I study the relationships of resources and personality characteristics to charitable giving, postmortem organ donation, and blood donation in a nationwide sample of persons in households in the Netherlands. I find that specific personality characteristics are related to specific types of giving: agreeableness to blood donation, empathic concern to charitable giving, and prosocial value orientation to postmortem organ donation. I find that giving has a consistently stronger relation to human and social capital than to personality. Human capital increases giving; social capital increases giving only when it is approved by others. Effects of prosocial personality characteristics decline at higher levels of these characteristics. Effects of empathic concern, helpfulness, and social value orientations on generosity are mediated by verbal proficiency and church attendance.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AmelangManfredPeterBorkenau1986. “The Trait Concept: Current Theoretical Considerations, Empirical Facts, and Implications for Personality Inventory Construction.” Pp. 7–34 in Personality Assessment via Questionnaires: Current Issues in Theory and Measurement, edited byAloisAngleitnerWigginsJerry S.Berlin: Springer
2.
ArdeltMonika2000. “Still Stable After All These Years? Personality Stability Theory Revisited.”Social Psychology Quarterly63: 392405
3.
AshtonMichael C.KibeomLee2001. “A Theoretical Basis for the Major Dimensions of Personality.”European Journal of Personality15: 32753
4.
AshtonMichael C.KibeomLeeGoldbergLewis R.2004. “A Hierarchical Analysis of 1,710 English Personality-Descriptive Adjectives.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 87: 707–21
5.
AshtonMichael C.KibeomLeeMarcoPeruginiPiotrSzarotaDe VriesReinout E.DiLisa BlasKathleenBoiesDeBoele Raad2004. “A Six-Factor Structure of Personality-Descriptive Adjectives: Solutions From Psycholexical Studies in Seven Languages.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology86: 35666
6.
BatsonC. Daniel1998. “Altruism and Prosocial Behavior.” Pp. 282–316 in Handbook of Social Psychology, vol. 2, 3d ed., edited byGilbertDaniel T.New York: Random House
7.
BatsonC. DanielBolenMichelle H.CrossJulie A.Neuringer-BenefielHelen E.1986. “Where Is the Altruism in the Altruistic Personality?”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology50: 21220
8.
BekkersRené.2003. “De Bijdragen der Kerckelijken” (The Contributions of the Religious). Pp. 141–72 in Geven in Nederland 2003, edited bySchuytTheo N.M.Houten/Dieghem: Bohn Stafleu van Loghum
9.
BekkersRené.2004. “Giving and Volunteering in the Netherlands: Sociological and Psychological Perspectives.” PhD dissertation, Department of Sociology, Utrecht University, The Netherlands
10.
BekkersRené.2005. “Participation in Voluntary Associations: Relations With Resources, Personality, and Political Values.”Political Psychology26: 43954
11.
Ben-NerAvnerLouisPuttermanFarminKongDanMagan2004. “Reciprocity in a Two-Part Dictator Game.”Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization53: 33352
12.
BradyHenry E.SchlozmanKay LehmanSidneyVerba1999. “Prospecting for Participants: Rational Expectations and the Recruitment of Political Activists.”American Political Science Review93: 15369
13.
BradyHenry E.SidneyVerbaSchlozmanKay Lehman1995. “Beyond SES:A Resource Model of Political Participation.” American Political Science Review89: 271–94
14.
BrouwerWendyFrieleRoland D.2004. “Nederlanders Over Orgaandonatie” (The Dutch On Organ Donation). Pp. 7–100 in: Tweede Evaluatie Wet op de Orgaandonatie (Second Evaluation of the Law on Organ Donation) edited byFrieleRoland D.GeversSjef K.M.RemcoCoppenJanssenAnke J.G.M.WendyBrouwerMarquetRichard L.Utrecht: Nivel
15.
BussDavid M.1987. “Selection, Evocation, and Manipulation.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology53: 121421
16.
CalleroPeter L.HowardJudith A.PiliavinJane A.1987. “Helping Behavior As Role Behavior: Disclosing Social Structure and History in the Analysis of Prosocial Action.”Social Psychological Quarterly50: 24756
17.
CaplanBryan2003. “Stigler-Becker Versus Myers-Briggs: Why Preference-Based Explanations Are Scientifically Meaningful and Empirically Important.”Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization50: 391405
18.
CarloGustavoNancyEisenbergDebraTroyerGalenSwitzerSpeerAnna L.1991. “The Altruistic Personality: In What Contexts Is It Apparent?” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology61: 450–58
19.
CramerJames S.1991. The Logit Model: An Introduction for Economists.London: Edward Arnold
20.
DavisMark H.1994. Empathy: A Social Psychological Approach.Madison, WI: Brown and Benchmark
21.
