Affect control theory and the stereotype content model share explanatory goals and employ compatible measurement strategies but have developed in largely separate literatures. The present article examines the models’ commensurability and discusses new insights that can be gained by comparing theories. We first demonstrate that the unique measurement dimensions used by each theory (evaluation/potency/activity vs. warmth/competence) describe much of the same semantic content. We then show how simulation techniques developed by affect control theorists can be applied to the study of interactions with stereotyped groups. These simulations indicate broad consistencies between the theories’ predictions but highlight three distinctive emphases of affect control theory. Specifically, affect control models predict that actors are motivated to behave in ways that (1) are consistent with self-meanings, (2) maintain cultural norms about the suitability of behaviors and emotions to role relations, and (3) account for behavior and emotion in prior interactions.
AsbrockFrank. 2010. “Stereotypes of Social Groups in Germany in Terms of Warmth and Competence.” Social Psychology41:76–81.
2.
AsbrockFrankCuddyAmy J. C.2013. “Interpersonal Behavioural Outcomes of Warmth and Competence Judgments.” Unpublished manuscript. Department of Psychology, Philipps-University of Marburg, Marburg, Germany.
3.
AverettChristine P.HeiseDavid R.1987. “Modified Social Identities: Amalgamations, Attributions, and Emotions.” Journal of Mathematical Sociology13:103–32.
4.
BarrettLisa. 2009. “The Future of Psychology: Connecting Mind to Brain.” Perspectives on Psychological Science4:326–39.
5.
BlumerHerbert. 1969. Symbolic Interactionism: Perspective and Method. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
6.
CaprarielloP.CuddyAmy J. C.FiskeSusan T.2009. “Social Structure Shapes Cultural Stereotypes and Emotions: A Causal Test of the Stereotype Content Model.” Group Processes and Intergroup Relations12:147–55.
7.
CloreGerald L.PappasJesse. 2007. “The Affective Regulation of Social Interaction.” Social Psychology Quarterly70:333–39.
8.
CuddyAmy J. C.FiskeSusan T.GlickPeter. 2007. “The BIAS Map: Behaviors from Intergroup Affect and Stereotypes.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology92:631–48.
9.
CuddyAmy J. C.FiskeSusan T.GlickPeter. 2008. “Warmth and Competence as Universal Dimensions of Social Perception: The Stereotype Content Model and the BIAS Map.” Pp. 61–149 in Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, Vol. 40, edited by ZannaM. P.New York: Academic Press.
10.
CuddyAmy J. C.FiskeSusan T.KwanVirginia S. Y.GlickPeterDemoulinStéphanieLeyensJacques-PhillipeBondMichael H.CroizetJean-ClaudeEllemersNaomiSleebosEdHtunTin TinKimHyun-JeongMaioGregPerryJudiPetkovaKristinaTodorovValeryRodríguez-BailónRosaMoralesElenaMoyaMiguelPalaciosMarisolSmithVanessaPerezRolandoValaJorgeZieglerRene. 2009. “Stereotype Content Model across Cultures: Towards Universal Similarities and Some Differences.” British Journal of Social Psychology48:1–33.
11.
DavidsonDonald. 1986. “A Coherence Theory of Truth and Knowledge.” Pp. 307–19 in Truth and Interpretation: Perspectives on the Philosophy of Donald Davidson, edited by LePoreE.Oxford, UK: Blackwell Scientific Publications.
12.
DuncanSethBarrettLisa F.2007. “Affect Is a Form of Cognition: A Neurobiological Analysis.” Cognition & Emotion21:1184–1211.
13.
DuranteFederica.2008. “Testing and Extending the Stereotype Content Model.” PhD dissertation, Department of Psychology, University of Padua, Padua, Italy.
14.
EaglyAliceFineGary A.2010. “Bridging Social Psychologies: An Introduction.” Social Psychology Quarterly73:313–15.
15.
EckesThomas. 2002. “Paternalistic and Envious Gender Stereotypes: Testing Predictions from the Stereotype Content Model.” Sex Roles47:99–114.
16.
FishbeinMartinAjzenIcek. 2010. Predicting and Changing Behavior: The Reasoned Action Approach. New York: Psychology Press.
17.
FiskeSusan T.CuddyAmy J. C.GlickPeter. 2007. “Universal Dimensions of Social Cognition: Warmth and Competence.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences11:77–83.
18.
