Drawing on previous research on patterns of organization structures, this paper examines the question of strategic structural choice between centralized and formalized means of control. An alternative approach in conceiving and operationalizing the problem of choice is suggested. This uses the 'Indifference Curves' postulate as put forward in neo-classical economic theory. An operational model featuring 'trade-offs' between centralized and formalized control is proposed.
The conclusions are that the framework based on the notion of 'indifference' provides reasonable theoretical strength in portraying and explaining trade-offs in structural choices. Theoretically infinite trade-offs in choices between means of control find limits in the purposive search for equilibrium (optimum choice), for example in matching the amount/type of structuring with constraints such as size.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Agarwal, C.N.1979'Nature of size-structure relationship: some further evidence' . Human Relations32/6: 441-450.
2.
Aldrich, H.E.1975 'Reaction to Donaldson's note'. Administrative Science Quarterly20: 457-459.
3.
Argyris, C.1973'Some limits of rational man organizations theory'. Public Administration Review (May/June): 253-267.
4.
Astley, W.G., and A.H. Van de Ven1983 'Central perspectives and debates in organization theory'. Administrative Science Quarterly28: 245-273.
5.
Ayoubi, Z.N.1981'Technology, size and organizational structure in a developing country: Jordan' in Organization and nation, (The Aston Programme IV). D. J. Hickson and C. J. McMillan (eds.), 155-172. Aldershot: Gower .
6.
Azumi, K., and C.J. McMillan1981'Management strategy and organization structure: a Japanese comparative study' in Organization and nation, (The Aston Programme IV). D. J. Hickson and C. J. McMillan (eds.), 115-131. Aldershot: Gower .
7.
Badran, N., and C.R. Hinings1981'Strategies of administrative control and contextual constraints in a less developed country: the case of Egyptian public enterprise' in Organization and nation, (The Aston Programme IV). D. J. Hickson and C. J. McMillan (eds.), 115-131. Aldershot : Gower.
8.
Baumol, W.J., and A.S. Blinder1979Economic principles and policyOrlando, FL: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
9.
Birnbaum, P.H., and G.Y.Y. Wong1985'Organizational structure of multinational banks in Hong Kong from a culture free perspective'. Administrative Science Quarterly30: 262-277.
10.
Blau, P.M., C., McHugh, W. Falbe, and K.T. Phelps1976 'Technology and organization in manufacturing'. Administrative Science Quarterly21: 20-40.
11.
Blau, P.M., and R.A. Schoenherr1971The structure of organizationsNew York: Basic Books.
12.
Burns, T., and G.M. Stalker1961The management of innovationLondon : Tavistock.
13.
Carter, N.M., and J.B. Cullen1984'A comparison of centralization/decentralization of decision-making concepts and measures'. Journal of Management10/2: 259-268.
14.
Child, J.1972a 'Organization structure and strategies of control: a replication of the Aston Study'. Administrative Science Quarterly17/2: 163-177.
15.
Child, J.1972b 'Organization structure, environment and performance: the role of strategic choice'. Sociology3/4: 351-353.
16.
Child, J.1982'Discussion note, divisionalization and size: a comment on the Donaldson/ Grinyer debate'. Organization Studies3/4: 351-353.
17.
Child, J.1984Organization: a guide to problems and practice, 4th Ed. London: Harper and Row.
18.
Child, J., and R. Mansfield1972 'Technology size and organization structure'. Sociology6: 369-393.
19.
Clegg, S.1981 'Organization and control'. Administrative Science Quarterly26: 545-562.
20.
Dewar, R.D., and J. Hage1978 'Size, technology, complexity and structural differentiation: toward a theoretical synthesis'. Administrative Science Quarterly23: 111-136.
21.
Donaldson, L., J. Child, and H. Aldrich1975 'The Aston findings on centralization: further discussions' . Administrative Science Quarterly20: 453-459.
22.
Donaldson, L.1982'Comments on contingency and choice in organization theory'. Georg Schreyogg, O.S. 1/4, Organization Studies2/4: 305-326.
23.
Donaldson, L.1985In defence of organization theory: a reply to the criticsLondon: Cambridge University Press .
24.
Donaldson, L.1986a 'Research note: the interaction of size and diversification as a determinant of divisionalisation—Grinyer revisited'. Organization Studies7/4: 368-379.
25.
Donaldson, L.1986b 'Size and bureaucracy in East and West: a preliminary meta analysis' in The enterprise and management in East AsiaS. R. Clegg, D. Dunphy, and S. G. Redding (eds), 67-91. Hongkong : University of Hong Kong.
26.
Donaldson, L.1987'Strategy and structural adjustment to regain fit and performance: in defence of contingency theory'. Journal of Management Studies24/1: 1-24.
27.
Drazin, R., and A.H. Van de Ven1985 'Alternative forms of fit in contingency theory'. Administrative Science Quarterly30: 514-539.
28.
Gerth, H.H., and W. Mills1961Max Weber: essays in sociology, 4th ed. London: Routledge and Kegan .
29.
Granick, D.1979'Managerial incentive systems and organizational theory', in Organizations alike and unlike. C. J. Lammers and D. J. Hickson (eds.), 76-96. London : Routledge and Kegan.
30.
Greenwood, R., and C.R. Hinings1976 'Centralization revisited: further discussion'. Administrative Science Quarterly21: 151-155.
31.
Grinyer, P., S. Al Bazzaz, and Y. Ardekani1980'Strategy, structure, the environment, and financial performance in forty-eight United Kingdom companies'. Academy of Management Journal23/ 2: 193-220.
32.
Grinyer, P.H.1982'Discussion note: divisionalization and size: a rejoinder' . Organization Studies4/4: 339-350.
