Alternative Explanations of Interorganizational Cooperation: the Case of Joint Programmes and Joint Ventures in Sweden

Abstract

Two alternative explanations of interorganizational cooperation are analysed. One is based on an open-systems approach (an outside-in explanation) where cooperation is viewed as a means to manage existing interdependencies with the environment. The other is an inside-out perspective, interpreting cooperation as a means to acquire resources that are necessary in order to establish new interdependencies. The two approaches imply different predictions as to the choice of partners and the type of resources pooled by the partners. This study attempts to reconcile the two explanations, and argues that they are contingent upon the strategic role of cooperation, as expressed by the significant actors of the cooperating organizations.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aiken, Michael , and Jerald Hage 1968

'Organizational interdependence and intra-organizational structure'

American Sociological Review 33: 912-930.

Aldrich, Howard 1975

'Resource dependence and interorganizational relations'

Administration and Society 7:419-455.

Aldrich, Howard 1976 'An organizational dependency perspective on relations between the employment service and the organization-set' in The Management of Organization Design, Vol. II. R. H. Kilman, L. R. Pondy, and D. P. Slevin (eds.), 231-266. New York:Elsevier.

Aldrich, Howard E. , and Jeffrey Pfeffer 1976

'Environments of organizations'

Annual Review of Sociology 2:79-105.

Aldrich, Howard , and David A. Whetten 1981 'Organization-sets, action-sets, and networks: making the most of simplicity' in Handbook of Organizational Design, Vol 1. Paul C. Nystrom and William H. Starbuck (eds.), 385-408. New York: Oxford University Press.

Allen, Michael Patrick 1974

'The structure of interorganizational elite cooptation: interlocking corporate directorates'

American Sociological Review 39:393-406.

Assael, Henry 1968

'The political role of trade associations in distributive conflict resolution'

Journal of Marketing 32:21-28.

Barnard, Chester I. 1946 'Functions and pathology of status systems in formal organizations' in Industry and Society , William Foote Whyte (ed.), 46-83. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Baty, Gordon B. , William M. Evan , and Terry W. Rothermel 1971

'Personnel flows as interorganizational relations'

Administrative Science Quarterly 16:430-443.

10.

Benson, J Kenneth 1975

'The interorganizational network as a political economy'

Administrative Science Quarterly 20:229-249.

11.

Benson, J. Kenneth 1977

'Innovation and crisis in organization analysis'

The Sociological Quarterly 18:3-16.

12.

Blau, Peter 1964 Exchange and power in social life New York: Wiley.

13.

Boyle, Stanley E. 1968

'An estimate of the number and size distribution of domestic joint subsidiaries'

Antitrust Law and Economics Review 1:81-92.

14.

Burns, Tom , and G.M. Stalker 1961 The management of innovation London : Tavistock.

15.

Cafferata, Gail Lee 1982

'The building of democratic organizations : an embryological metaphor'

Administrative Science Quarterly 27:280-303.

16.

Child, John 1972

'Organizational structure, environment and performance: the role of strategic choice'

Sociology 8:1-21.

17.

Cook, Karen S. 1977

'Exchange and power in networks of interorganizational relations'

The Sociological Quarterly 18:62-82.

18.

Cyert, Richard M. , and James G. March 1963 A behavioral theory of the firm Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.

19.

Dooley, Peter C. 1969

'The interlocking directorate'

American Economic Review 59:314-323.

20.

Edström, Anders , and Jay Galbraith 1977

'Transfer of managers as a coordination and control strategy in multinational organizations'

Administrative Science Quarterly 22:248-263.

21.

Edström, Anders , Bengt Högberg , and Lars Erik Norbäck 1983 'The strategic role of interfirm cooperation' in Mergers: motives, modes, methods. Walter Goldberg (ed.), 67-97. London: Gower.

22.

Emerson, Richard M. 1962

'Power-dependence relations'

American Sociological Review 27:31-41.

23.

Emerson, Richard M. 1976

'Social exchange theory'

Annual Review of Sociology 2:335-362.

24.

Evan, William M. 1972 'An organization-set model of interorganizational relations' in Interorganizational decision making. M. F. Tuite, M. Radnor, and R. K. Chisholm (eds.), 181-200. Chicago: Aldine-Atherton.

25.

Franko, Lawrence G. 1971 Joint venture survival in multinational cooperations New York: Praeger.

26.

Franko, Lawrence G. 1976 The European multinationals: a renewed challenge to American and British big business London: Greylock.

27.

Guetzkow, H. 1966 'Relations among organizations' in Studies on behavior in organizations. R. Bowers, (ed.), 13-44. Athens : University of Georgia Press.

28.

Gullander, Staffan 1975 'An exploratory study of interfirm cooperation of Swedish firms'. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, Columbia University , New York.

