The BBC Prison Study was an experimental case study in which participants were randomly assigned to groups as prisoners or guards. This paper examines the impact of interventions designed to increase prisoners' sense of shared social identity on processes of leadership. It presents psychometric, behavioral, and observational data which support the propositions that (a) social identity makes leadership possible, (b) effective leadership facilitates the development of social identity, and (c) the long-term success and failure of leadership depends on the viability of identity-related projects. The study also points to the role of identity failure in precipitating change in general and the emergence of authoritarian leadership in particular. Findings provide integrated support for claims that social identity and self-categorization processes are fundamental to the leadership process and associated experiences of collective efficacy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbelTheodore [1938] 1986. Why Hitler Came to Power. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
2.
AbseD. W.JessnerL.1962. “The Psychodynamic Aspects of Leadership.” Pp. 76–93 in Excellence and Leadership in a Democracy, edited byGraubardS.HoltonG., New York: Columbia University Press
3.
Adarves-YornoInmaculadaTomPostmesHaslamS. Alexander forthcoming. “Creative Innovation or Crazy Irrelevance? The Contribution of Group norms and Level of Identity to Innovative Behaviour and Perceptions of Creativity.”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology.
4.
AdornoTheodor W.1950. “Democratic Leadership and Mass Manipulation.” Pp. 418–435 in Studies in Leadership, edited byGouldnerA. W.New York: Harper Row
5.
AhmedAkbar S.1997. Jinnah, Pakistan, and Islamic Identity: The Search for Saladin.London: Routledge
6.
BarkerColinAlanJohnsonMichaelLavalette2001. Leadership in Social Movements.Manchester: Manchester University Press
7.
BessonYves1990. Identites et Conflits au Proche Orient.Paris: L'Harmattan
8.
BlumerHerbet1969. Symbolic Interactionism: Perspective and Method.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall
9.
BurnsJames MacGregor1978. Leadership.Harper & Row: New York
10.
CohenJacob1977. Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences.New York: Wiley
11.
DonnellonAnne1996. Team-talk: The Power of Language in Team Dynamics.Boston, MA: Harvard University Business School Press
12.
DoosjeBertjanNaomiEllemersRussellSpears1995. “Perceived Intragroup Variability as a Function of Group Status and Identification.”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology31: 410–436
13.
DruryJohnReicherStephen D.2005. “Explaining Enduring Empowerment: A Comparative Study of Collective Action and Psychological Outcomes.”European Journal of Social Psychology35: 35–58
14.
EllemersNaomi1993. “The Influence of Socio-structural Variables on Identity Enhancement Strategies.”European Review of Social Psychology4: 27–57
15.
EllemersNaomiDeDick GilderHaslamS. Alexander2004. “Motivating Individuals and Groups at Work: A Social Identity Perspective on Leadership and Group Performance.”Academy of Management Review29: 459–478
16.
FiedlerFred E.1978. “The Contingency Model and the Dynamics of the Leadership Process. Pp. 60–112 In Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, volume 11. New York: Academic Press
FrommErich1941. Escape From Freedom.New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston
19.
GastilJohn1994. “A Definition and Illustration of Democratic Leadership.”Human Relations47: 953–975
20.
GellatelyRobert2001. Backing Hitler.Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press
21.
HaneyCraigCurtisBanksZimbardoPhilip G.1973. “A Study of Prisoners and Guards in a Simulated Prison.” Naval Research Reviews: September (pp. 1–17). Office of Naval Research: Washington, D.C. [Reprinted in Readings about the Social Animal (3rd ed., 1981), pp. 52–67 edited by E. Aronson. San Francisco, CA: W. H. Freeman]
22.
HaslamS. Alexander2004. Psychology in Organizations: The Social Identity Approach.2d ed.London: Sage
23.
HaslamS. AlexanderCraigMcGarty2001. “A Hundred Years of Certitude? Social Psychology, the Experimental Method and the Management of Scientific Uncertainty.”British Journal of Social Psychology40: 1–21
24.
HaslamS. AlexanderPlatowM. J.2001. “The Link Between Leadership and Followership: How Affirming a Social Identity Translates Vision Into Action.”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin27: 1469–1479
25.
HaslamS. AlexanderTomPostmesNaomiEllemers2003. “More Than a Metaphor: Organizational Identity Makes Organizational Life Possible.”British Journal of Management14: 357–369
26.
HaslamS. AlexanderReicherStephen D.2005. “The Psychology of Tyranny.”Scientific American Mind16(3): 44–51
27.
