Industry Identity in an Oligopolistic Market and Firms’ Responses to Institutional Pressures

Abstract

This study sought to explain the puzzle of firm noncompliance under conditions of highly salient and coercive institutional pressures from stakeholders. Based on a qualitative study of the Canadian banking industry’s responses to institutional pressures from government, clients, and the media for higher-quality banking service to small and medium-size enterprises (SMEs), results revealed that oligopoly power could not account exclusively for firms’ dismissiveness of salient stakeholder expectations. We introduce the concept of industry identity to explain how market power interacted with industry identity to predict firms’ nonconformity to institutional pressures and their willingness to maintain identity–image misalignment. Our study contributes new insights into theories of institutional conformity, identity, and oligopoly behavior.

Keywords

industry identity institutional pressures oligopoly behavior

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Albert

Whetten

D. A.

(1985). Organizational identity. In Staw

B. M.

Cummings

L. L.

(Eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior (Vol. 7, pp. 263–295). Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.

Allen

R. F.

(1983). Efficiency, market power, and profitability in American manufacturing. Southern Economic Journal, 49, 933–941.

Audia

P. G.

Locke

E. A.

Smith

K. G.

(2000). The paradox of success: An archival and a laboratory study of strategic persistence following radical environmental change. Academy of Management Journal, 43, 837–853.

Baumol

W. J.

(1958). On the theory of oligopoly. Econometrica, August, 187–198.

Baumol

W. J.

(1967). Business behavior, volume and growth. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.

Business Week (2010). Bubble or not? Business Week, pp. 64–67.

Canadian Bankers Association (2003). Competition in the Canadian small and medium-sized business financing market: Submission by the Canadian Bankers Association to the Department of Financing (pp. 1–15): Canadian Bankers Association.

Canadian Bankers Association (2007a). Bank milestones. Retrieved from http://www.cba.ca/en/ViewDocument.asp?fl=2&sl=109&tl=&docid=225.

Canadian Bankers Association (2007b). Frequently asked questions. Retrieved from http://www.cba.ca/en/toolbar/faq.asp.

10.

Canadian Bankers Association (2007c). Legislation/Regulation. Retrieved from http://www.cba.ca/en/section.asp?fl=4&sl=269&tl=&docid=.

11.

Canadian Bankers Association (2008). Quick facts. Retrieved from http://cba.ca/en/viewdocument.asp?fl=3&sl=174&docid=413&pg=1.

12.

Canadian Bankers Association (2009). Submission to the House of Commons Standing Committee on Finance: 2009 Pre-Budget Consultations (pp. 1–6). Toronto: Canadian Bankers Association.

13.

Canadian Bankers Association (2010). Banks and the economy (pp. 2). Toronto: Canadian Bankers Association.

14.

Canadian Federation of Independent Business (2007). About us. Retrieved from http://www.cfib-fcei.ca/english/about_us.html.

15.

Demsetz

(1973). Industry structure, market rivalry, and public policy. Journal of Law and Economics, April, 109.

16.

Department of Finance. (2005). The Canadian financial services sector: June 2005. Retrieved from http://www.fin.gc.ca/toc/2005/fact-cfss-eng.asp.

17.

DiMaggio

P. J.

Powell

W. W.

(1983). The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. American Sociological Review, 48, 147–160.

18.

Dobbin

Sutton

J. R.

Meyer

J. W.

Scott

(1993). Equal opportunity law and the construction of internal labor markets. American Journal of Sociology, 99, 396–427.

19.

Dutton

J. E.

Dukerich

J. M.

(1991). Keeping an eye on the mirror: Image and identity in organizational adaptation. Academy of Management Journal, 34, 517–554.

20.

Dutton

J. E.

Dukerich

J. M.

Harquail

C. V.

(1994). Organizational images and member identification. Administrative Science Quarterly, 39, 239–263.

21.

Edelman

L. B.

(1992). Legal ambiguity and symbolic structures: Organizational mediation of civil rights law. American Sociological Review, 97, 1531–1576.

22.

Edelman

L. B.

Stryker

(2005). A sociological approach to law and the economy. In Smelser

N. J.

Swedberg

(Eds.), The handbook of economic sociology. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

23.

