This paper replicates Glisson and Martin's (1980) study of social welfare organizations (SWOs) in St. Louis, Missouri (U.S.A.), with data from two samples of Pacific Island cultures, Guam and Oahu, Hawaii. We test the culture-free vs. culture-specific arguments about the effects of societal culture on internal structure. Our structural dimensions are formalization and centralization. They are measured as perceptions (regime) of social service workers rather than form that is officially prescribed. As expected, Guam and Oahu SWOs are smaller and younger than those in St. Louis. Guam SWOs are the most formalized and centralized; Oahu SWOs do not differ structurally from those in St. Louis. Multivariate regression results show that culture/locale significantly predicts formalization (Guam SWOs are the most formal ized) and both culture/locale and size predict centralization. Significant interaction effects were discovered, prompting rejection of the culture-free argument: larger size leads to more formalization in Oahu and St. Louis but to less in Guam; higher average worker tenure leads to more centralization in St. Louis but to less in Oahu. Alternative interpretations and implications of the results are considered.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aiken M., and S.P. Bacharach1979'Culture and organizational structure and process: A comparative study of local government administrative bureaucracies in the Walloon and Flemish regions of Belgium' in Organizations alike and unlike. international and institutional studies in the sociology of organization. C. J. Lammers and D. J. Hickson (eds.), 215-250. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
2.
Aiken, M., and S.P. Bacharach1985'Environmental influences on authority and consensus in organizations' in Research in the sociology of organizations, Vol. 4. S. B. Bacharach and S. M. Mitchell (eds.), 351-377. Greenwich, Conn.: JAI Press.
3.
Anderson, W.A., and P.Y. Martin1982 'Bureaucracy and professionalism in the social services: A multi-dimensional approach to the analysis of conflict and congruity'. Journal of Social Service Research 5/3-4: 33-50.
4.
Austin, D., and Y. Hasenfeld1985 'A prefatory essay on the future administration of human services'. Journal of Applied Behavioural Science21: 351-364.
5.
Azumi. K., and F. Hull1981 'Comparative organizations'. International Journal of Comparative Sociology22: 197-212.
6.
Bell, D.1973The coming of post-industrial societyHarmondsworth: Penguin.
7.
Bellah, R.N., R. Madsen, W.M. Sullivan, A.Swidler, and S.M. Tipton1985Habits of the heart. New York: Harper and Row.
8.
Blau, P.M.1970 'A formal theory of differentiation in organizations'. American Sociological Review35: 201-218.
9.
Blau, P.M., and R. Schoenherr1971The structure of organizationsNew York : Basic Books.
10.
Brown, W.1966 'Japanese management: the cultural background'. Monumenta Nipponica21: 47-60.
11.
Buffum, W.E., and R.A. Ritvo1984 'Work autonomy and the community mental health professional' . Administration in social work8: 39-54.
12.
Bureau of the Census1982Statistical abstracts of the United States 1982. U.S. Department of Commerce. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
13.
Bureau of Planning1982A guide for the development of Guam's social welfare policies and services. Guam: The Government of Guam.
14.
Cameron, K.S.1986a 'Effectiveness as paradox: consensus and conflict in conceptions of organizational effectiveness'. Management Science32: 539-553.
15.
Cameron, K.S.1986b 'A study of organizational effectiveness and its predictors' . Management Science32: 86-112.
16.
Child, J., and A. Kieser1979'Organization and managerial roles in British and West German companies: an examination of the culture-free thesis' in Organizations alike and unlike. C. J. Lammers and D. J Hickson (eds.), 251-271. London : Routledge.
17.
Clark, P.1979'Cultural context as a determinant of organizational rationality: A comparison of the tobacco industries in Britain and France' in Organizations alike and unlike. C. J. Lammers and D. J. Hickson (eds.), 272-286. London : Routledge.
18.
Cohen, M.D., J.G. March, and J.P. Olsen1972 'A garbage can model of organizational choice'. Administrative Science Quarterly17: 1-25.
19.
Colignon, R.1987 'Organizational permeability in U.S. social service agencies '. Organization Studies8: 169-186.
20.