33.
Hage, J.1965 'An axiomatic theory of organizations'. Administrative Science Quarterly10: 289-320.
34.
Hickson, D. J., and C. J. McMillan (cds.) 1981Organization and nation (The Aston Programme IV). Aldershot: Gower.
35.
Hinings. C.R., and G. Lee1971 'Dimensions of organization structure and context: a replication '. Sociology5: 83-93.
36.
Hofstede, G.1980Culture's consequences: international differences in work-related valuesLondon: Sage.
Lawrence, P.R., and J.W. Lorsch1967Organization and environmentBoston : Harvard University Press.
39.
Lindenberg, S.1987'A sociological extension of the economic theory of organization '. Paper presented at the 8th EGOS Conference, U.I.A., Antwerp, Belgium (July).
40.
Mansfield, E. (ed.) 1979Microeconomics, Selected Readings. New York: Norton .
41.
Mansfield, R.1973 'Bureaucracy and centralization: an examination of organizational structure'. Administrative Science Quarterly18: 477-488.
42.
March, J.G., and H.A. Simon1958OrganizationsNew York: Wiley.
43.
Meyer, W.M.1968'The two authority structures of bureaucratic organization' . Administrative Science Quarterly13/2: 211-227.
44.
Miles, R.E., C. C. Snow, A.D. Meyer, and H.J. Coleman Jr.1978 'Organization strategy, structure and process'. Academy of Management Review3: 546-562.
45.
Miller, D., and P.H. Friesen1984Organizations: a quantum viewEnglewood Cliffs. NJ: Prentice-Hall.
46.
Miller, D., and C. Droge1986 'Psychological and traditional determinants of structure' . Administrative Science Quarterly31: 539-560.
47.
Miller, D.1987'Strategy making and structure: analysis and implications for performance'. Academy of Management Journal30/ 1: 7-32.
48.
Miller, G.A.1987'Meta-analysis and the culture-free hypothesis'. Organization Studies8/4: 309-325.
49.
Mintzberg, H.1983Structure in fives: designing effective organizationsEnglewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
50.
Montanari, J.R., and C.P. Morgan1983'The impact of technology and functional unit on centralization in organizations'. Human Relations36/8: 105-716.
51.
Negandhi, A., and C. Reimann1973'Correlates of decentralization: closed and open system perspective'. Academy of Management Journal16/ 4: 105-116.
52.
Pennings, J.M.1987'Structural contingency theory: a multivariate test'. Organization Studies8/1: 223-240.
53.
Pugh, D.S., D. J. Hickson, C.R. Hinings, and C. Turner1968 'Dimensions of organizational structure'. Administrative Science Quarterly13: 65-105.
54.
Pugh, D.S., D.J. Hickson, and C.R. Hinings1969'An empirical taxonomy of organizations'. Administrative Science Quarterly143/1: 115-125.
55.
Pugh, D. S., and D. J. Hickson , edutors 1976Organizational structure in its contextHants: Saxon House.
56.
Pugh, D. S., and D. J. Hickson , editors 1976Organizational structure: extensions and replicationsHants: Saxon House .
57.
Pugh, D.S.1981'The Aston Program perspective: The Aston program of research: retrospect and prospect' in Perspectives on organization design and behaviour. A. H. Van de and W. Joyce (eds.), 135-165. New York: Wiley .
58.
Randolf, W.A., and G.G. Dess1984'The congruence perspective of organization design: a conceptual model and multivariate research approach'. Academy of Management Review9/1: 114-127.
59.
Reimann, B.C., and A.R. Negandhi1975'Strategies of administrative control and organizational effectiveness'. Human Relations28/5: 475-486.
60.
Reimann, B.C.1980'Organization structure and technology in manufacturing: system versus workflow level perspectives'. Academy of Management Journal23/ 1: 61-77.
61.
Schoonhoven, C.B.1981'Problems with contingency theory: testing assumptions hidden within the language of contingency theory'. Administrative Science Quarterly26/3: 349-377.
62.
Schreyogg, G.1980'Contingency and choice in organization theory'. Organization Studies1/4: 305-326.
63.
Schreyogg, G.1982'Some comments about: a reply to Donaldson'. Organization Studies3/1: 73-78.
64.
Silverman, D.1970The theory of organizationsLondon: Heinemann.
65.
Tayeb, M.1987'Contingency theory and culture: a study of matched English and Indian manufacturing firms'. Organization Studies8/3: 241-261.
66.
Tosi, Jr., H.L., and J.W. Slocum, Jr. 1984'Contingency theory: some suggested directions' . Journal of Management10/1: 9-26.
67.
Van de Ven, A.H.1976'Equally efficient structural variations within organizations' in The management of organizational design: research and methodology. R. H. Kilmann, L. R. Pondy and D. P. Slevin (eds.), 155-170. New York: North Holland.
68.
Walsh, J.P., and R.D. Dcwar1987'Formalization and the organizational life cycle'. Journal of Management Studies24/3: 216-231.
69.
Williamson, O.E.1987'Economics and sociology: promoting a dialogue'. Paper presented at the 8th EGOS Conference, U.I.A., Antwerp. Belgium (July).
70.
Woodward, J.1958Technology and organizationsLondon : HMSO.
71.
Zeffane, R.M.1981Organizational patterns in different societies. PhD Thesis, Cardiff, U.K.: University of Wales, UWIST.
72.
Zeffane, R.M.1981a 'Context, technology and organization structure revisited: a tri-national study', in International perspectives on management and organization . R. Mansfield and M. Poole (eds.), 84-96. Aldershot: Gower .
73.
Zeffane, R.M., and R. Mansfield1983Organization structure and national contingenciesAldershot: Gower.
