Organization studies scholars have examined leadership development processes on only a handful of occasions. This paper argues that an organizational lens, rather than individualized and decontextualized research, can significantly advance this under-theorized field. A critical organizational framing, in particular, assists not only in problematizing the ‘leader’ identities produced within contemporary leadership development programmes (LDPs), but also in surfacing the ways in which power, context and identity can be inextricably linked within specific practices. The article contributes to critical leadership and organization studies in three main ways. First, it theorizes through a critical identity lens the regulatory practices that constitute an idealized leader self in two separate global LDPs, and which create tensions and paradoxes rarely examined in studies of LDPs and organizations more generally. Second, it examines participants’ considerable resistance to the prevailing models of global leader prescribed in the two programmes. Third, our dual case analysis highlights the role of discursive context, enabling us to compare two particular strategies of leadership development through identity regulation: ‘investiture’ and ‘divestiture’. The paper concludes by discussing the implications of this analysis for rethinking theory and practice, and suggests future research directions for critical organization studies of leadership and LDPs.
AckersP.PrestonD. (1997). Born again? The ethics and efficacy of the conversion experience in contemporary management development. Journal of Management Studies, 34, 677–701.
2.
AlvessonM.WillmottH. (2002). Identity regulation as organizational control. Journal of Management Studies, 39, 619–644.
3.
AlvessonM.SpicerA. (2012). Critical leadership studies: The case for critical performativity. Human Relations, 65, 367–390.
4.
AshcraftK. L. (2005). Resistance through consent? Occupational identity, organizational form, and the maintenance of masculinity among commercial airline pilots. Management Communication Quarterly, 19, 67–91.
5.
AshforthB. E.HarrisonS. H.CorleyK. G. (2008). Identification in organizations: An examination of four fundamental questions. Journal of Management, 34, 325–374.
6.
AvolioB.RichardR.HannahS.WalumbaF. O.ChanA. (2009). A meta-analytic review of leadership impact research. Leadership Quarterly, 20, 764–784.
7.
BarkerJ. R. (1993). Tightening the iron cage: Concertive control in self-managing teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 38, 408–437.
8.
BarleyS. R.KundaG. (1992). Design and devotion: Surges of rational and normative ideologies of control in managerial discourse. Administrative Science Quarterly, 37, 363–399.
9.
BergstromO.HasselbladhH.KarremanD. (2009). Organizing disciplinary power in a knowledge organization. Scandinavian Journal of Management, 25, 178–190.
10.
BoldenR.GoslingJ. (2006). Leadership competencies: Time to change the tune?Leadership, 2, 147–163.
11.
BrownA. D.StarkeyK. (2000). Organizational identity and learning: A psychodynamic perspective. Academy of Management Review, 25, 102–120.
12.
BrownA. D. (2001). Organization studies and identity: Towards a research agenda. Human Relations, 54, 113–121.
13.
BrownA. D.CouplandC. (2005). Sounds of silence: Graduate trainees, hegemony and resistance. Organization Studies, 26, 1049–1069.
14.
BrownA. D.LewisM. A. (2011). Identities, discipline and routines. Organization Studies, 32, 871–895.
15.
BurnsJ. M. (1978). Leadership. New York: Harper & Row.
16.
BuusI.SaslowS. (2005). The evolution of leadership development. Strategic Human Resource Review, 4, 28–31.
17.
CardenL. L.CallahanJ. L. (2007). Creating leaders or loyalists? Conflicting identities in a leadership development programme. Human Resource Development International, 10, 169–186.
18.
CarrollB.LevyL. (2008). Defaulting to management: Leadership defined by what it is not. Organization, 15, 75–96.
19.
CaseyC. (1999). ‘Come, join our family’: Discipline and integration in corporate organizational culture. Human Relations, 52, 155–178.
20.
ClarkeD.BrownA. D.Hope-HaileyV. (2009). Working identities? Antagonistic discursive resources and managerial identity. Human Relations, 62, 1–30.
21.
CollinsJ. (2001) Good to great. New York: Random House.
22.
CollinsonD. (1992). Managing the shop floor: Subjectivity, masculinity and workplace culture. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
23.
