Subject analysis: the critical first stage in indexing

Abstract

Studies of indexing neglect the first stage of the process, that is, subject analysis. In this study, novice indexers were asked to analyse three short, popular journal articles; to express the general subject as well as the primary and sec ondary topics in natural language statements; to state what influenced the analysis and to comment on the ease or diffi culty of this process. The factors which influenced the process were: the subject discipline concerned, factual is subjective nature of the text, complexity of the subject, clarity of text, possible support offered by bibliographic apparatus such as title, etc. The findings showed that with the social science and science texts, the general subject could be determined with ease, while this was more difficult with the humanities text. Clear evidence emerged of the importance of bibliographical apparatus in defining the general subject. There was varying difficulty in determining the primary and secondary topics.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

K.P. Jones , Towards a theory of indexing. Journal of Documentation 32(2) (1976) 118-125.

E. Svenonius , Directions for research in indexing, classification, and cataloging. Library Resources & Techmcal Services 25(1) ( 1981) 88-103.

D.E. Kieras , A model of reader strategy for abstracting main ideas from simple technical prose. Text 2(1-3) ( 1982) 47-82.

B.C. Vickery , Analysis of information. In: A. Kent and H. Lancour , eds. Encyclopedia of library and information science, vol. 1 (Dekker, New York , 1968) 355-384.

C. Schwartz , Indexing behavior - survey and state of the art. In: B.M. Fry, ed. Information management in the 1980s: proceedings of the 40th ASIS Annual Meeting, vol. 14, Chicago, Illinois, September 26-October 1, 1977. Part 2 (on microfiche): Full papers (American Society for Information Science, White Plains, N.Y., 1977) Fiche 8, Frame D5-D14.

W.J. Hutchins , The concept of "aboutness" in Subject indexing . Aslib Proceedings 30(5) (1978) 172-181.

D.F. Swift , V. Winn and D. Bramer , "Aboutness" as a strategy for retrieval in the social sciences. Aslib Proceedings 30(5) (1978) 182-187.

M.E. Maron , On indexing, retrieval and the meaning of about. In: S.K. Martin, ed. Information * politics: proceedings of the 39th ASIS Annual Meeting, vol. 13, San Francisco, California, October 4-9, 1976. Part 2 (on microfiche): Full papers (American Society for Information Science, Washington, D.C., 1966) Fiche 3, Frame E3.

K.P. Jones , How do we index?: a report of some ASLIB Informatics Group activity, Journal of Documentation 39(1) (1983) 1-23.

10.

A. Rake , South Africa wants to make friends, New Afncan (January 1991) 27.

11.

M.D. Lemonick , A restless venus unveiled, Time (October 8, 1990) 69.

12.

A. Berger , Too many options? A twentysomething woman ponders her future, Utne Reader (January/February 1991) 60-2. Excerpted from L.A. Weekly (March 30, 1990).