Is bureaucracy inevitable? Can an organization exist without a specialized division of labour and multiple rules, and escape the problems associated with bureaucracy? The present paper discusses the Chinese experience in 'eliminating' bureaucracy throughout history, particularly in the Cultural Revolution. The consequences of this attempt and its aftermath suggest that bureaucratic rules and specialization are inevitable, and that we should try to improve rather than eliminate bureaucracy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Andors, Stephen1974 'Hobbes and Weber vs. Marx and Mao: the political economy of decentralization in China'. Bulletin of Concerned Asian Scholars6:19-34.
2.
Andors, Stephen1977China's industrial revolutionNew York : Pantheon.
3.
Azrael, Jeremi1966Managerial power and Soviet politicsCambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
4.
Bendix. Reinhard1974Work and authority in industry: ideologies of management in the course of industrializationBerkeley: University of California Press.
5.
Berenstein, Thomas P.1967 'Leadership and mass mobilization in the Soviet and Chinese collectivisation campaigns of 1929-30 and 1955-56; a comparison' . China Quarterly31:1-47.
6.
Bratton, Dale1979 'University admissions policy in China, 1970-1978 '. Asian Survey19:1008-1022.
7.
Burns, Tom, and G.M. Stalker1971The management of innovation. Chicago : Quadrangle Books.
8.
Chang, Chin-chien1955 'Characteristics of Chinese bureaucracy' in History of Chinese BureaucracyTaipei: Chinese Culture Series.
9.
Cheng, Chu-yuang1980 'The modernization of Chinese industry' in China's four modernizations: the new technological revolution. Richard Baum (ed). Boulder, Colo.: Westview.
10.
Chrang, Jan-kwet 1973 'Impersonal bureaucratic rules and informal social norms'. Chinese Journal of Administration 21.
11.
China News Summary 1975, 1976
12.
Confucius 1938 The Analects, trans. Arthur Waley. New York: Vintage.
13.
Falkenheim, Victor C.1980 'Administrative reform and modernization in post-Mao China '. Pacific Affairs531:5-28.
14.
Fbis (ForeignBroadcast Information Service) 1979, 1980.
15.
Fischer, George1968The soviet system and modern society. New York: Atherton Press.
16.
Gouldner, Alvin W.1964Patterns of industrial bureaucracy. New York: The Free Press.
17.
Hall, Richard H.1962 'Intraorganizational structural variation: application of the bureaucratic model'. Administrative Science Quarterly7:295-308.
18.
Herson, Lawrence1957 'China's Imperial bureaucracy: its direction and control '. Public Administration Review17:44-53.
19.
Howe, Christopher1973 'Labour organization and incentives in industry' in Authority, participation and cultural change in China. Stuart R. Schram (ed.). Cambridge: Cambndge University Press.
20.
Hsieh, Pao-chao1978The government of China, 1644- 1911. New York: Octagon.
21.
22.
Jaenicke, Wolfgang1935 'Memorandum on administrative reform'. The Chinese Administrator, July-September.
23.
Jprs1970Joint Publications Research Service. 'Chairman Mao discusses twenty manifestations of bureaucracy'. Translations on Communist China 90 (Feb. 12, 1970): 40-43.
24.
Laaksonen, Oiva1984 'The management and power structure of Chinese enterpnses during and after the Cultural Revolution: with empirical data comparing Chinese and European enterprises.' Organization Studies5/1:1-21.
25.
Lawrence, Paul, and Jay Lorsch1967Organization and environment: managing differentiation and integration. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
26.
Lee, Hong-yung1978The politics of the Chinese Cultural RevolutionBerkeley: University of California Press.
27.
Lee, Hong-yung1979 'Mao's strategy for revolutionary change: a case study of the Cultural Revolution'. China Quarterly77:50-73.
28.
Mao, Tse-tung1966 Selected works. Vol. 2. Peking: Foreign Languages Press.
29.
Mao, Tse-tung1969 Selected works. Vol. 3. Peking: Foreign Languages Press.
30.
Mao, Tse-tung1977 Selected works. Vol. 4. Peking: Foreign Languages Press.