DavisMark H.MitchellKyle V.HallJennifer A.JenniferLothertTyraSnappMarneeMeyer1999. “Empathy, Expectations, and Situational Preferences: Personality Influences on the Decision to Participate in Volunteer Helping Behaviors.”Journal of Personality67: 469503
DiekmannAndreasPeterPreisendörfer1998. “Environmental Behavior: Discrepancies Between Aspirations and Reality.”Rationality and Society10: 79102
24.
DrakeAlvin W.FinkelsteinStan N.SapolskyHarvey M.1982. The American Blood Supply.Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
25.
EisenbergNancyMillerPaul A.MarkSchallerFabesRichard A.JimFultzRitaShellSheaCindy L.1989. “The Role of Sympathy and Altruistic Personality Traits in Helping: A Reexamination.” Journal of Personality57: 41–67
26.
ElsterJon1989. Nuts and Bolts for the Social Sciences.Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press
27.
EpsteinSeymourO'BrienEdward J.1985. “The Person-Situation Debate in Historical and Current Perspective.”Psychological Bulletin98: 51337
28.
FossRobert D.1983. “Community Norms and Blood Donation.”Journal of Applied Social Psychology13: 28191
29.
GerrisJan R.M.HoutmansTilly M.J.M.Kwaaitaal-RoosenElma M.G.SchipperJ. ClasienVermulstAd A.JanssensJan M.A.M.1998. Parents, Adolescents and Young Adults in Dutch Families: A Longitudinal Study.Nijmegen: Institute of Family Studies, University of Nijmegen
30.
GoereeJacob K.HoltCharles A.LaurySusan K.2002. “Private Costs and Public Benefits: Unraveling the Effects of Altruism and Noisy Behavior.”Journal of Public Economics83: 25576
31.
GoldbergLewis R.1992. “The Development of Markers of the Big-Five Factor Structure.”Psychological Assessment4: 2642
32.
GouldnerAlvin W.1960. “The Norm of Reciprocity: A Preliminary Statement.”American Sociological Review25: 16178
33.
GrazianoWilliam G.NancyEisenberg1997. “Agreeableness: A Dimension of Personality.” Pp. 795–824 in Handbook of Personality Psychology, edited byRobertHoganJohnJohnsonStephenBriggsSan Diego: Academic Press
34.
HauserSeth M.2000. “Education, Ability, and Civic Engagement in the Contemporary United States.”Social Science Research29: 55682
35.
HealyKieran2000. “Embedded Altruism: Blood Collection Regimes and the European Union's Donor Population.”American Journal of Sociology105: 163357
36.
HealyKieran2004. “Altruism As an Organizational Problem: The Case of Organ Procurement.”American Sociological Review69: 387404
37.
HertelGuidoKlausFiedler1998. “Fair and Dependent Versus Egoistic and Free: Effects of Semantic and Evaluative Priming on the ‘Ring Measure of Social Values.”’European Journal of Social Psychology28: 4970
38.
HillygusSunshine2005. “The Missing Link: Exploring the Relationship Between Higher Education and Political Engagement.”Political Behavior27: 2547
39.
HuberPeter J.1967. “The Behavior of Maximum Likelihood Estimates Under Non-Standard Conditions.” Pp. 221–33 in Proceedings of the Fifth Berkeley Symposium on Mathematical Statistics Probability, vol.1, edited byLeCamLucien M.JerzyNeymanBerkeley: University of California Press
40.
JacksonElton F.BachmeierMark D.WoodJames R.CraftElizabeth A.1995. “Volunteering and Charitable Giving: Do Religious and Associational Ties Promote Helping Behavior?”Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly24: 5978
41.
KohnAlfie1990. The Brighter Side of Nature: Altruism and Empathy in Everyday Life.New York: Basic Books
42.
KrahéBarbara1992. Personality and Social Psychology: Towards a Synthesis.London: Sage
43.
KuhlmanD. MichaelAlfredMarshello1975. “Individual Differences in the Game Motives of Own, Relative and Joint Gain.”Journal of Research in Personality9: 24051
44.
LatanéBibbDarleyJohn M.1970. The Unresponsive Bystander: Why Doesn't He Help?New York: Meredith
45.
LeeLichangPiliavinJane A.CallVaughn R.A.1999. “Giving Time, Money, and Blood: Similarities and Differences.”Social Psychological Quarterly62: 27690
46.
LenskiGerhard1966. Power and Privilege : A Theory of Social Stratification.New York: McGraw-Hill
47.
LinNan2001. Social Capital: A Theory of Social Structure and Action.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press
48.
McClintockCharles G.LiebrandWim B.G.1988. “Role of Interdepence Structure, Individual Value Orientation, and Another's Strategy in Social Decision Making: A Transformational Analysis.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology55: 396409
49.
McCraeRobert R.JohnOliver P.1992. “An Introduction to the Five-Factor Model and Its Applications.”Journal of Personality60: 175–215
50.
