Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Essentially, this paper argues that the understanding of organization is insepar able from the organization of understanding. This argument is developed and sustained through detailed consideration of the problematics of interpretation and of representation in organizational analysis, focusing on the understanding of significant problems within a particular arena of activity (organizational symbolism). Accordingly, from an analysis of forms of narrative in organizational symbolism, the paper articulates issues that are fundamental to both the theory and practice of organization. Through such a consideration of paradoxes of tex tuality in the inscription of order, current concerns in organizational analysis become connected to long-standing problems in Organization Studies.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adler, P.A. , and P. Adler 1987

'The past and the future of ethnography'

Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 16/1: 4-24.

Agar, M. 1986 Speaking of ethnography Beverly Hills: Sage.

Alexander, J., editor 1988 Durkheimian sociology: cultural studies Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Allaire, Y. , and M. Firsirotu 1984

'Theories of organizational culture'

Organization Studies 5/3: 193-226.

Alvesson, M. 1987 Organization theory and technocratic consciousness Berlin: de Gruyter.

Alvesson, M. , and P.O. Berg 1992 Corporate culture and organizational symbolism Berlin: de Gruyter.

Arrington, C. , and J. Francis 1989

'Deconstruction, privilege and accounting research'

Accounting, Organizations and Society 14/1-2: 1-28.

10.

Atkinson, P. 1990 The ethnographic imagination London: Routledge.

11.

Bakhtin, M. 1981 The dialogic imagination Austin : University of Texas Press.

12.

Bakhtin, M. 1984 Problems of Dostoevsky's poetics Manchester: University of Manchester Press.

13.

Barley, S. , G. Meyer , and D. Gash 1988

'Cultures of culture'

Administrative Science Quarterly 33: 24-60.

14.

Beckett, S. 1959 The Beckett trilogy London: Calder.

15.

Benson, J. 1959

'Paradigm and praxis in organizational analysis'

Research in Organizational Behaviour 5: 33-56.

16.

Berg, P.O. 1985 'Organization change as a symbolic transformation process' in Organizational culture. Frost et al. (eds.), 281-299. London : Sage.

17.

Boje, D. 1991

'The storytelling organization'

Administrative Science Quarterly 36: 106-126.

18.

Bordwell, D. 1985 Narration in the fiction film London: Methuen.

19.

Bryman, A., editor 1988 Doing research in organizations London: Routledge.

20.

Burrell, G. 1988

'Modernism, post modernism and organizational analysis 2'

Organization Studies 9/2: 221-235.

21.

Burrell, G. , and J. Hearn 1989 'The sexuality of organization' in The sexuality of organization. J. Hearn, D. Sheppard, P. Tancred-Sheriff and G. Burrell (eds.), 1-28. London: Sage.

22.

Clegg, S. 1990 Modern organizations London: Sage.

23.

Clifford, J. 1989 The predicament of culture London: Harvard University Press.

24.

Clifford, J., and G. Marcus, editors 1986 Writing culture London: University of California Press.

25.

Cockburn, C. 1985 Machinery of dominance London : Pluto Press.

26.

Cockburn, C. 1987 Two-track training London: Macmillan.

27.

Cooper, R. 1987 'The other: a model of human structuring' in Beyond method. G. Morgan (ed.), 202-218. London : Sage.

28.

Cooper, R. 1986

'Organization/disorganization'

Social Science Information 25/2: 299-335.

29.

Cooper, R. 1989

'Modernism, post modernism and organizational analysis 3'

Organization Studies 10/4: 479-502.

30.

Cooper, R. 1990

'Canctti's sting'

Notework 9/2-3: 45-53.

31.

Cooper, R. 1992 'Formal organization as representation' in Rethinking organization. M. Reed and M. Hughes (eds.), 254-272. London: Sage.

32.

Cooper, R. , and G. Burrell 1988

'Modernism, post-modernism and organizational analysis'

Organization Studies 9/1: 91-112.

33.

Culler, J. 1975 Structuralist poetics London : Routledge.

34.

Daudi, P. 1990

'Con-versing in management's public place'

Scandinavian Journal of Management 6/4: 285-307.

35.

Deal, T. , and A. Kennedy 1982 Corporate cultures Reading: Addison-Wesley.

36.

De Certeau, M. 1984 The practice of everyday life Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

37.

Deetz, S. 1985

'Critical cultural research'

Journal of Management 11/2: 121-136.

38.

Denzin, N. 1990

'Writing the interpretive postmodern ethnography'

Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 19/2: 231-236.

39.