Edelman

L. B.

Uggen

Erlanger

H. S.

(1999). The endogeneity of legal regulation: Grievance procedures as rational myth. American Journal of Sociology, 105, 406–454.

24.

Edwards

C. D.

(1955). Conglomerate bigness as a source of power. In National Bureau Committee for Economic Research (Ed.), Business concentration and price policy: A conference of the universities (pp. 331–359). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

25.

Eisenhardt

K. M.

(1989). Building theories from case study research. Academy of Management Review, 14, 532–550.

26.

Elsbach

K. D.

Kramer

R. M.

(1996). Members’ responses to organizational identity threats: Encountering and countering Business Week rankings. Administrative Science Quarterly, 41, 442–476.

27.

Equinox (2002). Gaps in SME financing: An analytical framework (pp. 1–80). Ottawa, Ontario: Prepared for Small Business Policy Branch, Industry Canada by Equinox Management Consultants Ltd.

28.

Fershtam

Muller

(1986). Capital investments and price agreements in semi-collusive markets. RAND Journal of Economics, 17, 214–226.

29.

Forbes (2011). Best countries for business (October 2011). Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/lists/2011/6/best-countries-11_Canada_CHI019.html.

30.

Gioia

D. A.

Schultz

Corley

K. G.

(2000). Organizational identity, image, and adaptive instability. Academy of Management Review, 25, 63–81.

31.

Glynn

M. A.

(2008). Beyond constraint: How institutions enable identities. In Greenwood

Oliver

Sahlin

Suddaby

(Eds.), The Sage handbook of organizational institutionalism (pp. 413–430). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications Inc.

32.

Granovetter

(2005). Business groups and social organization. In Smelser

Swedberg

(Eds.), Handbook of economic sociology (2nd Edition, pp. 429–450). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press and Russell Sage Foundation.

33.

House of Commons (2008). Committees: Practical guide. Ottawa, Ontario: House of Commons.

34.

Hsu

Hannan

M. T.

(2005). Identities, genres, and organizational forms. Organization Science, 5, 474–490.

35.

Huff

A. S.

(1982). Industry influences on strategy formulation. Strategic Management Journal, 3, 119–130.

36.

Illia

Lurati

(2006). Stakeholder perspectives on organizational identity: Searching for a relationship approach. Corporate Reputation Review, 8, 293–304.

37.

Industry Canada (2005). Key small business financing statistics (pp. 1–31): Industry Canada.

38.

Ingram

Yue

L. Q.

(2008). Structure, affect and identity as bases of organizational competition and cooperation. Academy of Management Annals, 2(1), 275–303.

39.

JDPower.com (2011). 2011 Canadian retail banking customer satisfaction survey. Retrieved from http://www.jdpower.com/ca/finance/ratings/canadian-retail-banking-ratings/big-five-banks/.

40.

Lum

(2007). Banks’ last frontier: Insurance. The Globe and Mail Report on Business Magazine.

41.

MacKay Task Force Report (1998). Competition, competitiveness and the public interest: Background paper #1 (pp. 1–192). Task Force on the Future of the Canadian Financial Services Sector.

42.

Marquis

Lounsbury

(2007). Vive la resistance: Competing logics and the consolidation of US community banking. Academy of Management Journal, 50, 799–820.

43.

McKendrick

D. G.

Jafee

Carroll

G. R.

Khessina

O. M.

(2003). In the bud? Disk array producers as a (possibly) emergent organizational form. Administrative Science Quarterly, 48, 60–93.

44.

Meyer

J. W.

Rowan

(1977). Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony. American Journal of Sociology, 83, 340–363.

45.

Miles

M. B.

Huberman

A. M.

(1994). Qualitative data analysis: An expanded sourcebook (2nd Edition). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.

46.

Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (2010). Financial data – banks. Retrieved from http://www.osfi-bsif.gc.ca/osfi/index_e.aspx?ArticleID=554.

47.

Oliver

(1991). Strategic responses to institutional processes. Academy of Management Review, 16, 145–179.

48.

Osborne

J. D.

Stubbart

C. I.

Ramaprasad

(2001). Strategic groups and competitive enactment: A study of dynamic relationships between mental models and performance. Strategic Management Journal, 22, 435–454.

49.

Perry

M. J.

(2010). Due North: Canada’s marvellous banking and mortgage system. Journal of the American Enterprise Institute.

