Information systems (IS) have significant potential for making quantum leaps in productivity, increasing the ability to compete, and maintaining sustainable competitive advantage. However, much of that potential remains to be achieved.
This paper uses dynamic case analysis and survey data to identify the critical success elements found in effective use of IS. These foundational elements are then integrated into a framework for innovatively deploying IS for sustainable competitive advantage. Common pitfalls are examined. Finally, a measure of the effective implementation of IS, information quotient (IQ), is proposed.
Results of this analysis are five fundamental mandates that form the basis for effective and innovative IS deployment for sustainable competitive advantage through advancement of organizational IQ. The IS of the future as prescribed here will promote both environmental responsiveness and strategic cohesiveness by providing internal and external intelligence to information processing.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
[1] L.M. Applegate , J.I. Cash Jr and D.Q. Mills , Information technology and tomorrow’s manager , Harvard Business Review (November-December 1988) 128-137 .
2.
[2] R. Ashkenas , D. Ulrich , T. Jick and S. Kerry , The Boundaryless Organization ( Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA , 1995).
3.
[3] W.E. Baker , Networking Smart ( McGraw-Hill, New York , 1994).
4.
[4] J. Barney , Organizational culture: can it be a source of sustained competitive advantage?Academy of Management Review11(3) (1986) 656-665 .
5.
[5] J. Barney , Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage , Journal of Management17(1) (1991) 99-120 .
6.
[6] J. Barney , Looking inside for competitive advantage , The Academy of Management Executive9(4) (1995) 49-61 .
7.
[7] B.E. Battles and D. Mark , Companies that just don’t get IT , The Wall Street Journal (9 December 1996) A14 .
8.
[8] R.H. Beeby , How to crunch a bunch of figures , The Wall Street Journal (11 June 1990) A14 .
9.
[9] R. Benjamin , Electronic links create new market dynamics , Computerworld (9 October 1989) SR22 .
10.
[10] R.I. Benjamin , J.F. Rockart , M.S.S. Morton and J. Wyman , Information technology: a strategic opportunity , Sloan Management Review (Spring 1984) 3-10 .
11.
[11] W.G. Bennis , On Becoming a Leader ( Addison-Wesley Publishing, Reading, MA , 1989).
12.
[12] R.A. Bettis , S.P. Bradley and G. Hamel , Outsourcing and industrial decline , The Academy of Management Executive6(1) (1992) 7-22 .
13.
[13] R. Brown , Answering the phone , Direct Marketing (December 1986) 64 .
14.
[14] B. Burrows , Essay review: the role of strategic planning in the information revolution , Long Range Planning22(1) (1989) 134-136 .
15.
[15] J.E. Butler , Theories of technological innovation as useful tools for corporate strategy , Strategic Management Journal9 (1988) 15-16 .
16.
[16] J. Carlton and J.E. Rigdon , After an Apple buyout, Sun could be mighty in Internet computers , The Wall Street Journal (24 January 1996) A1 and A6 .
17.
[17] D. Carnegie , How to Enjoy Your Life and Your Job ( Simon and Schuster, New York , 1985).
18.
[18] D.K. Carr and H.J. Johansson , Best Practices in Reengineering ( McGraw-Hill, New York , 1995).
19.
[19] Centennial edition: 100 Years in business: Merrill Lynch CMAs draw interest, 1977 , The Wall Street Journal (1 November 1989) B1 .
20.
[20] J. Child , Information technology, organization, and the response to strategic challenges , California Management Review (Fall 1987) 33-50 .
21.
[21] J. Child , Information technology and organization. In: K. Urabe , J. Child and T. Kagono (eds), Innovation and Management: International Comparisons ( Walter de Gruyter, Berlin , 1988), pp. 255-301.
22.
[22] Cigna puts premium on IS , Information Week (31 July 1989) 32-36 .
23.
[23] L.H. Clark Jr , Productivity lag may be management’s fault , The Wall Street Journal (11 January 1989) A12 .
24.
[24] J.W. Cortada , TQM for Information Systems Management ( McGraw-Hill, New York , 1995).
25.
[25] S. Covey , The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People ( Simon and Schuster, New York , 1990).
26.
[26] A. Crenshaw, IRS computer upgrade fails to make the grade , The Birmingham News (15 March 1996) A1 .
27.
[27] R.L. Daft and R.H. Lengel , Organizational information requirements, media richness and structural design , Management Science (May 1986) 554-571 .
28.
[28] T.H. Davenport , M. Hammer and T.J. Metsisto , How executives can shape their company’s information systems , Harvard Business Review (March-Apri1 1989) 130-135 .
29.
[29] F.D. Davis , Perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, and user acceptance of information technology , MIS Quarterly (September 1989) 318-339 .
30.
[30] P.F. Drucker , Managing in Turbulent Times ( Harper and Row, New York , 1980).