Derrida, J. 1990

'The blindness of the beginning'. Extracted from 'Mémoires d'Aveugle'

The Guardian, 2 Nov. 1990.

40.

Devereux, G. 1979 'Fantasy and symbol as dimensions of reality' in Fantasy and symbol. R. Hook (ed.), 19-32. London : Academic Press.

41.

Drucker, P. 1989 The new realities London. Heinemann.

42.

Dyer, W. 1985 'The cycle of cultural evolution in organizations' in Gaining control of the corporate culture. R. Kilmann et al. (eds.), 200-229. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.

43.

Ebers, M. 1985

'Understanding organizations: the poetic mode'

Journal of Management 7/2: 51-62.

44.

Featherstone, M., editor 1988 Postmodernism London: Sage.

45.

Feldman, S. 1986

'Management in context'

Journal of Management Studies 23/6: 587-607.

46.

Fox, S. 1990

'Strategic human resource management : post modern conditioning for the corporate culture'

Management Education and Development 21/3: 192-206.

47.

Freire, P. 1972 The pedagogy of the oppressed Harmondsworth: Penguin.

48.

Freire, P. 1985 The politics of education Basingstoke : Macmillan.

49.

Frost, P., L. Moore, M. Louis, C. Lundberg, and J. Martin, editors 1985 Organizational culture Beverly Hills: Sage.

50.

Gagliardi, P. 1986

'The creation and change of organizational cultures'

Organization Studies 7/2: 117-134.

51.

Gagliardi, P., editor 1990 Symbols and artifacts: views of the corporate landscape Berlin: de Gruyter.

52.

Garfield, C. 1986 Peak performers: the new heroes in business London: Hutchinson.

53.

Geertz, C. 1973 The interpretation of cultures New York: Basic Books.

54.

Geertz, C. 1983 Local knowledge. New York : Basic Books.

55.

Geertz, C. 1988 Works and lives: the anthropologist as author Cambridge: Polity Press.

56.

Gergen, K. 1992 'Organizational theory in the postmodern era' in Rethinking organization. M. Reed and M. Hughes (eds.), 207-226. London: Sage.

57.

Gheradi, S. , and B. Turner 1987

'Real men don't collect soft data'

Quaderno 13 (University of Trento).

58.

Giddens, A. 1984 The constitution of society Cambridge : Polity Press.

59.

Giddens, A. 1987 'Structuralism, post-structuralism and the production of culture' in Social theory today. A. Giddens and J. Turner (eds.). 195-223. Cambridge : Polity Press.

60.

Gordon, C., editor 1980 Power/knowledge Brighton: Harvester.

61.

Gregory, K. 1983

'Native view paradigms: multiple cultures and culture conflicts in organizations'

Administrative Science Quarterly 28/3: 359-376.

62.

Gudykunst, W., L. Stewart, and S. Ting-Toomey, editors 1985 Communication, culture and organizational process. Beverly Hills: Sage.

63.

Harvey, D. 1989 The condition of postmodernity Oxford: Blackwell.

64.

Hassard, J., and M. Parker, editors 1993 Postmodernism and organizations. London: Sage.

65.

Hassard, J., and D. Pym, editors 1990 The theory and philosophy of organizations. London: Routledge.

66.

Hekman, S. 1990 'Hermeneutics and the crisis of social theory' in Anthony Giddens; consensus and controversy. J. Clark, M. Modgril and S. Modgril (eds.), 155-165. London: Falmer Press.

67.

Hickman, C. , and M. Silva 1985 Creating excellence London: Allen and Unwin.

68.

Hopwood, A. 1987

'The archaeology of accounting systems'

Accounting, Organizations and Society 13/3: 207-234.

69.

Hoskin, K. , and R. Macve 1988

'The genesis of accountability'

Accounting, Organizations and Society 13/1: 37-73.

70.

Hutcheon, L. 1989 The politics of postmodernism London: Routledge.

71.

Jackson, N. , and P. Carter

1984

'The ergonomics of desire'

Paper presented to the First International Conference on Organizational Symbolism and Corporate Culture. University of Lund, Sweden

72.

Jeffcutt, P.S. 1983a 'Thought in organizations' International Studies of Management and Organization 13/2: 35-42.

73.

Jeffcutt, P.S. 1983b 'The public identity of the organization'

Paper presented to the European Workshop on Culture and Symbolism in Organizations, University of Groningen, the Netherlands

74.

75.

Jeffcutt, P.S. 1986

'Organization discourse'

CEBES Journal 1: 34-44.

76.