HaslamS. AlexanderReicherStephen D.2006a. “Debating the Psychology of Tyranny: Fundamental Issues of Theory, Perspective and Science.”British Journal of Social Psychology45: 55–63
28.
HaslamS. AlexanderReicherStephen D.2006b. “Stressing the Group: Social Identity and the Dynamics of Stress.”Journal of Applied Social Psychology91: 1037–1052
29.
HaslamS. AlexanderReicherStephen D.2006c. A User's Guide to ‘The Experiment’: Exploring the Psychology of Groups and Power.2nd ed.London: BBC Active
30.
HaslamS. AlexanderReicherStephen D.2007. “Social Identity and the Dynamics of Organizational Life: Insights from the BBC Prison Study.” Pp. 135–166 in Identity and the Modern Organization, edited byBartelC.BladerS.WrzesniewskiA.New York: Erlbaum
31.
HoggMichael A.2001. “A Social Identity Theory of Leadership.”Personality and Social Psychology Review5: 184–200
32.
HoggMichael A.KnippenbergDaan van2004. “Social Identity and Leadership Processes in Groups.”Advances in Experimental Social Psychology35: 1–52
33.
HollanderEdwin P.1995. “Organizational Leadership and Followership.” Pp. 69–87 in Social Psychology at Work: Essays in Honour of Michael Argyle, edited byCollettP.FurnhamA.London: Routledge
34.
HowellJon. P.DorfmanPeter. W.StevenKerr1986. “Moderator Variables in Leadership Research.”Academy of Management Review11: 88–102
35.
KellyCarolineSaraBreinlinger1996. The Social Psychology of Collective Action: Identity, Injustice, and Gender.London: Taylor and Francis
36.
KerrStevenJermierJohn M.1978. “Substitutes for Leadership: Their Meaning and Measurement.”Organizational Behavior and Human Performance22: 375–403
37.
KoppelGabySeries producerMirskyNickExecutive producer (2002, May 14, 15, 20, 21). The Experiment.London: British Broadcasting Corporation
38.
LasseyWilliam. R.1971. “Dimensions of Leadership.” Pp. 4–11 in Leadership and Social Change, edited byLasseyA. W.Iowa City, IA: University Associates Press
39.
LevineR. Mark2003. “Times, Theories, and Practices in Social Psychology.”Theory and Psychology13: 53–72
40.
McGartyCraigSmithsonMichael J.2005. “Independence and Non-Independence: A Simple Test for Comparing Groups Using Multiple Measures and the Binomial Test.”European Journal of Social Psychology35: 171–180
41.
MelucciAlberto1995. “The Process of Collective Identity.” Pp. 101–30 in New Social Movements: From Ideology to Identity, edited byLaranaE.JohnstonH.GusfieldJ. R.Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press
42.
MorrisAldon D.2000. “Reflections on Social Movement Theory: Criticisms and Proposals.”Contemporary Sociology29: 445–54
43.
MorrisAldon D.SuzanneStaggenborg2004. “Leadership in Social Movements.” Pp. 171–196 in The Blackwell Companion to Social Movements, edited bySnowD.A.SouleS.A.KriesiH.Oxford: Blackwell
OakesPenelope J.HaslamS. AlexanderTurnerJohn C.1994. Stereotyping and Social Reality.Oxford: Blackwell
46.
ParsonsTalcott(1947). “The Institutionalization of Authority.” Pp. 56–77 in The Theory of Social and Economic Organization, edited byWeberM.New York: Oxford University Press
47.
PlatowMichael J.StephanieHoarReidScott A.KerynHarleyDianneMorrison1997. “Endorsement of Distributively Fair or Unfair Leaders in Interpersonal and Intergroup Situations.”European Journal of Social Psychology27: 465–494
48.
PlatowMichael J.KnippenbergDaan van2001. “A Social Identity Analysis of Leadership Endorsement: The Effects of Leader Ingroup Prototypicality and Distributive Intergroup Fairness.”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin27: 1508–1519
49.
PopperKarl R.1972. Objective Knowledge: An Evolutionary Approach.OUP: Oxford
50.
ReichWilhelmVincentCarfango1970. The Mass Psychology of Fascism.New York: Farrar, Strauss, and Giroux
51.
ReicherStephen D.1996. “Social Identity and Social Change: Rethinking the Context of Social Psychology.” Pp. 317–336 in Social Groups and Identities: Developing the Legacy of Henri Tajfel, edited byRobinsonP.Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann
52.