29.

Hage, Jerald 1965

'An axiomatic theory of organizations'

Administrative Science Quarterly 10:289-320.

30.

Hannan, Michael T. , and John Freeman 1977

'The population ecology of organizations'

American Journal of Sociology 82:929-964.

31.

Högberg, Bengt 1977 Interfirm cooperation and strategic development Göteborg: BAS.

32.

Homans, George 1958

'Social behavior as exchange'

American Journal of Sociology 62:597-606.

33.

Jacobs, David 1974

'Dependency and vulnerability: an exchange approach to the control of organizations'

Administrative Science Quarterly 19:45-59.

34.

Katz, Daniel , and Robert L. Kahn 1966 The social psychology of organizations New York and London: Wiley.

35.

Lawrence, Paul R. , and Jay W. Lorsch 1967 Organization and environment. Managing differentiation and integration Boston: Harvard Business School.

36.

Levine, Sol , and Paul E. White 1961

'Exchange as a conceptual framework for the study of interorganizational relationships'

Administrative Science Quarterly 5:583-601.

37.

Litwak, Eugene , and Lydia Hylton 1962

'Interorganizational analysis: a hypothesis on coordinating agencies'

Administrative Science Quarterly 6:395-420.

38.

Litwak, Eugene , and Jack Rothman 1970 'Towards the theory of and practice of coordination between formal organizations' in Organizations and clients: essays in the sociology of service. William R. Rosengren and Mork Lefton (eds.), 137-186. Columbus, Ohio: Merrill.

39.

Mintz, Beth , and Michael Schwartz 1981

'Interlocking directorates and interest group formation'

American Sociological Review 46:851-869.

40.

Mitchell, J. Clyde 1969 'The concept and use of social networks' in Social networks in urban situations. J. C. Mitchell (ed.), 1-29. Manchester: Manchester University Press .

41.

Morgan, Gareth 1980

'Paradigms, metaphors, and puzzle solving in organization theory'

Administrative Science Quarterly 25:605-622.

42.

Norbäck, Lars Erik 1978 Relationer mellan samarbetande företag Goteborg: BAS.

43.

Paulson, Steven K. 1974

'Causal analysis of interorganizational relations: an axiomatic theory revised'

Administrative Science Quarterly 19: 319-337.

44.

Pennings, Johannes M. 1983 'Mergers and interlocking directorates : cases of interorganizational co-operation' in Mergers: motives, modes, methods, Walter Goldberg (ed.), 105-121. London : Gower.

45.

Pfeffer, Jeffrey 1972 a'Merger as a response to organizational interdependence' Administrative Science Quarterly 17:382-394.

46.

Pfeffer, Jeffrey 1972 b'Size and composition of corporate boards of directors: the organization and its environment' Administrative Science Quarterly 17:218-228.

47.

Pfeffer, Jeffrey 1973

'Size, composition and function of hospital boards of directors: a study of organization-environment linkage'

Administrative Science Quarterly 18: 349-364.

48.

Pfeffer, Jeffrey , and Huseyin Leblebici 1973

'Executive recruitment and the development of interfirm organizations'

Administrative Science Quarterly 18: 449-461.

49.

Pfeffer, Jeffrey , and Phillip Nowak 1976

'Joint ventures and mterorganizational interdependence'

Administrative Science Quarterly 21:398-418.

50.

Pfeffer, Jeffrey , and Gerald Salancik 1978 The external control of organizations New York: Harper and Row.

51.

Reid, W. 1964

'Interagency coordination m delinquency prevention and control.'

Social Service Review 38:418-428.

52.

SCB (The National Central Bureau of Statistics) 1975 Reports on statistical co-ordination No. 1975:4 Orebro, Sweden.

53.

Stopford, John M. , and Louis T. Wells 1972 Managing the multinational enterprise New York: Basic Books.

54.

Stopford, J. , and K. Haberich 1976

'Ownership and control of foreign operations'

Journal of General Management 3/4:3-20.

55.

Thompson, James D. 1967 Organizations in action New York : McGraw-Hill.

56.

Thompson, Victor A. 1961 Modern organizations New York : Alfred Knopf.

57.

Weber, Max 1947 The theory of social and economic organizations A. M. Hunderson and Talcott Parsons (trans. and eds.). New York: Oxford University Press.

58.

Weick, Karl E. 1979 The social psychology of organizing , 2nd ed. Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley .

59.

Williamson, Oliver E. 1979

'Transaction-cost economics: the governance of contractual relations'

The Journal of Law and Economics 22:233-261.

60.

Yuchtman, Ephraim , and Stanley E. Seashore 1967

'A system resource approach to organizational effectiveness'

American Sociological Review 32:891-903.