Network structures both enable and constrain the development of social relations. This research investigates these features by comparing the development of commitments in structurally enabled and structurally induced exchange relations. We integrate ideas from the theory of relational cohesion and the choice process theory of commitment. In an experiment we manipulate and compare a structurally enabled relation with a structurally induced relation. The main hypotheses are that a structurally enabled relation generates a greater sense of control, more positive emotions, greater perceived cohesion, and more commitment behavior than a structurally induced relation. The results of the experiment support these hypotheses. The implication is that enabling and constraining features of network structures exert important effects on cohesion and commitment in relations within those structures.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BacharachSamuel B.LawlerEdward J.1981. Bargaining: Power, Tactics, and Outcomes.San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
2.
BanduraAlbert1997. Self Efficacy: The Exercise of Control.New York: Freeman
3.
BanduraAlbert2001. “Social Cognitive Theory: An Agentic Perspective.”Annual Review of Psychology52: 126
4.
BienenstockElisa JaynePhillipBonacich1992. “The Core As a Solution to Exclusionary Networks.”Social Networks14: 23143
5.
BlauPeter1964. Exchange and Power in Social Life.New York: Wiley
6.
BlauPeter1994. Structural Contexts of Opportunities.Chicago: University of Chicago Press
7.
BonacichPhillipBienenstockElisa Jayne1993. “Assignment Games, Chromatic Number and Exchange Theory.”Journal of Mathematical Sociology17: 24359
CollinsRandall1981. “On the Microfoundations of Macrosociology.”American Journal of Sociology86: 9841014
10.
CollinsRandall1989. “Toward a Neo-Meadian Sociology of Mind.”Symbolic Interaction12: 132
11.
CookKaren S.EmersonRichard M.1978. “Power, Equity, and Commitment in Exchange Networks.”American Sociological Review43: 72139
12.
CookKaren S.EmersonRichard M.1984. “Exchange Networks and the Analysis of Complex Organizations.” Pp. 1–30 in Research on the Sociology of Organizations; vol. 3, edited byBacharachSamuel B.LawlerEdward J.Greenwich, CT: JAI
13.
CookKaren S.EmersonRicharch M.GillmoreMary R.ToshioYamagishi1983. “The Distribution of Power in Exchange Networks: Theory and Experimental Evidence.”American Journal of Sociology89: 275305
14.
CookKaren S.JosephWhitmeyer1992. “Two Approaches to Social Structure: Exchange Theory and Network Analysis.”Annual Review of Sociology18: 10927
15.
DeciEdward L.1980. The Psychology of Self Determination.Lexington, MA: Lexington Books
16.
DurkheimEmile1915. The Elementary Forms of Religious Life.New York: Free Press
17.
EkehPeter1974. Social Exchange Theory.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
18.
ElsterJon1986. “Introduction.” Pp. 1–33 in Rational Choice, edited byJonElsterNew York: New York University Press
19.
EmersonRichard M.1972. “Exchange Theory, Part II: Exchange Relations and Networks.” Pp. 58–87 in Sociological Theories in Progress, vol. 2, edited byJosephBergerMorrisZelditchJr.BoAndersonBoston: Houghton Mifflin
20.
EmersonRichard M.1981. “Social Exchange Theory.” Pp. 30–65 in Social Psychology: Sociological Perspectives, edited byRosenbergMorrisTurnerRalph H.New York: Basic Books, Inc
21.
FriedkinNoah1992. “An Expected Value Model of Social Power: Predictions for Selected Exchange Networks.”Social Networks14: 21329
22.
GecasViktor1989. “The Social Psychology of Self-Efficacy.”Annual Review of Sociology15: 291316
23.
GiddensAnthony1984. The Constitution of Society.Berkeley: University of California Press
24.
HochschildArlie R.1989. “The Economy of Gratitude.” Pp. 95–113 in The Sociology of Emotions: Original Essays and Research Papers, edited byDavidFranksMcCarthyE. DoyleGreenwich, CT: JAI
25.
