Comparison of search techniques (printed and computerised) with specific reference to the RTECS databank

Abstract

A comparative evaluation of three implementations of a large databank, the NIOSH Registry of Toxic Effects of Chem ical Substances, has been carried out. The three implementa tions are: a printed index, a text searching computer system, and a computerised chemical databank system, with substruc ture searching facilities. Seven test queries were used, with the aim of drawing conclusions of general relevance to chemical databank searching.

The computer systems were shown to have advantages over printed indexes for several of the queries, including those involving an element of browsing. Substructure search facilities were especially advantageous. Aspects of indexing of data present, and the criteria for inclusion of types of data, were also highlighted.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

S.A. Rossmassler and D.G. Watson , Data Handling for Science and Technology (North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1980).

B. Cronin , Databanks, Aslib Proc. 33 (1981) 243-250.

S.V. Meschel , Numeric databases in the sciences, Online Review 8 (1984) 77-103.

D. Bawden and A.M. Brock , Chemical toxicology searching: a collaborative Study comparing information resources and searching techniques, J. Inform. Science 5 (1982) 3-18.

D. Bawden , Chemical toxicology searching, Database 2 (1979) 11-18.

L. Cotton and J.B. Livesey , Toxicity data on TOXLINE and RTECS, Proc. 4th International Online Information Meeting, London, 1980 (Learned Information, Oxford , 1981) 481-485.

S.R. Heller , Linking scientific databases — the NIH-EPA chemical information system, Online 4 (1980) 45-56.

R.A. Feldmann et al., An interactive substructure search system, J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci. 17 (1977) 157-163.

D. Bawden and F.T. Jackson , Online Searching for the toxicology of chemical substances, Proc. 2nd International Online Information Meeting, London, 1978 (Learned Information, Oxford, 1979).

10.

M.F. Lynch et al., Computer Handling of Chemical Structure Information (Macdonald/Elsevier, London, 1971).

11.

T. Ormiston , Martindale Online Thesaurus, Proc. 11th AIOPI Annual Conference, 1984.

12.

A. Costigan , The Registry of Toxic Effects of Chemical Substances: a comparison of manual and online searching, unpublished M.Sc. thesis, University of Sheffield, Department of Information Studies, Sheffield , 1982.