ReicherStephen D.2001. “The Psychology of Crowd Dynamics.” Pp. 128–208 in Blackwell Handbook of Social Psychology: Group Processes, edited byHoggM A.TindaleS.Oxford: Blackwell
53.
ReicherStephen D.JohnDruryNicholasHopkinsCliffordStott2001. “A Model of Crowd Prototypes and Crowd Leadership.” Pp. 178–195 in Leadership and Social Movements, edited byBarkerC.LavaletteM.JohnsonA.Manchester: Manchester University Press
54.
ReicherStephen D.HaslamS. Alexander2006a. “Rethinking the Psychology of Tyranny: The BBC Prison Study.”British Journal of Social Psychology45: 1–40
55.
ReicherStephen D.HaslamS. Alexander2006b. “On the Agency of Individuals and Groups: Lessons from the BBC Prison Study.” Pp. 237–257 in Individuality and the Group: Advances in Social Identity, edited byPostmesT.JettenJ.London: Sage
56.
ReicherStephen D.HaslamS. AlexanderNicholasHopkins2005. “Social Identity and the Dynamics of Leadership: Leaders and Followers as Collaborative Agents in the Transformation of Social Reality.”Leadership Quarterly16: 547–568
57.
ReicherStephen D.NicholasHopkins1996. “Self-Category Constructions in Political Rhetoric: An Analysis of Thatcher's and Kinnock's Speeches Concerning the British Miners' Strike (1984–5).”European Journal of Social Psychology26: 353–372
58.
ReicherStephen D.NicholasHopkins2003. “On the Science of the Art of Leadership.” Pp. 197–209 in Leadership, Power and Identity, edited byvan KnippenbergDaanHoggM. A.London: Sage
59.
SherifMuzafer1956. “Experiments in Group Conflict.”Scientific American195: 54–58
60.
SimonBerndBertKlandermans2001. “Politicized Collective Identity: A Social Psychological Analysis.”American Psychologist56: 319–331
61.
SimonBerndBrownRupert J.1987. “Perceived Intragroup Homogeneity in Minority-majority Contexts.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology53: 703–711
62.
SlaterPhilipBennisWarren G.1992. “Democracy is Inevitable.”Harvard Business Review68: 167–178
63.
StennerKaren2005. The Authoritarian Dynamic.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
64.
StrykerSheldonOwensTimothy J.WhiteRobert W.2000. Self, Identity and Social Movements.Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press
65.
TajfelHenriTurnerJohn C.1979. “An Integrative Theory of Intergroup Conflict.” Pp. 33–47 in The Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations, edited byAustinW. G.WorchelS.Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole
66.
TurnerJohn C.1991. Social Influence.Milton Keynes: Open University Press
67.
TurnerJohn C.2005. “Explaining the Nature of Power: A Three-Process Theory.”European Journal of Social Psychology35: 1–25
68.
TurnerJohn C.2006. “Tyranny, Freedom and Social Structure: Escaping our Theoretical Prisons.”British Journal of Social Psychology45: 41–46
69.
TurnerJohn C.HaslamS. Alexander2001. “Social Identity, Organizations and Leadership.” Pp. 25–65 in Groups at Work: Advances in Theory and Research, edited byTurnerM. E.Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum
70.
TurnerJohn C.HoggMichael A.OakesPenelope J.ReicherStephen D.WetherellMargaret S.1987. Rediscovering the Social Group: A Self-Categorization Theory.Oxford: Blackwell
71.
TurnerJohn C.OakesPenelope J.HaslamS. AlexanderMcGartyCraig A., 1994. “Self and Collective: Cognition and Social Context.”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin20: 454463
72.
TurnerJohn C.ReynoldsKatherine. J.HaslamS. AlexanderKristineVeenstra2006. “Reconceptualizing Personality: Producing Individuality Through Defining the Personal Self.” Pp. 11–36 in Individuality and the Group: Advances in Social Identity, edited byPostmesT.JettenJ.London: Sage
73.
TylerTom R.2006. “Psychological Perspectives on Legitimacy and Legitimation.”Annual Review of Psychology57: 375–400
74.
Van KnippenbergDaanHoggMichael A. (Eds.), 2003. Leadership and Power: Identity Processes in Groups and Organizations.London: Sage
75.
VeenstraKristineHaslamS. Alexander2000. Willingness to participate in industrial protest: Exploring social identification in context.British Journal of Social Psychology, 39: 153–172
76.
WrightSteve. C.TaylorDon M.MoghaddamFathali M.1990. “Responding to Membership in a Disadvantaged Group: From Acceptance to Collective Protest.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology58: 994–1003