Coyle, E.M.1970Saint Louis: portrait of a river city. St. Louis: Folkestone.
21.
Donaldson, L.1986'Size and bureaucracy in East and West: a preliminary meta analysis' in The enterprise and management in East Asia. S. R. Clegg, D. C. Dunphy , and S. G. Redding(eds.), 67-91. University of Hong Kong: Centre of Asian Studies.
22.
Dore, R.1973British factory, Japanese factory: the origins of diversity in industrial relations. Los Angeles: University of California Press.
23.
Dressel, P.1987 'Patriarchy and social welfare work'. Social Problems34: 294-309.
24.
Frumkin, M., P.Y. Martin, and W.P. Page1987 'The future of large public human service organizations '. New England Journal of Human Services7: 15-23.
25.
Geertz, C.1973The interpretation of culturesNew York : Basic Books.
26.
Glisson, C.A.1978 'Dependence of technological routinization on structural variables in human service organizations'. Administrative Science Quarterly23: 383-395.
27.
Glisson. C.A. 1979 'In defense of determinism'. OMEGA, The International Journal of Management Science7: 181-182.
28.
Glisson, C.A., and M. Durick1988 'Predictors of job satisfaction and organizational commitment in human service organizations'. Administrative Science Quarterly33: 61-81.
29.
Glisson, C.A., and P.Y. Martin1980 'Productivity and efficiency of human service organizations in relation to structure, size, and age'. Academy of Management Journal23: 21-37.
30.
Goldner, F.H.1982Review of: M. Lipsky, Street-level bureaucracy (New York : Russell Sage
Goodenough, W.H.1981Culture, language, and societyMenlo Park, Cal.: Benjamin Cummings.
33.
Grandjean, B.D., L.H. Aiken, and C.M. Bonjean1976 'Professional autonomy and the work satisfaction of nursing educators'. Nursing Research25: 216-221.
34.
Grandjean, B.D., C.M. Bonjean, and L.H. Aiken1982 'The effect of centralized decision-making on work satisfaction among nursing educators'. Research in Nursing Health5: 29-36.
35.
Gummer, B.1984'The social administrator as politician' in Human services at risk, F. D. Perlmutter (ed.), 23-36. Lexington, Mass: Lexington Books.
36.
Hage, J., and M. Aiken1967'Relationship of centralization to other structural properties' . Administrative Science Quarterly12: 73-92.
37.
Hall, R.H.1963 'The concept of bureaucracy: an empirical assessment'. American Journal of Sociology69: 32-40.
38.
Hall, R.H., N.J. Johnson, and J.E. Haas1967 'Organizational size, complexity, and formalization'. American Sociological Review32: 903-912.
39.
Harrison, D.1987 'Reflective practice in social care'. Social Service Review61: 393-404.
40.
Hasenfeld, Y.1983Human service organizationsEnglewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
41.
Heydebrand, W.1973Hospital bureaucracy: a comparative study of organizationsNew York: Dunellen.
42.
Hickson, D.J., C. R. Hinings, C.J. McMillan, and J.P. Schwitter1974 'The culture-free context of organizational structure: a tri-national comparison'. Sociology8: 59-80.
43.
Hickson, D. J. and C. J. McMillan, editors 1981Organization and nation: The Aston Programme IV. Farnborough: Gower.
44.
Hickson, D.J., R.J. Butler, D. Cray, G.R. Mallory, and D.C. Wilson1986Top decisions: strategic decision-making in organizations . Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
45.
Hinings, C.R.1979'Continuities in the study of organizations: churches and local governments' in Organizations alike and unlike. C. J. Lammers and D. J. Hickson (eds.), 137-148. London: Routledge.
46.
Hsu, C.K., R.M. Marsh, and H. Mannari1983 'An examination of the determinants of organizational structure '. American Journal of Sociology88: 975-996.
47.
Imershein, A., L. Polivka, S. Gordon-Girvin, R. Chackerian, and P.Y. Martin1986'Service networks in Florida: administrative decentralization and its effects on service delivery'. Public Administration Review46: 161-169.
48.
