Using data spanning the 1996-98 fiscal years of 247 of Japan’s largest manufacturers, we empirically evaluate the extent to which a firm’s investment behaviour and financial performance are influenced by its ownership structure. To do so, we examine six distinct categories of Japanese shareholders: foreign investors, investment funds, pension funds, banks and insurance companies, affiliated companies and insiders. Our findings strongly indicate that the relationship between the equity stakes of a particular category of investor and a firm’s financial performance and investment behaviour is considerably more complex than is depicted in simple principal-agent representations. Such a result emphasizes the importance of making finely grained and contextually relevant distinctions when modelling and evaluating corporate governance relations.
Abegglen, James , and George Stalk1985Kaisha: The Japanese corporation. New York: Basic Books .
2.
Alchian, Armen A. , and Harold. Demsetz1972‘Production, information costs and economic organization’ . American Economic Review62: 777-795 .
3.
Amihud, Yakov , and Lev Baruch1981‘Risk reduction as a managerial motive for conglomerate mergers’ . Bell Journal of Economics12: 605-617 .
4.
Aoki, Masahiko1988Information, incentives, and bargaining in the Japanese economy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
5.
Baltagi, Badi1995Econometric analysis of panel data. New York: Wiley .
6.
Baumol, William J.1959Business behavior, value, and growth. New York: Macmillan .
7.
Berglöf, Erik , and Enrico C. Perotti1994‘The governance structure of the Japanese financial keiretsu’ . Journal of Financial Economics36: 259-284 .
8.
Berle, Adolf , and Gardiner C. Means1932The modern corporation and private property. New York: Macmillan .
9.
Bourgeois, L. J.1981‘On the measurement of organizational slack’ . Academy of Management Review6: 29-39 .
10.
Caves, Richard , and Masu Uekusa1976Industrial organization in Japan. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution .
11.
Chandler, Alfred D.1990Scale and scope: Industrial dynamics of capitalism. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
12.
Charkham, Jonathon1994Keeping good company: A study of corporate governance in five countries. Oxford: Clarendon Press .
13.
Claessens, Stijn , Simeon Djankov , Joseph Fan , and Larry Lang1999‘Expropriation of minority shareholders: Evidence from East Asia’. World Bank working paper, February.
14.
Clark, Rodney1979The Japanese company. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press .
15.
Cyert, Richard.A. , and James G. March1963A behaviourial theory of the firm. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall .
16.
Demsetz, Harold , and Kenneth Lehn1985‘The structure of corporate ownership: Theory and consequences’ . Journal of Political Economy93: 11-55 .
17.
Denis, David , Diane K. Denis , and Atulya Sarin1997‘Agency problems, equity ownership, and corporate diversification’ . Journal of Finance52: 135-160 .
18.
Dore, Ronald1998‘Asian crisis and the future of the Japanese model’ . Cambridge Journal of Economics22: 773-787 .
19.
Eisenhardt, Kathleen. M.1989‘Agency theory: An assessment and review’ . Academy of Management Review14: 57-74 .
20.
Fama, Eugene , and Michael Jensen1983‘Separation of ownership and control’ , Journal of Law and Economics26: 301-325 .
21.
Fukao, Mitsuhiro1999Japanese financial instability and weakness in the corporate governance structure. Paris: OECD .
22.
Gedajlovic, Eric R.1993‘Ownership, strategy and performance: Is the dichotomy sufficient?’Organization Studies14: 731-752 .
23.
Gedajlovic, Eric R. , and Daniel M. Shapiro2002‘Ownership and firm profitability in Japan’ . Academy of Management Journal45/3: 565-575 .
24.
Gerlach, Michael L.1992Alliance capitalism: The social organization of Japanese business. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press .
25.
Granovetter, Mark S.1973‘The strength of weak ties’ . American Journal of Sociology78: 1360-1380 .
26.
Greene, William1993Econometric analysis. New York: Macmillan
27.