31.
Metzger, Thomas A.1973The internal organization of Ch'ing bureaucracyCambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
32.
Meyer, John W., and Brian Rowan1977 'Institutionalized organizations: formal structure as myth and ceremony'. American Journal of Sociology83/2: 340-363.
33.
Nathan, Andrew J.1976 'Policy oscillations in the People's Republic of China: a critique'. China Quarterly68:734-750 (and a reply by Edwin A. Winckler).
34.
Nelsen, Harvey W.1977The Chinese military systemBoulder, Colo.: Westview.
35.
Oxenberg, M.C.1974 'Methods of communications within the Chmese bureaucracy' . China Quarterly57:1-39.
36.
Peking Review1977, 1978, 1979, 1980
37.
People's Daily1978, 1979, 1981
38.
Perrow, Charles1967 'A framework for the comparative analysis of complex organizations' . American Sociological Review32:194-2208.
39.
Pollack, Jonathan1980 'The modernization of national defence' in China's four modernizations. Richard Baum (ed). Boulder, Colo.: Westview .
40.
Pye, Lucian W.1968The spirit of Chinese politics: a psycho-cultural study of the authority crisis in political developmentCambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
41.
New York Times1980, 1982, 1983
42.
Schram, Stuart R., 1973 'Histoncal perspective' in Authority, participation and cultural change in China. S. T. Schram (ed). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
43.
Schram, S.T., editor 1973Authority, participation and cultural change in ChinaCambridge: Cambridge University Press.
44.
Schurmann, F.1973Ideology and organization in Communist ChinaBerkeley: University of California Press.
45.
Skinner, G.W., and Edwin A. Winckler1969 'Compliance succession in rural Communist China: a cyclical theory'. A sociological reader of complex organizations . Amitai Etzioni (ed.), 410-438. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
46.
Starr, John B.1979Continuing the revolution: the political thought of Mao . Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
47.
Sterba, Richard L. A.1978 'Clandestine management in the Imperial Chinese bureaucracy' . Academy of Management Review 3:69-78.
48.
Suttmeier, Richard P.1980 'The institutional structure for industrial research and development in China' in China's four modernizations. Richard Baum (ed.). Boulder, Colo.: Westview.
49.
Suttmeier, Richard P.1981 'Politics, modernization, and science in China'.Problems of Communism, Jan.-Feb. 22-36.
50.
Sun Yat-sen1925The three principles of the people, trans. Price. Shanghai: Commercial Press.
51.
Thompson, James D.1967Organizations in action, New York: McGraw-Hill.
52.
Treiman, Donald J.1977Occupational prestige in comparative perspectiveNew York: Academic Press.
53.
Udy, Stanley H., Jr. 1961 'Technical and institutional factors in production organization: a preliminary model'. American Journal of Sociology67/3:247-254.
54.
Udy, Stanley H., Jr. 1962 'Administrative rationality, social setting, and organizational development'. American Journal of Sociology68: 299-308.
55.
Wakeman, F.1973History and will: philosophical perspectives of Mao Tse-tung's thoughtBerkeley: University of California Press.
56.
Weber, Max1964The theory of social and economic organization, trans. Henderson and Parsons.New York : The Free Press.
57.
Whitney, Joseph B. R.1970China: area, administration, and nation building . Chicago: University of Chicago , Geography #123.
58.
Whyte, Martin K.1973 'Bureaucracy and modernization in China: the Maoist critique' . American Sociological Review38:149-163.
59.
Whyte, Martin K.1974Small groups and political rituals in ChinaBerkeley: University of California Press .
60.
Whyte, Martin K., Ezra R. Vogel, and William L. Parish1977 'Social structure of world regions: mainland China'. Annual Peview of Sociology3.
61.
Willett, F.J.1975 'The development of administrators in the PRC'. Current Scene13:1-7.
62.
Wright, Mary C.1957The last stand of Chinese conservatismStanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press.
63.
Zi, Etienne P.1896 'Pratique des examens militaire en Chine'. Variétés Sinologiques9:5-12.
