Research Note: The Kibbutz as a Situation for Cross-Cultural Research1

Abstract

It is argued that the kibbutz society comprises a unique combination of similarities and differences with other societies which makes it a fruitful area for cross-cultural research. The similarities lie in the personal characteristics of individuals, in the pattern of relationships between key variables and in some global features of the kibbutz communities. The differences centre upon the principles of organization and the conduct of kibbutz communities. The similarities thus facilitate comparison between kibbutzim and other industrial societies while the differences allow for the expansion of theories and further generalizations and experimentation with alternative solutions to social problems of industrial society. Finally, the paper presents some problems and difficulties in employing the kibbutz as part of cross-cultural research and suggests possible remedies to these problems of comparison.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Andrews, Frank , and Steven Withey 1976 Social indicators of well-being. London : Plenum Press.

Campbell, Angus , Philip Converse , and Willard Rodgers 1976 The quality of American life . New York: Russell Sage Foundation .

Cohen, Jiska , and Uri Leviatan 1982 'Sex differences in life expectance of kibbutz members: what it may mean for larger society' Proceedings, lst International Conference on Women, Haifa, Israel.

Eden, Dov , and Uri Leviatan 1974 'Farm and factory in the kibbutz: a study in agrico-industrial psychology'. Journal of Applied Psychology 59/5: 596-602.

Goffman, Erving 1969 'The characteristics of total institutions' in Complex organizations, 2nd ed. Amitai Etzioni (ed.), 312-388. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.

Herzberg, Fred 1966 Work and the nature of man. Cleveland : World Publications.

Kaffman, Mordechai 1965 'A comparison of psychopathology: Israeli children from kibbutz and from urban surroundings'. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 35: 509-520.

Katz, Elihu , and Michael Gurvitz 1973 Leisure culture in Israel. Tel Aviv: Am Oved Press. (Hebrew)

Larson, R. 1978 'Thirty years of research on the subjective well-being of older Americans'. Journal of Gerontology 33/1: 109-125.

10.

Levi, Shulamit , and Luis Guttman 1975 'Values and attitudes of the youth in school in Israel' . Jerusalem, Institute for Applied Social Research. (Hebrew)

11.

Leviatan, Uri , Eliette Orchan , and Alexander Avnat 1977 'Increasing retention among kibbutz-born members'. Givat Haviva: Center for Social Research on the Kibbutz.

12.

Leviatan, Uri 1980 'What do Israelis think of kibbutz life and why'. University of Haifa, Institute for Research of the Kibbutz and the Cooperative Idea.

13.

Leviatan, Uri , Gila Adar , and Zvi Am-Ad 1982 'Aging in the kibbutz: satisfaction with life and its antecedents' . University of Haifa, Institute of Research of the Kibbutz and the Cooperative Idea.

14.

Leviatan, Uri , and Eliette Orchan 1982 'Kibbutz ex-members and their adjustment to life outside the kibbutz'. Interchange 13/1: 16-28.

15.

Leviatan, Uri 1982a 'Higher education in the Israeli kibbutz: revolution and effect'. Interchange 13/1: 68-82.

16.

Leviatan, Uri 1982b 'Kibbutz society in the public eyes in Israel 1976-1981' Hakibbutz 8: 235-256. (Hebrew)

17.

Macarov, David 1972 'Work patterns and satisfaction in an Israeli kibbutz: a test of the Herzberg hypothesis'. Personal Psychology 25:483.

18.

Rabin, Albert 1965 Growing up in the kibbutz. New York : Springer.

19.

Rosner, Menachem , and David Mittleberg 1979 'Interactional influences between Jewish American youth temporarily dwelling in the kibbutz and the absorbing kibbutzim'. University of Haifa, The Institute for Research of the Kibbutz and the Cooperative Idea.

20.

Rosner, Menachem 1982 Democracy, equality and change: the kibbutz and social theory. Derby, Pa: Norwood Editions .

21.

Tannenbaum, Arnold , Bogdan Kavcic , Menachem Rosner , Mino Vianello , and George Wieser 1974 Hierarchy in organizations. San Francisco : Jossey-Bass.

22.

Shur, Shimon 1979 'The kibbutz in research: bibliography'. University of Haifa, Institute for Research of the Kibbutz and the Cooperative Idea. (Hebrew)

23.

Shur, Shimon , Benjamin Beit Hallahmi , Joseph Blasi , and Albert Rabin 1981 The kibbutz: a bibliography of scientific and professional publications in English. Derby, Pa.: Norwood Editions.