In recent years, digital competencies have become progressively more valuable in the labour market, and digital skills are increasingly becoming a prerequisite for employment.
Objective
Our research focuses on the digital literacy of human capital in the 27 EU Member States.
Methods
Using mathematical-statistical methods, correlation graph matrix and panel regression, we searched for significant correlations that can impact the digital readiness of human resources. The Hausman test suggests that the random effects panel regression model should be used along with the two main types of multivariate panel regression. We used Eurostat databases and the first dimension (human resources) of the DESI index for 2017–2022 for our analyses.
Results
Our analysis revealed several significant factors influencing digital readiness: a 10% increase in STEM student enrolment raises the DESI index by 6 percentage points; €10,000 higher real GDP per capita increases digital readiness by 4.9%; a €10 billion increase in public education spending improves the HC index by 1%. Conversely, each additional 1000 students in mobility programs decreases the HC index by 0.028 percentage points, while each decade of delayed EU accession correlates with a 2.3% lower HC index.
Conclusions
Complementing descriptive statistics with our methods helps link macroeconomics and practical solutions for digital readiness.
KarlÉMolnárG. A digitális kompetencia fejlesztésének igénye és lehetőségei a szakképzésben, napjaink reformterhelt világában (The need and opportunities for the development of digital competence in vocational training, in today’s reform-laden world). Pedagógiai Szemle2021; 71(5-6): 55–68.
2.
KovácsTZBittnerBHuzsvaiL, et al.Convergence and the matthew effect in the European union based on the DESI index. Mathematics2022; 10(4): 23.
3.
European Commission. Digital economy and society index (DESI) 2022: European Commission, 2022.
4.
Sungur GulKSaylan KirmizigulAAtesH, et al.Advantages and challenges of STEM education in K-12: systematic review and research synthesis. Int J Res Educ Sci2023; 9(2): 283–307.
5.
BaranEBiliciSCMesutogluC, et al.Moving STEM beyond schools: students' perceptions about an out-of-school STEM education program. Int J Educ Math Sci Technol2016; 4(1): 9–19.
6.
BaşolOSevgiHYalçınEC. The effect of digitalization on youth unemployment for EU countries: treat or threat?Sustainability2023; 15(14): 11080.
7.
AzmukN. The interaction of labour markets and higher education in the context of digital technology. Economic Annals-XXI2015; 7-8(1): 98–101.
RobinsonDSDattaNMasseyE, et al.Digital jobs for youth : young women in the digital economy. : World Bank Group, 2018.
10.
BaşolOYalçınEC. How does the digital economy and society index (DESI) affect labor market indicators in EU countries?Hum Syst Manag2021; 40(4): 503–512.
11.
Grinberga-ZaliteGHernikJ. Digital performance indicators in the EU. In: Digital Performance Indicators in the EU. Research for Rural Development, 2019, vol 2, pp. 183–188.
12.
VidalIMGGewercBA. Socioeducational gaps derived from the impact of digitization in Spain 2020. Revista de Educación a Distancia (RED)2021; 21(68): 1–12.
13.
VītolsGArhipovaIPauraL (eds). Programming Skills Gap Reduction by Extramural School Development: University Success Case Study In Latvia. 12th International Technology, Education and Development Conference. 2018.
14.
European Commission. Erasmus+ higher education impact study – final reportConsultCConsultingI (eds). European Commission, Directorate-General for Education Y, Sport, Culture. Publications Office, 2018.
15.
European Commission. Study on the impact of Erasmus+ higher education partnerships and knowledge alliances at local, national and European levels on key higher education policy priorities – final reportPolicyPInstituteM (eds). Directorate-General for Education Y, Sport, Culture, Technology AIo. Publications Office, 2018.
16.
European Commission. Erasmus+ annual report 2023. Directorate-general for education Y, sport, culture. Commission E. Publications Office of the European Union, 2024.
17.
CommissionE. Directorate-general for education Y, sport, culture. Erasmus+ annual report 2023 – annex. Publications Office of the European Union, 2024.
18.
MartinsDSilvaSSilvaC (eds). Knowledge transfer between european universities through the Erasmus students programme. 17th European Conference on Knowledge Management (ECKM 2016) 2016; Coleraine, United Kingdom Academic Conferences and. Publishing International Ltd.
TruemanSBorell-DamianLSmithJH. The evolution of university-based knowledge transfer structures. 2014.
21.
DorneanuANeamţuDMHapenciucCV (eds). Education and digitalization, the path to a more sustainable, resilient and secure society International Conference on Business Excellence: The Bucharest University of Economic Studies, 2022.
22.
StofkovaJPoliakovaAStofkovaKR, et al.Digital skills as a significant factor of human resources development. Sustainability2022; 14(20): 13117.
23.
KovacsTZBittnerB. Examination of the category of digitalisation of public services in the digital economy and society index among the eastern enlargement of EU. Industry 402022; 7(1): 30–32.
24.
Jakoet-SalieARamalobeK. The digitalization of learning and teaching practices in higher education institutions during the Covid-19 pandemic. Teach Public Adm2022; 41(1): 59–71.