Jacobs, J.1969 'Symbolic bureaucracy: A case study of a social welfare agency'. Social Forces47: 413-422.
49.
Kamerman, S.1983 'The new mixed economy of welfare: public and private' . Social Work28: 5-9.
50.
Katz, R.1982 'The effects of group longevity on project communication and performance'. Administrative Science Quarterly27: 81-104.
51.
Katz, D., and R.L. Kahn1978The social psychology of organizationsNew York: Wiley.
52.
dc Kervasdoue, J., and J.R. Kimberly1979'Are organization structures culture-free ? The case of hospital innovation in the US and France' in Organizational functioning in cross-cultural perspective, G. England, A. Neghandi, and B. Wilpert (eds.), 191-109. Kent, Ohio: Kent State University Press.
53.
Kimberly, J.R.1975 'Environmental constraints and organizational structure: a comparative analysis of rehabilitation organizations'. Administrative Science Quarterly20: 1-9.
54.
Kuc, B., D.J. Hickson, and C. McMillan1980'Centrally planned development: a comparison of Polish factories with equivalents in Britain, Japan, and Sweden'. Organization Studies3: 253-270.
55.
LaMendola, W., and P.Y. Martin1983 'The service orientation of social service administrators: towards a normative model'. Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare10: 40-55.
56.
Lammers, C.J., and D.J. Hickson1979'Are organizations culture-bound?' in Organizations alike and unlike. C. J. Lammers and D J. Hickson (eds. ), 402-419. London: Routledge.
57.
Lincoln, J.R., M. Hanada, and J. Olson1981 'Cultural orientations and individual reactions to organizations: a study of employees of Japanese-owned firms'. Administrative Science Quarterly26: 93-115.
58.
Lincoln, J.R., and A.L. Kalleberg1986 'Work organization and workforce commitment: A study of plants and employees in the US and Japan'. American Sociological Review50: 738-760.
59.
Lincoln, J.R., J. Olson, and M. Hanada1978 'Cultural effects on organizational structure'. American Sociological Review43: 829-847.
60.
Lind, A.W.1980Hawaii's people. Honolulu: The University Press of Hawaii.
61.
Lipsky, M.1980Street-level bureaucracy: dilemmas of the individual in public servicesNew York: Russell Sage.
62.
Mannheim. B.F., and N. Moskovitz1979'Contextual variables and bureaucratic types of Israeli service organizations' in Organizations alike and unlike, C. J. Lammers and D. J. Hickson (eds.), 149-167. London: Routledge .
63.
March, J.G., and H. Simon1958OrganizationsNew York: Wiley.
64.
Marsh, R.M., and H. Mannari1980'Technological implications theory: a Japanese test'. Organization Studies1/2: 161-183.
65.
Martin, P.Y., and B. Segal1977 'Bureaucracy, size, and staff expectations for client behavior in halfway houses'. Journal of Health and Social Behavior18: 376-390.
66.
Martin, P.Y.1979 'Size in residential service organizations: a multidimensional analysis'. The Sociological Quarterly20: 565-579.
67.
Martin, P.Y.1980a 'Multiple constituencies, dominant societal values, and the human services administrator: implications for service delivery'. Administration in Social Work.4: 14-17.
68.
Martin, P.Y.1980b 'Multiple constituencies, differential power, and the question of effectiveness in human service organizations'. Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare6: 801-816.
69.
Martin, P.Y.1981 'Organizational time in alcoholism halfway houses: Implications for stability and survival'. Journal of Drug Issues22: 93-106.
70.
Martin, P.Y.1984'Trade unions, conflict, and the nature of work in residential service organizations'. Organization Studies5/2: 169-185.
71.
Martin, P.Y.1987 'Multiple constituencies and organizational performance: action strategies for administrators'. Administration in Social Work11: 223-239.
72.
Martin, P.Y., and W.A. Anderson1979 'The conceptualization and measurement of organizational size in residential treatment settings'. Journal of Social Service Research2: 177-198.
73.
Martin, P.Y., R. Chackerian, A. Imershein, and M. Frumkin1983 'The concept of integrated services reconsidered'. Social Science Quarterly64: 747-763.
74.