HomansGeorge L.1950. The Human Group.New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich
26.
HomansGeorge L.1961. Social Behavior: Its Elementary Forms.New York: Harcourt Brace and Jovanovich
27.
IzardCarroll E.1991. The Psychology of Emotion.New York: Plenum
28.
JöreskogKarl G.SörbomDag1993. LISREL 8: Structural Equation Modeling With the SIMPLIS Command Language.Chicago: Scientific Software
29.
KanterRosabeth M.1968. “Commitment and Social Organization: A Study of Commitment Mechanisms in Utopian Communities.”American Sociological Review33: 499517
30.
KemperTheodore D.1978. A Social Interactional Theory of Emotions.New York: Wiley
31.
KohnMelvin L.SlomczynskiKazimierz M.1990. Social Structure and Self Direction.Cambridge, UK: Blackwell
32.
KollockPeter1994. “The Emergence of Exchange Structures: An Experimental Study of Uncertainty, Commitment, and Trust.”American Journal of Sociology100: 31545
33.
KollockPeter1999. “The Production of Trust in Online Markets.” Pp. 99–124 in Advances in Group Process, vol. 16, edited byThyeShane R.LawlerEdward J.MacyMichael W.WalkerHenry A.Stamford, CT: JAI
34.
LawlerEdward J.1992. “Choice Processes and Affective Attachments to Nested Groups: A Theoretical Analysis.”American Sociological Review57: 32739
35.
LawlerEdward J.1997. “Affective Attachments to Nested Groups: The Role of Rational Choice Processes.” Pp. 387–403 in Status, Networks, and Structures: Theory Development in Group Processes, edited byJohnSkvoretzJacekSzmatkaJosephBergerStanford: Stanford University Press
36.
LawlerEdward J.2001. “An Affect Theory of Social Exchange.”American Journal of Sociology107: 32152
37.
LawlerEdward J.2002. “Micro Social Orders.”Social Psychology Quarterly65: 417
38.
LawlerEdward J.ThyeShane R.1999. “Bringing Emotions Into Social Exchange Theory.”Annual Review of Sociology25: 21744
39.
LawlerEdward JThyeShane R.JeongkooYoon2000. “Emotion and Group Cohesion in Productive Exchange.”American Journal of Sociology106: 61657
40.
LawlerEdward J.JeongkooYoon1993. “Power and the Emergence of Commitment Behavior in Negotiated Exchange.”American Sociological Review58: 46581
41.
LawlerEdward J.JeongkooYoon1996. “Commitment in Exchange Relations: Test of a Theory of Relational Cohesion.”American Sociological Review61: 89108
42.
LawlerEdward J.JeongkooYoon1998. “Network Structure and Emotion in Exchange Relations.”American Sociological Review63: 87194
43.
LazarusRichard S.1984. “On the Primacy of Cognition.”American Psychologist39: 12429
44.
McPhersonMillerLynnSmith-Lovin2002. “Cohesion and Membership Duration: Linking Groups, Relations, and Individuals in an Ecology of Affiliations.” Pp.1–36 in Advances in Group Processes, Volume 22: Group Cohesion, Trust, and Solidarity, edited byThyeShane R.LawlerEdward J.Oxford, UK: Elsevier
45.
MarkovskyBarryJohnSkvoretzDavidWillerLovagliaMichael J.JefferyErger1993. “The Seeds of Weak Power: An Extension of Network Exchange Theory.”American Sociological Review58: 197209
46.
MarkovskyBarryDavidWillerTravisPatton1988. “Power Relations in Exchange Networks.”American Sociological Review53: 22036
47.
MolmLinda1987. “Extending Power Dependency Theory: Power Processes and Negative Outcomes.” Pp. 178–98 in Advances in Group Processes, vol. 4, edited byLawlerEdward J.BarryMarkovskyGreenwich, CT: JAI
48.
MolmLinda1990. “Structure, Action, and Outcomes: The Dynamics of Power in Social Exchange.”American Sociological Review55: 42747
49.