50.

Peteraf

Shanley

(1997). Getting to know you: A theory of strategic group identity. Strategic Management Journal, 18, 165–186.

51.

Phillips

M. E.

(1994). Industry mindsets: Exploring the cultures of two macro-organizational settings. Organization Science, 5, 384–402.

52.

Pólos

Hannan

M. T.

Carroll

G. R.

(2002). Foundations of a theory of social forms. Industrial and Corporate Change, 11(1).

53.

Porac

J. F.

Thomas

Wilson

Paton

Kanfer

(1995). Rivalry and the industry model of Scottish knitwear producers. Administrative Science Quarterly, 40, 203–228.

54.

Porac

J. F.

Thomas

Baden-Fuller

(1989). Competitive groups as cognitive communities: The case of Scottish knitwear manufacturers. Journal of Management Studies, 26, 397–416.

55.

Porter

M. E.

(1980). Competitive strategy. New York: Free Press.

56.

Randel

A. E.

Jaussi

K. S.

Standifird

S. S.

(2009). Organizational responses to negative evaluation by external stakeholders: The role of organizational identity characteristics in organizational response formulation. Business & Society, 48, 438–466.

57.

Ravasi

Schultz

(2006). Responding to organizational identity threats: Exploring the role of organizational culture. Academy of Management Journal, 49, 433–458.

58.

Romanelli

Khessina

O. M.

(2005). Regional industrial identity: Cluster configurations and economic development. Organization Science, 16, 344–358.

59.

Rubin

H. J.

Rubin

I. S.

(1995). Qualitative interviewing: The art of hearing data. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.

60.

Ruef

(2000). The emergence of organizational forms: A commuinity ecology approach. American Journal of Sociology, 106, 658–714.

61.

Schmalensee

(1987). Competitive advantage and collusive optima. International Journal of Industrial Organization, 5, 351–367.

62.

Scott

Lane

V. R.

(2000). A stakeholder approach to organizational identity. Academy of Management Review, 25, 43–62.

63.

Scott

W. R.

(1998). Organizations: Rational, natural and open systems (4th Edition). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.

64.

Scott

W. R.

(2000). Institutions and organization. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.

65.

Short

C. M.

(1932). The present practice of Canadian Banking: An outline of its origin and history, and some recent improvements in the system. Barron’s (1921–1942), 12(26), 10.

66.

Spender

J. C.

(1989). Industry recipes. Cambridge, MA: Basil Blackwell.

67.

Staber

(2010). Imitation without interaction: How firms identify with clusters. Organization Studies, 31(2), 53–174.

68.

Steele

C. M.

Spence

S. J.

Aronson

(2002). Contending with group image: The pyschology of stereotype and social identity threat. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 34, 379–440.

69.

Stigler

(1964). A theory of oligopoly. Journal of Political Economy, 72, 44–61.

70.

Suchman

M. C.

Edelman

L. B.

(1996). Legal rational myths: The new institutionalism and the law and society tradition. Law & Society Inquiry, 21, 903–966.

71.

TNS Canadian Facts (2004). Global reputation study: Detailed findings for Canada. Toronto, Ontario: TNS Canadian Facts.

72.

Tripsas

Gavetti

(2000). Capabilities, cognition and inertia: Evidence from digital imaging. Strategic Management Journal, 21, 1147–1161.

73.

Whetten

D. A.

(1997). Part II: Where do reputations come from? Theory development and the study of corporate reputation. Corporate Reputation Review, 1(1), 25–34.

74.

Whetten

D. A.

(2006). Albert and Whetten revisited: Strengthening the concept of organizational identity. Journal of Management Inquiry, 15, 219–234.

75.

Whetten

D. A.

Mackey

(2002). A social actor conception of organizational identity and its implications for the study of organizational reputation. Business and Society, 41, 393–414.

76.

White

H. C.

(Ed.) (1981). Production markets as induced role structure. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.

77.

Zajac

E. J.

Bazerman

M. H.

(1991). Blind spots in industry and competitor analysis: Implications of interfirm (mis)perceptions for strategic decisions. Academy of Management Review, 16, 37.

78.

Zuckerman

E. W.

(1999). The categorical imperative: Securities analysts and the illegitimacy discount. American Journal of Sociology, 104, 1398–1438.