FiskeSusan T.CuddyAmy J. C.GlickPeterXuJun. 2002. “A Model of (Often Mixed) Stereotype Content: Competence and Warmth Respectively Follow from Perceived Status and Competition.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology82:878–902.
19.
FiskeSusan T.TaylorShelley E.2008. Social Cognition: From Brains to Culture. Boston, MA: McGraw-Hill.
20.
FontaineJohnny R. J.SchererKlaus R.RoeschEtienne B.EllsworthPhoebe C.2007. “The World of Emotions Is Not Two-Dimensional.” Psychological Science18:1050–57.
HeiseDavid R.1999. “Controlling Affective Experience Interpersonally.” Social Psychology Quarterly62:4–16.
26.
HeiseDavid R.2001. “Project Magellan: Collecting Cross-Cultural Affective Meanings via the Internet.” Electronic Journal of Sociology5. Retrieved August 16, 2011 (http://www.sociology.org/content/vol005.003/mag.html).
27.
HeiseDavid R.2007. Expressive Order: Confirming Sentiments in Social Action. New York: Springer.
28.
HeiseDavid R.2010. Surveying Cultures. Discovering Shared Conceptions and Sentiments. New York: Wiley.
29.
HeiseDavid R.LernerSteven J.2006. “Affect Control in International Interactions.” Social Forces85:993–1010.
30.
HeiseDavid R.MacKinnonNeil J.1987. “Affective Bases of Likelihood Perception.” Journal of Mathematical Sociology13:133–51.
31.
HeiseDavid R.WeirBrian. 1999. “A Test of Symbolic Interactionist Predictions about Emotions in Imagined Situations.” Symbolic Interaction22:129–61.
32.
JassoGuillermina. 2004. “The Tripartite Structure of Social Science Analysis.” Sociological Theory22:401–31.
33.
KemperTheodore D.1978. A Social Interactional Theory of Emotion. New York: Wiley.
34.
KemperTheodore D.CollinsRandall. 1990. “Dimensions of Microinteraction.” American Journal of Sociology96:32–68.
35.
LaPiereRichard T.1934. “Attitudes vs. Actions.” Social Forces13:230–37.
36.
LeeTiane L.FiskeSusan. 2006. “Not an Outgroup, Not Yet an Ingroup: Immigrants in the Stereotype Content Model.” International Journal of Intercultural Relations30:751–68.
37.
LeventhalHowardSchererKlaus R.1987. “The Relationship of Emotion to Cognition: A Functional Approach to a Semantic Controversy.” Cognition & Emotion1:3–28.
38.
LindquistKristen A.WagerTor D.KoberHedyBliss-MoreauElizaBarrettLisa F.2012. “The Brain Basis of Emotion: A Meta-Analytic Review.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences35:121–43.
39.
MacKinnonNeil J.1994. Symbolic Interactionism as Affect Control. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
40.
MacKinnonNeil J.BowlbyJeffrey W.2000. “The Affective Dynamics of Stereotyping and Intergroup Relations.” Advances in Group Processes17:37–76.
41.
MacKinnonNeil J.HeiseDavid R.2010. Self, Identity, and Social Institutions. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
42.
MacKinnonNeil J.LangfordTom. 1994. “The Meaning of Occupational Prestige Scores: A Social Psychological Analysis and Interpretation.” Sociological Quarterly35:215–45.
43.
McClellandKent A.FararoThomas J., eds. 2006. Purpose, Meaning, and Action: Control Systems Theories in Sociology. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
44.
MorganRick L.HeiseDavid R.1988. “Structure of Emotions.” Social Psychology Quarterly51:19–31.
45.
NeurathOtto. 1979. “Radikaler Physikalismus und wirkliche Welt” (Radical Physicalism and the Real World). Pp. 102–19 in Wissenschaftliche Weltauffassung, Sozialismus und Logischer Empirismus, edited by HegselmannR.Frankfurt, Germany: Suhrkamp.
46.
OishiShigehiroKesebirSelinSnyderBenjamin H.2009. “Sociology: A Lost Connection in Social Psychology.” Personality and Social Psychology Review13:334–53.
47.
OsgoodCharles E.1969. “On the Whys and Wherefores of E, P, and A.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology12:194–99.
48.
OsgoodCharles E.MayWilliam H.MironMurray S.1975. Cross-Cultural Universals of Affective Meaning. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
49.
OsgoodCharles E.SuciGeorge J.TannenbaumPercy H.1957. The Measurement of Meaning. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
50.