CollinsonD. (1994). Strategies of resistance: Power, knowledge and subjectivity in the workplace. In JermierJ.KnightsD.NordW. (Eds.), Resistance and power in organizations. London: Routledge.
24.
CollinsonD. (2003). Identities and insecurities: Selves at work. Organization, 10, 527–547.
25.
CollinsonD. (2005). Dialectics of leadership. Human Relations, 58, 1419–1442.
26.
CollinsonD. (2011). Critical leadership studies. In BrymanA.CollinsonD.GrintK.JacksonB. (Eds.), The Sage handbook of leadership (pp. 179–192). London: SAGE Publications.
27.
CollinsonD. (2012). Prozac leadership and the limits of positive thinking. Leadership, 8, 87–107.
28.
ContuA. (2008). Decaf resistance: On misbehavior, cynicism, and desire in liberal workplaces. Management Communication Quarterly, 21, 364–379.
29.
CovaleskiM. A.DirsmithM. W.HeianJ. B.SamuelS. (1998). The calculated and the avowed: Techniques of discipline and struggles over identity in Big Six public accounting firms. Administrative Science Quarterly, 43, 293–327.
30.
CunliffeA. L. (2009). The philosopher leader: On relationalism, ethics and reflexivity – a critical perspective to teaching leadership. Management Learning, 40, 87–110.
31.
DayD. (2011). Leadership development. In BrymanA.CollinsonD.GrintK.JacksonB.Uhl-BienM. (Eds.), The Sage handbook of leadership. London: SAGE Publications.
32.
DayD.HarrisonM.HalpinS. (2009). An integrative approach to leader development: Connecting adult development, identity and expertise. New York: Taylor & Francis.
33.
DenisJ. L.LangleyA.SergiV. (2012). Leadership in the plural. Academy of Management Annals, 6: 211–283.
34.
DeRueD. S.AshfordS. J. (2010). Who will lead and who will follow? A social process of leadership identity construction in organizations. Academy of Management Review, 35, 1–21.
35.
Delves BroughtonP. (2009). What they teach you at Harvard Business School. New York: Penguin Books.
EdwardsG.ElliottC.Iszatt-WhiteM.SchedlitzkiD. (2013). Critical and alternative approaches to leadership learning and development. Management Learning, 44, 3–10.
38.
ElyR. J.ThomasD. A. (2001). Cultural diversity at work: The effects of diversity perspectives on work group processes and outcomes. Administrative Science Quarterly, 46, 229–273.
39.
ElyR.IbarraH.KolbD. (2011). Taking gender into account: Theory and design for women’s leadership development programs. Academy of Management Learning and Education, 10, 474–493.
40.
FairhurstG. T. (2008). Discursive leadership: A communication alternative to leadership psychology. Management Communication Quarterly, 21, 510–521.
41.
Finch-LeesT.MabeyC.LiefoogheA. (2005). ‘In the name of capability’: A critical discursive evaluation of competency-based management development. Human Relations, 58, 1185–1222.
42.
FlemingP.SewellG. (2002). Looking for the good soldier, Svejk: Alternative modalities of resistance in the contemporary workplace. Sociology: the Journal of the British Sociological Association, 36, 857–873.
43.
FlemingP.SpicerA. (2003). Working at a cynical distance: Implications for power, subjectivity and resistance. Organization, 10, 157–179.
44.
FlemingP.SpicerA. (2007). Contesting the corporation: Struggle, power and resistance in organizations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
45.
FordJ. (2006). Discourses of leadership: Gender, identity and contradiction in a UK public sector organization. Leadership, 2, 77–99.
46.
FoucaultM. (1972). Archaeology of knowledge. London: Routledge.
47.
FoucaultM. (1977). Discipline and punish. London: Allen Unwin.
48.
FoucaultM. (1979). The history of sexuality (Vol. 1). London: Allen Lane.
49.
GabrielY. (2005). MBA and the education of leaders: The new playing fields of Eton?Leadership, 1, 147–163.
50.
GagnonS. (2008). Compelling identities: Selves and insecurities in global corporate management development. Management Learning, 39, 375–391.