Harris, Milton , and Artur Raviv1991‘The theory of capital structure’ . Journal of Finance46: 297-355 .
28.
Hill, Charles W. , and Scott Snell1988‘External control, corporate strategy, and firm performance in research intensive industries’ . Strategic Management Journal9: 577-590 .
29.
Hollingsworth, J. Rogers , and Robert Boyer1997Contemporary capitalism: The embeddedness of institutions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
30.
Hoshi, Takeo , Anil Kashyap , and David Scharfstein1991‘Corporate structure, liquidity, and investment: Evidence from Japanese industrial groups’ . Quarterly Journal of EconomicsFebruary, 33-60 .
31.
Inoue, Hideaki1999The accelerating dissolution of stock cross-holding.Tokyo: NLI Research Institute . Japan Economic Journal (Nihon Keizai Shimbun) Various issues
32.
Jensen, Michael1989‘Eclipse of the public corporation’ . Harvard Business ReviewSeptember-October, 61-74 .
33.
Jensen, Michael , and William Meckling1976‘Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure’ . Journal of Financial Economics3: 305-360 .
34.
Kamin, J. Y. , and J. Ronen1985‘The effects of corporate control on apparent profit performance’ . Southern Economics Journal33: 181-191 .
35.
Kester, W. Carl1986‘Capital and ownership structure: A comparison of United States and Japanese manufacturing corporations’ . Financial ManagementSpring, 5-16 .
36.
Kester, W. Carl1991Japanese takeovers: The global contest for corporate control. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press .
La Porta, Rafael , Florencio Lopez-de-Silanes , and Andrei Shleifer1999‘Corporate ownership around the world’ . Journal of Finance54: 471-517 .
39.
La Porta, Rafael , Florencio Lopez-de-Silanes , Andrei Shleifer , and Robert W. Vishny2000‘Agency problems and dividend policies around the world’ . Journal of Finance55: 1-33 .
40.
Lieberman, Marvin B. , and David B. Montgomery1988‘First-mover advantages’ . Strategic Management Journal9: 41-58 .
41.
Lincoln, James R. , Michael L. Gerlach , and Christina L. Ahmadjian1996‘Keiretsu networks and corporate performance in Japan’ . American Sociological Review61: 67-88 .
42.
Lincoln, James R. , Christina L. Ahmadjian , and Eliot Mason1998‘Organizational learning and purchase-supply relations in Japan’ . California Management Review40/3: 241-264 .
43.
Maddala, G. S.1977Econometrics. New York: McGraw Hill .
44.
Marris, Robin1964The economic theory of managerial capitalism. London: Macmillan .
45.
May, D. O.1995‘Do managerial motives influence firm risk reduction strategies?’Journal of Finance50: 1291-1308 .
46.
Milgrom, Paul , and John Roberts1992Economics, organization, and management. Englewood Cliffs, CT: Prentice Hall .
47.
Modgiliani, Franco , and Merton Miller1958‘The cost of capital, corporate finance and the theory of investment’ . American Economic Review48: 261-297 .
48.
Morck, Randall , and Masao Nakamura1999‘Banks and corporate control in Japan’ . Journal of Finance54: 319-339 .
49.
Morck, Randall , Andrei Shleifer , and Robert W. Vishny1988‘Managerial ownership and market evaluation: An empirical analysis’ . Journal of Financial Economics20: 293-317 .
50.
Nakamae, Tadashi1998‘Three futures for Japan: Views from 2020’ . The EconomistMarch 21: 25-28 .
51.
Nakatani, Iwao1984‘The economic role of financial corporate grouping’ in The economic analysis of the Japanese firm. M. Aoki (ed.), 227-258. Amsterdam: North-Holland .
52.
Nitta, Keisuke2000‘Kabushiki mochiai to kigyo keiei: Kabunushi kosei no eikyo ni kansuru jissho bunseki’ (Cross-shareholdings and firm management: An empirical study on the effects of ownership structure) . Security Analyst Journal38: 72-93 .