31.
[31] P.F. Drucker , Innovation and Entrepreneurship ( Harper and Row, New York , 1985).
32.
[32] P.F. Drucker , The coming of the new organization , Harvard Business Review66(1) (1988) 45-53 .
33.
[33] P.F. Drucker , The New Realities ( Harper and Row, New York , 1989).
34.
[34] P.F. Drucker, Presentation on closed circuit TV to 130 locations, at the University of Texas at Arlington, Arlington, TX, 1 November 1990.
35.
[35] P.F. Drucker , How to be competitive though big , The Wall Street Journal (7 February 1991) A14 .
36.
[36] P.F. Drucker , Japan: new strategies for a new reality , The Wall Street Journal (2 October 1991) A12 .
37.
[37] P.F. Drucker , The discipline of innovation. In: J. Henry and D. Walker (eds), Managing Innovation ( Sage Publications, London , 1991), pp. 9-17.
38.
[38] P.F. Drucker , A turnaround primer , The Wall Street Journal (2 February 1993) A10 .
39.
[39] P.F. Drucker , Managing in a Time of Great Change ( Truman Talley Books, New York , 1995).
[41] J.A. Falvey , A winning philosophy becomes an albatross , The Wall Street Journal (25 September 1989) A8 .
42.
[42] J. Forsythe , Inside trading - Morgan Stanley pioneered strategic use of IS in the brokerage house , Information Week (18 September 1989) 60-61 .
43.
[43] J. Forsythe , Million dollar man , Information Week (6 November 1989) 38-44 .
44.
[44] L. Freeman , Lands’ End a beacon for mail-order market: ex-adman delivers high profits , Advertising Age (8 December 1986) 4 .
45.
[45] J.O’C. Hamilton and C.L. Harris , For drug distributors information is the Rx for survival , Business Week (14 October 1985) 116 .
46.
[46] M. Hammer and J. Champy , Reengineering the Corporation: A Manifesto for Business Revolution ( Harper Business, New York , 1993).
47.
[47] B. Harper and A. Harper , Succeeding as a Self-Directed Work Team ( MW Corporation, New York , 1990).
48.
[48] K. Harridan , Interview: advantageous alliances , Computerworld (9 October 1989) SR7 .
49.
[49] C.L. Harris , Information power , Business Week (14 October 1985) 108-114 .
50.
[50] L.R. Harris , AICorp’s Harris on artificial intelligence: integration with existing systems is key , Datamation (15 March 1990) 41-44 .
51.
[51] R. Henderson , Managing innovation in the information age , Harvard Business Review (January-February 1994) 100-105 .
52.
[52] F. Hesselbein , M. Goldsmith and R. Beckhard (eds), The Leader of the Future ( The Drucker Foundation, New York; Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA , 1996).
53.
[53] G.C. Hill and K. Yamanda , Five electronics giants hope general magic will turn the trick , The Wall Street Journal (8 February 1993) A1 and A4 .
54.
[54] G.M. Hoffman , Technology Payoff ( Richard D. Irwin, Burr Ridge, IL , 1994).
55.
[55] M.D. Hopper , Rattling SABRE - new ways to compete on information , Harvard Business Review (May-June 1990) 118-125 .
56.
[56] N. Imprato and O. Harari , Jumping the Curve ( Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA , 1994).
57.
[57] C. Jackson , Building a competitive advantage through information technology , Long Range Planning22(4) (1989) 29-39 .
58.
[58] V.S. Jacob , L.D. Gaultney and G. Salvendy , Strategies and biases in human decision-making and their implications for expert systems , Behavior and Information Technology5(2) (1986) 119-140 .
59.
[59] B.L. Joiner , Fourth Generation Management ( McGraw-Hill, New York , 1994).
60.
[60] H. Kahalas and K. Suchon , Managing a perpetual idea machine: inside the creator’s mind , The Academy of Management Executive9(2) (1995) 57-66 .
61.
[61] R.W. Keidel , Rethinking organizational design , The Academy of Management Executive8(4) (1994) 12-30 .
62.
[62] C. Kennedy , Xerox charts a new strategic direction. In: J. Henry and D. Walker (eds), Managing Innovation ( Sage Publications, London , 1991), pp. 253-267.
63.
[63] P. Kennedy , The Rise and Fall of Great Powers ( Random House, New York , 1987).
64.
[64] B. Keys and T.R. Miller , The Japanese management theory jungle , Academy of Management Review9 (1984) 345 .
65.
[65] H.W. Koch Jr , How to Use ‘Top Secrets’ of Innovation to Expand Company Profits and the Executives’ Personal Success ( Executive Reports Corporation, Englewood Cliffs, NJ , 1973).
66.
