We investigate whether underweight, normal-weight, overweight, and obese Americans differ in their evaluations of positive and negative aspects of their interpersonal relationships. Analyses are based on data from the Midlife Development in the United States (MIDUS) study, a survey of more than 3,000 adults ages 25 to 74 in 1995. We find no significant differences across the body mass index (BMI) categories in the quality of relationships with friends, coworkers, and spouses. Severely obese persons report significantly higher levels of strain and lower levels of support in their family relationships. This pattern, however, is contingent upon one's adolescent body weight. Among persons who were of “normal” weight at age 21, current BMI is not associated with relationship quality. For persons who were overweight at age 21, the level of social support received from family during adulthood declines as adult BMI increases. Implications for stigma theory are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllonNatalie1981. “The Stigma of Overweight in Everyday Life.” Pp. 130–74 in Psychological Aspects of Obesity: A Handbook, edited byWolmanBenjamin B.New York: Van Nostrand Rheinhold
2.
AntonucciToni C.2001. “Social Relations: An Examination of Social Networks, Social Support, and Sense of Control.” Pp. 427–53 in Handbook of the Psychology of Aging, 5th ed., edited byBirrenJames E.SchaieK. WarnerSan Diego: Academic Press
3.
AverettSusan L.SandersKorenman1999. “Black-White Differences in Social and Economic Consequences of Obesity.”International Journal of Obesity23: 16673
4.
BanisHeatherJamesVerneJanWallenderBarbaraKorsch1988. “Psychological and Social Adjustment of Obese Children and Their Families.”Child Care Health and Development14: 15773
5.
BarbarinOscarMildredTirado1994. “Family Involvement and Successful Treatment of Obesity: A Review.”Family Systems Medicine2: 3745
6.
BartlettSusan J.WaddenThomas A.VogtRenee A.1996. “Psychosocial Consequences of Weight Cycling.”Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology64: 58792
7.
BedfordVictoriaRosemaryBlieszner1997. “Personal Relationships in Later Life Families.” Pp. 523–39 in Handbook of Personal Relationships, 2nd ed., edited bySteveDuckNew York: Wiley
8.
BellStephen K.MorganSam B.2000. “Children's Attitudes and Behavioral Intentions Toward a Peer Presented As Obese: Does a Medical Explanation for the Obesity Make a Difference?”Journal of Pediatric Psychology25: 13745
BowmanR. L.DeLucaJ. L.1992. “Accuracy of Self-reported Weight: A Meta-Analysis.”Behavior Therapy23: 63756
11.
BrimOrville GilbertRyffCarol D.KesslerRonald C.2004. “The MIDUS Survey: An Overview.” Pp. 1–34 in How Healthy Are We? A National Study of Well-Being at Midlife, edited byBrimOrville G.RyffCarol D.KesslerRonald C.Chicago: University of Chicago Press
12.
BuhrmesterDuaneWyndolFurmanMitchellWittenbergReisHarry T.1988. “Five Domains of Interpersonal Competence in Peer Relationships.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology55: 9911008
13.
CahnmanWerner J.1968. “The Stigma of Obesity.”Sociological Quarterly9: 28399
14.
CarrDeborahMichaelFriedman2005. “Is Obesity Stigmatizing? Body Weight, Perceived Discrimination, and Psychological Well-Being in the United States.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior46: 24459
15.
CashThomas F.BrendaCountsHuffineChristopher E.1990. “Current and Vestigial Effects of Overweight Among Women: Fear of Fat, Attitudinal Body Image, and Eating Behaviors.”Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment12: 15767
16.
Centers for Disease Control (CDC).2000. CDC Growth Charts for the United States: Methods and Development.Washington, DC: Centers for Disease Control
17.
ChristoffelKatherineForsythBrian W.1989. “Mirror Image of Environmental Deprivation: Severe Childhood Obesity of Psychosocial Origin.”Child Abuse and Neglect13: 24956
18.
CohenSheldonSymeS. Leonard1985. “Issues in the Application and Study of Social Support.” Pp. 3–22 in Social Support and Health, edited bySheldonCohenSymeS. LeonardOrlando: Academic Press
19.
ConstanzoPhilip R.WoodyErik Z.1985. “Domain-Specific Parental Styles and Their Impact on the Child's Development of Particular Deviance: The Example of Obesity Proneness.”Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology3: 42530
20.
CoyneJames C.1976. “Depression and the Response of Others.”Journal of Abnormal Psychology85: 18693
21.