MenschKarin2000. “Niedrigkostensituationen, Hochkostensituationen und Andere Situationstypen: Ihre Auswirkungen auf die Möglichkeit von Rational-Choice-Erklärungen” (Low Cost Situations, High Cost Situations, and Other Types of Situations: Their Effects on the Possibiliy of Rational-Choice Explanations).Kölner Zeitschrift zur Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie52: 24663
51.
MeslinEricKimberlyQuaid2004. Health Related Philanthropy: The Donation of the Body (and Parts Thereof).Indianapolis, Indiana University/Purdue University Indianapolis, Department of Bioethics
52.
MocanNaciErdalTekin2005. “The Determinants of the Willingness to Be an Organ Donor.” Working Paper 11316, National Bureau Of Economic Research, Cambridge MA
53.
NeubergSteven L.CialdiniRobert B.BrownStephanie L.CarolLucsSagarinBrad J.1997. “Does Empathy Lead to Anything More Than Superficial Helping? Comment on Batson et al. (1997).”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology73: 51016
54.
OlinerSamuel P.OlinerPearl M.1988. The Altruistic Personality: Rescuers of Jews in Nazi Europe.New York: Macmillan
55.
ParkJerry Z.ChristianSmith2000. “To Whom Much Has Been Given: Religious Capital and Community Voluntarism Among Churchgoing Protestants.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion39: 27286
56.
PennerLouis A.2002. “Dispositional and Organizational Influences on Sustained Volunteerism: An Interactionist Perspective.”Journal of Social Issues58: 447–68
57.
PennerLouis A.FinkelsteinMarcia A.1998. “Dispositional and Structural Determinants of Volunteerism.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology74: 52537
58.
PennerLouis A.FritzscheBarbara A.CraigerJ. PhilipFreifeldTamara S.1995. “Measuring the Prosocial Personality.” Pp. 147–63 in Advances in Personality Assessment, vol. 10, edited bySpielbergerCharles D.ButcherJames N.Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum
59.
PiliavinJane A.CalleroPeter L.1991. Giving Blood: The Development of an Altruistic Identity.Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press
60.
PutnamRobert D.2000. Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community.New York: Simon and Schuster
61.
ReedPaul B.SelbeeL. Kevin2001. “The Civic Core in Canada: Disproportionality in Charitable Giving, Volunteering, and Civic Participation.”Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly30: 76180
62.
SandersJosé.2003. Leven Door Geven: Religieuze en Levensbeschouwelijke Standpunten over Orgaandonatie. (Passing On Life: Religious Beliefs about Organ Donation). Zoetermeer: Meinema
63.
SimpsonBrent2004. “Social Values, Subjective Transformations, and Cooperation in Social Dilemmas.”Social Psychology Quarterly67: 38595
64.
SmithVincent H.KehoeMichael R.CremerMary E.1995. “The Private Provision of Public Goods: Altruism and Voluntary Giving.”Journal of Public Economics58: 10726
65.
SnyderMarkWilliamIckes1985. “Personality and Social Behavior.” Pp. 883–947 in Handbook of Social Psychology, edited byLindzeyGardnerElliottAronsonNew York: Random House
66.
SteblayN. Mehrkens1987. “Helping Behavior in Rural and Urban Environments: A Meta-Analysis.”Psychological Bulletin102: 34656
67.
StoopIneke A.L.2005. The Hunt for the Last Respondent: Nonresponse in Sample Surveys.The Hague: SCP
68.
UtzSonja2004. “Self-Activation Is a Two-edged Sword: The Effect of I Primes on Cooperation.”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology40: 76976
69.
VanLangePaulA.M.1999. “The Pursuit of Joint Outcomes and Equality in Outcomes: An Integrative Model of Social Value Orientation.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology77: 33749
70.
VanLangePaulA.M.2000. “Beyond Self-Interest: A Set of Propositions Relevant to Interpersonal Relations.” Pp. 75–104 in European Review of Social Psychology, edited byStroebeWolfgangMilesHewstoneLondon: Wiley
71.
VanLangePaulA.M.WilmaOttenDe BruinEllen M.N.JoiremanJeffrey A.1997. “Development of Prosocial, Individualistic and Competitive Orientations: Theory and Preliminary Evidence.”Journal Of Personality and Social Psychology73: 73346
72.
VanLangePaulA.M.VugtMark vanRenéBekkersSchuytTheo N.M.2003. “From Experimental Games to Prosocial Behavior: Ecological Support for Social Value Orientation.” Department of Social Psychology, Free University, Amsterdam. Unpublished manuscript
73.
WilsonJohnMarkMusick1997. “Who Cares? Toward an Integrated Theory of Volunteer Work.”American Sociological Review62: 694713
74.
WilsonJohnMarkMusick1999. “Attachment to Volunteering.”Sociological Forum14: 24372