Martin, P.Y., and G.G. O'Connor1988The social environment: open systems applicationsNew York: Longman.
75.
Martin, P.Y., and B. Whiddon1988 'Conceptualization and measurement of staff performance' . Public Productivity Review11: 15-26.
76.
Maurice, M., A. Sorge. and M. Warner1980'Societal differences in organizing manufacturing units: A comparison of France, West Germany, and Great Britain'. Organization Studies1/1: 59-86.
77.
McDermott, J.F., W.S. Tseng, and W.T. Maretzki1980People and cultures of Hawaii. Honolulu : University of Hawaii Press.
78.
Meyer, J.W.1983a 'Organizational factors affecting legalization in education' in Organizational environments: ritual and rationality. J. W. Meyer and W. R. Scott (eds.), 199-216. Beverly Hills, Cal.: Sage.
79.
Meyer, J.W.1983b 'Conclusion: institutionalization and the rationality of formal organizational structure' in Organizational environments, J. W. Meyer and W. R. Scott (eds. ), 261-282. Beverly Hills, Cal.: Sage.
80.
Meyer, J.W., and B. Rowan1977 'Institutionalized organizations: formal structure as myth and ceremony'. American Journal of Sociology83: 440-463.
81.
Meyer, J.W., W.R. Scott, and T.E. Deal1981'Institutional and technical sources of organizational structure: explaining the structure of educational organizations' in Organization and the human services: cross-disciplinary reflections. H. D. Stein (ed.), 151-179. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
82.
Mileti, D.S., D.F. Gillespie, and J.E. Haas1977 'Size and structure in complex organizations'. Social Problems56: 208-217.
83.
Nakane, C.1970Japanese societyBerkeley: University of California Press.
84.
Olmstead, J., and H.E. Christensen1973Effects of agency work contexts: an intensive field study, Vols. 1 and 2 (Research Report No. 2). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
85.
Palafax, N., and A. Warren1980Cross-cultural caring: a handbook for health care. Honolulu: Transcultural Health Care Forum, John A. Burns School of Medicine, University of Hawaii.
86.
Pennings, J.1973 'Measures of organizational structure: a methodological note'. American Journal of Sociology79: 686-704.
87.
Peters, T.J., and R.H. Waterman1982In search of excellenceNew York: Harper and Row
88.
Price, J.L., and C.W. Mueller1986Handbook of organizational measurementMarshfield, Mass.: Pitman.
Pugh, D.S. D. J. Hickson, C.R. Hinings, and C. Turner1969 'The context of organization structures'. Administrative Science Quarterly14: 91-114.
91.
Rowan, B.1982 'Organization structure and institutional environments: the case of public schools'. Administrative Science Quarterly27: 259-279.
92.
Scott, W.R.1983'The organization of environments: network, cultural, and historical elements' in Organizational environments. J. W. Meyer and W. R. Scott (eds.). Beverly Hills, Cal.: Sage.
93.
Smircich, L.1983 'Concepts of culture and organizational analysis'. Administrative Science Quarterly38: 339-358.
94.
Stinchcombe, A.L.1965'Social structure and organizations' in Handbook of Organizations , J. G. March (ed.), 142-193. Chicago : Rand. McNally.
95.
Tracy, P., and K. Azumi1976 'Determinants of administrative control: a test of a theory with Japanese factories'. American Sociological Review41: 80-93.
96.
Turner, B.A.1986'Sociological aspects of organizational symbolism'. Organization Studies7/1: 101-115.
97.
Whiddon, B., and P.Y. Martin1989'Organizational democracy and work quality in a state welfare agency'. Social Science Quarterly. Forthcoming.
98.
Whitman, A. 1979 St. Louis. New York: Doubleday.
99.
Wittermans, E.1980-1981 'Inter-ethnic relations in Hawaii'. Social Process in Hawaii28: 148-156.
100.
Zald, M.1978 'The social control of industry'. Social Forces59: 79-102.
101.
Zucker, L.G.1983'Organizations as institutions' in Research in the sociology of organizations, Vol. 2. S. P. Bacharach (ed.), 1-47. Greenwich, Conn.: JAI Press.