CoyneJames CKesslerRonald C.MargalitTalJoanneTurnbullCamilleWortmanGredenJohn F.1987. “Living With a Depressed Person.”Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology55: 34752
22.
CraigP.L.TruswellA. Stewart1990. “Dynamics of Food Habits of Newly Married Couples: Weight and Exercise Patterns.”Australian Journal of Nutrition and Dietetics47: 4246
23.
CrandallChristian S.RebeccaMartinez1996. “Culture, Ideology, and Anti-Fat Attitudes.”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin22: 116576
24.
CrandallChristian S.SchiffhauerKristin L.1998. “Anti-Fat Prejudice: Beliefs, Values, and American Culture.”Obesity Research6: 45860
25.
CrockerJenniferBrendaMajor1989. “Social Stigma and Self-Esteem: The Self-Protective Properties of Stigma.”Psychological Review96: 60830
26.
CrockerJenniferBrendaMajorClaudeSteele1998. “Social Stigma.” Pp. 504–33 in The Handbook of Social Psychology, edited byGilbertDaniel T.FiskeSusan T.Boston: McGraw-Hill
27.
CuttingTanja M.FisherJennifer O.KarenGrimm-ThomasBirchLeann L.1999. “Like Mother, Like Daughter: Familial Patterns of Overweight Are Mediated by Mother's Dietary Disinhibition.”American Journal of Clinical Nutrition69: 60813
28.
DeJongWilliam1980. “The Stigma of Obesity: The Consequences of Naïve Assumptions Concerning the Causes of Physical Deviance.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior21: 7587
29.
DohertyWilliam J.HarkawayJill E.1990. “Obesity and Family Systems: A Family FIRO Approach to Assessment and Treatment Planning.”Journal of Marital and Family Therapy16: 28798
30.
FerraroKenneth F.Kelley-MooreJessica A.2003. “Cumulative Disadvantage and Health: Long-Term Consequences of Obesity.”American Sociological Review68: 70729
31.
FinchJohn FOkunMorris A.GregoryPoolRuhlmanLinda S.1999. “A Comparison of the Influence of Conflictual and Supportive Social Interactions on Psychological Distress.”Journal of Personality67: 581621
32.
FischerClaude S.1982. To Dwell Among Friends.Chicago: University of Chicago Press
33.
FlegalKatherine M.CarrollMargaret D.CynthiaOgdenJohnsonClifford L.2002. “Prevalence and Trends in Obesity Among U.S. Adults, 1999–2000.”Journal of the American Medical Association288: 172327
34.
FriedmanKelli E.ReichmannSimona K.ConstanzoPhilip R.MusanteGerard J.2002. “Body Image Partially Mediates the Relationship Between Obesity and Psychological Distress.”Obesity Research10: 3341
35.
FriedmanMichael A.BrownellKelly D.1995. “Psychological Correlates of Obesity: Moving to the Next Research Generation.”Psychological Bulletin117: 3–20
36.
FriedmanMichael A.WilfleyDenise E.WelchR. RobinsonKunceJoseph T.1997. “Self-Directed Hostility and Family Functioning in Normal-Weight Bulimics and Overweight Binge Eaters.”Addictive Behaviors22: 36775
37.
FuHaishanNoreenGoldman1996. “Incorporating Health Into Models of Marriage Choice: Demographic and Sociological Perspectives.”Journal of Marriage and the Family58: 74058
38.
GanleyRichard M.1986. “Epistemology, Family Patterns, and Psychosomatics: The Case of Obesity.”Family Process25: 43751
39.
GeorgeLinda1993. “Sociological Perspectives on Life Transitions.”Annual Review of Sociology19: 35373
40.
GieslerR. BrianJosephsRobert A.SwannWilliam B.Jr.1996. “Self-Verification in Clinical Depression: The Desire for Negative Evaluation.”Journal of Abnormal Psychology105: 35868
41.
GoffmanErving1963. Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall
42.
GoldmanWilliamPhilipLewis1977. “‘Beautiful Is Good’: Evidence That the Physically Attractive Are More Socially Skillful.”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology13: 12530
43.
GortmakerSteven L.AvivaMustPerrinJames M.SobolArthur M.DietzWilliam H.1993. “Social and Economic Consequences of Overweight in Adolescence and Young Adulthood.”New England Journal of Medicine329: 100812
44.
GotlibIan H.MeltzerSari J.1987. “Depression and the Perception of Social Skill in Interaction.”Cognitive Therapy and Research11: 4154
45.