51.
GagnonS.VoughH.NickersonR. (2012). Learning to lead, unscripted: Teaching leadership through improvisational theatre. Human Resource Development Review, 11, 299–325.
52.
GordonR. (2002). Conceptualizing leadership with respect to its historical-contextual antecedents to power. Leadership Quarterly, 13,151–167.
53.
GreilA. L.RudyD. R. (1983). Conversion to the world view of Alcoholics Anonymous: A refinement of conversion theory. Qualitative Sociology, 6, 5–28.
54.
GrintK. (2010). The sacred in leadership: Separation, sacrifice and silence. Organization Studies, 31, 89–107.
55.
HallierJ.JamesP. (1999). Group rites and trainer wrongs in employee experiences of job change. Journal of Management Studies, 36, 45–67.
56.
HaslamS. A.ReicherS. D.PlatowM. J. (2011). The new psychology of leadership: Identity, influence, and power. Hove: Psychology Press.
57.
HodgsonD. (2005). ‘Putting on a professional performance’: Performativity, subversion and project management. Organization, 12, 51–68.
58.
HoggM. (2001). A social identity theory of leadership. Personality & Social Psychology Review, 5, 184–200.
59.
HughesP. D.GrantM. (2007). Learning and development outlook 2007. Ottawa, ON: Conference Board of Canada.
60.
JamrogJ. J. (2005). Leading into the future: A global study, 2005–2015. New York: American Management Association.
61.
JarosS. (2012). Identity and the workplace: An assessment of contextualist and discursive approaches. Tamara: Journal for Critical Organization Inquiry, 10, 45–59.
62.
JermierJ. M.KnightsD.NordW. R. (1994). Resistance and power in organizations. London: Routledge.
63.
JonesA. (2006). Developing what? An anthropological look at the leadership development process across cultures. Leadership, 2, 481–498.
64.
KärremanD.AlvessonM. (2004). Cages in tandem: Management control, social identity, and identification in a knowledge-intensive firm. Organization, 11, 149–175.
65.
KennyK.WhittleA.WillmottH. (2011). Understanding identity and organizations. London: SAGE Publications.
66.
KondoD. K. (1990). Crafting selves: Power, gender and discourses of identity in a Japanese workplace. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
67.
KonradA. M.PrasadP.PringleJ. K. (2006). The handbook of workplace diversity. London: SAGE Publications.
68.
LockeK. (2001). Grounded theory in management research. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
69.
LordR. G.BrownD. J. (2004). Leadership processes and follower self-identity. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
70.
LordR. G.HallR. J. (2005). Identity, deep structure and the development of leadership skill. Leadership Quarterly, 16, 591–615.
71.
MabeyC. (2013). Leadership development in organizations: Multiple discourses and diverse practice. International Journal of Management Reviews, 15, 359–380.
72.
MabeyC.Finch-LeesT. (2008). Management and leadership development. London: SAGE Publications.
73.
McCullochG. (1991). Philosophers and kings: Education for leadership in modern England. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
74.
MumbyD. K. (2005). Theorizing resistance in organization studies: A dialectical approach. Management Communication Quarterly, 19, 19–44.
75.
NicholsonH.CarrollB. (2013). Identity undoing and power relations in leadership development. Human Relations, 66, 1225–1248.
76.
NyeJ. (2008). The powers to lead. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
77.
ObodaruO. (2012). The self not taken: How alternative selves develop and how they influence our professional lives. Academy of Management Review, 37, 34–57.
78.
PattonM. Q. (2002), Qualitative research and evaluation methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
79.
PetriglieriG.SteinM. (2012). The unwanted self: Projective identification in leaders’ identity work. Organization Studies, 33, 1217–1235.
80.
PrasadA.PrasadP. (1998). Everyday struggles at the workplace: The nature and implications of routine resistance in contemporary organizations. In BambergerP. A.SonnenstuhlW. J. (Eds.), Research in the sociology of organizations, 15: Deviance in and of organizations (pp. 225–257). Stamford: JAI.
81.
PrasadP. (2005). Crafting qualitative research: Working in the post positivist traditions. New York: ME Sharpe.
