The rapid advance of computer technology, especially computer graphics, has fostered the use of dynamic graph ical display in decision support systems (DSS). However, empirical evidence on the usefulness of dynamic graphics in decision support is limited. This paper presents an empirical study investigating this important issue. Results of the study offer moderate support to using dynamic graphics in DSS. Watching the dynamic visual display seems to be beneficial in decision support. However, no observable link between information processing strategy and decision performance is found. Further research is required to fully explore the impact of dynamic graphics on decision support tools.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
A.A. Angehrn and H-J. Luthi, Intelligent decision support systems: a visual interactive approach, Interfaces20(6) (1990) 17-28.
2.
R.H. Ashton and S.S. Kramer, Students as surrogates in behavioral accounting research: some evidence, Journal of Accounting Research18(1) (1980) 1-13.
3.
P.C. Bell , Visual interactive modelling as an operations research technique, Interfaces15(4) (1985) 26-33.
4.
P.C. Bell, Visual interactive modelling: the methodological issues. In: G.K. Rand (ed.), Operational Research '87 (North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1987).
5.
P.C. Bell , Visual interactive modelling: the past, the present, and the prospects, European Journal of Operational Research54(3) (1991) 274-286.
6.
P.C. Bell , Stochastic visual interactive simulation models , Journal of the Operational Research Society40(7) (1989) 615-624.
7.
P.C. Bell andR.M. O'Keefe, An Experimental Investigation into the Efficacy of Visual Interactive Simulation (Technical Report) ( Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, New York, 1992).
8.
I. Benbasat and A.S. Dexter, An Experimental Evaluation of Graphical and Colour-enhanced Information Presentation (Working Paper No. 1031) (Faculty of Commerce and Business Administration, University of BritishColumbia, 1984).
9.
I. Benbasat and A.S. Dexter, An investigation of the effectiveness of colour and graphical information presentation under varying time constraints , MIS Quarterly10(1) (1986) 59-81.
10.
I. Benbasat , A.S. Dexter and P. Todd, The influence of colour and graphical information presentation in a managerial decision simulation, Human-Computer Interaction2(1) (1986) 65-92.
11.
J.H. Bookbinder and T.R. Kotwa, Modelling an AGV automobile body-framing system, Interfaces17 (1987) 41-50.
12.
P.Y.K. Chau and P.C. Bell, Decision support for the design of a new production plant using visual interactive simulation, Journal of the Operational Research Society45(11) (1994) 1273-1284.
13.
P.Y.K. Chau and P.C. Bell, Designing effective simulation-based decision support systems: an empirical assessment of three types of decision support systems, Journal of the Operational Research Society46(3) (1995) 315-331.
14.
H. Chernoff , Using faces to represent points in k-dimensional space graphically, Journal of the American Statistical Association68 (1973) 361-368.
15.
G. DeSanctis , Computer graphics as decision aids: directions for research, Decision Sciences15(4) (1984) 463-487.
16.
G.W. Dickson , G. DeSanctis and D.J. McBride, Understanding the effectiveness of computer graphics for decision support: a cumulative experimental approach, Communications of the ACM, 29(1) (1986) 40-47.
17.
H.B. Eom and S.M. Lee, A survey of decision support system application (1971 - April 1988), Interfaces20(3) (1990) 65-79.
18.
R.D. Hurrion , Implementation of visual interactive consensus decision support system, European Journal of Operational Research , 20(2) ( 1985) 138-144.
19.
S. Jarvenpaa , The effect of task and graphical format on information processing strategies, Management Science35(3) (1989) 285-303.
20.
S. Jarvenpaa , G.W. Dickson and G. DeSanctis, Methodological issues in experimental IS research: experiences and recommendations, MIS Quarterly9(2) ( 1985) 141-156.
21.
P. Kirkpatrick and P.C. Bell, Visual interactive modelling in industry: results from a survey of visual interactive model builders, Interfaces19(5) (1989) 71-79.
22.
M.R. Lembersky and U.H. Chi, Decision simulators speed implementation and improve operations, Interfaces14(4) (1984) 1-15.
23.
T.P. Liang , Critical success factors of decision support systems: an empirical study, Data Base17(2) (1986) 3-16.
24.
H.C. Lucas , An experimental investigation of the use of computer-based graphics in decision making, Management Science27(7) ( 1981) 757-768.
25.
D.B. MacKay and A. Villarreal, Performance differences in the use of graphical and tabular displays of multi-variate data, Decision Sciences18(4) (1987) 535-546.
26.
I.M. Miller , Computer graphics for decision making, Harvard Business Review47(6) (1969) 121-132.
27.
J. Palme , Moving pictures show simulation to user, Simulation39(4) (1978) 204-209.
28.
J.W. Payne , Task complexity and contingent processing in decision making: an information search and protocol analysis, Organizational Behaviour and Human Performance16 (1976) 366-387.
29.
W.E. Pracht , Model visualization: graphical support for DSS problem structuring and knowledge organization, Decision Support Systems6(1) (1990) 13-27.
30.
W.E. Pracht and J.F. Courtney, Effects of a computer-graphics based DSS to support problem structuring, Decision Sciences19(3) (1988) 598-621.
31.
W. Remus , An empirical investigation of the impact of graphical and tabular data presentations on decision making, Management Science30(5) (1984) 533-542.
32.
W. Remus , Graduate students as surrogates for managers in experiments on business decision making, Journal of Business Research14(1) (1986) 19-25.
33.
R.L. Smith and L. Platt, Benefits of animation in the simulation of a machining and assembly line, Simulation48(1) (1987) 28-30.
34.
P. Todd and I. Benbasat, An experimental investigation of the impact of computer-based decision aids on decision making strategies, Information Systems Research2(1) ( 1991) 87-115.
35.
I. Vessey , Cognitive fit: a theory-based analysis of the graphs versus tables literature, Decision Sciences22(1) (1991) 219-240.
36.
S.J. Withers and R.D. Hurrion, The interactive development of visual simulation models, Journal of the Operational Research Society33(11) ( 1982) 973-975.