Jeffcutt, P.S. 1988

'Verbal imagery and organization'

Dragon (The Journal of the Standing Conference on Organizational Symbolism) 2/3: 77-91.

77.

Jeffcutt, P.S. 1989 'Persistence and change in an organization culture'. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Manchester.

78.

Jeffcutt, P.S. 1990a 'Transitions in a transient organization' in Uneasy transitions. J. Corbett (ed.), 147-169. Basingstoke : Falmer Press.

79.

Jeffcutt, P.S. 1990b 'The structures of transition and the transition of structures in organizational settings'

Paper presented to the Seventh International Conference on Organizational Symbolism and Corporate Culture, University of Saarland, West Germany

80.

81.

Jeffcutt, P.S. 1993a 'From interpretation to representation' in Postmodernism and organizations. J. Hassard and M. Parker (eds.), 25-48.

82.

Jeffcutt, P.S. 1993b 'The interpretation of organization; a contemporary analysis and critique' Journal of Management Studies 30/2: 225-250.

83.

Jeffcutt, P.S. 1994 The management of transition: culture and complex organisation in modern society London: Sage.

84.

Jones, M., M. Moore, and R. Snyder, editors 1988 Inside organizations Beverly Hills: Sage.

85.

Kanter, R. 1983 The change masters London: Allen and Unwin.

86.

Kaplan, D. , and C. Ziegler 1985

'Clans, hierarchies and social control'

Human Organization 44/1: 83-88.

87.

Kilmann, R. et al., editors 1985 Gaining control of the corporate culture San Francisco

Jossey Bass.

88.

Knights, D. , and G. Morgan 1991

'Corporate strategy, organizations, and subjectivity: a critique'

Organization Studies 12/2: 251-273.

89.

Kunda, G. 1986

'Ideology as a system of meaning'

International Studies of Management and Organization 16/1: 54-79.

90.

Lash, S. 1990 Sociology of postmodernism London : Routledge.

91.

Letiche, H. 1990

'Five post-modern aphorisms for trainers

Management Education and Development 21/3: 207-218.

92.

93.

Linstead, S. 1993 'Deconstruction in the study of organizations' in Postmodernism and organizations. J. Hassard and M. Parker (eds.), 49-70. London: Sage.

94.

Linstead, S. , and R. Grafton-Small 1989 'Organizational bricolage' in Organizational symbolism. B. Turner (ed.), 291-309. Berlin : de Gruyter.

95.

Linstead, S. , and R. Grafton-Small 1990 a'Theory as artifact: artifact as theory' in Symbols and artifacts: views of the corporate . P. Gagliardi (ed.), 387-419. Berlin: de Gruyter.

96.

Linstead, S. , and R. Grafton-Small 1990b 'Corporate culture; the reading and the text'

Paper presented to the British Academy of Management Annual Conference, University of Glasgow, Scotland

97.

Linstead, S. and Grafton-Small, R. 1992

'On reading organizational culture'

Organization Studies 13/3: 331-356.

98.

Lodge, D. 1990 After Bakhtin: essays on fiction and criticism London: Routledge.

99.

Lundberg, C. 1985 'On the feasibility of cultural intervention in organizations' in Organizational culture. P. Frost, L. Moore, M. Louis, C. Lundberg and J. Martin (eds.), 169-185. Beverly Hills: Sage.

100.

Marcus, G. , and M. Fischer 1986 Anthropology as cultural critique London: University of Chicago Press.

101.

Martin, J. , and C. Siehl 1983

'Organizational culture and counter culture'

Organizational Dynamics 12/2: 52-64.

102.

Meek, V. 1988

'Organizational culture: origins and weaknesses'

Organization Studies 9/4: 453-473.

103.

Meyerson, D. , and J. Martin 1987

'Cultural change'

Journal of Management Studies 24/6: 623-647.

104.

Miller, P. , and T. O'Leary 1987 'Accounting and the construction of the governable person'. Accounting, Organizations and Society 12/3: 235-265.

105.

Mitroff, I. , and R. Kilmann 1985 'Corporate taboos as the key to unlocking culture' in Gaining control of the corporate culture. R. Kilmann et al. (eds.), 184-199. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.

106.

Morgan, G. 1986 Images of organization London : Sage.

107.

Morgan, G. 1988 Riding the waves of change San Francisco: Jossey Bass.

108.

Morgan, G. , P. Frost , and L. Pondy 1983 'Organizational symbolism' in Organizational symbolism. L. Pondy et al. (eds.), 3-38. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.

109.