[66] P. Krass , Service advantage - unpretentious Wal-Mart may be the most IT-savvy retailer in the market , Information Week (18 September 1989) 52 .
67.
[67] P. Krass , C. Pelton and M. Fillon , Making progress , Information Week (16 September 1991) 47-60 .
68.
[68] A. Layne , Totally electronic - Ford’s driven toward a high-tech vision - and leading the pack. Overview - spending to save - the 100 best. The best, the biggest, and the debate , Information Week (18 September 1989) 6-41 and 64 .
69.
[69] R. Layne , The best, the biggest, and the debate , Information Week (18 September 1989) 6--12 .
70.
[70] S. Leibs , Can Sears tower again?Information Week (18 September 1989) 32-34 .
71.
[71] H.C. Lucas Jr , Utilizing information technology: guidelines for managers , Sloan Management Review (Fall 1986) 39-47 .
72.
[72] K. Maney , Megamedia Shakeout ( Wiley, New York , 1995).
73.
[73] J. Martin , An Information Systems Manifesto ( Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ , 1984).
74.
[74] T. McCuster , IS drives distribution , Datamation (21 November 1988) 20 .
75.
[75] G. Morgan , Drastic changes for management , Business Month (March 1989) 67-70 .
76.
[76] W.S. Mossberg , Apple of America’s eye falls , The Wall Street Journal (24 January 1996) B1 .
77.
[77] C. Palmer , Using IT for competitive advantage at Thomson Holidays , Long Range Planning21(6) (1988) 26-29 .
78.
[78] G.L. Parsons , Information technology: a new competitive weapon , Sloan Management Review (Fall 1983) 3-14 .
79.
[79] R. Pastore , ‘Search for new heroes’ honors 11 for ‘courage’ at CW Smithsonian awards , Computerworld (26 June 1989) 120-121 .
80.
[80] T. Pearce , Leading Out Loud ( Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA , 1995).
81.
[81] C. Pelton , ARCO’s IS democracy , Information Week (18 September 1989) 44-46 .
82.
[82] Personal computing: the directions for the 1990s , The Wall Street Journal (14 November 1989). [A supplement on an industry perspective, featuring insights and perspectives of top executives in the PC industry.]
83.
[83] T.J. Peters , Pamphlet on Quality ( The Tom Peters Group, Palo Alto, CA , 1986).
84.
[84] T.J. Peters , Facing up to the need for a management revolution , California Management Review (Winter 1987) 7-37 .
85.
[85] T.J. Peters , Thriving on Chaos ( Alfred A. Knopf, New York , 1987).
86.
[86] T.J. Peters , The role of structure and climate: a skunkworks tale. In: R. Katz (ed.) Managing Professionals in Innovative Organizations ( Ballinger Publishing, Cambridge, MA , 1988), pp. 433-441.
87.
[87] T.J. Peters , Get innovative or get dead , California Management Review (Fall 1990) 9-26 .
88.
[88] T.J. Peters , Restoring American competitiveness: looking for new models of organizations. In: D.A. Kolb , I.M. Rubin and J.S. Osland (eds), The Organizational Behavior Reader ( Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ , 1991), pp. 607-616.
89.
[89] T.J. Peters , Liberation Management ( Excel, New York , 1992).
90.
[90] T.J. Peters , The pursuit of WOW! ( Vintage Books, New York , 1994).
91.
[91] T.J. Peters and N. Austin , A Passion for Excellence ( Macmillian, Delran, NJ , 1985).
92.
[92] T.J. Peters and R.H. Waterman Jr , In Search of Excellence ( Warner, New York , 1984).
93.
[93] B.J. Pine II , D. Peppers and M. Rogers , Do you want to keep your customers forever?Harvard Business Review (March-April 1995) 103-114 .
94.
[94] A. Pope , Using the results , Computerworld (18 September 1989) 20 .
95.
[95] O. Port , Innovation in America: back to the basics , Business Week [Special issue - Innovations in America] (1989) 15-18 .
96.
[96] M.E. Porter , Competitive Strategy ( Macmillan, New York , 1980).
97.
[97] M.E. Porter , Competitive Advantage ( Macmillan, New York , 1985).
98.
[98] M.E. Porter , Interview: building competitive advantage by extending information systems , Computerworld (9 October 1989) SR19 .
99.
[99] M.E. Porter , The Competitive Advantage of Nations ( Macmillan, New York , 1990).
100.
[100] P. Pritchett , The Employee Handbook of New Work Habits for a Radically Changing World ( Pritchett and Associates, Dallas, TX , 1994).
101.
[101] P. Pritchett and R. Pound , A Survival Guide to the Stress of Organizational Change ( Pritchett and Associates, Dallas, TX , 1995).
102.
[102] J.B. Quinn , Innovation and corporate strategy: managed chaos. In: M.L. Tushman and W.L. Moore (eds), Readings in the Management of Innovation2nd ed. (1988), pp. 123-137.
