Social Stability Network Perspective on Dyadic Stability.” Social Forces79:1259–87.
13.
FelmleeDianeSprecherSusan. 2000. “Close Relationships and Social Psychology: Intersections and Future Paths.” Social Psychology Quarterly63:365–76.
14.
FelmleeDianeSprecherSusanBassinEdwin. 1990. “The Dissolution of Intimate Relationships: A Hazard Model.” Social Psychology Quarterly53:13–30.
15.
FinchJanet. 1987. “The Vignette Technique in Survey Research.” Sociology21:105–14.
16.
GoodwinPaula Y.2003. “African American and European American Women’s Marital Well-Being.” Journal of Marriage and the Family65:550–60.
17.
GraupmannVerenaJonasEvaMeierEsterHawelkaStefanAichhornMarkus. 2012. “Reactance, the Self, and Its Group: When Threats to Freedom Come from the Ingroup Versus the Outgroup.” European Journal of Social Psychology42:164–73.
18.
HeiderFritz. 1958. The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations. New York: Wiley.
19.
HongSung-Mook. 1992. “Hong’s Psychological Reactance Scale: A Further Factor Analytic Validation.” Psychological Reports70:512–14.
20.
InesiM. EnaRiosKimberly. 2013. “Fighting for Independence: Significant Others’ Goals for Oneself Incite Reactance among the Powerful.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology49:1168–76.
21.
JohnsonMichael P.MilardoRobert M.1984. “Network Interference in Pair Relationships: A Social Psychological Recasting of Slater’s Theory of Social Regression.” Journal of Marriage and the Family46:893–99.
22.
JonasonPeter K.BryanAngelaHerreraJacob. 2010. “Trimming the Fat Reveals a One-Factor Construct of Hong’s Psychological Reactance Scale.” Individual Differences Research8:220–28.
23.
KelleyHarold H.BerscheidEllenChristensenAndrewHarveyJohn H.HustonTed L.LevingerGeorgeMcClintockEviePeplauLetitia AnnePetersonDonald R.1983. “Analyzing Close Relationships.” Pp. 20–67 in Close Relationships, edited by KelleyH.ChristensenA.HarveyJ. H.HustonT. L.LevingerG.McClintockE.PeplauL. A.PetersonD. R.New York: Freeman.
24.
LeBenjaminDoveNatalieAgnewChristopher R.KornMiriam S.MutsoAmelia A.2010. “Predicting Nonmarital Romantic Relationship Dissolution: A Meta-Analytic Synthesis.” Personal Relationships17:377–90.
25.
LehmillerJustin J.AgnewChristopher R.2007. “Perceived Marginalization and the Prediction of Romantic Relationship Stability.” Journal of Marriage and Family69:1036–49.
26.
LeslieLeigh A.HustonTed L.JohnsonMichael P.1986. “Parental Reactions to Dating Relationships: Do They Make a Difference?” Journal of Marriage and the Family48:57–66.
27.
LundMary. 1985. “The Development of Investment and Commitment Scales for Predicting Continuity of Personal Relationships.” Journal of Social and Personal Relationship2:3–23.
28.
MacDonaldGeoffJessicaMargareta. 2006. “Family Approval as a Constraint in Dependency Regulation: Evidence from Australia and Indonesia.” Personal Relationships13:183–94.
29.
McPhersonMillerSmith-LovinLynnCookJames M.2001. “Birds of a Feather: Homophily in Social Networks.” Annual Review of Sociology27:415–44.
30.
MerzJürgen. 1983. “Fragebogen zur Messung der psychologischen Reaktanz.” Diagnostica29:75–82.
31.
NiehuisSylviaHustonTed L.RosenbandReva. 2006. “From Courtship into Marriage: A New Developmental Model and Methodological Critique.” The Journal of Family Communication6:23–47.
32.
ParksMalcolm R.2007. Personal Relationships and Personal Networks. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
33.
ParksMalcolm R.StanCharlotte M.EggertLeona L.1983. “Romantic Involvement and Social Network Involvement.” Social Psychology Quarterly46:116–31.
34.
QuickBrian L.2012. “What Is the Best Measure of Psychological Reactance? An Empirical Test of Two Measures.” Health Communication27:1–9.
35.
QuickBrian L.StephensonMichael T.2008. “Examining the Role of Trait Reactance and Sensation Seeking on Perceived Threat, State Reactance, and Reactance Restoration.” Human Communication Research34:448–76.
36.
ShenLijiangDillardJames P.2005. “Psychometric Properties of the Hong Psychological Reactance Scale.” Journal of Personality Assessment85:74–81.
37.
SilviaPaul J.2005. “Deflecting Reactance: The Role of Similarity in Increasing Compliance and Reducing Resistance.” Basic and Applied Social Psychology27:277–84.
38.
SinclairH. ColleenBlaneyAbigailFelmleeDianeSprecherSusan. 2012. “Defying or Disregarding Disapproval?: Reactance and the Romeo and Juliet Effect.” Poster presented at the 2012 Society for Personality and Social Psychology conference, San Diego, CA.
39.
SinclairH. ColleenHoodKristina B.WrightBrittany L.2014. “Revisiting the Romeo and Juliet Effect (Driscoll, Davis, and Lipetz, 1972): Reexamining the Links between Social Network Opinions and Romantic Relationship Outcomes.” Journal of Social Psychology45:170–78.
40.
SprecherSusanFelmleeDiane. 2000. “Romantic Partner Perceptions of Social Network Attributes with the Passage of Time and Relationship Transitions.” Personal Relationships7:325–40.
41.
SprecherSusanFelmleeDianeOrbuchTerriWillettsMarion. 2002. “Social Networks and Change in Personal Relationships.” Pp. 257–84 in Stability and Change in Relationships, edited by VangelistiA.ReisH.FitzpatrickM.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
42.
SprecherSusanFelmleeDianeSchmeeckleMariaShuXiaoling2006. “No Breakup Occurs on an Island: Social Networks and Relationship Dissolution.” Pp. 457–78 in Handbook of Divorce and Relationship Dissolution, edited by FineM. A.HarveyJ. H.Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
43.
SternbergRobert J.1997. “Construct Validation of a Triangular Love Scale.” European Journal of Social Psychology27:313–35.
44.
WildermuthSusan. 2004. “The Effects of Stigmatizing Discourse on the Quality of On-Line Relationships.” Cyberpsychology and Behavior7:73–84.
45.
WrightBrittany L.SinclairH. Colleen. 2012. “Pulling the Strings: Effects of Parent and Friends Opinions on Dating Choices.” Personal Relationships19:743–48.
46.
WrightBrittany L.SinclairH. ColleenHoodKristina B.2014. “In Search of Romeo and Juliet.” Journal of Social Psychology45:313–14.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