53.
Porter, Michael1980Competitive strategy: Techniques for analyzing industries and competitors. New York: Free Press .
54.
Prevost, Andrew K. , and Ramesh P. Rao2000‘Of what value are shareholder proposals sponsored by public pension funds?’Journal of Business73/2: 177-204 .
55.
Prowse, Stephen D.1992‘The structure of corporate ownership in Japan’ . Journal of Finance47: 1121-1140 .
56.
Prowse, Stephen D.1996‘Corporate finance in international perspective: Legal and regulatory influences on financial system development’ . Economic Review,Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, 3rd Quarter: 2-15 .
57.
Rajan, Raghuram G. , and Luigi Zingales1998‘Which capitalism? Lessons from the East Asian crisis’ . Journal of Applied Corporate Finance1/3: 40-48 .
58.
Roe, Mark J.1994Strong managers, weak owners. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
59.
Sheard, Paul1994a‘Interlocking shareholdings and corporate governance’ in The Japanese firm: The sources of competitive strength. M. Aoki & R. Dore (eds), Oxford: Oxford University Press .
60.
Sheard, Paul1994b‘Bank executive on Japanese corporate boards’ . Bank of Japan Monetary and Economic Studies12: 85-121 .
61.
Sheard, Paul1997Mein banku shihonshugi no kiki (Crisis of the main bank capitalism). Tokyo, Toyo Keizai Shimposha .
62.
Shleifer, Andrei , and Robert W. Vishny1997‘A survey of corporate governance’ . Journal of Finance52: 737-783 .
63.
Stock Distribution Survey(Kabushiki Bunpu Chosa)2001Tokyo: Association of Stock Exchanges .
64.
Stulz, Rene M.1988‘Managerial control of voting rights, financing policies and the market for corporate control’ . Journal of Financial Economics20: 25-54 .
65.
Thomas, L.G. III , and Geoffrey Waring1999‘Competing capitalisms: Capital investment in American, German, and Japanese firms’ . Strategic Management Journal20: 729-748 .
66.
Thomsen, Steen , and Torben Pedersen2000‘Ownership structure and economic performance in the largest European companies’ . Strategic Management Journal21: 689-705 .
67.
Useem, Michael1998‘Corporate leadership in a globalizing equity market’ . Academy of Management Executive12/4: 43-59 .
68.
Weinstein, David E. , and Yishay Yafeh1995‘Japan’s corporate groups: Collusive or competitive? An empirical investigation of keiretsubehavior’ . Journal of Industrial Economics43: 359-376 .
69.
Whittaker, D. Hugh , and Yoshitaka Kurosawa1998‘Japan’s crisis: evolution and implications’ . Cambridge Journal of Economics22: 761-771 .
70.
Whitley, Richard1999Divergent capitalisms: The social structuring and change of business systems. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
71.
Whitley, Richard2000‘The institutional structuring of innovation strategies: Business systems, firm types and patterns of technological change in different market economies’ . Organization Studies21: 855-886 .
72.
Whitley, Richard , and Peer Kristensen , editors 1996The changing European firm: Limits to convergence. London: Routledge .
73.
Whitley, Richard , and Laszlo Czaban1998‘Institutional transformation and enterprise change in an emerging capitalist economy: The case of Hungary’ . Organization Studies19: 259-280 .
74.
Williamson, Oliver E.1985The economic institutions of capitalism. New York: Free Press .
75.
Yasui, Takahiro1999Corporate governance in Japan. Paris: OECD .
76.
Yoshikawa, Toru , and Eric Gedajlovic2002‘The impact of global capital market exposure and stable ownership on investor relations practices and performance of Japanese firms’ . Asia Pacific Journal of Management19: 525-540 .
77.
Yoshikawa, Toru , and Phillip H. Phan2001‘Alternative corporate governance systems in Japanese firms: Implications for a shift to stockholder-centered corporate governance’ . Asia Pacific Journal of Management18: 183-205 .