103.
[103] J.B. Quinn , Services technology and manufacturing: cornerstones of the US economy. In: B.R. Guile and J.B. Quinn (eds), Managing Innovation: Cases from the Services Industries ( National Academy Press, Washington, DC , 1988), pp. 9-35.
[110] R.K. Reger , J.V. Mullane , L.T. Gustafson and S.M. DeMarie , Creating earthquakes to change organizational mindsets , The Academy of Management Executive8(4) (1994) 31-46 .
111.
[111] F.F. Reichheld , Solving the productivity puzzle , The Wall Street Journal (4 March 1996) A14 .
112.
[112] Reservation systems , Information Week (6 November 1989) 28 .
113.
[113] H. Robbins and M. Finley , Why Teams Don’t Work: What Goes Wrong and How to Make It Right ( Peterson’s/Pacesetter Books, Princeton, NJ , 1995).
114.
[114] M. Robert , Product Innovation Strategy ( McGraw-Hill, New York , 1995).
115.
[115] E.B. Roberts , What we’ve learned managing invention and innovation , Research Technology Management (January-February 1988) 11-29 .
116.
[116] A. Ropo and J.G. Hunt , A Dynamic Case Study Perspective for Management and Organizational Research. [An unpublished manuscript received from: Professor J.G. Hunt, Institute for Management and Leadership Research, College of Business Administration, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX (1991).]
117.
[117] G.R. Rosen , VP information , Business Month (September 1989) 41 .
118.
[118] G.A. Rummler and A.P. Branche , Improving Performance ( Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA , 1990).
119.
[119] D. Russell , At Lands’ End , American Demographics (September 1987) 52 .
120.
[120] A.J. Ryan , Mixing business, technical savvy , Computerworld (21 August 1989) 97 .
121.
[121] W. Schatz , The Pentagon’s botched mission , Datamation (1 September 1989) 22-26 .
122.
[122] R.L. Schill , Managing technology for competitive advantage in interindustry markets , R&D Management16(2) (1986) 103-116 .
123.
[123] S.G. Scott and R.A. Bruce , Determinants of innovative behavior: a path model of individual innovation in the workplace , The Academy of Management Journal37(3) (1984) 580-607 .
124.
[124] P. Sellers , Pepsi keeps on going after no. 1 , Fortune (11 March 1991) 62-63 and 68-70 .
125.
[125] P. Senge , The Fifth Discipline ( Doubleday, New York , 1990).
126.
[126] R.W. Service , Organizational innovativeness: a comprehensive review and models. In: M.A. Runco (ed.), The Creativity Research Handbook, Volume Three ( Hampton Press, Cresskill, NJ , 1999).
127.
[127] G.T. Shahenn , Managing information: just what can technology do for you?Business Month (November 1989) 97 .
128.
[128] R.L. Simison , Ford’s net falls 5.9% to $2.38 billion, while core auto business jumps 24% , The Wall Street Journal (16 July 1998) A4 .
129.
[129] R. Simons , Levers of Control ( Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA , 1995).
130.
[130] C. von Simson , Lands’ End’s down-home approach to technology , Information Week (24 July 1989) 32-34 .
131.
[131] A.J. Slywortsky and D. Morrison , Insights from a falling Apple , The Wall Street Journal (29 January 1996) A14 .
132.
[132] G. Stalk Jr and T.M. Hout , Competing Against Time ( The Free Press, New York , 1990).
133.
[133] D. Stanglin and J. Chetwynd , Technology wasteland , US News and World Reports (15 January 1996) 45-47 .
134.
[134] W.B. Stevenson and M.C. Gilly , Information processing and problem solving: the migration of problems through formal positions and networks of ties , The Academy of Management Journal34(4) (1991) 918-928 .
135.
[135] D. Tapscott and A. Caston , Paradigm Shift ( McGraw-Hill, New York , 1993).
136.
[136] D. Todd , McKesson goes on-line , Information Week (6 November 1989) 15 .
137.
[137] D. Ulrich and M.F. Wiersema , Gaining strategic and organizational capability in a turbulent business environment , The Academy of Management Executive3 (1989) 115-122 .
138.
[138] V.H. Vroom and A.G. Jago , The New Leadership: Managing Participation in Organizations ( Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ , 1988).
139.
[139] S. Walton , Made in America ( Doubleday, New York , 1992).
140.
[140] T.N. Warner , Information technology as a competitive burden , Sloan Management Review (Fall 1987) 55-61 .
141.
[141] J.A. Welch and R. Nayak , Strategic sourcing: a progressive approach to the make-or-buy decision , The Academy of Management Executive6(1) (1992) 23-31 .
142.
[142] R.S. Wellins , W.C. Byham and J.M. Wilson , Empowered Teams ( Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA , 1991).