GreenbergBradley S.MatthewEastinLindaHotschireKenLachlanBrownellKelly D.2003. “Portrayals of Overweight and Obese Individuals on Commercial Television.”American Journal of Public Health93: 134248
46.
HarrisMary B.HarrisRichard J.StephenBochner1982. “Fat Four-Eyed and Female: Stereotypes of Obesity, Glasses and Gender.”Journal of Applied Social Psychology12: 50316
47.
HouseJames S.LandisKarl R.DebraUmberson1988. “Social Relationships and Health.”Science241: 54045
48.
LevittMary J.SilverMarcia E.NathalieFranco1996. “Troublesome Relationships: A Part of Human Experience.”Journal of Social and Personal Relationships13: 52336
49.
LinkBruce G.PhelanJo C.2001. “Conceptualizing Stigma.”Annual Review of Sociology27: 36385
50.
LinkBruce G.ElmerStreuningCullenFrancis T.ShroutPatrick E.DohrenwendBruce P.1989. “A Modified Labelling Theory Approach to Mental Disorders: An Empirical Assessment.”American Sociological Review54: 40023
51.
LitwakEugene1981. The Modified Extended Family, Social Networks, and Research Continues in Aging.New York: Columbia University Center for Social Sciences
52.
LissauIngeSorensenThorkild I.A.1994. “Parental Neglect During Childhood and Increased Risk of Obesity in Young Adulthood.”Lancet343: 32427
53.
LumengJulie C.KateGannonHowardCabralFrankDeborah A.BarryZuckerman2003. “Association Between Clinically Meaningful Behavior Problems and Overweight in Children.”Pediatrics112: 113845
54.
MargolinLeslieLynnWhite1987. “The Continuing Role of Physical Attractiveness in Marriage.”Journal of Marriage and the Family49: 2127
55.
McLaughlinJulieHorwitzAllan V.WhiteHelene Raskin2002. “The Differential Importance of Friend, Relative, and Partner Relationship for the Mental Health of Young Adults.”Social Networks and Health8: 22346
56.
McPhersonMillerLynnSmith-LovinCookJames M.2001. “Birds of a Feather: Homophily in Social Networks.” Annual Review of Sociology27: 415–44
57.
MillerCarol T.RothblumEsther D.LindaBarbourBrandPamela A.FelicioDiane M.1990. “Social Interactions of Obese and Non-Obese Women.”Journal of Personality58: 36580
58.
MillerCarol TRothblumEsther D.BrandPamela A.FelicioDiane M.1995. “Do Obese Women Have Poorer Social Relationships Than Non-Obese Women? Reports by Self, Friends and Coworkers.”Journal of Personality63: 6585
59.
MokdadAliMarySerdulaWilliamDietzBarbaraBowmanJamesMarksJeffreyKoplan1999. “The Spread of the Obesity Epidemic in the United States, 1991–1998.”Journal of the American Medical Association282: 151922
60.
National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute [NHLBI].1998. Clinical Guidelines on the Identification, Evaluation, and Treatment of Overweight and Obesity in Adults.Bethesda, MD: National Institutes of Health
61.
NevidJeffrey S.1984. “Sex Differences in Factors in Romantic Attraction.”Sex Roles11: 40111
62.
OgdenCynthia L.FlegalKatherine M.CarrollMargaret D.JohnsonClifford L.2002. “Prevalence and Trends in Overweight Among U.S. Children and Adolescents, 1999–2000.”Journal of the American Medical Association288: 172832
63.
OkunMorris A.KeithVerna M.1998. “Effects of Positive and Negative Social Exchanges With Various Sources on Depressive Symptoms in Younger and Older Adults.”Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences53B: 4–20
64.
PagelMark D.ErdlyWilliam W.JosephBecker1987. “Social Networks: We Get By With (and in Spite of) a Little Help From Our Friends.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology53: 793804
65.
PaltaMariPrineasRonald J.ReubenBermanPeterHannan1982. “Comparison of Self-Reported and Measured Height and Weight.”American Journal of Epidemiology115: 22330
66.
PuhlRebeccaBrownellKelly D.2001. “Bias, Discrimination and Obesity.”Obesity Research9: 788805
67.
PuhlRebeccaBrownellKelly D.2003. “Ways of Coping With Obesity Stigma: Review and Conceptual Analysis.”Eating Behaviors4: 5378
68.