OsgoodCharles E.TannenbaumPercy H.1955. “The Principle of Congruity in the Prediction of Attitude Change.” Psychological Review62:42–55.
51.
RobinsonDawn T.Smith-LovinLynn. 1992. “Selective Interaction as a Strategy for Identity Maintenance: An Affect Control Model.” Social Psychology Quarterly55:12–28.
52.
RobinsonDawn T.Smith-LovinLynn. 2006. “Affect Control Theory.” Pp. 137–64 in Contemporary Social Psychological Theories, edited by BurkeP. J.Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
53.
RogersKimberly B.SchröderTobiasvon ScheveChristian. Forthcoming. “Dissecting the Sociality of Emotion: A Multi-Level Approach.” Emotion Review.
54.
SchererKlaus R.2005. “What Are Emotions? And How Can They Be Measured?” Social Science Information44:695–729.
55.
SchneiderAndreasHeiseDavid R.1995. “Simulating Symbolic Interaction.” Journal of Mathematical Sociology20:271–87.
56.
SchollWolfgang. 2013. “The Socio-Emotional Basis of Human Interaction and Communication: How We Construct Our Social World.” Social Science Information52:3–33.
57.
SchröderTobias. 2011. “A Model of Language-Based Impression-Formation among Germans.” Journal of Language and Social Psychology30:82–102.
58.
SchröderTobiasNetzelJanineSchermulyCarsten C.SchollWolfgang. 2013. “Culture-Constrained Affective Consistency of Interpersonal Behavior: A Test of Affect Control Theory with Nonverbal Expressions.” Social Psychology44:47–58.
59.
SchröderTobiasRogersKimberly B.IkeShuuichiroMellJulijaSchollWolfgang. 2013. “Affective Meanings of Stereotyped Social Groups in Cross-Cultural Comparison.” Unpublished manuscript. Department of Philosophy, University of Waterloo, Ontario, Canada.
60.
SchröderTobiasSchollWolfgang. 2009. “Affective Dynamics of Leadership: An Experimental Test of Affect Control Theory.” Social Psychology Quarterly72:180–97.
61.
SchröderTobiasThagardPaul. 2013. “The Affective Meanings of Automatic Social Behaviors: Three Mechanisms That Explain Priming.” Psychological Review120:255–80.
62.
SimonDanHolyoakKeith J.2002. “Structural Dynamics of Cognition: From Consistency Theories to Constraint Satisfaction.” Personality and Social Psychology Review6:649–62.
63.
SmithEliot R.1993. “Social Identity and Social Emotions: Toward New Conceptualizations of Prejudice.” Pp. 297–315 in Affect, Cognition, and Stereotyping: Interactive Processes in Group Perception, edited by MackieD. M.HamiltonD. L.San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
64.
SmithHerman W.MatsunoTakanoriIkeShuuichiro. 2001. “The Affective Basis of Attributional Processes among Japanese and Americans.” Social Psychology Quarterly64:180–94.
65.
Smith-LovinLynn. 1987. “Impressions from Events.” Journal of Mathematical Sociology13:35–70.
66.
Smith-LovinLynn. 1991. “An Affect Control View of Cognition and Emotion.” Pp. 143–69 in The Self-Society Dynamic: Cognition, Emotion, and Action, edited by HowardJ. A.CalleroP. L.New York: Cambridge University Press.
67.
Smith-LovinLynn. 2001. “Roles, Identities, and Emotion: Parallel Processing and the Production of Mixed Emotions.” Pp. 125–43 in Self and Identity: Personal, Social, and Symbolic, edited by KashimaY.FoddyM.PlatowM. J.New York: Erlbaum.
68.
Smith-LovinLynnHeiseDavid R.1988. Analyzing Social Interaction: Advances in Affect Control Theory. New York: Gordon and Breach.
69.
StephanCookie W.StephanWalter G.PettigrewThomas F., eds. 1991. The Future of Social Psychology. New York: Springer.
70.
SwannWilliam B.RentfrowPeter J.GuinnJennifer S.2003. “Self-Verification: The Search for Coherence.” Pp. 367–83 in Handbook of Self and Identity, edited by LearyM.TagneyJ.New York: Guilford.
71.
WickerAllan W.1969. “Attitudes Versus Actions: The Relationship of Verbal and Overt Behavioral Responses to Attitude Objects.” Journal of Social Issues25:41–78.
