The study compares the managerial orientations and workers' attitudes in labour- owned enterprises to those in privately owned enterprises in Israel. Data were collected by means of closed questionnaires from production managers and 847 production workers in a representative sample of 57 industrial plants stratified by size and sector of ownership. Contrary to the expectations derived from the formal ideology of labour control, no differences were found in the orientations of line managers to workers and in the work centrality, job satisfaction and identification with the enterprise of workers in labour-owned plants as compared to privately owned plants. It was found, however, that in small plants managerial orientations explain more variance of workers' responses, especially of work centrality, in labour as compared to private plants. In large plants, these stronger relationships were not found.
The findings are discussed in terms of their implications for labour ownership and worker outcomes, both from a general theoretical point of view and in the context of the labour economy in Israel.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aharoni, Yair, and Ran Lachman1982 'Can the manager's mind be nationalized'. Organization Studies3: 33-46.
2.
Barkai, Haim1981 ' Management and workers' control: theory and practice of the Histadrut industrial sector'. The Maurice Falk Institute for Economic Research in Israel, Jerusalem, Discussion Paper No. 811.
3.
Child, John1975 ' Industrial participation in Israel — a personal impression'. University of Aston Management Center, Working Paper No. 42.
4.
Daniel, Abraham1976Labor enterprise in Israel. Jerusalem : Academic Press.
5.
Dar-El, E.M., and Uzi De-Haan1977 'Autonomous decision making and its implications for job design'. International Journal of Production Research15: 331-350.
6.
De-Haan, Uzi1975 'Autonomy and technology: limits and optimal states.' Doctoral Dissertation, Technion — Israel Institute of Technology , Haifa, Israel.
7.
Derber. Milton1973 'Histadrut and industrial democracy: an interpretive essay from an American perspective'. In Israel: social structure and changeMichael Curtiss and M. Chertoff (eds.) New Brunswick, N.J. : Transaction Books.
8.
Dubin, Robert1965 'Supervision and productivity: empirical findings and theoretical considerations'. In Leadership and productivity. Robert Dubin, G. C. Homans , F. C. Mann, and D. C. Miller (eds.) San Francisco: Chandler Publishing.
9.
Ford, Jeffrey D.1981 'Departmental context and formal structure as constraints on leader behavior'. Academy of Management Journal24: 274-288.
10.
Gordon, E., and Douglas T. Hall1974 'Self-image and stereotypes of femininity: their relationships to women's role conflict and coping'. Journal of Applied Psychology59: 241-243.
11.
Hammer, Tove H., and R.W. Stern1980 'Employee ownership implications for the organizational distribution of power'. Academy of Management Journal23: 78-100.
12.
Hickson, David J., D.S. Pugh, and D.C. Pheysey1969 'Operations technology and organizational structure: an empirical reappraisal'. Administrative Science Quarterly14: 379-397.
13.
IDE International Research Group1981 'Industrial democracy in Europe: differences and similarities across countries and hierarchies'. Organization Studies2: 113-129.
14.
Kerr, S.C., C. Schriesheim, C.J. Murphy, and R.M. Stogdill1974 'Towards a contingency theory of leadership based upon the consideration and initiation of structure literature'. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance12: 62-82.
15.
Lavon, P.1958 'Histadrut economy: new ways for old'. Jewish Frontier, September, p 17.
16.
Long, R.1980 'Job attitudes and organizational performance under employee ownership'. Academy of Management Journal23: 726-737.
17.
Mannheim, Bilha1975'A comparative study of work centrality, job rewards and satisfaction'. Sociology of Work and Occupation2: 79-101.
18.
Mannheim, Bilha, and Ayala Cohen 1978 'Multivariate analysis of factors affecting work centrality of occupational categories'. Human Relations32: 525-553.
19.
Murray, Michael1975 'Comparing public and private management: an exploratory essay'. Public Administration Review35: 345-365.
20.
Nightingale, Donald V.1979 'Work, formal participation and employee outcomes' Sociology of Work and Occupations8: 277-296.
21.
Nunnaly, J.C.1967Psychometric theory. New York: McGraw-Hill.
22.
Oldham, Greg R., and J. Richard Hackman1981 'Relationships between organizational structure and employee reactions: comparing alternative frameworks' Administrative Science Quarterly26: 66-83.
23.
Porter, Lyman W., Edward E. Lawler III. and J. Richard Hackman1975Behavior in organizations. New York: McGraw-Hill .
24.
Preparatory Committee of the 13th General Convention of the Histadrut 1977 Draft of proposals for decisions.
25.
Preparatory Committee for the Council of Hevrat Ha'ovdim 1982 Draft of porposals for decisions.
26.
Rabinowitz, Samuel, Douglas T. Hall, and James G. Goodale1977 'Job scope and individual differences as predictors of job invlovement: independent or interactive?' Academy of Management Journal20: 273-281.
27.
Rainey, Hal G., Robert W. Backoff, and Charles H. Levine1976 'Comparing public and private organizations'. Public Administration Review36: 233-244.
28.
Rim, Yeshayahu, and Bilha Mannheim1963 'Factors related to attitudes of management and union representatives' . Personnel Psychology17: 149-165.
29.
Rosenberg, Richard D1983 'Business and national priorities for industrial development: intersectoral consensus priorities in Israel'. Strategtc Management4: 67-78.
30.
Rosenstein, Eliezer1977 'Workers' participation in management: problematic issues in the Israeli system'. Industrial Relations8: 55-69.
31.
Rosenstein, Eliezer1981 'The Israeli industrial relations system' in European Industrial Relations. Industrial Relations International Research Group (IDE). Oxford: Clarendon Press.
32.
Rosner, Menahem1973 'Worker participation in decision making in Kibbutz industry' in Israel— Social Structure and Change. Michael Curtis and M. Chertoff (eds). New Brunswick, N.J.: Transaction Books.
33.
Rousseau, Denise M.1978 'Characteristics of departments, positions, and individuals: contexts for attitudes and behavior'. Administrative Science Quarterly23: 521-540.
34.
Shepard, J.M.D.I. Kim, and I.G. Hougland1979Effects of technology in industrialized and industrializing societies'. Sociology of Work and Occupations66: 457-481.
35.
Strauss, George1982 'Workers participation in management: an international perspective in Research in Organizational Behavior. Barry M. Staw and L. L. Cummings (eds.). Greenwich, Conn.: JAI Press.
36.
Taylor, James C., and D.G. Bowers1972Survey of organizations: a machine-scored standardized questionnaire instrumentAnn Arbor: University of Michigan, Institute for Social Research.
37.
Vardi, Joav, Arie Shirom, and Dan Jacobson1980'A study on leadership beliefs of Israeli managers'. Academy of Management Journal23: 367-374.
38.
Woodward. Joan1965Industrial organization: theory and practice. London: Oxford University Press.