MolmLindaKarenCook1995. “Social Exchange and Exchange Networks.” Pp. 209–35 in Sociological Perspectives on Social Psychology, edited byKarenCookGaryFineJamesHouseBoston: Allyn and Bacon
50.
MolmLindaGretchenPetersonNobuyukiTakahashi1999. “Power in Negotiated and Reciprocal Exchange.”American Sociological Review64: 87690
51.
MuellerCharles WLawlerEdward J.1999. “Commitment to Nested Organizational Units: Some Basic Principles and Preliminary Findings.”Social Psychology Quarterly62: 32546
52.
ParsonsTalcott1937. The Structure of Social Action.New York: Free Press
53.
ReeveJohn MarshallGlenNix1997. “Expressing Intrinsic Motivation Through Acts of Exploration and Facial Displays of Interest.”Motivation and Emotion21: 23750
54.
RussellJames A.1980. “A Circumplex Model of Affect.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology39: 116178
55.
SkvoretzJohnLovagliaMichael J.1995. “Who Exchanges With Whom: Structural Determinants of Exchange Frequency in Negotiated Exchange Networks.”Social Psychology Quarterly58: 16377
56.
SkvoretzJohnDavidWiller1993. “Exclusion and Power: A Test of Four Theories of Power in Exchange Networks.”American Sociological Review58: 80118
57.
SkvoretzJohnPidiZhang1997. “Actors' Responses to Outcomes in Exchange Networks: The Process of Power Development.”Sociological Perspectives40: 18397
58.
StolteJohn F.EmersonRichard M.1977. “Structural Inequality: Position and Power in Exchange Structures.” Pp. 117–38 in Behavioral Theory in Sociology, edited byHamblinRobert L.KunkelJames H.New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books
59.
StrykerSheldon1980. Symbolic Interactionism: A Social Structure Version.Menlo Park: Benjamin/Cummings
60.
TajfelHenriTurnerJohn C.1986. “The Social Identity Theory of Intergroup Behavior.” Pp. 7–24 in Psychology of Intergroup Relations, edited byWorchelStevenWilliamG.Austin. Chicago: Nelson-Hall
61.
ThibautJohn W.KelleyHarold H.1959. The Social Psychology of Groups.New York: Wiley
62.
ThyeShane R.2000a. “A Status Value Theory of Power in Exchange Relations.”American Sociological Review65: 40732
63.
ThyeShane R.2000b. “Reliability in Experimental Sociology.”Social Forces74: 12771309
64.
ThyeShane R.LovagliaMichael J.BarryMarkovsky1997. “Responses to Social Exchange and Social Exclusion in Networks.”Social Forces75: 103147
65.
ThyeShane R.JeongkooYoonLawlerEdward J.2002. “The Theory of Relational Cohesion: Review of a Research Program.” Pp. 139–66 in Advances in Group Process, vol. 19, edited byThyeShane R.LawlerEdward J.Oxford: Elsevier
66.
WalkerHenry A.ThyeShane R.BrentSimpsonLovagliaMichael J.DavidWillerBarryMarkovsky2000. “Network Exchange Theory: Recent Developments and New Directions.”Social Psychology Quarterly63: 32437
67.
WeberMax [1918] 1968. Economy and Society.Berkeley: University of California Press
68.
WeinerBernard1986. An Attributional Theory of Motivation and Emotion.New York: Springer-Verlag
69.
WestcottMalcolm R.1988. The Psychology of Human Freedom.New York: Springer-Verlag
70.
WhiteRobert W.1959. “Motivation Reconsidered: The Concept of Competence.”Psychological Review66: 297333
WillerDavidBoAnderson, eds. 1981. Networks, Exchange, and Coercion.New York: Elsevier
73.
YoonJeongkoo2001. “The Role of Structure and Motivation for Workplace Empowerment: The Case of Korean Employees.” Social Psychology Quarterly64: 195–206