82.
PrasadP.PrasadA. (2000). Stretching the iron cage: The constitution and implications of routine workplace resistance. Organization Science, 11, 387–403.
83.
PrattM. G. (2000a). Building an ideological fortress: The role of spirituality, encapsulation and sensemaking. Culture and Organization, 6, 35–69.
84.
PrattM. G. (2000b). The good, the bad, and the ambivalent: Managing identification among Amway distributors. Administrative Science Quarterly, 45, 456–493.
85.
PullenA.RhodesC. (2013). Corporeal ethics and the politics of resistance in organizations. Organization, published online May9, 2013, doi: 10.1177/1350508413484819.
86.
RhodesC. (2009). After reflexivity: Ethics, freedom and the writing of organization studies. Organization Studies, 30, 653–672.
87.
SchwalbeM.GodwinS.HoldenD.SchrockD.ThompsonS.WolkomirM. (2000). Generic processes in the reproduction of inequality: An interactionist analysis. Social Forces, 79, 419–452.
88.
ShamirB.HouseR. J.ArthurM. B. (1993). The motivational effects of charismatic leadership: A self-concept based theory. Organization Science, 4, 577–594.
89.
SinclairA. (2007) Leadership for the Disillusioned. London: Allen and Unwin.
90.
SnowD. A.MachalekR. (1984). The sociology of conversion. Annual Review of Sociology, 10, 167–190.
91.
SpicerA.BohmS. (2007). Moving management: Theorizing struggles against the hegemony of management. Organization Studies, 28, 1667–1698.
92.
StakeR. E. (1995). The art of case study research. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
93.
StoreyJ.SalamanG. (2009). Managerial dilemmas. Chichester: John Wiley.
94.
StraussA. (1987). Qualitative analysis for social scientists. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
95.
ThompsonP. (1993). Postmodernism: Fatal distraction. In HassardJ.ParkerM. (Eds.), Postmodernism and organizations (pp. 183–203). London: SAGE Publications.
96.
ThomasR.MillsA.MillsJ. H. (Eds.) (2004). Identity politics at work: Resisting gender, gendering resistance. New York: Routledge.
97.
ThomasR.DaviesA. (2005). Theorizing the micro-politics of resistance: New Public Management and managerial identities in the UK public services. Organization Studies, 26, 683–706.
98.
ThomasR. (2009). Critical management studies on identity. In AlvessonM.BridgmanT.WillmottH. (Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Critical Management Studies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
99.
ThomasR.SargentL. D.HardyC. (2011). Managing organizational change: Negotiating meaning and power-resistance relations. Organization Science, 22, 22–41.
100.
ThornborrowT.BrownA. (2009). ‘Being regimented’: Aspiration, discipline and identity work in the British Parachute Regiment. Organization Studies, 30, 355–376.
101.
TourishD. (2013). The dark side of transformational leadership. London: Routledge.
102.
TourishD.VatchaN. (2005). Charismatic leadership and corporate cultism at Enron: The elimination of dissent, the promotion of conformity and organizational collapse. Leadership, 1, 455–480.
103.
TrehanK. (2007). Psychodynamic and critical perspectives on leadership development. Advances in Developing Human Resources, 9, 72–82.
104.
TownleyB. (1993). Foucault, power, knowledge and its relevance for human resource management. Academy of Management Review, 18, 518–545.
105.
Van MaanenJ. (1978). People processing: Strategies of organizational socialization. Organization Dynamics, Summer, 19–36.
106.
WillmottH. (1993). Strength is ignorance, slavery is freedom: Managing culture in modern organizations. Journal of Management Studies, 30, 515–552.
107.
YbemaS. (2010). Talk of change: Temporal contrasts and collective identities. Organization Studies, 31, 481–503.
108.
ZanoniP.JanssensM. (2007). Minority employees engaging with (diversity) management: An analysis of control, agency and micro-emancipation. Journal of Management Studies, 44, 1371–1397.
109.
ZollerH.FairhurstG. (2007). Resistance leadership: The overlooked potential in critical organization and leadership studies. Human Relations, 60, 1331–1360.