RichardsonStephen A.1970. “Age and Sex Differences in Values Toward Physical Handicaps.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior11: 20714
69.
RickarbyGeoff A.1981. “Psychological Dynamics in Obesity.”Medical Journal of Australia3: 602605
70.
RookKaren S.1984. “The Negative Side of Social Interaction: Impact on Psychological Well-Being.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology46: 10971108
71.
RookKaren S.1998. “Investigating the Positive and Negative Sides of Personal Relationships: Through a Lens Darkly?” Pp. 369–93 in The Dark Side of Close Relationships, edited bySpitzbergBrian H.CupachWilliam R.Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum
72.
RossCatherine E.1994. “Overweight and Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior35: 6379
73.
SackettDavid LAndersonG. D.RussellMillnerManningFeinleibKannelWilliam B.1975. “Concordance for Coronary Risk Factors for Spouses.”Circulation52: 58995
74.
SchneiderJosephPeterConrad1980. “In the Closet With Illness: Epilepsy, Stigma Potential, and Information Control.”Social Problems28: 3244
75.
SnyderEric E.BrandonWaltsLouisPerusseChagnonYvon C.WeisnagelS. JohnTuomoRankinenClaudeBouchard2004. “The Human Obesity Gene Map: The 2003 Update.”Obesity Research12: 369–439
76.
SnyderMarkTankeElizabeth D.EllenBerscheid1977. “Social Perception and Interpersonal Behavior: On the Self-Fulfilling Nature of Social Stereotypes.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology35: 65666
77.
SobalJeffreyVasilikiNicolopoulosJenniferLee1995. “Attitudes About Weight and Dating Among Secondary School Students.”International Journal of Obesity Research19: 37681
78.
SobalJeffreyRauschenbachBarbara A.FrongilloEdward A.Jr.1992. “Marital Status, Fatness and Obesity.” Social Science and Medicine35: 915–23
79.
SobalJeffreyRauschenbachBarbara A.FrongilloEdward A.Jr.1995. “Obesity and Marital Quality: Analysis of Weight, Marital Unhappiness, and Marital Problems in a U.S. National Sample.”Journal of Family Issues16: 76886
80.
SobalJeffreyRauschenbachBarbara A.FrongilloEdward A.Jr2003. “Marital Status Changes and Body Weight Changes: A U.S. Longitudinal Analysis.”Social Science and Medicine56: 154355
81.
SobalJeffreyStunkardAlbert J.1989. “Socioeconomic Status and Obesity: A Review of the Literature.”Psychological Bulletin105: 26075
82.
StraussRichard S.PollackHarold A.2003. “Social Marginalization of Overweight Children.”Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine157: 746–53
83.
StuartRichard B.BarbaraJacobson1987. Weight, Sex, and Marriage: A Delicate Balance.New York: Norton
84.
StunkardAlbert J.AlbaumJanet M.1981. “The Accuracy of Self-Reported Weights.”American Journal of Clinical Nutrition34: 159399
85.
TaylorHumphrey1998. Differences in American and Japanese Attitudes to Extramarital Sex and Divorce.Rochester, NY: Louis Harris and Associates
86.
ThomasWilliam I.FlorianZnaniecki1918. The Polish Peasant in Europe and America.New York: Dover
87.
Van ItallieTheodore B.1985. “Health Implications of Overweight and Obesity in the United States.”Annals of Internal Medicine103: 98388
88.
VinokurAmiram D.RynMichelle van1993. “Social Support and Undermining in Close Relationships: Their Independent Effects on the Mental Health of Unemployed Persons.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology65: 35059
89.
WardleJaneJoWallerEmilyFox2002. “Age of Onset and Body Dissatisfaction in Obesity.”Addictive Behaviors27: 56173
90.
WeihsKarenLarryFisherMacaranBaird2002. “Families, Health, and Behavior.”Family Systems and Health20: 746
91.
WeissRobert S.1991. “The Attachment Bond in Childhood and Adulthood.” Pp. 66–76 in Attachment Across the Lifecycle, edited byParkesColin MurrayJoanStevenson-HindePeterMarrisLondon: Tavistock
92.
WellmanBarryWongRenita Y.DavidTindallNancyNazer1996. “A Decade of Network Change: Turnover, Persistence, and Stability in Personal Communities.”Social Networks19: 2750
93.
World Health Organization (WHO).1998. Obesity: Preventing and Managing the Global Epidemic: Report of WHO Consultation on Obesity.Geneva: World Health Organization