Ouchi, W. , and A. Jaeger 1978

'Type Z organization: stability in the midst of mobility'

Academy of Management Review 3: 293-317.

110.

Ouchi, W. , and A. Wilkins 1985

'Organizational culture'

Annual Review of Sociology 11: 457-483.

111.

Parker, M. 1992

'Post-modern organizations or postmodern organization theory?'

Organization Studies 13/1: 1-17.

112.

Peters, T. 1987 Thriving on chaos London: Macmillan.

113.

Peters, T. , and R. Waterman 1982 In search of excellence New York : Harper and Row.

114.

Pettigrew, A. 1979

'On studying organizational cultures'

Administrative Science Quarterly 24/4: 570-581.

115.

Pheby, K. 1988 Interventions: displacing the metaphysical subject Washington : Maisonneuvc Press.

116.

Pondy, L., P. Frost, G. Morgan, and T. Dandridge, editors 1983 Organizational symbolism. Greenwich : JAI Press.

117.

Power, M. 1990 'Modernism, post modernism and organization' in The theory and philosophy of organizations. J. Hassard and D. Pym (eds.), 109-124. London: Routledge.

118.

Quinn, R., and K. Cameron, editors 1988 Paradox as transformation: toward a theory of change in organization and management Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.

119.

Rabinow, P. 1986a 'Representations are social facts: modernity and postmodernity in anthropology' in Writing culture. J. Clifford and G. Marcus (eds.), 234-261. London: University of California Press.

120.

Rabinow, P., editor 1986 bThe Foucault reader London: Penguin.

121.

Ray, C. 1986

'Corporate culture: the last frontier of control'

Journal of Management Studies 23/3: 287-297.

122.

123.

Reed, M., and M. Hughes, editors 1992 Rethinking organization London: Sage.

124.

Rosaldo, R. 1989 Culture and truth Boston: Beacon Press.

125.

Rosen, M. 1986

'Some notes from the field'

Dragon 1/6: 57-77.

126.

Rosen, M. 1988

'You asked for it: Christmas at the bosses expense'

Journal of Management Studies 25/5: 463-481.

127.

Rusted, B. 1990 'Housing modifications as organizational communication' in Symbols and artifacts: views of the corporate landscape . P. Gagliardi (ed.), 85-105. Berlin: de Gruyter.

128.

Sahlins, M. 1985 Islands of history Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

129.

Said, E. 1978 Orientalism London: Routledge.

130.

Sandelands, L. , and R. Drazin 1989

'On the language of organization theory'

Organization Studies 10/4: 457-477.

131.

Schein, E. 1985 'How culture forms, develops and changes in Gaining control of the corporate culture. R. Kilmann et al. (eds.), 17-43. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.

132.

Schneider, M. 1987

'Culture as text in the work of Clifford Geertz'

Theory and Society 16: 809-839.

133.

Schneider, S. , and P. Shrivastava

1984

'The content of basic assumptions'. Paper presented to the First International Conference on Organizational Symbolism and Corporate Culture, University of Lund, Sweden

134.

Schwartz, H. 1990 'The symbol of the space shuttle and the degeneration of the American dream' in Symbols and artifacts: views of the corporate landscape. P. Gagliardi (ed.), 303-322. Berlin : de Gruyter.

135.

Seabrook, J. 1990 The myth of the market: promises and illusions Hartland: Green Books.

136.

Sievers, B. 1987 'Work, death and life itself Working Paper No. 8, Bergische University.

137.

Silverman, D. 1985 Qualitative methodology and sociology London: Gower.

138.

139.

Slatter, S. 1984 Corporate recovery Harmondsworth : Penguin.

140.

Smircich, L. 1983

'Concepts of culture and organizational analysis'

Administrative Science Quarterly 28/3: 339-358.

141.

Smircich, L. 1985 'Is the concept of culture a paradigm for understanding organizations and ourselves' in Organizational culture. P. Frost, L. Moore, M. Louis, C. Lindberg and J. Martin (eds.), 55-72. Beverly Hills: Sage.

142.

Smircich, L. , and M. Calás 1987 'Organizational culture: a critical assessment' in Organizational communication. F. Jablin, L. Patnam, K. Roberts and L. Porter (eds.), 228-263. London: Sage.

143.

Smith, K. , and V. Simmons 1983

'A Rumplestiltskin organization: metaphors on metaphors in field research'

Administrative Science Quarterly 28/3: 377-392.

144.

Spencer, J. 1989

'Anthropology as a kind of writing'

MAN 24/1: 145-164.

145.

Stoller, P. , and C. Olkes 1987 In sorcery's shadow Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

146.