25.
KutieshatRFarmaneshP. The impact of new human resource management practices on innovation performance during the covid 19 crisis: a new perception on enhancing the educational sector. Sustainability2022; 14(5): 2872.
26.
WilliamsonBEynonRPotterJ. Pandemic politics, pedagogies and practices: digital technologies and distance education during the coronavirus emergency. Learning, Media Technology, 2020, vol 45, pp. 107–114.
27.
ZhaoYWatterstonJ. The changes we need: education post COVID-19. J Educ Change2021; 22(1): 3–12.
28.
HudaM. Between accessibility and adaptability of digital platform: investigating learners' perspectives on digital learning infrastructure. High Educ Skills Work base Learn2024; 14(1): 1–21.
29.
JandrićPMartinezAFReitzC, et al.Teaching in the age of covid-19—the new normal. Postdigit Sci Educ2022; 4(3): 877–1015.
30.
Eurostat. Real GDP per capita [sdg_08_10]. European Commission, 2024.
31.
Eurostat. Students enrolled in STEM education fields - per thousand of population aged 20-29[educ_uoe_enra31__custom_9863003]. 2024.
32.
Eurostat. Mobile students from abroad enrolled by education level, sex and field of education[educ_uoe_mobs01__custom_9862955]. 2024.
33.
Eurostat. General government expenditure by function (COFOG) [gov_10a_exp__custom_10359926]. 2024.
WooldridgeJM. Introductory econometrics: a modern approach. South-Western Cengage Learning, 2013.
36.
BellAJonesK. Explaining fixed effects: random effects modeling of time-series cross-sectional and panel data. Political Sci Res Methods2015; 3(1): 133–153.
37.
HausmanJA. Specification tests in econometrics. Econometrica1978; 46(6): 1251–1271.
38.
TripoJ. A devizaárfolyam volatilitásának hatása a gabona kereskedelmére (The impact of exchange rate volatility on grain trade). Staféta2021; 6: 79–99.
39.
BreuschTSPaganAR. The Lagrange multiplier test and its applications to model specification in econometrics. Rev Econ Stud1980; 47(1): 239–253.
PesaranMH. Testing weak cross-sectional dependence in large panels. Econom Rev2015; 34(6-10): 1089–1117.
42.
DrukkerDM. Testing for serial correlation in linear panel-data models. STATA J2003; 3(2): 168–177.
43.
BaltagiBH. Econometric analysis of panel data. 3rd ed.: John Wiley & Sons Ltd, 2005.
44.
HunyadiLVitaL. Statisztika (statistics): Aula, 2008, p. 300.
45.
KovácsTZBittnerBNagyAS, et al.Digital transformation of human capital in the EU according to the DESI index. Issues in Information Systems2022; 23(4): 293–311.
46.
DebrentiELászlóB. Developing elementary school students' mental computation skills through didactic games. Acta Didact Napoc2020; 13(2): 80–92.
47.
GrigorescuAPelinescuEIonAE, et al.Human capital in digital economy: an empirical analysis of central and eastern European countries from the European union. Sustainability2021; 13(4): 2020.
48.
CsathM. Növekedési vagy fejlődési csapda (Growth or development trap). Hitelintézeti Szemle2022; 21(2): 152–174.
49.
OECD. Value for money in school education. Smart investments, quality outcomes, equal opportunities, 2022.
50.
BarroRJ. Human capital and growth. Am Econ Rev2001; 91(2): 12–17.
51.
SvodziwaM.STEM education as a human capital development strategy for the industrialization and modernization of Zimbabwe. SSRN Journal2021; 1–17. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3788852
UrbanovičJWilkinsS. Internationalisation as a strategy to improve the quality of higher education in small states: stakeholder perspectives in Lithuania. High Educ Pol2013; 26(3): 373–396.
de WitHAltbachPG. Internationalization in higher education: global trends and recommendations for its future. Policy Reviews in Higher Education2021; 5(1): 28–46.
56.
KluzerSPujol PriegoLCarretero GomezS, et al.DigComp into Action: get inspired, make it happenA user guide to the European digital competence framework: Publications Office of the European Union, 2018.
57.
AksayAEYağmurKVan De VıjverF. A qualitative study of Erasmus program challenges and paradoxes based on the experiences of students from Turkey. Yükseköğretim Dergisi2021; 11(1): 63–73.
58.
FrenkenKHeimeriksGJHoekmanJ. What drives university research performance? An analysis using the CWTS Leiden Ranking data. J Informetr2017; 11(3): 859–872.
59.
WadhwaRJhaS. Internationalization of higher education: implications for policy making. Higher Education for the Future2014; 1(1): 99–119.
60.
CoronelVJDíaz-RoldánC. Government expenditure, education, and productivity in the European union: effects on economic growth. Economics2024; 18: 1–21.
61.
CrescenziRDi CataldoMGiuaM. It’s not about the money. EU funds, local opportunities, and Euroscepticism. Reg Sci Urban Econ2020; 84: 103556.
62.
European Policies Research C. The recovery plan for Europe and cohesion policy: an initial assessment: University of Strathclyde, 2021.