Sutton, R. 1987

'The process of organizational death'

Administrative Science Quarterly 32: 542-569.

147.

Sypher, B. , J. Applegate , and H. Sypher 1985 'Culture and communication in organizational contexts' in Communicational, culture and organizational process. W. Dugykunst, L. Stewart and S. Ting-Toomey (eds.), 13-29. Beverly Hills: Sage.

148.

Thomas, A. 199?

'One-minute management education'

Management Education and development 20/1: 23-38.

149.

Thompson, J. 1983 Learning liberation Beckenham : Croom Helm.

150.

Thompson, J. 1988 'Adult education and the women's movement' in Radical approaches to adult education. T. Lovett (ed.), 181-201. London: Routledge.

151.

152.

Travers, A. 1989 'Symbolic life and organization research in a postmodern frame' in Organizational symbolism. B. Turner (ed.), 271-289. Berlin: de Gruyter.

153.

Trice, H. 1985

'Rites and ceremonials in organizational cultures'

Research in the Sociology of Organizations 4: 221-270.

154.

Turner, B. 1978 Man-made disasters London: Wykeham Press.

155.

Turner, B. 1986

'Sociological aspects of organizational symbolism'

Organization Studies 7/2: 101-115.

156.

Turner, B. 1988 'Connoisseurship in the study of organizational cultures' in Doing research in organizations. A. Bryman (ed.), 108-122. London: Routledge.

157.

Turner, B., editor 1989 Organizational symbolism Berlin: de Gruyter.

158.

Turner, B. 1990 'The rise of organizational symbolism' in The theory and philosophy of organizations. J. Hassard and D. Pym (eds.), 83-96. London: Routledge.

159.

Turner, E., editor 1986 On the edge of the bush: anthropology as experience Tucson: University of Arizona Press.

160.

Turner, V. 1974 Dramas, fields and metaphors Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

161.

Turner, V. 1986 Anthropology of performance New York: Performing Arts Journal Publications.

162.

Tyler, S. 1986 'Post modem ethnography' in Writing culture. J. Clifford and G. Marcus (eds.), 122-140. London: University of California Press.

163.

Van de Ven, A. , and M. Poole 1988 'Paradoxical requirements for a theory of change' in Paradox as transformation: toward a theory of change in organization and management. R. Quinn and K. Cameron (eds.), 19-64. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.

164.

Van Maanen, J., editor 1983 Qualitative methodology Beverly Hills: Sage.

165.

Van Maanen, J. , and D. Kolb 1985

'The professional apprentice'

Research in the Sociology of Organizations 4: 1-33.

166.

Van Maanen, J. 1988 Tales of the field Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

167.

Wakefield, N. 1990 Postmodernism. London : Pluto Press.

168.

Walter, G. 1983 'Psyche and symbol' in Organizational symbolism. L. Pondy, P. Frost, G. Morgan and T. Dandridgc (eds.), 257-272. Greenwich : JAI Press.

169.

Weber, S. 1990

'The vaulted eye; remarks on knowledge and professionalism'

Yale French Studies 77: 44-60.

170.

Weick, K. 1985 'The significance of corporate culture' in Organizational culture. P. Frost, L. Moore, M. Louis, C. Lundberg and J. Martin (eds.), 381-389. Beverly Hills: Sage.

171.

White, H. 1987 The content of the form Baltimore : Johns Hopkins University Press.

172.

Wilkins, A. , and W. Ouchi 1983

'Efficient cultures'

Administrative Science Quarterly 28/3: 468-481.

173.

Willis, P. 1977 Learning to labour Farnborough : Saxon House.

174.

Willis, P. 1978 Profane culture London: Routledge.

175.

Willis, P. 1990 Common culture Milton Keynes : Open University Press.

176.

Willmott, H. 1990 'Beyond paradigmatic closure in organizational enquiry' in The theory and philosophy of organizations. J. Hassard and D. Pym (eds.), 44-62. London: Routledge.

177.

178.

Worton, M. and J. Still, editors 1990 Intertextuality Manchester: Manchester University Press.

179.

Wright, P. 1987

'Excellence'

London Review of Books, 21 May 1990, pp. 8-11.

180.

Wuthnow, R. 1987

Meaning and moral order — explorations in cultural analysis

Berkeley: University of California Press.

181.

Young, E. 1989

'Interests and multiple meanings as elements of organizational culture'

Organization Studies 10/2: 187-206.

From Interpretation to Representation in Organizational Analysis: Postmodernism,Ethnography and Organizational Symbolism

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References